Wednesday, November 29, 2006

The Churchill Series – Nov. 29, 2006

(One of a series of weekday posts on the life of Winston S. Churchill.)

This is the second of a three part series in recognition of Churchill birthday, November 30. In each post I’m try to provide a “snapshot” of Churchill at some moment in his life. I mean the “snapshots” to honor the man but I also mean them to provide something different from the typical and well deserved Churchill birthday tributes.

Today’s post focuses on a extremely important contribution Churchill made to the Allied victory in WW II. But it’s not the brilliant, resolute leadership he provided as Prime Minister when “England stood alone” we’ll be talking about. Instead we’ll go back to 1919 and examine something Churchill did then that subsequently proved vital to Britain’s victory in WWII.

In January 1919 the Prime Minister, Lloyd George, appointed Churchill Secretary of State for War and Air. The most immediate and important problem Churchill faced was arranging for the demobilizing of the millions of men from the Army. But another problem had to do with the Royal Air Force.

At the outbreak of WW I the Army and Navy each had their air services which both used primarily for reconnaissance tasks. As the war progressed the size of the air services grew; and along with that grew all the problems of building, maintaining, and providing trained personnel to fly and service the planes. Both the Army and Navy struggled to support their air services. When it was suggested that a separate air service be created to manage the various demands of the growing air services the Army and Navy quickly agreed to pass over the tasks to a newly formed Royal Air Force.

But with the Armistice and peace came the Army and Navy’s demand that the Royal Air Force be deactivated and its functions returned to them. RAF officers objected and made the case for a separate service.

Initially, it seemed the older services would carry the argument; and the RAF would cease to function as a separate service. But Churchill weighed in on the RAF’s side. If was a struggle of many months but eventually the government adopted Churchill’s view and the RAF was preserved as a separate service.

Fast forward now to the summer of 1940 and the Battle of Britain. For many weeks it was uncertain the RAF would win the battle. In the end, the RAF’s victory was, as Wellington said of his victory at Waterloo, a “close run thing.”

The RAF in 1940 was just strong enough to win. If it hadn’t been a separate service for the previous 20 years it would not have been as strong as it was. So we can fairly say one of those made victory possible in the Battle of Britain was the man who was Secretary of State for War and Air in 1919.
_______________________________________________________
Martin Gilbert, Churchill: A Life. ( use the index to locate the issues discussed here)

Are Americans Cheap?

That’s the question ABC correspondent and 20/20 anchor John Stossel considers in an column posted at Realclearpolitics.com. Excerpts:

The New York Times and Washington Post editorialize about America's "stinginess." Former President Jimmy Carter says when it comes to helping others, "The rich states don't give a damn."

Standing outside the White House, the singer Bono told the press that America doesn't do enough to help the needy.

It seems obvious to Bono and President Carter that America offers "crumbs" because the governments of most other wealthy countries distribute a larger percentage of their nations' wealth in foreign aid.

Yes, the U.S. government gave out $20 billion last year, much more than other countries give, but that's only because we are so stupendously wealthy. If you calculate foreign aid as a percentage of our wealth, the United States gives much less than others.[…]
I hope nobody’s getting “steamed” at Stossel. He’s just laying out the case.

Stossel continues:
But wait a second ... when talking aid,[why]talk just about what the government gives? Why conflate America with our government? America is the people. …

America is 300 million private individuals, and their contributions far exceed what government gives. When you include those, America is anything but cheap.

After the Asian Tsunami two years ago, the U.S. government pledged $900 million to tsunami relief. American individuals donated $2 billion -- three times what government gave -- in food, clothing, and cash. Private charities could barely keep up with the donations.

Americans' preference for voluntary contributions over forced giving through government is one way in which Americans differ from other people. (Don't think it's forced? See what happens if you don't pay your taxes.)

Syracuse University professor Arthur Brooks's new book, "Who Really Cares", points out that Americans give more than the citizens of any other country.

Individually, Americans give seven times more money than people in Germany and 14 times more than Italians give. We also volunteer more. …
Strossel says a lot more before closing with:
America is a uniquely charitable country. So when you hear that "Americans are cheap," just remember: We gave $260 billion in charity last year. That's almost $900 for every man, woman, and child.

Of course some people give nothing. Some people are cheap. Which raises the question: Who gives and who doesn't? I'll report on that in my next column.
I’ll be looking for Stossel’s next column. If you see it first, please give me a heads up. I want to post on it. You can read all of his first column here.

Meanwhile, some thoughts:

A huge part of America’s “giving” is the human and finaccial costs of our military. Without America's military sheilding it , what would most of the rest of the world be like?

We know the answer: Darfur, Zimbabwe and North Korea. It certainly wouldn’t be like Europe, Berkeley or your nearby comfy college campus where military recruiters are banned.

The military services and sacrifices of literally tens of millions of Americans during the last century and through today have made the world a much better place than it would otherwise be.

What price can you put on that service and those sacrifices? The trillions Americans have spent since WW II shielding much of the world doesn’t begin to get at the real “costs” Americans have paid out.

American higher education is heavily taxpayer subsidized. Contribute to your favorite private college and you take a tax deduction for what you gave. The burden of the lost tax revenue resulting from your contribution is passed on to other taxpayers.

Americans cheer those who give to private colleges. That’s fine. But people like Jimmy Carter and Bono should keep that in mind when they’re doing their “giving math.”

The Carters and Bonos should also remember that each year Americans welcome to our shores great numbers of foreign citizens who come here and study and train at taxpayer subsidized colleges and universities.

When they complete their educations, most of those foreign citizens will return to their home countries where they’ll offer their fellow citizens the benefits of the education and training they received in America.

Has anyone ever calculated the amount of the taxpayer subsidized dollars that in any given year go into the cost of the education and training of foreign citizens?

That most of us haven’t even thought of that question is a testament to the generosity and good will of the American people.

There is a lot more I could say, but I’ll end here.

What are your thoughts on all of this?

The Tragedy at Duke: Part I

A KC Johnson post today provides a detailed, gripping account of how key Duke University administrators acted when confronted with what was on its face a wildly improbable story involving the gang-rape of a black exotic dancer by a group of white Duke students during a party at a University owned house.

Johnson’s account is based “on e-mail or personal discussions with more than two dozen participants in the campus events" he describes.

Today’s post is the first of a two-post series. The second will appear tomorrow. Johnson posts here, usually just after midnight.

Most of Johnson's post is a day-by-day account with probing commentary concerning what key Duke administrators knew, did and didn’t do beginning on March 16, when police first searched the house, and the three Lacrosse captains living there provided them with extraordinary cooperation, including signed statements and voluntary submission to DNA testing.

Johnson's day-by-day account takes readers up to March 26, one day after the Raleigh News & Observer published it's grossly biased, inflammatory and now thoroughly discredited “anonymous interview” story.

Johnson reports new information concerning events and individuals, including a March 25 meeting attended by some Duke administrators and a large group of lacrosse parents. We also learn more about Dean of Students Sue Wasiolek's role in “arranging” for at least some players to be represented by an attorney of her choosing. What she did seems very questionable.

I hope Wasiolek speaks publicly concerning what Johnson reports. The parents of current Duke students should have been informed months ago of just what it was she did concerning the players. The parents of future Duke students and the public that’s followed the Hoax Case will also be interested to know what Wasiolek did.

For me, the post’s “biggest bombshell” was the report that at least some Duke administrators told some of the players not to tell their parents what was going on.

I hope when I finish this post and go to Duke University’s website there’s already a news release there at least responding to Johnson’s “don’t tell parents” report. If not, I plan to contact Duke News and ask for a statement.

Some of what Johnson’s sources provided is “old news.” For example, President Brodhead refused on March 25 to meet with the players’ parents. But that news still shocks.

What’s more, it raises a very important question Brodhead and the PR people Duke’s retained to “help us get past this” won’t answer: Just why did Brodhead refuse to meet with the parents?

While Johnson's is a “can’t stop reading” post, it’s also almost physically painful to learn that top Duke administrators – President Brodhead, Executive Vice president Tallman Trask III, Dean of Students Sue Wasiolek, Athletic Director Joe Alleva, and others - initially recognized the hoax for what it was, but nevertheless, over the course of many days and for reasons they’ve never explained, frequently acted in ways that at the least enabled the witch hunt and its monumental injustices.

Based on the information Johnson’s sources have provided, it’s even reasonable to ask whether Brodhead’s and other administrators’ actions didn’t, in fact, help make the witch hunt and its injustices inevitable.

Brodhead now tells everyone they shouldn't look back at events at Duke last March and thereafter. He wants us all to “look to the future.”

Johnson’s post makes it easy to understand why Brodhead doesn’t want us looking back. It also helps us understand why Duke’s trustees, top administrators and alumni association officers and directors are so reluctant to talk about what the University did and didn't do in response to the Hoax.

The events that have flowed from the initial false witness have rightly been described as a tragedy for the forty-six victimized students and their families.

Brodhead acknowledges there's been a tragedy at Duke. He’s even assigned himself a role: the well-intentioned but befuddled ditherer new to tragedy and all its complexities.

But Johnson doesn’t let Brodhead walk away with that role.

In the tragedy Johnson describes Brodhead is Cassius, the students and their families are the assassinated Caesar, and the rest of “the Brodhead team” are the other senators,not one of whom evidences any of Brutus’ redeeming qualities.

Back on September 9 I put up a post that included the following:

Brodhead likes to tell alumni groups and others he's been "very fair" to the lacrosse players.

Really?

How was Brodhead's withholding important information concerning the players’ cooperation fair to them?

How was it fair to any of us seeking to learn as much truth as possible about the situation?

How was it fair to Duke University or the community?

Whose interests were served by Brodhead's and his top administrators' withholding of that information from the public on Mar. 25?
Johnson’s post revives those questions. More importantly, it takes us closer to the answers.

Advice to Duke: Duck, cover and silence isn’t going to get you “past this.” Start answering the questions. Begin making things as right as you can.

Endorse Professor Coleman’s proposal that Nifong step aside and let a special prosecutor take over the case. Condemn the racists who threatened Reade Seligmann on May 18. Apologize to Seligmann and his family for not doing that when he was first threatened.

There’s much more you need to do but those actions will be important initial steps. They’ll be welcomed by people who love Duke and value fairness.

Words to KC Johnson: You’ve rendered another extraordinary service to those falsely accused; to those who seek as much justice as it’s possible to obtain now; and to those who want Duke to get “past this” with the openness, truth and courage that befit a great university.

Final word to readers: You're right. I plan to post tomorrow on Johnson's second post. I can't wait to read it.

John

Tuesday, November 28, 2006

The Churchill Series – Nov. 28, 2006

(One of a series of weekday posts on the life of Winston S. Churchill.)

In recognition of Churchill’s birthday on November 30, I’m beginning today the three-post series I discussed in yesterday's post.

Before reaching age six a child typically accomplishes some extraordinary things: walking, running, balancing, climbing and learning to speak, even perhaps to begin reading, a language. Those accomplishments mostly speak to the child’s physical and intellectual capacities. They don’t necessarily tell us a lot about the child’s character or his or her empathy for others. To learn something of them, we need to look at how the child responds to life's events and treats other people.

In Churchill’s case we know that he was born into a wealthy and privileged family. His parents, talented and ambitious, largely ignored their baby and child. His care was turned over to a nurse, Mrs. Everest. With her he formed a bond of love that lasted throughout their lives. He would care for Everest in her last illness and keep her picture in his bedroom until he died.

When Churchill was age 5 his brother John, always “Jack” in the family, was born. “I remember my father coming into my bedroom (and) telling me, ‘You have a little brother,” he recalled sixty-five years later. As with Winston, the Churchill’s placed Jack in Everest’s care.

The birth of a sibling is a formidable, often threatening event. We’ve all seen children age 5 or so react by reverting to baby talk, thumb-sucking and the like. Sibling rivalry can be intensely competitive, brutally aggressive, and often last a lifetime.

We all could have understood if Churchill had reacted to Jack that way. But he didn’t. Everything we know about the boys early years indicates that, with the exception of occasional, transient squabbles, Winston was an affectionate and protective older brother who joined with Everest in caring for Jack. The brothers were close and mutually supportive throughout their lives. They married within a few months of each other, and the two Churchill couples became “best friends.”

Jack's birth presented young Winston with a great challenge to which he responded magnificently.

The child is father to the man.
____________________________________________________________
Sources will be provided later today.

"Mike, the Knife"

Yesterday I posted concerning a Cash Michaels' column in which he mentioned "DA Mike Knifing." I've emailed Michaels to find out whether "Knifing" was a typo or what.

Meantime, an anonymous reader composed this wonderful takeoff on the song from Three Penny Opera. You all know it. Hum along as you read it.

Hey man, there goes Mike the Knife!

Oh, the shark, has pretty teeth, dear
and he shows them pearly white
Just a jackknife has MikeNifong, dear
and he keeps it, out of sight
When that shark bites with his teeth, dear
scarlet billows start to spread.
Fancy gloves though wears MikeNifong, dear
so there's not a trace of red.

On the sidewalk,
Sunday morning,
lies a body oozin' life.
Someone's sneakin' 'round the corner,
is that someone Mike the Knife?

From a tugboat
by the river
a cement bag's droopin' down
Yeah, the cement's just for the weight, dear
bet you MikeNifong's back in town.

Lookie here, Ole Lady Justice disappeared, dear
after withdrawing all her cash.
And MikeNifong spends like a sailor.
Did our boy
do somethin' rash?

Judge Bushfan, Judge Stevens
Judge Titus, Judge Smith
Oh, the line forms on the right, dear
now that Mikey's back in town.


Anonymous added: I am no Joan Foster. So if anyone would like to improve on this, feel free to do so.

Imporve it? I think it's wonderful as it.

Thanks, Anonymous.

MSM ignores Edwards’ latest stumble

Yesterday I posted concerning the Manchester Union Leader’s report former Senator John Edwards would hold a book signing that night at a local Barnes & Noble that pays its employees a starting wage of $7 an hour.

Just behind the B&N is a Wal-Mart that also sells books and pays it workers a starting wage of $7.50 an hour.

Edwards has frequently criticized Wal-Mart for is employee wage scale. He’s encouraged people not to shop at Wal-Mart.

So why was Edwards holding a book signing at a B&N that pays its workers a lower starting wage than a nearby Wal-Mart, the Union Leader asked?

I asked two other questions:

Are people who know Edwards really surprised to learn he's holding his book signing at Barnes & Noble?

And don't you think most of those people are already asking themselves: "I wonder who John will blame for this one?"
Today, Edwards gave us his answer to my second question. It included a major stumble MSM are ignoring. From an AP report:
"I've never asked anyone not to shop at Wal-Mart," he said. "I understand people need to buy inexpensive goods... But there are other companies, like Costco, who can do it and pay a decent wage and provide health care coverage, and I don't think that responsibility should be passed to taxpayers."
So Edwards effectly blames Wal-Mart. OK, nothing new there.

But to justify blaming Wal-Mart, Edwards cites “companies like Costco” which he says “pay a decent wage and provide health care coverage, and I don’t think that responsibility should be passed to taxpayers.” (bold added)

Did Edwards mean to say the government shouldn’t provide health care coverage to millions of uninsured Americans, with the cost of that coverage “passed to taxpayers?”

Does Edwards think there’s any way the government can provide health care coverage to the uninsured without the cost of that coverage “passed to taxpayers?”

MSM should be asking those questions but so far news organizations appear to be giving Edwards a pass.

Just completed searches of network news sites and news.google.com come up “empty” regarding any MSM follow-up on Edwards' extraordinary stumble.

Monday, November 27, 2006

The Churchill Series - Nov. 27, 2006

(One of a series of weekday posts on the life of Winston S. Churchill.)

It's some "this and that" today.

First, thank you to the two readers who responded to the question of what it is that Churchill is holding in his left hand in this photo of him and Clementine leaving St. Paul's Cathedral after a V-E Thanksgiving Service. Both responses were informed but I'm still not sure what he's holding.

One of Churchill's many "isms" was that, with certain notable exceptions, he liked, if at all possible, to keep his hands free. He was reluctant to carry even small, light objects. When, for example, walking to a spot where he would paint, he'd typically ask friends and aides to carry his brushes, paints and canvases.

The most notable exception to Churchill's "hands free" ism I can think of is his frequent use over many decades of a walking stick.

In recognition of Churchill's birthday November 30, tomorrow I'll begin a three-part post series which I hope will provide you some different from the well-deserved, but very familiar, birthday appreciations we usually read.

Two posts will concern his private life: his relationship with his younger brother, Jack, and his treatment during the 30s of a gypsy couple who first occupied land near Chartwell and then, at his invitation, moved onto Chartwell property.

The third post will concern his critical role after WWI in preserving the RAF as a separate service in the face of Army and Navy demands for its abolition and the distributing of its functions to them. In helping preserve the RAF as a seperate service, Churchill made an incredibly important contribution to the development of British air power which was just strong enough in 1940 to win the Battle of Britain.

John

Did Edwards surprise anyone?

At Manchester, New Hampshire's Union Leader online we read:

Former Sen. John Edwards is to spend an hour at the Manchester Barnes & Noble tonight promoting his new book. ...

In Manchester, the local Wal-Mart store sits right behind the Barnes & Noble. It has more floor space, a parking lot several times the size of Barnes & Noble's, and is easier to access by car or public transportation.

But Edwards would not be caught dead inside a Wal-Mart. Saying that the company pays its employees too little, Edwards has embarked on an anti-Wal-Mart crusade. He instructs his staff members and all Americans not to shop at Wal-Mart.

"Wal-Mart makes plenty of money. They need to pay their people well," Edwards said at a Pittsburgh anti-Wal-Mart rally in August.

So naturally Edwards is holding his book signing at Barnes & Noble instead of Wal-Mart. Which is too bad for his anti-low-wages campaign, because in Manchester Wal-Mart pays hourly employees more than Barnes & Noble does.

The Barnes & Noble where Edwards will hawk his book pays $7 an hour to start. The Wal-Mart that sits just yards away pays $7.50 an hour. ...
You can read the rest of the article here.

Two questions: Are people who know Edwards really surprised to learn he's holding his book signing at Barnes & Noble?

And don't you think most of those people are already asking themselves: "I wonder who John will blame for this one?"

To get the answer, let's keep an eye on the Union Leader's site.

DUKE MOM PLUCKS PROF

It wasn't so long ago that Professor Stuart Rojstaczer occupied one of those tenured faculty “roosts” at Duke University.

And it was only a day or two ago that Rojstaczer was strutting through the blogoshere gobbling about:

“Duke lacrosse [blogs] with a severe right-wing slant [that] state outright that the charges against the lacrosse players are bogus.”
Sure, Liestoppers, Johnsville and KC Johnson all took shots at him. So did I.

But we must’ve all missed because at 4 pm today Rojstaczer could still be "heard" on this Liestoppers’ thread gobbling:
“The role of the [‘Group of 88’s] ad in this tragedy is so minor that at best, those that dwell on it and its signatories are simply making a mountain out of a molehill."
I don’t know what happened after that but by 7 tonight Momtothree had him trussed and was plucking her first "Rojstaczer feather:"
"Well, Mr. R., I’m a Duke mom and the ad certainly had an impact on me.”
You can “digest” the rest of her post here.

And please leave something for me. I may do "leftovers" tomorrow.

“Faculty Survivors” (Nov. 27)

Last week's “Faculty Survivors” show featured Duke Professor Thomas J. Crowley who offered Hoax Case “items” he said people had overlooked.

"Items" such as:

”Why was the woman sober when she arrived and staggering to the point of passing out a mere 30 minutes later? Was she possibly drugged by someone when they encouraged her to have a drink? If so, what were the motives?
It all seemed very important. Crowley looked like a sure bet to make it to the season’s final show.

Then blogger KC Johnson, a professor himself, asked Crowley what he knew about toxicology testing done at Duke Hospital the night of the alleged crimes. Test results were negative.

As KC subsequently reported:
Crowley responded: [original all caps]
I DID NOT KNOW ABOUT THE TOXICOLOGY REPORT.
Oops! And you guessed it: Professor Crowley isn’t back this week.

BUT DON’T TOUCH THAT REMOTE.

I want you to meet the newest member of our “Faculty Survivors” cast, blogger and former Duke Professor Stuart Rojstaczer

Rojstaczer brings to the show some things we haven’t heard before.

Tell us about them, Stuart:
“Lately, I’ve read blogs about the Duke lacrosse scandal that have a severe right-wing slant. They tend to focus on a few points.

First, they state outright that the charges against the lacrosse players are bogus.”
I know some bloggers do that. Many don't even bother providing a parental warning. They just come right out and say the charges are bogus. And that concerns you, does it?
”If [that] were their only issue, I’d have no problem. But it doesn’t just stop there. They tend to go on and on." […]
By “they.” I assume you’re talking about blogs such as Durham-in-Wonderland, Johnsville News and Liestoppers.

You should know I respect those blogs and visit them every day. So do many of our “Faculty Survivors” viewers.

But, Stuart, we want to hear what you think. So tell us, besides saying the players are innocent, what else do the bloggers do that upsets you?
”[They] demonize the “Group of 88,” the 88 faculty members that signed an advertisement in the Duke student newspaper decrying the state of race relations at Duke."
Stuart, I’m sorry to cut you off on this but next week’s entire show is devoted to the “Group of 88.” And we’re running out of time. Can you quickly summarize what it is you’re saying?
“Essentially, these bloggers are trying to use the lacrosse scandal as a way not only to state the innocence of the lacrosse players, but: 1) perpetuate the status quo of a student culture where debauchery trumps academics; 2) make a quixotic attempt to remove left wing faculty at Duke.

As for issue number one, I don’t think they need to make this effort.”
Stuart, you’re going on and on. Briefly, what are you saying?
”The culture of debauchery and anti-intellectualism at Duke will not go away. No one in Duke leadership has a sincere interest in changing this culture.”
I’m worried our viewers are confused. You seem more upset with Duke than with the bloggers.

A few closing thoughts, Stuart. Ten seconds:
"The right-wing bloggers don’t have to worry. Duke will be Duke for the foreseeable future. It's one of the reasons why I left."
I see. Well, thank you.

We’re out of time. Remember, folks, next week’s our “Group of 88” show._________________________________________

Professor Rojstaczer says more in his blog post. He and Durham-in-Wonderland’s KC Johnson comment on the thread.

Be sure to read Liestoppers response to Rojstaczer.

Also, Johnsville News responds here. (Scroll down)

About DA Mike Knifing

Random House’s Unabridged Dictionary defines knifing as “to attempt to defeat or undermine in a secret or underhanded way.”

And in Wilmington Journal columnist Cash Michaels’ most recent column (online) we find this paragraph:

Duke Three supporters have also blasted Pres. Brodhead for not speaking out against what they believe to be a “false prosecution” of the defendants by Durham District Attorney Mike Knifing, based on reportedly scant evidence and an allegedly corrupted police photo ID lineup. (bold added)
Well, what do you think? Understandable typo of the kind we all make or did Michaels intend to just come right out and ......?

I plan to drop Michaels an email later today and ask him.

I’ll let you know what I hear back.

In the meantime, if Dr. Freud reads this, I hope he'll comment.

I found Michaels’ column at Friends of Duke University’s media links page.

Sunday, November 26, 2006

Welcome back

I hope you all had a very good Thanksgving.

I'm glad to be "in touch" with you again.

John

To The Chronicle: Letter 5

Readers’ Note: On Oct. 27, Duke’s student newspaper, The Chronicle, published an editorial, “Bloggers get point, miss complexity.” The editorial and its comment thread are here.

The Chronicle editorial leveled extremely serious charges at bloggers.

I’ve responded to The Chronicle with a series of electronic letters which I’m posting at JinC. Each letter is headed "To The Chronicle" and enumerated. Here are links to letters one, two, three and four.

Letter five follows.

John
_________________________

Editorial Board
The Chronicle
Duke University

Dear Editorial Board Members:

This is the last of five letters responding to your Oct. 27 editorial, “Bloggers get point, miss complexity.” (Here are letters one, two, three and four.)

At JinC and blogs where I regularly read about Duke Hoax issues, bloggers are careful not to misrepresent people, including Duke faculty and President Brodhead. We typically link to documents we reference.

So, for example, concerning then Duke Professor Houston Baker’s March 29 letter in which he said there’s “scarcely any shame more egregious than one that wraps itself in the pious sentimentalism of liberal rhetoric,” I’ve told readers Baker meant by “pious sentimentalism of liberal rhetoric” what most of us mean when we use terms such as “due process,” “presumption of innocence,” and “constitutional rights.”

I think that’s a very straightforward interpretation of what Baker said. But I’ve made sure to link to his letter so readers can judge for themselves.

Recently Professor Thomas J. Crowley published an op-ed in the Durham Herald Sun. He told readers he was “surprised” so many people without “legal knowledge” nevertheless were asking that the lacrosse case be dismissed. He said he knew of “items about the case that would lead one to hesitate before throwing out the case.”

Crowley’s “items” included the following questions :

Why was the woman sober when she arrived and staggering to the point of passing out a mere 30 minutes later? Was she possibly drugged by someone when they encouraged her to have a drink? If so, what were the motives?
Whatever our individual thoughts may be about the case, I'm sure we agree that Crowley’s questions dealt with extremely important matters that needed follow up.

Blogger KC Johnson did just that. He promptly emailed Crowley and informed him regarding toxicology testing done at Duke Hospital the night of the alleged crimes.

KC subsequently reported :
Crowley responded: [original all caps]
I DID NOT KNOW ABOUT THE TOXICOLOGY REPORT.
Yet again, it seems to me extraordinary that a professor would publicly suggest that a student or students at his own institution could have used a date-rape drug without checking as to whether the state had performed a toxicology test; and, if so, what results that test produced. (Results were negative. JinC)
Growing numbers of readers want and expect KC's kind of factual reporting and informed commentary. Serious bloggers, like serious journalists, strive to provide it. Other bloggers, like other journalists, don’t seem to even try.

I hope we now agree that some of the best Duke Hoax reporting and commentary have come from MSM and blog sources as have some of the worst.

I look forward to hearing from you.

Sincerely,

John
www.johnincarolina.com

Thursday, November 23, 2006

Blogging resumes Sunday night

There are many family and friends here for the weekend.

Blogging will resume Sunday night around 8 pm with another letter to The Chronicle's Editorial Board. This one responds to The Chronicle's concerns about how I and a few other bloggers' have reacted to statements by certain Duke faculty. I hope you'll be "listening" to what I say.

I'll also have a post concerning aspects of the Raleigh News & Observer's Duke lacrosse coverage that deserve more attention than they've received.

More posts will follow including a "look" at former Mayor Rudy Giuliani and his chances of winning the GOP's 2008 presidential nomination.

I hope you all enjoy the rest of Thanksgiving and the weekend.

John

HAPPY THANKSGIVING

I hope you all have a wonderful Thanksgiving.

To our serving military, our veterans and their families goes a heartfelt thanks and prayer.

Without your sacrifices the rest of us wouldn't have the great blessings we enjoy.

John

Wednesday, November 22, 2006

The Churchill Series – Nov. 22, 2006

(One of a series of weekday posts on the life of Winston S. Churchill.)

Today, something about a Thanksgiving Service: a bit of a mystery if you will.

On May 13, 1945, Winston and Clementine Churchill attended a Service of Thanksgiving at St. Paul’s Cathedral, London, for the victory over Germany.

As they came down the cathedral steps after the service, a breeze was blowing. Clementine put her hand to her head to keep her hat in place. Churchill held his hat in his right hand. He held something else in his left hand. You can see the Churchill’s descending the steps in the photo here.

For the life of me I can’t figure out what the object is. Do any of you know what the object is or have an educated guess?

Notice also that he appears to have lost some weight. While his buttoned jacket fits, his pants are very baggy.

The St. Paul’s photo was included in the Smithsonian exhibit “Churchill and the Great Republic.” I’ve included a link to the exhibit's website home page.

Perhaps Thanksgiving Day or over the weekend, you, family and friends will enjoy “visiting” the exhibit. It’s wonderful.

I plan to spend a lot of time with family this Thanksgiving, so I’ll be taking a break from blogging.

The Churchill Series will resume Monday, Nov. 27.

I wish each of you a blessed Thanksgiving and hope you're back on Monday.

John

Good signs from NAACP's McSurely

Liestoppers notes we’ve gotten "A Curiously Mixed Message" from North Carolina’s state chapter of the NAACP. Its President, Rev. William J. Barber II, has told us that “maintain[ing] community and do[ing] justice requires tenacity to seek the truth and willingness to face the truth.”

But at the state NAACP’s website, LS finds an essay by the organization’s Legal Redress Chair, attorney Al McSurely, that LS demonstrates contains “distortions” and what LS delicately calls “departures from the truth.”

JinC Regulars may recall McSurely was the subject of posts on June 3 (“Duke lacrosse letter: So bad it's a good sign for the indicted”) and June 4 (“Remember that Duke lacrosse letter? Here's a follow up”)

The posts commented on a letter McSurely wrote to the Raleigh News & Observer in response to a David Brooks column, "The Duke Witch Hunt," which first appeared in the New York Times.

In light of all the public had learned by late May about DA Mike Nifong’s “case,” Brooks said “simple decency” required that he and millions of others “correct the slurs” they’d uttered in March and April against the Duke Men’s lacrosse team.

McSurely didn't like that one bit. He went after Brooks with statements such as:

“Brooks conceded the team is ‘mostly white’ (46 out of 47). He cited favorably a National Journal essay [by Stuart Taylor] that estimated "an 85 percent chance" the men are innocent.”
I noted that “conced[ing]” a team is mostly white is no more a concession that “conceding” a team is mostly black. I also noted McSurely couldn’t bring himself to acknowledge what Brooks had actually said about Taylor :
“[Law journalist] Stuart Taylor has written a devastating couple of essays on the weak case of the prosecutor, Mike Nifong [citing] lack of DNA evidence, the seemingly exculpatory digital photos and the testimony of a taxi driver.”
McSurely’s letter was so weak I said “it had to be a good sign for the indicted players.”

Liestoppers' post shows us why McSurely's essay is another "good sign" for the players.

Patriotism and reporters

On Nov. 6 I posted “The Press at War.” It concerned James Q. Wilson’s WSJ op-ed on the role of press bias in undermining America’s efforts in Iraq now and in Vietnam during the 60s.

A blog friend emails today with more by Wilson on the same subject. Excerpts from Wilson’s essay in City Journal with blog friend’s comments in italics.
______________________________________________
Austin Bay posts on a James Q. Wilson piece about patriotism and reporters. Some excerpts:

We are told by careful pollsters that half of the American people believe that American troops should be brought home from Iraq immediately. This news discourages supporters of our efforts there. Not me, though: I am relieved. Given press coverage of our efforts in Iraq, I am surprised that 90 percent of the public do not want us out right now.

Between January 1 and September 30, 2005, nearly 1,400 stories appeared on the ABC, CBS, and NBC evening news. More than half focused on the costs and problems of the war, four times as many as those that discussed the successes. About 40 percent of the stories reported terrorist attacks; scarcely any reported the triumphs of American soldiers and marines. The few positive stories about progress in Iraq were just a small fraction of all the broadcasts.

When the Center for Media and Public Affairs made a nonpartisan evaluation of network news broadcasts, it found that during the active war against Saddam Hussein, 51 percent of the reports about the conflict were negative. Six months after the land battle ended, 77 percent were negative; in the 2004 general election, 89 percent were negative; by the spring of 2006, 94 percent were negative. This decline in media support was much faster than during Korea or Vietnam….
Wilson concludes:
The mainstream media’s adversarial stance, both here and abroad, means that whenever a foreign enemy challenges us, he will know that his objective will be to win the battle not on some faraway bit of land but among the people who determine what we read and watch. We won the Second World War in Europe and Japan, but we lost in Vietnam and are in danger of losing in Iraq and Lebanon in the newspapers, magazines, and television programs we enjoy.
The MSM has a lot to answer for….
__________________________________________________

My blog friend has it right. But how do we counter the effects of a press that magnifies any American mistake or wrong action (Remember all those Abu Ghraib stories?)while seeking to "understand," not America's enemies, but "the insurgents."

In WW II the press routinely referred to American forces as "we" and "our" and German and Japanese forces as "the enemy." Katie Couric or Brian Williams would never make that "mistake," would they? That would be a bigger mistake than going on camera without their makeup.

Hat Tip: Mike Williams

Tuesday, November 21, 2006

The Churchill Series – Nov. 21, 2006

(One of a series of weekday posts on the life of Winston S. Churchill.)

Richard Langworth is a respected historian and editor of the Churchill Centre’s journal, Finest Hour. When he speaks, I listen.

I was delighted the other day when I learned he’d confirmed a remark I’d heard attributed to Churchill but was never quite sure he’d actually said. So I’ve hesitated to pass it on to you. Here from Langworth:

"It is established that in 1915 he wrote his brother Jack from Hoe Farm, where he was spending the summer, that he had all the necessities of life; ‘Hot baths, cold Champagne, new peas and old brandy.’”
BTW – I owe you all an apology. The other day I said Churchill’s Chartwell home is in Surry. An anonymous commenter correctly noted it’s in Kent.

I’m sorry for my error and thank Anonymous for pointing it out.

In a separate post I plan to use Anonymous’ comment to demonstrate that despite what some people think, bloggers have “editors” who review our work. Look for the post in the next week. It may take the form of a letter to an MSM editor.

John

To The Chronicle: Letter 4

Readers’ Note: On Oct. 27, Duke’s student newspaper, The Chronicle, published an editorial, “Bloggers get point, miss complexity.” The editorial and its comment thread are here.

The Chronicle editorial leveled extremely serious charges at bloggers.

I’ve responded to The Chronicle with a series of electronic letters which I’m posting at JinC. Each letter is headed "To The Chronicle" and enumerated. Here are links to letters one, two and three.

Letter four follows.

John
_________________________

Editorial Board
The Chronicle
Duke University

Dear Editorial Board Members:

This is my fourth letter responding to your Oct. 27 editorial, “Bloggers get point, miss complexity.” (Here, for reference, are letters one, two and three. ) The qualifiers I laid out in those letters apply to this one as well.

You say blogs have “villainized … major media [and made assertions] with little true reporting” but offer no specifics.

So I’ll move on and say some things about what's actually happened at my blog.

If you search JinC achieves, you’ll see I often write about the importance of good reporting and frequently recommend print stories and news programs. I encourage readers to bookmark many journalists and news organizations.

Most of what I’ve written about “major media” has been quite positive.

That said, I’ve also been very critical of certain individuals and news organizations. Let's look at some of that and you decide whether I’ve really "villainized …with little true reporting” or simply reported things as they are and offered reasonable commentary.

Concerning the Duke lacrosse case, I’ve been sharply critical of much of the coverage of the Durham Herald Sun and the Raleigh News & Observer.

For example, these links take you to posts (here and here) concerning a H-S story claiming it was reporting “previously undisclosed [DNA] matches” to David Evans. I cited and linked to three month old news stories that had reported on the H-S's “previously undisclosed [DNA] matches” and made clear the DNA matches didn’t link Evans to the alleged events of the night of Mar. 13/14.

I asked H-S Editor Bob Ashley for an explanation of what appeared to be a "fake" story. Ashley said he wasn’t interested in a “debate.”

This post links to the H-S's Oct. 17 editorial commenting on the Oct. 15 60 Minutes episode generally regarded as having effectively exposed numberous travesties in the investigation and indictments of Duke lacrosse players. The H-S editorial recycled the false claim that Collin Finnerty had attacked a gay man. The H-S claim had been refuted five months previously. (scroll down on post)

On Mar. 24 the Raleigh N&O first “broke” the lacrosse story with an article that seven times referred to the accuser as either the “victim” or with the possessive “victim’s,” never once using the customary qualifies “alleged” or “reported.” In doing that, the N&O effectively cast the accuser as “the victim” and your classmates as her “victimizers.

Since Mar. 24 I’ve reported frequently on what the N&O did, revealing that it was not standard practice for the N&O to refer to the accuser in the preadjudication phase of a disputed rape case as “the victim.” I asked why, on Mar. 24 and again on Mar. 25 the N&O would make an exception to its standard practice, since doing that had the effect of framing the Duke players as a team composed of three gang-rapists and their teammates who were covering up for them.

What I did was what many bloggers do:digging, fact-checking and publically reporting the facts.

Yet for seven months the N&O mislead the public and denied it had done anything wrong in its use of “victim.”

Finally, on Oct. 20 before a “blog-smart” audience at Duke Law School which knew what the N&O had done, the paper’s managing editor, John Drescher acknowledged, as reported by the N&O, that the “ alleged rape has not been proven, and thus it isn't clear whether there is a victim.”

That’s not a full, frank acknowledgement of error but it’s a small first step. It's a pity the N&O took seven months to begin to acknowledge some of what it did to frame the players as “victimizers?”

For months I’ve asked N&O editors and reporters when the N&O first learned of the extensive cooperation the players provided police. Here’s the most recent and detailed response I’ve received. It’s on the thread of a post at the N&O’s Editors’ Blog. Melanie Sill is the N&O's executve editor for news:

Comment from: Melanie Sill [Member] • http://www.newsobserver.com
10/26/06 at 17:04

John, as to your specific question about "when we knew the players had cooperated," I believe our information about the level of cooperation of various players was gained over days and weeks after the initial story and in bits and pieces from police and from lawyers and other people speaking for the players or for Duke


Your editorial comments regarding blog treatment of "major media and true reporting" don't apply to my blog or the blogs of any responsible blogger, many of whom have provided outstanding Duke lacrosse reporting and commentary.

In a few days, I’ll respond regarding blog criticisms of the A&S faculty, individual faculty and President Brodhead.

In the meantime, I wish you all and your families a blessed Thanksgiving.

Sincerely,

John
www.johnincarolina.com

Monday, November 20, 2006

The Churchill Series – Nov. 20, 2006

(One of a series of weekday posts on the life of Winston S. Churchill.)

FDR, Ike, Harry Hopkins, George Marshall, Joe Kennedy and Bernard Baruch. Those are just some of the Americans Churchill was eager to meet and learn more about. Today we’ll add two other Americans to that list: William Cody and Ulysses S. Grant.

In the summer of 1887, “Wild Bill” Cody was bringing his “Wild West Show” to London. Naturally the twelve year old Winnie Churchill, considered by some teachers and relatives “wild” himself, was eager to see the show. Biographer Martin Gilbert tell us about what happened next:

[Cody’s] advertisement in The Times trumpeted its attractions in capital letters.” GRANDSTAND FOR 20000 PEOPLE. BANDS OF SIOUX, ARAPAHOES, SHOSHONES, CHEYENNES, AND OTHER INDIANS, CCOWBOYS, SCOUTS AND MEXICAN VACQUEROS.”

There would be riding, shooting, lassoing and hunting, attacks on a stagecoach and on a settler’s cabin. […]

Churchill, then at boarding school in Brighton, wrote several times to his mother, urging her to write to the two sister who ran the school to let him go up to London.
In the beginning Jennie said no, but Churchill, always a persistent campaigner, kept at it until he got a “Yes.” Needless to say, he enjoyed the show hugely and talked about it into old age.

Ulysses S. Grant? That Christmas, Churchill, having just turned 13, told his mother that one of the gifts he most wanted for Christmas was Grant’s recently released 2 volume memoirs. What an extraordinary request from any 13 year old, but particularly from one who was seen by many schoolmasters as not very bright and a problem student.

I’ve always found the following a good predictor with young students who “have school problems:” If they’re independent readers of serious material there’s a very good chance theyll turn out OK in the end even if they’re always failing spelling tests and not turning in many homework assignments.
_______________________________________________
Martin Gilbert, Churchill and America (pgs. 8-9)

A Duke student misses

Duke senior Shadee Malaklou, a double major in women’s studies and cultural anthropology, has just published an op-ed in the Durham Herald Sun, “Lacrosse players far from innocent." (Her Nov. 19 op-ed is not yet online. I'll link when and if it becomes available. – JinC).

Malaklou begins:

Joseph B. Cheshire’s Nov. 11 angry words did not go unnoticed. For every smug remark by a smug, white attorney representing a smug, white lacrosse player, there is a woman cringing. This time that woman was me.

Not only was Cheshire’s guest column unprofessional, but it was also completely insensitive to the multitudes of women who have been victim, in one way or another, to the lacrosse players actions. […]
Folks, I hope you appreciate what you’ve just read. Look at all Ms. Malaklou did in two brief paragraphs.

She told readers she’s a victim (“woman cringing”) of an “angry …smug, white attorney representing a smug, white lacrosse player.” What's more Attorney Cheshire is “unprofessional (and) completely insensitive to ... multitudes of women.”

O horrors! Cheshire not only victimized Malaklou but he's also been insensitive to “multitudes of [other] women.”

Imagine that! Until now I’d thought the worst thing Cheshire did was wear a goatee.

If you read Cheshire’s Nov. 11 op-ed, you’re probably wondering how anyone could see what he said as “victimizing” a woman. “It’s just not there,” you say.

No it's not, but in the "PC world" it doesn't have to be. What matters is that you cast yourself as a victim and call whomever you disagree with a victimizer. Make charges; avoid facts. If the other person introduces facts, they're further victimizing you. Highlight that.

Remember, if you live in the “PC world" you are able to see things others don't see. Duke’s Professor Wahneema Lubiano, a signer of the "Group of 88’s" “listening” statement, explains :
” In everyday life, people are unable to easily see structural racism, sexism and class divisions.”
So, folks, we shouldn’t feel badly about not seeing what Lubiano and Malaklou see. We don't have the specialized training Duke’s faculty "Group of 88" provides its devoted students.

Malaklou goes on to say:
Much of the emphasis on this “innocence” has ignored the gender and racial prejudice of the March 13 party. If nothing else, Nifong is holding the lacrosse players accountable for that; and as a woman at Duke who knows just how much these men get away with, I’m thankful.
Let's wind it up here, folks.

Are there any of you “in everyday life” who can’t easily see in those two sentences Malaklou’s sexism, major factual error, smugness and her willingness to embrace a DA who will ignore innocence and act instead to satisfy her prejudices?

It's sad to think Malaklou is no doubt sincere and unaware of her actual thought processes and values.

Sadder still is the fact that many Duke faculty, such as the "Group of 88", will reinforce Malaklou instead of trying to educate her.

Liestoppers has an excellent, extensive post on Malaklou's op-ed.

Sunday, November 19, 2006

Re: "Duke faculty duties"

I appreciate reader comments regarding my “Duke faculty duties” letter to Professor Karla Holloway, a signatory of the Duke faculty “Group of 88’s” “listening” statement advertisement and a member of the Campus Cultural Initiative committee.

A few readers said Holloway very likely will not respond. I hope she does, but I know she may not. In fact, she may not even read the letter. She could hit “delete” after the first few words.

I hope she doesn’t and instead responds. But even if she doesn’t respond, writing and publishing the letter has been useful.

In theory everyone at Duke can read the letter and the comment thread; and some certainly will.

They can then judge the letter and comments against remarks attributed to Holloway in a recent Chronicle article [excerpt]:

Holloway wrote in an e-mail that misreadings of the advertisement have attracted the most attention.

"It was extraordinarily telling that these respondents displaced the actual content of the ad for the fiction of their own meagerly articulated agendas," she wrote.

She added that she would sign the petition again "in a heartbeat."

Both [Professor] Kaplan and Holloway said they have received hate mail from strangers.

"The often vicious, frequently racist and generally poorly composed responses I have received speak for themselves," Holloway said.

"Those who cower under the cover of anonymous e-mail and who find their life's blood in producing unending streams of blogged nonsense are probably better left to these subaltern spaces," she added.
The letter and readers’ comments constitute a civil and on-point rejoinder to what Holloway told The Chronicle. They’ll leave sensible people wondering if perhaps Holloway hasn’t gotten other similarly civil and on-point comments.

People who want to find out whether Holloway responds can check with her or at JinC from time to time in the next few weeks.

If Holloway doesn’t respond, people can make their own judgments as to why not. And they’ll have a better basis on which to judge what Holloway told The Chronicle than just Holloway’s statements.

The letter also gave me another opportunity to raise the matter of the University's silence regarding the racist attacks on Reade Seligmann on May 18. I plan to raise that matter as often as I can.

I’ve left replies to reader comments on the duties post.

Sowell: Right early and now

One of my favorite pundits is syndicated columnist Thomas Sowell. He almost always “gets it right;” usually before most others.

He’s been that way with the Duke lacrosse case. Back in April “righteous townies” were banging pots, Duke faculty were demanding to know “why they haven’t been expelled?’, and the Raleigh News & Observer was running the “Swagger” story and publishing the “vigilante” poster. In that atmosphere Sowell offered this:

People who were not within 1,000 miles of Duke University have already taken sides in the case of a stripper who has accused Duke lacrosse players of rape. One TV talk show hostess went ballistic when a guest on her program raised questions about the stripper's version of what happened.

Apparently we dare not question accusations of rape when it involves the new sacred trinity of race, class, and gender.

Media irresponsibility is one thing. Irresponsibility by an agent of the law is something else -- and much more dangerous. Prosecutors are not just supposed to prosecute. They are supposed to prosecute the right people in the right way. In this case, prosecutor Michael Nifong has proceeded in the wrong way.

Having an accuser or a witness pick out the accused from a lineup is standard procedure. That procedure not only serves to identify someone to be charged with a crime, it also tests the credibility of the accuser or witness -- or it should, if the lineup is not stacked.

A lineup should include not only people suspected of a crime but also other people, so that it tests whether the accuser or witness can tell the difference, and is therefore credible. But the stripper who claimed to have been raped by members of the Duke lacrosse team was presented with a lineup consisting exclusively of photographs of members of the lacrosse team.

In other words, whoever she picked out had to be a lacrosse player and would be targeted, with no test whatever of her credibility, because there was no chance for her to pick out somebody who had no connection with the team or the university.

Apparently District Attorney Nifong was no more wiling to test the accuser's credibility than was the TV talk show hostess who went ballistic, though credibility is often crucial in rape cases
To put a bit more perspective on Sowell’s column, he wrote it more than seven weeks before Duke Law Professor James Coleman wrote his excellent letter calling on Nifong to step aside and allow a special prosecutor to take charge of the Duke lacrosse case because the public had lost confidence in Nifong’s handling of the case.

The rest of Sowell’s column is here. I hope you read it; and ask yourself whether, with the benefit of seven months of hindsight, there is anything Sowell said in that column that hasn’t stood up.

Sowell's Nov. 17 column is here.

Saturday, November 18, 2006

POWERLINE SETS BBC STRAIGHT

We’ve been reading in the American press that British PM Tony Blair said Iraq has been a “disaster.”

Well, that’s not quite the case. From Powerline:

"Triumphant headline from the BBC: "Blair accepts 'disaster' in Iraq." The Beeb's story begins :
Tony Blair has publicly agreed with the opinion that the violence in Iraq since the 2003 invasion has been a disaster.

But this is one of those "all headline, no story" episodes that we often see nowadays. What happened was that Blair was being interviewed on al Jazeera by David Frost:

Mr Blair was challenged by Sir David over the violence in Iraq, saying it had "so far been pretty much of a disaster".
Blair replied:

It has, but you see what I say to people is why is it difficult in Iraq?

It's not difficult because of some accident in planning.

It's difficult because there's a deliberate strategy - al-Qaeda with Sunni insurgents on one hand, Iranian-backed elements with Shia militias on the other - to create a situation in which the will of the majority for peace is displaced by the will of the minority for war.
That all seems clear enough.

As Powerline’s John Hinderaker points out:
: [That’s] what Blair, like President Bush, has been saying for a long time.

Blair didn't say that Iraq was a mistake; or that the war has been mishandled; or that our efforts there are doomed to failure. Those are the "admissions" the BBC desperately wants to hear, and tried to suggest through its coverage of Blair's inconsequential exchange with Frost.
Hinderaker has it right. "The facts on the ground” don’t support the BBC’s “story.”

Friday, November 17, 2006

The Churchill Series – Nov. 17, 2006

(One of a series of weekday posts on the life of Winston S. Churchill.)

A while back a post included a link to a Nazi propaganda cartoon intended for a British audience. It was produced in 1940 when America was still officially neutral and Britain “stood alone.”

The cartoon depicted "piggish" President and Mrs. Roosevelt seated at a table eating with their hands food overflowing large bowls. A few scraps had fallen to the floor. Churchill, in formal attire, stood in a doorway, bowl in hand, begging for the scraps. The Roosevelt’s were ignoring him.

The cartoon brought questions from some readers regarding other forms and topics of propaganda the Nazis used when targeting the British people.

One form was radio. It’s all but forgotten now but there were daily propaganda broadcasts from Germany to Britain throughout the war. The Churchill government could have “jammed” them but decided to let them through. Here’s one Brit's recollection of those broadcasts:

.Most people found the broadcasts humorous and entertaining although many took them seriously and were alarmed by them.

The hard news presentations were generally factual, quite accurate and often "scooped" the BBC in announcing important wartime events. The propaganda commentary was wickedly clever and aimed at demoralizing the British Home Front -- mostly seeking to foment public unrest, distrust of the British Government, a sense of hopelessness in opposing the Nazi war machine -- and anti-Semitic at every opportunity. Letters from captured British soldiers were frequently read at the conclusion of the broadcasts which generated a substantial listening audience.
You can read more about Nazi propaganda in general and propaganda aimed at the British at this Wikipedia site and this BBC site.

I hope you all have a nice weekend and are back on Monday.

John

Duke faculty duties

Readers’ note: If you’re not familiar with what people refer to as “the Duke faculty’s Group of 88’s ‘listening’ statement,” please read this post.

John
_____________________________________________

Karla FC Holloway
William R. Kenan Professor of English
Duke University

Dear Professor Holloway:

Since April 6 when you, other faculty, and various academic departments and programs sponsored a full page Chronicle ad called “the ‘listening’ statement,” I’ve read a number of your statements in media and your recent article, "The Cultural Value of Sport: Title IX and Beyond."

They’ve helped me understand what you see as your rights, your victimization, and the shortcomings of other people and Duke University.

But your statements and article say almost nothing about your duties as a Duke faculty member. Nor do they say anything about what you, as a faculty representative on President Brodhead’s Campus Cultural Initiative committee, see as your faculty colleagues’ duties.

I use duties in the common dictionary sense of things one is expected or required to do by moral or legal obligation.

Concerning faculty duties, the ad says its faculty sponsors are “listening [to] the anger and fear of many students who know themselves to be objects of racism and sexism.” That’s followed by students’ statements, mostly anonymous, including this one:

“Being a big, black man, it’s hard to walk anywhere at night, and not have a campus police car slowly drive by me.”
It’s true that at night campus police cars drive slowly by big, black men. We’ve both seen them do it.

But we also know that at night Duke police cars drive slowly by small white women, elderly Asian couples, Hispanics and grandparents of every ethnicity holding their grandchildren’s hands.

Duke police are watching out for all of us regardless of our size, race, or gender. To do that, they need to see us and any threats that might be behind or about us. So they “slowly drive by” us.

Responsible adults would explain all of that to the “big, black man.” Who would leave him seeing a racial aspect in a police practice that has none? The student’s misperception doesn’t help him or the police who seek to protect him. In fact, it makes serious misunderstandings between them more likely.

Didn’t you, as a faculty member, have a duty to tell the student why the campus police drive slowly by him at night? Didn’t your “listening” statement colleagues have that same duty?

I hope you agree it was a failure of duty to advertise the student’s misperception in The Chronicle under any circumstances, but especially so at a tense time when some on campus were circulating “vigilante” posters targeting Duke students and others were encouraging them.

Reade Seligmann was one of the students targeted by the “vigilante” posters.

On May 18 Seligmann was again targeted when racists twice shouted threats at him. The first threats occurred as he walked to Durham’s County Courthouse and included shouts of “Justice will be done, Rapist.” Then, within the courtroom and before the judge entered, there were more threats including: “There’s a dead man walking.”

The faculty, as far as I know, was silent at the time and has been so since. But surely you agree the faculty has a duty to speak out when something like the events of May 18 happen?

If the faculty remains silent about those events, what kind of campus culture can it provide students?

I’ve heard some of your colleagues say they believe President Brodhead had a duty to speak out at the time and should do so now.

I agree but that doesn’t lessen in any way the duty the faculty has to speak out as well, does it?

I hold two degrees from the University and blog at www.johnincarolina.com. I’ve included this letter in a post. Here’s the link:

I look forward to your response. I will post in full a response of up to about 1500 words.

Thank you for your attention to this letter.

Sincerely,

John in Carolina
www.johnincarolina.com

A poem for Brodhead

They say Duke University President Richard H. Brodhead loves poetry.

Well, the Poet of the Piedmont, Joan Foster, just sent one his way. It's an intentional parody of the op-ed Professor Thomas Crowley published in last Sunday's Durham Morning Herald. Crwoley apparently meant the piece as an expression of his most serious thoughts concerning legal aspects of the Duke Hoax. Instead, it was more of an unintentional self-parody.

You can read some blog responses here, here, here and here.

Joan's parody begins:

Good Morning, President Brodhead.
Did you enjoy your Cheerios?
Ready for your morning briefing, Dick?
Everything you need to know!
.
Prof Crowley wrote to the Herald Sun.
Unfortunately, he signed his name.
He wandered off the talking points.
It really was a shame.
.
Time and again we've told them, Dick,
To avoid this consternation
The trinity is... "American Pyscho,"
Racial Slurs, and Urination!
It continues here.

Enjoy!

Thursday, November 16, 2006

The Churchill Series – Nov. 16, 2006

(One of a series of weekday posts on the life of Winston S. Churchill.)

When Churchill became Prime Minister on May 10, 1940, he "inherited" John (Jock) Colville.

Colville worked in Chamberlain’s Private Office and Churchill kept Colville on in order to assure a smooth transition in the PM’s office in those desperate days.

Colville had been a supporter of appeasement and no admirer of Churchill. But his view of Churchill gradually changed. He became not just an admirer but a friend. In Franklin and Winston: An Intimate Portrait of an Epic Friendship Jon Meacham includes this Colville description of Churchill :

He behaved in public just as he behaved in private. There were no two faces, no mask that would drop when the audience had retired….

If Churchill was not in the mood, he found it difficult, he found it difficult to put on an act of affability even when circumstances demanded it; and in so far as he had good manners (which many would have denied) they came from fundamental kindness of heart. They were in no way cultivated, and it was unnatural for him to display a sentiment he did not genuinely feel.(pgs. 9-10)
Most others who worked closely with Churchill have said things very similar to what Colville says about “no two faces, no mask.”

In that regard what a contrast we have between Churchill and FDR, almost all of whose intimates record, often with admiration, his ability to wear any number of “masks,” depending on the occasion and the people he was with. Historians are still uncertain regarding how many people FDR told in 1944 he’d like to have as his Vice-Presidential running mate. They also dispute whether Truman was really his preferred choice or "pushed" on him by party bosses.

Advice for Prof. Crowley

Concerning Duke University Professor Thomas Crowley’s Durham Herald Sun op-ed, “Don't be too quick to toss lacrosse case,” I said yesterday that Crowley had apparently fooled himself into believing he had “no preconditioned preference” on the critical issue of the players’ guilt or innocence. I then asked where Duke was finding professors like Crowley and others we’ve been hearing from since last March.

Today I want to comment on another part of his op-ed.

Crowley says :

”[Nifong’s] statements to the media at the beginning of the case are open to interpretation about motives. I think many people might have felt totally off guard and swept away by the tidal wave of media attention that so quickly came down after the event was publicized. I am hesitant to be totally critical of Nifong's response because I could not say for sure if I too might have been swept away by all that was happening.”
If before he sent those sentences off to the Herald Sun Crowley had asked my advice, I’d have told him something like the following:
“Thomas, I don’t think Nifong’s statements "at the beginning" are hard to interpret.

Between March 27 and 29 Nifong said such things as:

"I would like to think that somebody [not involved in the attack] has the human decency to call up and say, 'What am I doing covering up for a bunch of hooligans?' "

and

"And one would wonder why one needs an attorney if one was not charged and had not done anything wrong."


and

"My guess is that some of this stonewall of silence that we have seen may tend to crumble once charges begin to come out."

It's perfectly clear he was working to cast the players as villains.

And now that we know about the cooperation the captains gave police on March 16, the 46 players cooperation in the DNA testing and their attorneys trying to make contact with Nifong to discuss the case, it’s also clear Nifong’s “wall of silence” statements were lies.

You’re opening yourself up to criticism with your Nifong was “swept away by a tidal wave of media attention” claim. He’s a veteran attorney. He knows he shouldn’t ridicule people for retaining defense counsels. Average citizens know it. And then he goes on with that business of “why one needs an attorney.”

Who is going to believe Nifong got so swept away that he forgot the kinds of thing UNC Law School Professor Ken Broun was saying at the time:

"Their attorneys advise them not to talk to police even if they're totally innocent, because of the possibility that things that you might say even if you're totally innocent in the case might be viewed differently by the person hearing them than you meant them.” …

And I wouldn't draw any reflection on guilt or innocence based upon the failure to talk, particularly after a lawyer gets involved. That's pretty standard operating procedure?"


My advice is rework the part you just showed me. Or maybe throw it out altogether.

And if you have time, drop by Professor Johnson’s office and see what he has to say. Also, go over to the Liestoppers department building and talk to some of the people there.

Wednesday, November 15, 2006

The Churchill Series – Nov. 15, 2006

(One of a series of weekday posts on the life of Winston S. Churchill.)

Today we go to a book store: Chartwell Booksellers.

If you’re not familiar with the store the first thing to know is it’s not near Churchill's Chartwell home in Kent, England. It’s in midtown Manhattan. The second thing to know about it you’ve already guessed: the shop deals in all kinds of books regarding Churchill.

Chartwell has rare first editions of some of Churchll’s own works, including ones signed by him. Many of them run into the thousands of dollars. But there are also some of his works still in print that are offered at the jacket price.

Then there are the “about” books. They number in the hundreds.

Chartwell has a good selection of “wit and wisdom of Churchill” books which will make nice holiday gifts. Kay Halle’s is one of my favorites. Kay was a long-time friend of Churchill’s and led the effort here to convince our government to award Churchill honorary American citizenship, which he received in April, 1963.

Chartwell sells only at full price; no discounts.

I’ve no connection to Chartwell other then I love searching its site and ordering from time to time.

Coleman seeks clemency for death row inmate

Duke Law Professor James Coleman met yesterday with North Carolina’s Governor Mike Easley to plead for clemency for convicted murderer Guy La Grande.

La Grande is scheduled to die by lethal injection on Dec. 1 if last minute court appeals and pleas to Easley for clemency fail.

From today’s Raleigh News & Observer, “Lawyers lobby for killer’s life:”

Convicted murderer Guy LeGrande's attorneys hope that Gov. Mike Easley will spare LeGrande's life because his case is similar to that of the only death row inmate to whom Easley has granted clemency.

On Tuesday, Easley listened to arguments from prosecutors and defense attorneys about whether LeGrande should die by lethal injection or spend the rest of his life in prison.

LeGrande, 47, is scheduled to be executed Dec. 1 at Raleigh's Central Prison for the 1993 shooting of Ellen Munford in Stanly County, east of Charlotte.

While prosecutors depicted LeGrande as a calculating killer-for-hire, LeGrande's attorneys described him as a severely mentally ill man who was chosen to commit the crime and prosecuted capitally because of his race. The defense team hopes the racial parallels between LeGrande's case and that of Robert Bacon Jr. will sway the governor.

Bacon, who is black, was sentenced to death for the 1987 stabbing of his lover's husband. His co-defendant, Bonnie Sue Clark, a white woman who recruited Bacon to kill her husband, got a lesser sentence and is eligible for parole. In October 2001, Easley commuted Bacon's sentence to life in prison -- the only time he has granted clemency.

Since taking office in January 2001, Easley has denied clemency for 27 death row inmates, who have all been executed.

Tommy Munford, the victim's estranged husband, recruited LeGrande to do the killing in exchange for $6,500. Munford, who is white, is eligible for a parole hearing in January. Prosecutors allowed him to plead guilty to second-degree murder in exchange for his testimony against LeGrande.

Both Bacon and LeGrande were sentenced to death by all-white juries. In both cases, Julian Bond, chairman of the NAACP's board of directors, wrote a letter to Easley asking for clemency.

In comparison to Bacon's clemency claim, "this is a much more deserving case," said Duke University law professor Jim Coleman, who was one of Bacon's attorneys and now represents LeGrande. [The rest of the story follows here.]
Coleman has represented pro bono many death row inmates. He serves as a faculty advisor to Duke Law School’s Innocence Project which gives students an opportunity to work of cases of convicted felons who likely are actually innocent.

Back on June 13 when Coleman’s letter calling for DA Mike Nifong to step aside and allow a special prosecutor to take charge of the Duke lacrosse case was published, KC Johnson posted on the latter and also provided information about Coleman’s work on behalf of inmates thought likely to have been wrongly convicted.

Here's another Duke prof

Concerning the possibility that indictments in the Duke Hoax case might be dismissed because of massive investigative irregularities and the absence of sufficient evidence to warrant a trial, Duke University Professor Thomas Crowley tells Durham Herald Sun readers he:

“most certainly [does] not think the case should be thrown out just because of some half-baked and half-true legal opinions by people who don't know what they are talking about, and by a group of lawyers and advocates who seem to be doing their best to confuse the public."
Crowley assures readers:
”I do not know what happened that night. I have no preconditioned preference for whether the accused were guilty or not.”
But the professor with “no preconditioned preference” concerning guilt or innocence does want us to consider some important questions:
"Why are photographs available before and after the alleged event, but not during it? Is it possible that the photographer did not want to document what was happening during that time?"
Well, aren’t we lucky to have a Duke professor with “no preconditioned preference” regarding guilt or innocence point out there are what he calls "before and after" photos but none during “the alleged event , [ possibly because ] the photographer did not want to document what was happening during that time?”

Question: Besides fooling himself regarding having "no preconditioned preference," do you think Professor Crowley fooled anyone else except perhaps colleagues like Professors Starn, Holloway, Rosenberg, Lubiano, Wood, etc, etc,?

Where does Duke find such professors?

Liestoppers does a great takedown of Crowley's "offeriings." Don't miss the last paragraph.

Tuesday, November 14, 2006

The Churchill Series – Nov. 14, 2006

(One of a series of weekday posts on the life of Winston S. Churchill.)

Lord Randolph Churchill died on January 20, 1895 convinced that his son Winston would be a failure and bring no honor to the family name.

Four weeks later, on February 20, 1895 Winston began his life of service to his country. As his biographer, Martin Gilbert, tells it:

”Churchill entered the cavalry. … His commission was made out, according to custom, from Queen Victoria to ‘Our Trusty and well beloved Winston Leonard Spencer Churchill, Gentleman,’ and was signed by the Secretary of State for War, Campbell-Bannerman, who less than eleven years later was to give Churchill his first Ministerial office, as Under-Secretary of State for the Colonies.
During the next half-century, Churchill would serve four Kings - Edward VII, George V, Edward VIII and George VI - and another Queen - Elizabeth II - in a number of Ministerial offices.

Churchill’s last day of Ministerial service was April 5, 1955, on which day he resigned as the Queen’s Prime Minister.

In his later years, Churchill often expressed regret that his father, whom he loved and admired, had not lived long enough to see the course his life was taking. He died on January 20, 1965, seventy years to the day of his father’s death.
_________________________________________________________
For this post, I drew from Martin Gilbert’s Churchill: A Life. The passage quoted is found on pg. 51 of the Henry Holt & Co’s 1991 American Edition.

Concerning Collin Finnerty and his family

At Friends of Duke University's website (not affiliated with Duke), I just read a warm, informative and poignant profile of Collin Finnerty and his family: three generations of them.

It's Joan Collins’ “Profile in Courage – My Meeting with the Finnertys”

If I said more, I’d only be holding you up from reading it. So go on.

But when you finish, please come back and comment.

In a few days I’ll do what I did today with the Bob Harris thread: pass on your comments.

Two “88” classic posts

Johnsville News provides a very valuable service with it’s recent post: “Duke case: The ‘listening’ statement.”

JN’s post could have been subtitled: “A history and analysis of an irresponsible and exploitive document that a large group of Duke University faculty rushed to sign.” The post has many links, including one to a recent Chronicle article on the growing ridicule and scorn faculty who signed the listening statement are enduring and their various attempts to avoid responsibility for what they did.

Be sure to read The Chronicle article’s comment thread. Readers really sounded off when one of the 88 signers posted what I’m sure he thought would be a dismissal of his critics. O boy! Was he ever wrong.

JN’s post includes the full text of the 88’s statement as well as a link to it.

Another of JN’s links is to an April 23 KC Johnson post at Cliopatria: “The Duke 88.” That post was my first “contact” with KC.

Was I ever impressed? I kept asking myself, “Why isn’t faculty at Duke saying what this guy’s saying?” I still ask that question. There are many decent people on the A&S faculty who should be speaking up and countering the 88’s exploitations of students and misrepresentation of the University.

KC ended his April 23 post with these questions:

How many of the Duke 88 would affix their signatures to a public affirmation that they are “listening” to the exculpatory evidence of a student at their own institution, and expressing concern that local authorities could be veering toward a miscarriage of justice regarding Seligmann? Or do they “listen” only to versions of events that conform to their preconceived worldview, like the student at North Carolina Central, seeking “justice for things that happened in the past”?
So far he answer to KC’s first question is: “at most a few.” The answer to his second question seems to be: “Yes, they do quite a lot of that.”


I’ll be posting often in the next few weeks on the “88” and their “listening statement.” I’ll use this post as a reference for those needing background to my posts.

Congrats to JN and KC for their “88” classic posts.

St. Pete Times: Drop it, Nifong

Florida’s St. Petersburg Times is the latest newspaper calling on Durham DA Mike Nifong to turn the Duke case over to a special prosecutor who can bring some “sense of fairness to the prosecution.”

The Times says [excerpts]:

[It’s no surprise] the rape charges emerging from a team party in March that included underage drinking and strippers performing became a national cause and have riven the Durham, N.C., community along racial, gender and class lines.

The surprise has come from the irresponsibility of the district attorney. Michael Nifong first tried the case in the media, fanning the flames of social discord, and has refused to reconsider the case as evidence emerged that strongly pointed to the innocence of the accused.

Nifong has behaved irresponsibly and significantly compromised this case. He should hand it off to an impartial prosecutor.

From every vantage it appears that Nifong grandstanded this tragic case as a way to build voter support in Durham's African-American community. …

The CBS News show 60 Minutes recently did a thorough review of the evidence available and found that there is little to corroborate the accuser's story.

The DNA of the three accused men failed to match that found on the accuser's body.

One of the accused, Reede Seligmann, has cell phone records that show he made nine phone calls when the crime was alleged to have been committed. He was also photographed by a bank security camera at an ATM machine about that time.

The other exotic dancer at the party that evening says that she didn't see an attack and was with the alleged victim nearly the entire time.

The accuser has apparently changed her story a number of times and reportedly went back to performing even while going to hospitals to say she was racked by pain from the attack.

The lives of the three young men accused, Seligmann, Collin Finnerty and David Evans, are on hold until their trial next spring.

Yet Nifong, the man who has upended their lives, seems increasingly uninterested in the facts of the case. He recently said that he has not ever talked with the alleged victim, and he has refused to consider the alibi evidence from one of the accused.

Nifong has a prosecutor's obligation to be open to new evidence that might challenge original conclusions. His primary goal should be to seek justice, not keep his job by fanning public outrage and playing on racial and class bias.

Only an outside, independent prosecutor can bring some sense of fairness to a prosecution that has been terribly mishandled from the beginning.
The St. Pete Times is right on every point.

I’m sending copies of the editorial and this post to Durham Herald Sun editor Bob Ashely and Raleigh News & Observer editorial page editor Steve Ford.

To the list of reasons the St. Pete Times gives for Nifong stepping aside, I can add two more:

1) Nifong’s claim that he hasn’t been able to get the accuser to talk to him about the alleged crimes is a very strong argument for a special prosecutor taking over the case. Surely, whoever is going to prosecute the case needs to talk to the accuser and assess first-hand what she is saying. Eight months have passed since the alleged events.

2) If a trial is held, jury selection is expected to take several weeks and the trial that will follow is expected to take many months. During all that time, the legal proceding will necessarily absorb almost all, if not all, Nifong’s professional time and attention, including as always happens with major trials the need to work weekends.

Durham has a very serious crime problem, made much worse be the recent rapid growth in gang activity. By stepping aside and allowing a special prosecutor to take over the case, Nifong will free himself to do what he promised during the campaign to do: fight violent street crime and the gang problem

KC Johnson reports The Charlotte Observer, The Rocky Mount Telegram, and The Winston-Salem Journal have all called for Nifong to step aside and allow a special prosecutor to take charge of the case.

I hope we can soon add the N&O and the H-S to that list.