Wednesday, December 03, 2008

Viewers challenge NBC & Williams' silence on McCaffrey 's conflicts

From Privacy Digest - - -

The New York Times's David Barstow, whose excellent and aggressive journalism led to the uncovering last April of the Pentagon's domestic propaganda program involving network "military analysts," today returns to this topic with another lengthy front-page exposé.

Barstow focuses today on the numerous, undisclosed conflicts of interest of Gen. Barry McCaffrey, who continues to be featured frequently by NBC News as an objective analyst as opines about war policies in which he has a substantial (and concealed) financial stake.

Some of the key facts which Barstow reports concerning the improper behavior of McCaffrey and NBC News were documented all the way back in April, 2003, in this excellent article from The Nation, which Barstow probably should have credited today.

That article -- entitled "TV's Conflicted Experts" -- detailed the numerous defense contractors to which McCaffrey had a substantial connection -- including Mitretek, Veritas and Integrated Defense Technologies, all featured by Barstow today -- and highlighted how the policies and viewpoints McCaffrey was advocating as a "military analyst" on NBC directly benefited those companies. ...

PD's entire post's here.

So far Williams and NBC are refusing to comment on the NYT's latest.

But at MSNBC's The DailyNightly blog, viewers are speaking up.

Williams' puffy post about traffic in New Jersey and Thanksgiving shopping drew such comments as this from Alan Nelson - - -

I'd like to hear an explanation from you rather than the NBC pr department speaking to this weekend's revelations in the New York Times that Barry McAffrey has been promoting his private defense industry interests in the guise of "expert commentary" on NBC News.

This is corruption at its most insidious, influence peddling masquerading as objective commentary. I would expect better from NBC News.

Tim asked - - -

Any plans for Mr. Williams, Anchor and Managing Editor, to address the latest NYT's article in a non-spin, serious manner? Or will your organization continue to dismiss and belittle serious journalism just because it is embarrassing to NBC and Mr Williams, Anchor and Managing Editor?

From gkokoris - - -

Mr. Williams,

How long will it be before your conscience or your shame compels you to publicly, and honestly, address NBC's disgraceful promotion of General McCaffrey as as an independent military analyst?

The NYT's article is a devastating indictment of your shoddy journalistic ethics, and your ongoing efforts to obscure or dismiss this scandal.

The story has only grown since the initial reporting in April of '08. You need to offer more than snide dismissals, defensive back-pedaling, or protestations of innocence.
***************************************************

There was a time Williams and NBC could stiff viewers on the McCaffrey story.

But not in the Internet Age with the NYT pumping out the news and viewers putting it right to Williams and NBC on Williams' post thread.

It will properly be lame, but look for some kind of statement soon from Williams and NBC. And look for less McCaffrey on NBC.

I'm going to try to watch NBC News tonight.

More on this story tomorrow.

Hat tip: Romenesko


Duke filing against insurer comments & my responses

On the thread of Duke filing against insurer in connection with lax suits are comments I mainly want to bring to you attention and thank the commenters.

Reader comments are in italics; my responses in plain

Ex-prosecutor said...

There is one aspect of this latest lawsuit which should be very interesting to those of us following this unfolding situation.

In the civil rights suit brought by the players against various defendants, the defense lawyers, as I recall, were successful in getting a ruling that discovery (depositions, production of most documents, etc.) will be postponed until the judge rules on the defendants' summary judgment motions.

The judge will decide which, if any of the plaintiffs' claims do not make out a legal basis upon which recovery can be based. If some of the claims are dismissed as a matter of law, depositions and discovery of documents will be limited to the surviving claims and defendants.

The civil rights suits are breathtaking in their complexity and length, so it may take and judge and his law clerks awhile to make a ruling.

However, as to Duke's claims against its insurance carrier, one of the company's main defenses, I expect, will be that the misdeeds of Duke officials triggered an exclusion to the policy, so it does not cover Duke.

What makes this defense interesting is that to determine exactly what the Duke officials did, the insurance company should be able to depose the Duke officials and employees and obtain copies of relevant documents. Ultimately, copies of some depositions may be filed with the court clerk, meaning that they will be available for public review.

It's likely that a copy of the policy is attached as an exhibit to Duke's lawsuit. An examination of it would show what acts are excluded from coverage.


I’ve nothing to say to Ex-prosecutor except “thank you.”

Jim in San Diego said...

This is an intriguing development in the Lacrosse case.

Jurisdictions of which I have knowledge prohibit insurers from covering or defending against claims for intentional wrongs.

This prohibition if for obvious policy reasons. If you could insure in advance for committing an intentional wrong, you could "buy" the right to do a wrong. (This was done in Medieval times through purchase from the Church of advance dispensations for sins the purchaser intended to commit. It is frowned upon here.)

The insurer would not have lightly refused to pay defense costs in a case like this. Thus, they must have a reason, and a good reason.

Discovery in the insurance case, which will begin very soon, will be fascinating.


“Thank you” to Jim, too. And welcome back. It’s good to have you commenting again.

Steve in New Mexico said - - -

You two guys offer articulate, literate, informative and yes Jim, fascinating comments. Thank you from a regular reader for the time and effort you take to make them.

Yes, they do, Steve. And so do you and many other JinC commenters who add to the blog.

Anonymous @ 9:51 - - -

John - I love your work, but you have some factual errors in your write-up.

The "McFadyen et al lawsuit" (3 plaintiffs) is being managed by the attorney R. Ekstrand.

The "Carrington et al lawsuit" (38 plaintiffs) is being managed by the attorney C. Cooper.

Keep up the good work.


Anon was right. I made the corrections and put a readers note at the head of post in which I noted a correction had been made, referenced Anon’s comment on the thread and thanked Anon.

I also added this comment to the thread - - -

To Anon @ 9:51,

Thanks for combining a very helpful piece of editing with some nice words for me.

I appreciate your help to me and others who'll read the post.

Best,

John
______________________________________

I’ll wrap with this:

Since both Duke and National Union surely went a long way to avoid the suit Duke’s brought, the cause(s) and degree(s) of difference(s) between the two must be huge, vital and viewed by both as irresolvable so that in Duke’s case, it brought a federal suit against National Union, and, in NU’s case, it's chosen to face a suit in federal court rather then accede to Duke’s indemnity requests.

Tuesday, December 02, 2008

The Churchill Series - Dec. 2, 2008

(One of a series of weekday posts about the life of Winston S. Churchill.)

Readers Note: Today I found the following post prepared for publication in Dec. 2005.

It appears it wasn't published. I can't explain why not.

Whatever the case, I'm happy to publish it today.

John
__________________________________

A November, 2005 press release from a UK National Achieves says:

A document unearthed today as part of Archive Awareness Campaign, and as part of National Tree Week, reveals that Winston Churchill was not only a fearsome wartime leader but also a keen environmentalist.

A concerned member of the public wrote to Churchill in 1954 to warn him of the decimation of forests throughout Surrey as well as the lopping of trees in Hyde Park and Kensington Gardens. Churchill was sufficiently concerned to request a "special note" on this subject.

He wrote to the Minister of Works:
"What is this you have been doing in the parks? Let me have a special note. It is a dreadful thing to cut down a tree which has life in it."
The Minister of Works replied straight away, defending the lopping and chopping as necessary. When trees were in old age, diseased or were dangerous they would be destroyed but replanting was going on at the same time. The document, held at The National Archives in Kew, West London, records the whole correspondence and shows that Churchill was satisfied that responsible tree-felling was taking place
No doubt Churchill was satisfied with “responsible tree-felling." He did a lot of that at his home, Chartwell, where he ordered trees cut to improve views and allow for building.

Churchill was a "keen environmentalist" as the term was used in his day. He built gardens and fish ponds. He loved to be out in the countryside steeple-chasing, polo-playing, fox-hunting, and grouse and stag shooting.

But would Churchill qualify as a "keen environmentalist" today? What would he make of a Barbara Streisand owning a 10 thousand gallon, heated pool while urging other woman to hang clothes on a line to save energy? Or Robert Kennedy Jr. criticizing as energy hogs people who drive SUVs while Kennedy owns four large houses and frequently travels by private jet.

And now, ladies and gentlemen, those three keen environmentalists: Barbra Streisand, Winston Churchill, and Robert Kennedy Jr.

No, it doesn't work, does it.

Duke filing against insurer in connection with lax suits

Readers Note: As first published, this post contained two citation errors as you'll see if you read the comment thread. The errors have now been corrected.

My thanks to the Anon who called them to my attention.

John
_________________________________________


A Dec. 1 Chronicle story begins - - -

Duke has filed suit seeking compensatory and punitive damages from National Union Fire Insurance Company for refusing to pay the expenses of the University's settlements with members of the 2005-2006 men's lacrosse team.

The suit stems from a dispute between Pittsburgh-based National Union-an affiliate of American Insurance Group, Inc.-and United Educators Insurance, another company with which Duke has a policy, The (Durham) Herald-Sun reported Nov. 26. The two insurance companies are wrangling over who is obligated to cover the University's legal expenses for a settlement with the three wrongly indicted former lacrosse players, sources told The Herald-Sun. …

The entire Chronicle story’s here.

I’ve read the Duke and Duke Health Systems complaint filing. (pdf)

The complaint says National Union has failed to pay any compensation not only in connection with actions brought by members of the 2005-2006 men’s lacrosse team, but by Coach Mike Pressler as well.

In addition to the settlement with the three wrongly indicted students later declared innocent by the NC attorney general, separate suits have been brought by three team members (called McFadyen suit in Duke’s filing; more often called the Ekstrand suit), thirty-eight team members and some parents (called Carrington suit ) and Kyle Dowd’s now settled suit in response to grade retaliation.

All those actions are specifically mentioned in the Duke filing as resulting in expenses for which Duke maintains National Union must indemnify it.

There is nothing in Duke’s filing that speaks to a dispute between insurance companies as to which of them must indemnify Duke.

That may simply be because that material doesn’t belong in the filing.

Still, I’m very eager to read the reason(s) National Union gives in its response for its refusal to date to pay one dime in connection with any of the legal actions brought against Duke in connection with its disgraceful and mismanaged Duke lacrosse case actions and inactions.

The Raleigh News & Observer’s account of Duke’s filing is here; the Durham Herald Sun’s account’s here.

None of the three newspapers mentions a date by which National Union must respond.

I have a call in now to its legal office in New York City and will let you know what I learn.

Rare for Indians to carry guns

In a SpiegelOline International Mumbai commentary the following left me thinking how rare it is for Indian civilians to carry guns, something I’m sure the terrorists took into account when they planned their raid.

They walked the streets in pairs and killed anything that moved.

They slaughtered dozens of people in the train station, moving platform to platform.

They killed random passersby on the streets. They dropped in on a famous café and massacred everyone they could.

They shot down an old couple who had looked out their window to see what was going on.

They blasted people eating in restaurants.

They took over two of the city's most famous hotels and hunted down people room to room in hotels, some of whom managed to survive for days before being murdered. ...
The entire article’s here.

Monday, December 01, 2008

The Churchill Series - Dec. 1, 2008

(One of a series of weekday posts about the life of Winston S. Churchill.)

Something different today.

Todd Ronnei has collected Churchill stamps and covers for 20 years. On November 30 he posted at his Web site a birthday tribute page in honor of the man many of us regard as the greatest Englishman of all time.

You can visit Ronnei’s site here. His birthday tribute here includes a photocopy of an envelope addressed and mailed in England the day of Churchill’s birth.

He sells some Churchill stamps and commemorative covers. See here.

I know very little about stamp and cover collecting but Ronnei has a good reputation and some of his items are only a few dollars.

Economist’s Mumbai article stands out

The Mumbai terrorist attacks have spawned a lot of seat-of-the-pants and just plain wrong reporting and commentary.

But there’s been some careful reporting and thoughtful commentary, too.

Of everything I’ve read coming out of Mumbai, I’d put this Economist,com article – “Terrorism in India: Mumbai counts the cost” – near the top of the “careful, thoughtful” category.

The article closes noting some major political, security and social issues Mumbai and India face. Its last sentence wraps with a wise reminder for India and her friends:

India’s friends and neighbours can hope for a measured reaction, but they should not assume it. After an attack on its national parliament in 2001, India mobilised hundreds of thousands of troops on the border with Pakistan.

The Hindu nationalist Bharatiya Janata Party (BJP), then in power, routinely accuses its successor, the Congress party, of being soft on terrorism.

The desperate spectacle in Mumbai could damage Congress's prospects in pending state polls and even cost it the next general election, which must be held by May. The BJP is now choosing its words carefully but a front-page newspaper advert, presumably commissioned before the Mumbai attacks, accused Congress of being “incapable and unwilling” to fight terror; a sentiment illustrated with a large splatter of blood.

The Indian government, in turn, hopes for restraint from its own people, particularly in crowded, polyglot Mumbai.

The metropolis is sometimes called “Maximum City”, because it is always pressed up hard against its limits. Its commuter trains are crushed with passengers each morning; its squalid slums hum with industry and ambition. No other city in India bears such colossal inconveniences with such phlegmatic grace.

No Mumbaikar would describe the city as liveable; yet many Mumbaikars cannot imagine living anywhere else.

But this attack on its people and landmarks represents an enormous test of Mumbai’s civic temperament. Its assailants may have wished to provoke a backlash against Muslim inhabitants—which in turn would help to radicalise India’s vast Muslim minority.

Even after the last of the terrorists have been killed or captured, that is how they could still hope to win.
The entire Economist.com article's here.

A good news report

from delawareonline - - -

Victim shoots man during robbery try
Holdup suspect tells police he was hit by gang of men

By TERRI SANGINITI
The News Journal

An armed robber who tried to stick up a man Monday night ended up getting shot when the victim pulled out his own gun, police said.

The would-be bandit later told police he was shot by a gang of men who tried to rob him.

The initial holdup happened at 5:45 p.m. in the first block of Chesterfield Drive in Garfield Park, north of New Castle, said Cpl. Trinidad Navarro, a New Castle County police spokesman.

While officers were on their way there, they got another call from the same vicinity about a man who said he was wounded by men who tried to rob him, Navarro said.

Officers talking to the first victim were told that he was taking items out of his car when two men walked up to him and stuck an object he believed to be a gun in his side.

The 37-year-old victim said he thought the assailants were going to shoot him, so he pulled out his own 9 mm handgun and fired one round at them.

The victim wasn't sure whether he hit anyone but heard a loud moan. He then saw the two would-be robbers run in the direction of Bizarre Drive.

Officers who later interviewed the wounded 18-year-old at a home on Bizarre Drive were told he was shot by a group of men who attempted to rob him on Briarcliff Drive.

The man, who suffered a gunshot wound to the upper chest, was reported in stable condition at Christiana Hospital.

Officers investigating the first case on Chesterfield Road recovered the gun from the victim who had placed it in a safe place.

Investigators are now holding the gun as evidence while they continue to investigate, Navarro said.

No charges have been filed pending the outcome of the investigation.

Anyone with information may call Detective Thomas Abram at 395-8110 or Delaware Crime Stoppers at (800) TIP-3333.

It’s a shame a peaceful citizen is set up to be a crime victim. Thank goodness he had a gun with which to defend himself and others who the would be robbers might have targeted later that night.

*********************************************************

My favorite comment on the story thread - - -

What a heartwarming story for the Holiday Season. It is people like this man that was being robbed that show the generosity to share a bullet with a robber that make this country great. God Bless him.

Hat tip: Instapundit


The blame America for Mumbai game

You knew it would be played. You knew you’d read and hear it from the usual blame America first, most and always news orgs such as NPR, the NYT, the BBC, the AP, Reuters and CNN.

But did you think the “blame America” slanders along with their “excuse the Muslims” corollaries would begin even while Mumbai authorities were still counting the dead?

From WSJ editorial writer Dorothy Rabinowitz - - -

If the Mumbai terror assault seemed exceptional, and shocking in its targets, it was clear from the Thanksgiving Day reports that we weren't going to be deprived of the familiar, either. Namely, ruminations, hints, charges of American culpability that regularly accompany catastrophes of this kind.

Soon enough, there was Deepak Chopra, healer, New Age philosopher and digestion guru, advocate of aromatherapy and regular enemas, holding forth on CNN on the meaning of the attacks.

How the ebullient Dr. Chopra had come to be chosen as an authority on terror remains something of a mystery, though the answer may have something to do with his emergence in the recent presidential campaign as a thinker of advanced political views.

Also commending him, perhaps, is his well known capacity to cut through all sorts of complexities to make matters simple. No one can fail to grasp the wisdom of a man who has informed us that "If you have happy thoughts, then you make happy molecules."

In his CNN interview, he was no less clear. What happened in Mumbai, he told the interviewer, was a product of the U.S. war on terrorism, that "our policies, our foreign policies" had alienated the Muslim population, that we had "gone after the wrong people" and inflamed moderates. And "that inflammation then gets organized and appears as this disaster in Bombay." …

Two subsequent interviews with Larry King brought much of the same -- a litany of suggestions about the role the U.S. had played in fueling assaults by Muslim terrorists, reminders of the numbers of Muslims in the world and their grievances.

A faithful adherent of the root-causes theory of crime -- mass murder, in the case at hand -- Dr. Chopra pointed out, quite unnecessarily, that most of the terrorism in the world came from Muslims.

It was mandatory, then, to address their grievances -- "humiliation," "poverty," "lack of education." The U.S., he recommended, should undertake a Marshall Plan for Muslims.

Nowhere in this citation of the root causes of Muslim terrorism was there any mention of Islamic fundamentalism -- the religious fanaticism that has sent fevered mobs rioting, burning and killing over alleged slights to the Quran or the prophet. Not to mention the countless others enlisted to blow themselves and others up in the name of God.

Nor did we hear, in these media meditations, any particular expression of sorrow from the New Delhi-born Dr. Chopra for the anguish of Mumbai's victims: a striking lack, no doubt unintentional, but not surprising, either.

For advocates of the root-causes theory of crime, the central story is, ever, the sorrows and grievances of the perpetrators. For those prone to the belief that most eruptions of evil in the world can be traced to American influence and power there is only one subject of consequence. . . .

So natural does it feel, now, to hold such views that their expression has become second nature.

Which is how it happens also that the U.S. is linked to the bloodletting in Mumbai, with scarcely anyone batting an eye, and Larry King -- awash perhaps, in happy molecules -- thanking guest Dr. Chopra for his extraordinary enlightenment.

Rabinowitz’s entire column here.

I hope you give it a read.

Hat tip: Realclearpolitics.com

Mumbai, Muslims and Other: Steyn has it right

Mark Steyn in the Washington Times - - -

When terrorists attack, media analysts go into Sherlock Holmes mode, metaphorically prowling the crime scene for footprints, as if the way to solve the mystery is to add up all the clues.

The Bombay gunmen seized British and American tourists. Therefore, it must be an attack on Westerners!

Not so, said Newsweek's Fareed Zakaria.

If they had wanted to do that, they would have hit the Hilton or the Marriott or some other target-rich chain hotel. The Taj and the Oberoi are both Indian-owned, and popular watering holes with wealthy Indians.

OK, how about this group that's claimed credit for the attack? The Deccan Mujahideen.

As a thousand TV anchors asked on Wednesday night, "What do we know about them?"

Er, well, nothing. Because they didn't exist until they issued the press release. "Deccan" is the name of the vast plateau that covers most of the triangular peninsula that forms the lower half of the Indian Subcontinent.. . .."

OK. So does that mean this operation was linked to al Qaeda? Well, no.

Not if by "linked to" you mean a wholly owned subsidiary coordinating its activities with the corporate head office.

It's not an either/or scenario, it's all of the above.

Yes, the terrorists targeted locally owned hotels. But they singled out Britons and Americans as hostages.

Yes, they attacked prestige city landmarks like the Victoria Terminus, one of the most splendid and historic railway stations in the world.

But they also attacked an obscure Jewish community center.

The Islamic imperialist project is a totalitarian ideology: It is at war with Hindus, Jews, Americans, Britons - everything that is other. , , ,

Steyn’s entire column’s here.

War on “everything that is other” nails it

Sunday, November 30, 2008

Stunning Raleigh N&O circulation numbers

Last Tuesday, Nov. 25, readers of the McClatchy Company’s Raleigh News & Observer found splashed across the first page of the N&O’s Triangle & Co. section a story headlined “N&O photos still tell the hot stories.”

The story’s accompanied by a five-column-wide photo of the above the fold portion of the N&O's May 28, 1957 front page.

After scanning that 1957 N&O edition’s headline – “Legislators’ Liquor Arrives On Time” – I noticed a small item in the upper right-hand corner of the page.

It read:
Yesterday’s Paid Circulation – 125, 401.

The N&O’s May 28, 1957 announcement of paid circulation the previous day of 125,401 brought to mind a very recent post –
Raleigh N&O’s print circulation drops - in which I reported current N&O Sunday and weekly (M-F) paid print circulation.

Extract from that post - - -

According to the ABC [Audit Bureau of Circulations] … for the six-month period Apr-Sept. 30, 2008, the N&O had a daily circulation (M-F) of 159,000. (ABC circulation numbers and U. S. Census numbers to follow rounded to the nearest thousand)

Also according to the ABC, during the same [period] the N&O’s Sunday circulation [was] 206,000.


Now, readers, hold on to those numbers while I drop a few more numbers “on the table.”

At WakeGov.com you'll find 1960 U.S. Census population for the N&O's home county - Wake- given as 169,000.

Also at WakeGov.com you'll find July 1, 2007 U.S. Census population for Wake County given as 833,000.

Using the U.S. Census population numbers for 2007 and 1960, and subtracting from Wake's 2007 population (833,000) the 1960 Wake population of 169,000, yields a difference of 664,000.

Thus, according to U.S. Census reporting the population of Wake County grew between 1960 and 2007 by 664,000.

Now, if you take the ABC's N&O daily (M-F) print circulation finding of 159,000 for the period ending Sept. 30, 2008 and subtract from it the N&O's Monday, May 27,1957 print circulation of 125,000 (rounded to nearest thousand), you have a difference of 34,000.

So during the last half-century or so, the population of the N&O's home county and the core of its circulation area has grown by 664,000 while its daily (M-F) circulation has grown by 34,000.

If you're a McClatchy stockholder, an N&O advertiser, or an employee at the N&O, are the numbers in this post a surprise to you?

How about those of you who are N&O readers? Or those of you who are following the decline of what some media analysts call "the dead tree media?"

I found them stunning.

Look for more posts soon concerning the N&O's circulation.

Traveling today

Blogging resumes about 9 PM ET tonight.

Look for posts on some Raleigh N&O circulation history, Duke's disputes (now before a court) with its insurers who are refusing to pay for expenses in connection with suits growing out of Duke shameful response to the Mangum/Nifong lies and the frame-up attempt which followed, and a post concerning some now largly forgotten Jesse Jackson actions that are very much in character with the Jackson we know.

John

Attention Sen. Reid: Iraq War wasn’t lost

Investors Business Daily reminds us of that - - -

Nineteen months after Senate Majority Leader Harry Reid declared the war "lost," a freely elected Iraqi Parliament signs a security pact with the United States. We won. It is the terrorists and their appeasers who lost.

While Americans sat down for Thanksgiving dinner deciding what they were thankful for, the Iraqi parliament Thursday passed an agreement with the U.S. that set a date certain for American withdrawal, as war critics wanted. But it was based on conditions on the ground, as the Bush administration insisted.

The conditions on the ground are that the jihadists are a spent force that lost the war as well as the hearts and minds of the Iraqi people.

Province after province has been returned to Iraqi control, and the young Iraqi nation appears both willing and able to defend itself. . . .

The entire IBS editorial's here.

Iraq still has a long struggle ahead before it secures the domestic peace typical of a stable democracy.

It will certainly come under attack from terrorists bent on destabilizing the country and increasing their own power.

It exists in a very rough part of the world where neighbors are often enemies.

It has an ethnically fractious population.

Corruption is a major problem that will hold back economic growth so essential to domestic peace and the ability of the country to arm and defend itself.

With all of that in mind, I can’t bring myself to says simply, “It’s over. We won.”
There are tough days and severe trial ahead of Iraq.

But it has a chance to become a functioning democracy with all the good that can be for its people, the Middle East and the world.

I wish the new Iraq well.

For President Bush, General Petraeus and our magnificent forces serving there and their families, my admiration and three full-throated cheers.

What about Sen. Reid? Has anyone heard from him lately?

Pakistan Now Won’t Send Intel Chief to India

Yesterday I posted India pressures Pakistan for terrorist intel. I said Pakistan’s agreement to send its ISI chief, rather than a subordinate, to New Delhi in response to a demand from Indian PM Singh had something of the feeling of a school boy being called to the Principal’s office and was a tacit admission of a Pakistan connection to the Mumbai.

Now with tensions and national feelings in both countries escalating, Pakistan has reversed itself.

From a Washington Post report:

. . .Pakistan reversed a decision to send its spy chief to aid India's investigation, saying it would send a lower-level official. But officials said they would help India identify and capture those behind the attacks.
The entire WaPo story's here.

Saturday, November 29, 2008

Mumbai: Don’t buy the “only 10 attackers” claim

The NYT Company owned International Herald Tribune self-describes as “The Global Edition of the New York Times.”

It’s much worse (read more leftist) than the NYT, but that’s for another post.

The IHT’s latest story on the Mumbai terror attacks got one thing right that many news orgs are getting wrong.

ITH reported, but didn’t swallow, the claim that only 10 (or in some stories only 12) men were responsible for all the killings, hostage-taking and other carnage.

The IHT reported:

…Perhaps the most troubling question to emerge Saturday for the Indian authorities was how, if official estimates are accurate, just 10 gunmen could have caused so much carnage and repelled Indian police officers, paramilitary forces and soldiers for more than three days in three different buildings. …
But then, in the following paragraph,the ITH let readers know it wasn’t swallowing the “just 10” claim:
As the investigation continued, it was unclear whether the attackers had collaborators already in the city, or whether others in their group had escaped. All told, the gunmen struck 10 sites in bustling south Mumbai (emphasis added)….
As we learn more about these attacks, we’ll learn there were many more than 10 terrorists directly involved in the Mumbai killings, hostage-taking and other carnage as well as many dozen more who supported them from the initial planning through the attacks and were no doubt ready to aide those terrorist who might survive the attacks.

The entire IHT story’s here.

More tomorrow.

Law prof’s requiem for his NY Times subscription

Kenneth Anderson’s a professor of law at American University’s Washington College of Law. He also blogs at the Law of War and Just War Theory Blog.

Anderson recently asked himself: Why pay $600 a year for home delivery for a partisan opinion magazine available free on the web?


After decades of being subscribers, my wife and I are giving up our home delivery of the New York Times here in Washington, D.C. We’re going online for free, like everyone else we know.

Pajamas Media readers must be wondering how it could have occurred to anyone, especially outside of New York City, to subscribe in the first place, not why we would have decided to give it up. It’s expensive: $56 a month, which is over $600 a year in what are soon to be scarcer post-tax Obama dollars. And it’s biased, obviously; zero argument there.

If it falls financially for some reason I can’t yet foresee on account of the sheer mendacity of its front-page performance this election cycle, I’ll shed no tears and lift a glass to karma.

But cut us a break — my wife is a native New Yorker, I lived there forever, and even after a dozen years in D.C., the Times is still the hometown paper. And anyway, one of the asymmetries between right and left intellectuals (I’m a center-right law professor lost in a sea of left-wingers for whom Obama is savior but still scarcely radical enough) is that the right, being an intellectual counterculture, reads across the political spectrum.

It has to, merely to be part of the conversation. Whereas the left? I doubt most of my colleagues have heard, for example, of the Weekly Standard, let alone read it. Pajamas Media? Forget about it.

No, the fundamental question is not whether one should read the New York Times. The question is whether (forgetting about the incontrovertible fact that it’s expensive on paper and free online) one should ever pay for it.

And that is a question about the New York Times’ evolving business model — the question interacts with the politicization and deep partisanship of the paper, but is still separate from it. What exactly are subscribers paying for? …

Anderson goes on to provide a penetrating, informed synopsis of the Times’ development since the early 1990s. Most interesting to me was his explanation of how the Times’ readership has influenced the paper’s development into a magazine in which facts take second place to opinions that fit its readers views.

Anderson concludes - - -

Magazines are wonderful things. But there is a difference between them and daily newspapers.

The newspaper says “this happened today,” and frankly that’s enough to justify the paper’s existence.

The magazine, by definition, is an analysis and commentary on events — and for that reason, magazines are weekly or monthly events, not dailies. At their best, magazines are informed opinion — each of those a separate requirement.

But they are always a matter of opinion. And that’s what the Times showcased on its front pages. A magazine of opinion.

The problem, from a business model standpoint, is that the Times is not a magazine. It is a daily. In order to price its product as the daily news, however, the Times has very deliberately asserted that its opinions are actually facts.

We Pajamas Media reader/media critics tend to think of that as a political move, and it is. But it is also firmly located in the business model of a newspaper turning itself into a magazine — but trying to grapple with daily publication. It promotes itself as offering the facts, and charges for its front-page opinions as thought they were facts.

Anderson’s entire post’s here.

Be sure to read the comments at least as far down as the fellow who speaks up for the quality of the Times’ crossword puzzles.



Where, O Where’s Kyoto

Canwest News reporting, followed by my comments.

Canwest begins - - -

PARIS - There is both growing public reluctance to make personal sacrifices and a distinct lack of enthusiasm for the major international efforts now underway to battle climate change, according to findings of a poll of 12,000 citizens in 11 countries, including Canada.

Results of the poll were released this week in advance of the start of a major international conference in Poland where delegates are considering steps toward a new international climate-change treaty to replace the Kyoto Protocol, which expires in 2012.

There already are reports emerging that some countries, such as coal-dependent Poland, are pushing for special treatment to avoid making major commitments to slash carbon emissions during a global economic downturn.

Less than half of those surveyed, or 47 per cent, said they were prepared to make personal lifestyle changes to reduce carbon emissions, down from 58 per cent last year.

Only 37 per cent said they were willing to spend "extra time" on the effort, an eight-point drop.

And only one in five respondents - or 20 per cent - said they'd spend extra money to reduce climate change. That's down from 28 per cent a year ago.

The Canadian results, from a poll of 1,000 respondents conducted in September, were virtually identical to the overall figures. ….

The entire article’s here.

Comments:

My reaction to this story: Is anyone surprised?

If there had been any real interest in implementing Kyoto’s provisions and standards, nations could have gone ahead and implemented them.

The real Kyoto “implementation” these past eight years has been to beat President Bush and the U. S. over the head for “not agreeing to the treaty and taking the lead in implementing its provision.”

Foreign countries and most of the international and domestic MSM have had a jolly time playing Green Goodies while hammering President Bush and America.

But folks, did you hear much mention of Kyoto during the recent presidential election campaign?

Any NYT or WaPo editorial demanding Sen. Obama promise to begin the process of implementing Kyoto during his “first hundred days?”

And now we learn they’ll soon be a “major international conference” to consider “steps toward a new international climate-change treaty.”

World’s easiest predictions: 1) The conference will result in a new, “stronger” commitment to address climate change; 2) It will be as effective as Kyoto.

BTW - If some of you recall reading over the last eight years how some European nations were “making progress toward meeting reduced emissions” and the like, just about all those “reductions” happened at the time the nations were suffering severe economic growth problems – unemployment at 10% or higher; GDP at 1% or lower, etc.


Friday, November 28, 2008

India pressures Pakistan for terrorist intel

This from the Press Trust of India - - -

New Delhi/Islamabad, Nov 28 (PTI) Angered by the Mumbai terror strikes, India today forced Pakistan to send its ISI [Inter-Services Intelligence] chief here to provide evidence about the role of Pakistan- based "elements" in the "outrageous" attacks as it made clear that the bilateral ties would be hurt if these don't stop.

Prime Minister Manmohan Singh told Pakistan President Asif Ali Zardari and Prime Minister Yousuf Raza Gilani that investigators had found involvement of Pakistan-based elements in the attacks in the commercial capital.He told Gilani that Pakistan should send its ISI chief Lt Gen Shuja Pasha to New Delhi "to cooperate in the investigations of the Mumbai attack and for sharing certain information".

Pakistan agreed to Singh's proposal and said Pasha would travel to New Delhi soon, for which modalities would be worked out by the two sides.During the telephonic conversation with Singh, Zardari assured him that Islamabad "will cooperate with India in exposing and apprehending the culprits and masterminds behind" the attacks in Mumbai.

The President told Singh "non-state actors wanted to force upon the governments their own agenda but they must not be allowed to succeed. We should not fall into the trap of the militants."

[Indian] External Affairs Minister Pranab Mukherjee called up his counterpart Shah Mehmood Qureshi, who is in New Delhi, and bluntly told him that if "outrages" like Mumbai attack don't stop, it would be "impossible" to ensure a "leap" in the bilateral relations that is desired.
_______________________________________________

Comments:

What to make of Pakistan’s willingness to send to India its top intel chief, Lt. Gen. Shuria Pasha, rather than a high ranking subordinate?

For Pakistan, there’s a high degree of humiliation involved when the PM of a neighbor country with whom its often warred and now has a most uneasy “peace” issues what amounts to a public summons for it chief intel officer to come to New Delhi in connection with terrorists attacks India’s left no doubt it believes were planned and supported by people in Pakistan.

PM’s Singh’s summons has something of the feel of the school boy being called to the Principal’s office.

I take Pakistan’s agreement to send it top intel chief to New Delhi as a sign India has already let Pakistan know in a way Pakistan can verify, that India has irrefutable intel which incriminates in the Mumbai attacks members of Pakistan’s civil government, military and ISI.

India takes it as a given some authorities in Pakistan support terrorists bent on attacking India. Justice for those people may have to wait a while.

What the Indians wants to know right now from the Paha is who in India sheltered and abetted the terrorists and how the terrorists slipped into India.

The Indian’s will no doubt need to do some arm-twisting to get that information.

What can they hold over the Pakistanis?

India is a nuclear armed nation, but it surely won’t go that route or even threaten it.

Most likely the card India will play involves the U. S. as an intelligence ally and a force which, along with India, can do a lot to destabilize an already shaky Pakistani government.

In the present situation, Pakistan can’t look to China for much help.

The Chinese are already angry at the Pakistani government for not doing enough to reign in Muslim terrorists operating in Western China with their support bases in Pakistan.

What do you folks think?

Here's Wiki's entry on Pakistan's ISI.

Update @ 11/30/08 @ 9 AM ET: Pakistan now won't send intel chief to India

Here’s good news

From James Hibberd’s The Live Feed, a daily news site covering the television industry - - -

NBC's Rosie O’Donnell variety show disappoints

The network's attempt to revive the primetime variety show failed to draw an audience Wednesday night, tying for the evening's lowest-rated program.

A mere 5 million viewers tuned in for the 8 p.m. premiere of "Rosie Live," with the program earning a 1.2 preliminary adults 18-49 rating. The telecast matched ABC's recently canceled "Pushing Daisies" as the night's lowest-rated program on a major broadcast network.

NBC had high hopes for the special and planned to expand the program into a series should viewers re-embrace the decades-old variety format. Other networks, too, were watching closely since several are developing variety shows of their own.

"There's a notion that the climate is right for the genre to make a comeback," emailed one executive at a rival network. "I guess we now know what not to do, thanks to Rosie."

Segments included Kathy Griffin impersonating Nancy Grace, Alec Baldwin hitting Conan O'Brian with a pie, O'Donnell singing "City Lights" with Liza Minnelli and Jane Krakowski doing a product-placement-themed striptease for White Castle burgers and Crest Whitestrips.

Critics were not kind. The NY Times described it as "hokey comedy with an enemies list." TV Guide called it a "ghastly ego trip." And the LA Times asked, "Rosie, what on earth were you thinking?" ….

Hibberd’s entire report’s here.

As for what on earth Rosie was thinking, I’d guess it was that her basic cheap and nasty programming that’s worked for her in the past will work now.


Thursday, November 27, 2008

Blogging will resume

tomorrow, Friday, at about Noon ET.

Happy Thanksgiving.

John

Thanksgiving wishes

I want to wish all the thoughtful, helpful, caring people who visit and comment at JinC a very Happy Thanksgiving and all God's blessings.

You add a great deal to this blog and I don't doubt to the well-being of many who pass your way.

Best,

John

In sympathy and solidarity with Mumbai and the Indian government

Readers Note: A link to this post with a covering email is being sent to the Indian Embassy in Washington.

John
_____________________________________________

Like all decent Americans, the decent people who visit this blog express to the people of Mumbai and the Indian government our deep sympathy for the victims and their families.

We are in solidarity with the government of India in its fight against terrorists who seek to destroy peace and democracy in India and the rest of the world.

They are the enemies of all good people. The world must rid itself of them.

We hold in admiration and gratitude the members of the Indian serving forces, police, rescue and medical personnel who are now combating the terrorists and ministering to the victims.

As news becomes available about how we in the States can aid the victims of this latest terrorist atrocity, I will post it.

Thank you to our military and their families

Without the U. S. military, we wouldn't have our freedoms and the plenty we'll share today.

Hundreds of thousands of our men and women are serving all of the world today, often in very dangerous circumstances, to protect us from the likes of the terrorists who've wrecked havoc in Mumbai.

Give thanks for their service and the sacrifices of their families.

Please consider ways you can directly express your thanks.

Operation Valor is one way to do that. It's site is here where you'll read:

Every cent raised for Project Valour-IT goes directly to the purchase and shipment of laptops and other technology for severely wounded service members. As of November 2008, Valour-IT has distributed over 2700 laptops to severely wounded Soldiers, Sailors, Airmen and Marines across the country, and is now expanding its mission to include other technology that supports physical and psychological recovery.

Valour-IT accepts donations in any amount to support our mission, but also offers a sponsorship option for laptops. An individual or organization may sponsor a wounded soldier by completely funding the cost of a laptop and continuing to provide that soldier with personal support and encouragement throughout recovery. This has proved to be an excellent project for churches, groups of coworkers or friends, and members of community organizations such Boy Scouts.

Originally Valour-IT provided the voice-controlled software that accompanies the laptops, but now works closely with the Department of Defense Computer/electronic Accommodations Program (CAP): CAP supplies the adaptive software and Valour-IT provides the laptop.

In addition, DoD caseworkers serve as Valour-IT’s “eyes and ears” at several medical centers, identifying patients in need of laptops and other technological support for their recovery.

Wounded military personnel can also directly request a laptop through the sign-up form or through the Valour-IT/Soldiers' Angels representatives at the following medical centers:

* Balboa Naval Hospital

* Brooke Army Medical Center

* Madigan Regional Medical Center

* National Naval Medical Center (Bethesda Naval Hospital)

* Naval Hospital, Camp Pendleton

* Robert E. Bush Naval Hospital (29 Palms)

* Walter Reed Army Medical Center
____________________________________________

Project Valor is part of Soldiers' Angels whose Web site you can visit here.

Hat tip: Ace of Spades HQ

Laughter at the Thanksgiving table

Do the adults in your family sit around the table after Thanksgiving dinner reminiscing and telling funny stories?

We do in mine. Here, clipped from JinC posts, are a few humorous anecdotes you might want to share with you family.

Whatever the case, I hope they leave you smiling.

John
_____________________________________



Isaaac Stern was being interviewed by Bill Moyers or some other self-important MSM-type who kept mentioning his age, 72 at the time, and asking Stern questions like: "As you look back at your career, what do ..." and "Do you have a favorite concert you'd like to be remembered for?"

Stern finally had enough.

"Look, I may be 72 but I don't think my career is over. And I feel like I'm just in the middle of my life. Of course, it would help if I knew someone who was 144."

Four Bill Buckley stories - - -

From my memory:

Buckley once said given a choice between being governed by the Harvard faculty or the first 500 people listed in the Boston phone directory, he'd go with the phone directory.

He received a letter from an irate National Review reader telling him in great detail what a miserable editor he was. The letter ended with "cancel my subscription."

Buckley wrote back that he certainly had shortcomings and would try to do better. But as for canceling the subscription, he told the reader, "Dammit, cancel it yourself."

These from a Jeff Jacoby column:

When asked why Robert Kennedy was refusing to appear on his Firing Line interview program, Buckley asked "Why does baloney resist the meat grinder?"

A National Review editorial comment began: "The attempted assassination of Sukarno last week had all the earmarks of a CIA operation. Everyone in the room was killed except Sukarno."

Enjoy Thanksgiving.

"Being thus arived in a good harbor"

(I publish this post each Thanksgiving Day. -- John)

From the journal of William Bradford, Pilgrim leader and second Governor of Plymouth Colony (spellings as in the original):

"Being thus arived in a good harbor and brought safe to land, they fell upon their knees & blessed ye God of heaven, who had brought them over ye vast & furious ocean, and delivered them from all ye periles & miseries therof, againe to set their feete on ye firme and stable earth, their proper elemente. And no marvell if they were thus joyefull, seeing wise Seneca was so affected with sailing a few miles on ye coast of his owne Italy; as he affirmed, that he had rather remaine twentie years on his way by land, then pass by sea to any place in a short time; so tedious & dreadfull was ye same unto him.

But hear I cannot but stay and make a pause, and stand half amased at this poore peoples presente condition; and so I thinke will the reader too, when he well considered ye same. Being thus passed ye vast ocean, and a sea of troubles before in their preparation (as may be remembred by yt which wente before), they had now no friends to wellcome them, nor inns to entertaine or refresh their weatherbeaten bodys, no houses or much less townes to repaire too, to seeke for succoure. ..

Let it also be considred what weake hopes of supply & succoure they left behinde them, yt might bear up their minds in this sade condition and trialls they were under; and they could not but be very smale. It is true, indeed, ye affections & love of their brethren at Leyden was cordiall & entire towards them, but they had litle power to help them, or them selves; and how ye case stode betweene them & ye marchants at their coming away, hath already been declared.

What could not sustaine them but ye spirite of God & his grace? May not & ought not the children of these fathers rightly say : Our faithers were Englishmen which came over this great ocean, and were ready to perish in this willdernes; but they cried unto ye Lord, and he heard their voyce, and looked on their adversitie…"

A Thanksgiving Lesson

(This post was first published last Thanksgiving Day.)

John Stossel at RealClearPolitics.com:

Every year around this time, schoolchildren are taught about that wonderful day when Pilgrims and Native Americans shared the fruits of the harvest. "Isn't sharing wonderful?" say the teachers.

They miss the point.

Because of sharing, the first Thanksgiving in 1623 almost didn't happen.

The failure of Soviet communism is only the latest demonstration that freedom and property rights, not sharing, are essential to prosperity. The earliest European settlers in America had a dramatic demonstration of that lesson, but few people today know it.

When the Pilgrims first settled the Plymouth Colony, they organized their farm economy along communal lines. The goal was to share everything equally, work and produce.

They nearly all starved.

Why?

When people can get the same return with a small amount of effort as with a large amount, most people will make little effort. Plymouth settlers faked illness rather than working the common property. Some even stole, despite their Puritan convictions.

Total production was too meager to support the population, and famine resulted. Some ate rats, dogs, horses and cats. This went on for two years.

"So as it well appeared that famine must still ensue the next year also, if not some way prevented," wrote Gov. William Bradford in his diary. The colonists, he said, "began to think how they might raise as much corn as they could, and obtain a better crop than they had done, that they might not still thus languish in misery. At length after much debate of things, [I] (with the advice of the chiefest among them) gave way that they should set corn every man for his own particular, and in that regard trust to themselves. ... And so assigned to every family a parcel of land."

The people of Plymouth moved from socialism to private farming. The results were dramatic.

"This had very good success," Bradford wrote, "for it made all hands very industrious, so as much more corn was planted than otherwise would have been. ... By this time harvest was come, and instead of famine, now God gave them plenty, and the face of things was changed, to the rejoicing of the hearts of many. ... "

Because of the change, the first Thanksgiving could be held in November 1623
Near the end of his column Stossel says:
What private property does -- as the Pilgrims discovered -- is connect effort to reward, creating an incentive for people to produce far more. Then, if there's a free market, people will trade their surpluses to others for the things they lack. Mutual exchange for mutual benefit makes the community richer.
Now what about countries that don’t have free market economies?

Well, Cuba and North Korea are the two I’ve read the most about.

I often give thanks I don’t live in either of them.

Even Princeton professor and NY Times columnist Paul Krugman, for all his advocacy of government solutions, doesn't want to live in either place.

Stossel’s entire column is here.

The Churchill Series - Nov. 26, 2008

(One of a series of weekday posts about the life of Winston S. Churchill.)

Churchill was always interested in mail from the public. Naturally he couldn't read it all, but staff did; and Churchill had staff keep a tally of the letters by categories he determined. The categories were a mix of "perennials" and subjects of current interest.

Here's the list he made and count for the week of April 2, 1955, when his retirement as Prime Minister was widely rumored:

Requests for autographs, photographs - 45

Foreign letters - 23

On the atom bomb and H-bomb - 21

Requests not to retire - 42

Congratualtion and good wishes - 30

"Lunatics" - 76

____________________________________________________
Martin Gilbert,
Winston S. Churchill: Never Despair. (p. 1117)

Wednesday, November 26, 2008

Latest on Coleman - Franken recount battle

Weekly Standard's blog reports - - -

Board Unanimously Rejects Franken Petition to Include Rejected Absentee Ballots in Recount

CNN reports:

Minnesota's Canvassing Board voted unanimously to reject Franken's request to include thousands of absentee ballots that are not included in the recount in the Minnesota senate race between the Democratic challenger and Republican incumbent Norm Coleman.

The Canvassing Board, which oversees the recount, stressed during a hearing today, that they weren't rejecting the merits made by Franken's attorneys. The panel also indicated that the fight over the exclusion of the absentee ballots from the recount will most likely land in court. ...

The Minneapolis Star Tribune's story just posted is here.

WSJ’s Fund warns “Minnesota nice” may change soon

Al Franken’s demanding to know the identity of every voter whose absentee ballot was rejected.

The WSJ’s John Fund, an expert in election law, judicial rulings on same and vote fraud is concerned about where the Minnesota Senate seat recount appears to be heading.

Fund reports - - -

… Intent on harvesting absentee ballots, the Franken campaign has presented affidavits from four voters who claim their ballots were improperly rejected. It hopes to find more, now that a Ramsey County judge has agreed to a Franken demand that it have access to data from that county on whose absentee ballots had been rejected.

After initially saying rejected absentee ballots shouldn't be part of the recount, the secretary of state's office now says the information should be made public.

If the absentee names are made public, a mad scramble will ensue to contact those voters and get them to demand their ballots be counted. That's just what happened in the 2004 governor's race in Washington State after King County Judge Dean Lum allowed local Democrats access to the list of provisional voters that hadn't been counted because either there was no signature or no match between the signature and the voter registration on file with officials.

Judge Lum's ruling was criticized by many election lawyers because, in the 2002 Help America Vote Act, Congress stipulated that provisional ballot votes remain private -- a provision mirrored by Washington State's constitution.

But Judge Lum ruled such arguments weren't as important as the need to make sure every vote counted -- an echo of the arguments Democrats made during Florida's 2000 recount.

His ruling set off a partisan hunt for votes. Ryan Bianchi, communications assistant for Ms. Gregoire, told the Seattle Times that Democratic volunteers asked voters if they had cast ballots for Ms. Gregoire. "If they say no, we just tell them to have a nice day," he said. Only if they said yes did Democrats ask if they wanted to make their ballots valid.

Margot Swanson, a voter in Redmond who forgot to sign her ballot, told me she was contacted by phone and asked whom she voted for. When she said Republican Dino Rossi, the caller quickly hung up. "I puzzled out there might be a problem with my ballot, and I found out there was," she said. "But I would never have known from the tricky call I got."

Republicans played catch-up by belatedly using their own phone banks to call voters. But Democrats turned in some 600 written oaths from people declaring how they had intended to vote, and Republicans about 200. Those ballots were all counted, and made the difference in the race. . . .

There’s more before Fund closes with - - -

If the strategy of adding previously rejected ballots to the Minnesota Senate recount is successful, a final outcome could be months away. In 1975, the U.S. Senate refused to accept New Hampshire's certification that Republican Louis Wyman had won by two votes.

The seat was vacant for seven months, with the Senate debate spanning 100 hours and six unsuccessful attempts to break a filibuster and vote on who should be seated. The impasse ended only when a special election was agreed to, which was won by Democrat John Durkin.

Given how critical Minnesota's election is for the outcome of filibusters, don't be surprised if this recount becomes "Washington mean" when the Senate convenes in January.

Fund’s entire column’s here.


N&O’s “smoke and mirrors” can’t hide circulation losses

I recently posted Raleigh N&O's print circulation drops.

One of the points I made was that the McClatchy Company’s Raleigh News & Observer doesn’t regularly report its print circulation numbers as provided by the Audit Bureau of Circulations.

Naturally, that makes it hard to systematically track and assess the N&O’s circulation, which in recent years has been declining both in actual numbers and as a percent of population in the N&O’s circulation area.

In this post, I want to give you a sample of the “smoke and mirrors” approach the N&O now takes to “reporting” its print circulation – the principal factor determining its revenue – followed by an example of how I try to get as accurate a picture as possible of what’s actually happening with N&O print circulation.

Let’s start with a portion of a March 30, 2008 post - N&O says it'll be "greater than ever - which began - -

A big part of the Raleigh News & Observer’s Q Section today is devoted to telling readers how great the N&O is now and how swiftly and smartly it’s moving to make the paper, in the words of executive editor for news John Drescher, even “greater than ever.”

N&O publisher Orage Quarles III, Drescher, editorial page editor Steve Ford, and other senior editors all have columns in the Q which beat the “better than ever” drum.

But!

But instead of headlining the Q Section with the question:

WHAT IS THE FUTURE OF THE N&O?

the headline should have asked:

CAN THE N&O FOOL YOU YET AGAIN?

Let’s look at Drescher’s and Quarles’ columns. You already have links to them and I’ll provide links again at the post’s end. Now extracts from the columns in italics with my comments in plain.

First, from Drescher’s column titled “The N&O is winning new readers” - - -

More people are reading The N&O than ever.

In fact, depending on how you slice the numbers, our growth in readership is faster than the growth in population in the Triangle -- one of the fastest-growing areas in the country.

What?

How can that be?

Aren't newspapers dying?

It's true that revenue is down for most of us.

But for many newspapers, including this one, readership is up.

When you add our paid print circulation to our online readership, more people than ever are reading The N&O. By far.


All Drescher has offered so far concerning circulation is “smoke and mirrors.”

He provides nothing that lets you compare N&O print circulation year-by-year, and nothing that lets you compare print circulation growth to population growth in the N&O’s circulation area.

Our future depends on our ability to sustain this growth -- and for advertisers to recognize that more people than ever are turning to The N&O for news, sports, business, features and commentary.

In the past decade, our Sunday print circulation has grown every year. Daily circulation has grown every year but one.

But that growth has been slow, especially since the rise of the Internet in the past five years. Our paid daily print circulation has plateaued at about 170,000.


Folks, you see what I mean about his not giving you figures which allow for meaningful assessment of print circulation growth itself and compared to population growth. …

End of portion of March 30, 2008 post.

Now in there amidst all the smoke and mirrors editor Drescher states the N&O’s “paid daily print circulation has plateaued at about 170,000.”

Since just before mentioning that he talked about the N&O’s Sunday print circulation which for some years has been above 200, 000, I think we’re safe to assume Drescher’s 170,000 number refers to what the Audit Bureau of Circulations refers to as daily (M-F) circulation.

In that case Drescher’s “about 170,000” print circulation number can be compared to the ABC report for the period Apr. 1 – Sept. 30, 2008 which reported a daily (M-F) print circulation for the N&O of 157,000. (See the ABC chart in this post. The ABC reports total numbers. I posted numbers rounded to the nearest thousand.)

Based on what editor Drescher reported on March 30 and what the ABC reported for the following six month period ending Sept. 30, 2008, the N&O’s daily (M-F) print circulation for that period fell about 13,000.

That’s a huge loss.

Who can’t understand why an editor might use “smoke and mirrors” to try to hide it?

N&O finally reports Gattis Street rape suspect’s latest arrest

On Nov. 17 Michael Burch was arrested and charged with rape and other crimes. His bail was set at $1.85 million.

At the time of his arrest, Burch was free on $50 thousand bail awaiting trial on charges growing out of a reported rape on Feb. 11, 2007 at a fraternity party near Duke’s East Campus. The alleged victim was a Duke freshman at the time. She’s since transferred to another school.

The Raleigh News & Observer did not initially report on Burch’s Nov. 17 arrest even after receiving phone calls from area residents.

This Monday, Nov. 24, Duke’s student newspaper, The Chronicle, published a lengthy story on Burch’s most recent arrest. (See here)

The following day the N&O finally reported on the story.

Here’s the N&O story in its entirety, followed by my comments below the star line.

Beneath the lede - "Out on bail, man charged with rape" – the N&O’s story began - - -

A man who was out on bail awaiting trial for second-degree rape was arrested again this month and charged with second-degree rape again.

Michael Jermaine Burch, 23, of 1903 Cherrycrest Drive, Apt. B, was arrested during a traffic stop on Nov. 17, according to police reports. In addition to the rape charge, Burch was accused of first-degree sexual offense and aiding and abetting in a felony that police say occurred June 21 in the 1300 block of Cherrycrest Drive.

Burch was awaiting trial for an incident that investigators say happened Feb. 11, 2007. A court hearing on the case is set for January.

In that case, a Duke University freshman told police she was sexually assaulted at an off-campus fraternity party that drew more than 50 people to a rental property on Gattis Street and spilled outside the duplex.

The 18-year-old accuser told investigators she was sexually assaulted about 3 a.m. in a bathroom.

She went to Duke University Hospital afterward, according to police radio reports.

Burch was 21 at the time, and booked into the Durham County Jail in lieu of $50,000 bail. He was released on bond later that month.

Police have released few details about the arrest this month.

Burch was being held Monday in the Durham County jail with bail set at $1.85 million.

****************************************************

Comments:

The N&O clearly wanted to ignore this story as long as it could.

When forced to report it, it gave the story as little “play” as possible.

The story’s buried in the “B” section under Triangle Briefs.

The lede is small font.

No reporter was bylined. Attribution was “Staff reports”

Staff reports are often nothing more than rewrites of a press release, public documents and even material “lifted” from other news orgs stories. (I’m sure the N&O would say it never lifts.)

Burch is black; the alleged victim at the Gattis Street fraternity party is white.

The N&O will no doubt say that has nothing to do with its treatment of the story.

I don’t believe that.

The entire Chronicle story's here

Tuesday, November 25, 2008

The Churchill Series - Nov. 25, 2008

(One of a series of weekday posts about the life of Winston S. Churchill.)

While a young officer in India, Churchill was very critical of many of the Army's tactics and ranking officers. He put his criticisms into dispatches which he sent off to newspaper editors who were eager to publish them.

Churchill knew he was letting himself in for a great deal of criticism from powerful people with experience much greater than his. But he was prepared for that. He wrote a friend:

"There will not be wanting those who will remind that in this matter my opinion finds no support in age or experience. To such I shall reply that if what is written is false or foolish neither age nor experience should fortify it; and if it is true,it needs no such support."

When I read Churchill's remarks, I thought of something President Lincoln said concerning criticism he knew he was sure to get:

"If the end brings me out all right, what's said against me won't amount to anything. If the end brings me out wrong, ten angels swearing I was right would make no difference."

The words of each of the great men resonate with those of the other. ______________________________________________________________ For the Churchill quote and background see William Manchester, The Last Lion (p. 256-260) For the familiar Lincoln quote I used Google.