Readers’ Note: After today I’ll name the False Accuser in posts and allow her name to be used on the threads. In this post I tell you why I’m doing that.
For one week starting tomorrow, I’ll put “Cautions” at the head of posts relating to the Hoax. They’ll let readers know this is a “name her” blog. After that, I’ll drop the “Cautions.”
So now you’re alerted. Please let others know as you can.
I think most of you will agree with what I’m about to say. I wish the rest of you well should you choose to move on.
John
________________________________________
There’s much public discussion now regarding news organizations’ practice of granting anonymity to those claiming to be victims of sex crimes, and at the same time identifying those who are accused.
Many say it’s very unfair that an accuser is granted anonymity while the accused are not only identified, but are sometimes framed by false reporting and character abuse as we’ve seen the Raleigh News & Observer do in the case of the Duke lacrosse players.
Even when news organizations strive to be fair and honest, “anonymity for the accuser, public exposure for the accused” is unfair to the accused, as Duke Law professor James Coleman and many others have said.
Those arguing for anonymity for accusers rely on a “greater good” argument: without anonymity victims of sex crimes will be reluctant to come forward. As a result, criminals will go unpunished and be free to repeat their crimes.
All in all, I come down on the side of granting anonymity.
But anonymity is not a right; it’s a privilege that should never be abused.
In the Duke Hoax case, the accuser and much of media have repeatedly and grossly abused the anonymity privilege.
In a future post, I’ll talk about media’s abuse.
Today I want to tell you why the Duke Hoax accuser has lost all claim to the privilege of anonymity, at least in my opinion and here at JinC.
The Duke Hoax accuser they call “Precious” used the cloak of anonymity to tell “her story” (there were really many of them) not to authorities, but to the N&O, which then told readers she was granted anonymity because she was a victim of “sex crimes.”
It can be fairly argued that when Precious granted that press interview she lost all claim to the unfair advantage anonymity gave her.
However, it may be the accuser was caught off guard by the N&O.
We may even learn she was encouraged to speak to the N&O by police investigators or someone from DA Mike Nifong’s office who “brokered” the interview. The N&O has never said who put it in touch with Precious or why the person(s) did that.
So I’m willing, until I learn more about it, to give the accuser a pass on the interview.
I also don’t hold her responsible for how the N&O reported the interview, including suppressing news the players had cooperated with the police and informing readers she was granted anonymity because the N&O did that for “victims of sex crimes.”
But then media began reporting interviews with family members who were also granted anonymity so Precious’ anonymity could be preserved. The family members told much more of “her story.” We were also told she’d be suing the players once they were convicted.
The accuser never did anything to correct any of that. She let it all work for her.
The April “no wrong choices” photo ID process was essential for the frame-up to go forward. Precious did her part and picked four players she was sure raped her.
Nifong indicted three players (we’ve never, as far as I know, been told why it was only three and not four). None of the three fit the physical descriptions of her “attackers” that Precious had given police.
Precious knew all of that. But neither she nor her family, previously so willing to talk to media, said anything. They hid behind the cloak of anonymity.
Precious knew Reade Seligmann was one of those indicted. But she said nothing for eight months before telling a DA investigator he hadn’t attacked her; he’d only watched.
And by the way, she wasn’t sure she’d been raped, but she wanted the players prosecuted for, you know, the other parts of the frame-up she and Nifong and others had arranged. Only she didn’t call it a frame-up.
Precious has grossly abused the privilege of anonymity.
It’s one thing for us to grant a person the protection of anonymity; it’s quite another thing, and an unacceptable and odious thing, to stand by and watch that person perpetrate frauds and injustices under the cloak of anonymity.
Professor Coleman has described what Nifong and Precious have done as “almost like mooning the system.” I agree.
By not acting sooner to identify the False Accuser, I helped enable her to moon the system.
But that changes tomorrow. Naming her is my way of putting sunlight on her mooning.
Tuesday, January 30, 2007
Fairness demands she be named
Posted by JWM at 6:58 PM 11 comments
Carolina-Duke tix auction for ATAF
Duke Basketball Report is sponsoring an auction to help raise funds to defend the lacrosse players so grievously wronged by DA Mike Nifong and his enablers.
From DBR:
We have a very special auction to announce: four tickets for the UNC game (2/7), all together. The tickets are section 15, row h, seats 6,8,10, 12. These are near center court. There aren’t too many seats which are better than these. On top of everything else, you’ll see the action on the bench.Here’s an opportunity to do good and enjoy a Carolina-Duke basketball game in Cameron, the greatest b'ball setting in America.
The proceeds of the sale of these tickets will benefit ATAF, the Association for Truth and Fairness, which was spawned out of the criminal investigation of the Duke men’s lacrosse team. The Duke lacrosse players need to raise $3 million dollars to help defray their legal expenses.
Please bid on these tickets and remember that every dollar you pay for these tickets will help defray the legal expenses of the Duke lacrosse players, which have been $3 million so far.
Even if you don’t bid - and we hope you do, even if it’s just to push the price up higher - you can help out by making an online donation. If everyone who reads DBR contributed just five dollars, we’d help them a lot.
There is this unfortunate myth that somehow, this is just an inconvenience to three wealthy families.
That’s absurd of course. These families are spending everything they have to defend their children against a prosecutor who has no interest at all in offering them a fair trial.
You can learn more or contribute at TRUTHandFAIRNESS.
Important caveat: you’ll need to check on whether or not this auction is tax-deductible for you or not.
Hat Tip: Durham-in-Wonderland
Posted by JWM at 11:44 AM 0 comments
Monday, January 29, 2007
The Churchill Series - Jan. 29, 2007
(One of a series of weekday posts on the life of Winston S. Churchill.)
In the fall of 1929 Churchill sailed for America to begin a speaking tour. He had just served five years as Chancellor of the Exchequer. Threats on his life had been made by Indian extremists. Therefore, the British government arranged for Churchill to be accompanied by a Scotland Yard bodyguard, even though he was no longer in office.
To Churchill’s delight the man chosen to guard him was Detective-Inspector Walter Thompson, who'd been his bodyguard when he was in office.
In those days, when a liner was due to arrive in New York, the press would charter a tug and go down the harbor to meet the ship; then go on board to interview celebrities and statesmen before the ship docked.
Thompson tells us what happened when the New York press came aboard Churchill’s liner and demanded to see our hero:
When we arrived in New York, I had my first experience of the American press. The ship had not docked but at dawn one morning my cabin was besieged by a crowd of men and women making a most fearful row. I thought that the Indian terrorists must be at hand!Who doubts it did?
They were shouting for Mr. Churchill. I stepped out and asked them who they were and what they wanted.
“Newspapermen,” they replied, as though that explained everything. “We must see Churchill.”
I replied that I was astonished at their behaviour, and told them bluntly that I had no intention at all of letting them interview the British statesman at this ridiculous hour.
This led to further uproar
Eventually everything worked out. The press went to a lounge where a short while later Churchill joined the reporters for an interview. Thompson added:
Those whom I met that day were by no means the worst representatives of the American press against whom I have protected Mr. Churchill.Thompson’s remarks put me in mind of something. Churchill no doubt had his opinions about how the American press compared with the British press. But I can’t bring to mind anytime he ever expressed them. I’m sure he did. Can anyone shed light on this matter?
_______________________________________________
Thompson, Walter - Beside the Bulldog: The Intimate Memoirs of Churchill’s Bodyguard Ex- Detective Inspector Walter Thompson. (p. 71)
Posted by JWM at 11:50 PM 0 comments
An N&O joke
A Raleigh News & Observer reporter witnessed a man risk his life to save a child from an attack by a rabid dog.
The reporter asked the man if he could interview him for the story he was going to write for the next day’s N&O.
The man said sure. The reporter got out his laptop and began entering story text.
Soon the man noticed the reporter had typed as his lede: “Tar Heel fan risks life, saves child”
“Why are you calling me a Tar Heel fan,” the man asked?
“We’re in Chapel Hill. Isn’t everyone here a Tar Heel fan?” the reporter replied.
“Not me,” the man said. "I’m a Duke fan.”
The story appeared in N&O under the lede: “Duke fan kills family pet”
Posted by JWM at 2:11 PM 8 comments
Race and Rev. Barber’s sermon
A few hours ago I posted: “Rev. Barber at Duke Chapel.”
The post, as you can read for yourselves here, reported on the sermon delivered today at Duke Chapel by the Rev. William J. Barber II, pastor of Goldsboro’s Greenleaf Christian Church and current president of NC’s NAACP. The post also included my commentary on the sermon.
A JinC reader has responded with this comment:
I'm sorry - but the moment I read Rev. Barber was black, I knew which 'side' he was on.Hold on, Reader!
When he said he would speak about silence, I knew he would not speak of the black community's silence towards the suffering of the white Duke players but the other way around.
When he said he would speak about racial slurs, I knew he would not speak about Kim Roberts hurling them at the lacrosse players but the other way around.
When he said he would speak about bad choices, I knew he would not speak about Kim's bad choice to strip in front of strangers or Crystal's bad choice to use a sex toy on herself for money but the bad choices of the Duke players for hiring strippers.
For God's sake - and I mean that literally - I sincerely wish Rev. Barber had proven me wrong. But he chose not to.
How do we know, based on race, “which ‘side’” a person’s on in terms of the Duke lacrosse case overall, or in terms of its many facets?
How can you know, based only on Barber’s sermon text, that his race determined what he said?
Haven’t many white Duke professors made statements very similar to what
Barber said today?
In fact, couldn’t Barber’s sermon just as easily have been composed and delivered by any number of white preachers, including many who hold endowed professorships at Duke’s Divinity School?
I’ll bet even the Chapel Dean, the Rev. Canon Dr. Sam Wells, would agree about that.
I’ll end with four brief points on which you and I, and others should all be able to come together:
1) Durham Herald Sun editor Bob Ashley and N&O editors Melanie Sill, John Drescher and Linda Williams are all responsible for grossly unfair and false reporting concerning the Duke lacrosse players.
2) Ashley, Sill and Drescher are white; Williams is black.
3) CBS’s 60 Minutes' investigative reporter Ed Bradley spent the last months of his life working on a story that helped millions of Americans realize David Evans, Collin Finnerty and Reade Seligmann were framed.
4) Race, as the writer said, matters. Yet it doesn’t ever explain everything; and sometimes it doesn’t even explain very much. But character always matters. We we’re reminded of that when we learned of Ed Bradley’s death. RIP
Posted by JWM at 12:19 AM 16 comments
Sunday, January 28, 2007
Rev. Barber at Duke Chapel
Readers’ Note:
News reporting is above the star-line; commentary’s below it.
John
____________________________________________
Rev. Dr. William J Barber II, pastor of Greenleaf Christian Church in Goldsboro, NC, preached the sermon today at the 11 A.M. service at Duke Chapel.
Barber’s a graduate of NC Central University (BA in Public Administration, cum laude) and Duke’s Divinity School, where he was a Benjamin Mays Fellow and earned a Masters of Divinity degree. Barber earned his doctoral degree at Drew University, Madison, NJ. (More bio information can be found here.)
Barber, who also serves as NC’s NAACP state president, spoke out often last spring concerning the Duke lacrosse case. At a series of news conferences he urged a prompt, full and fair investigation of charges made by a woman many at the time were calling “the victim.” Barber also met with Duke’s president, Richard H. Brodhead, who later described him as a friend from whom he had learned a great deal.
In recent months Barber’s said little about the case. But during today’s sermon he directly addressed it along with some issues many see as related to it. (I viewed the entire Chapel service via webcast.)
Barber told the congregation he would not speak about the treatment the players have received or “the indictments.” He was “putting them aside,” he said, because he wanted to talk about “silences” and “injustices.”
The “silences” existed, Barber said, because of our “denials” as individuals and a society of problems such as those evident in the racial slurs directed at the women the night of Mar. 13/14 and less than adequate educational opportunities for many children.
Barber invoked the memory and words of Dr. King in urging the congregation to make its own King’s work of bettering the opportunities available to the less fortunate and assuring that America continues to strive to be more just.
Just prior to his sermon Barber expressed appreciation to people who’d instructed and befriended him during his student days at Duke. He thanked Greenleaf Christian congregants who accompanied him to the Chapel. And he said he was glad to be with his “good friend,” Chapel Dean Sam Wells.
***********************************************************************
First, many of you will want to access Rev. Barber’s sermon. You can do that by going to the Chapel’s home page where you’ll see on your right a menu with a yellow background. The first listing is View Webcasts. Click. Now you’re at Webcast Archive. Archived sermons are in reverse chronological order.
Barber’s sermon is the first listed but it’s not active as of 6 P.M 1/28. Tech support will likely have the sermon active within a few days of its delivery.
When you click to activate the sermon it will take a minute or two before the sermon “loads up.” If you use Real Player there’s a clip bar, so you can move back and forth through the service. My recollection is Barber began preaching with the timer at about forty minutes.
Thanks are due the Friends of the Chapel who make the webcasts possible.
Now, my commentary -------
We benefit when we’re reminded of those in need and our responsibility to help them. The same is true when injustices are called to our attention and we’re offered the example of someone like Dr. King who sought to undo injustices.
Barber spoke about those things, but with less effect than he could have had.
That’s because, for reasons he never really explained, he put aside considerations of the monumental injustices done the lacrosse players while bringing “front and center” considerations of racial slurs made the night of March 13/14, and his judgment that the women dancers were at the party as a consequence of economic and social forces rather than as a result of individual choices they made.
Many in the congregation know the second dancer, Kim Roberts, acknowledges she began the racial slurring a neighbor overheard when Roberts taunted some of the players with “little ---- white boys.” But Barber only focused on the black women as victims of the slurs; and he directed his censure only at the white players.
Such discriminations are expected nowadays from NAACP leaders and others like them, but such discriminations have no basis in Christian theology.
Do you doubt there were at least some informed congregants, free of PC bias, who listened to Barber and asked themselves:
“Has he ever mounted a pulpit and condemned the racists who made threats of physical violence and death against Reade Seligman last May 18?I’m sure everyone in the congregation who worships the holy trinity of race, class and gender agreed with Barber that social and economic forces brought the women to the house that night. But I wonder exactly how Barber and such congregants explain to themselves the fact that millions of women subject to the same economic and social forces as the two exotic dancers don’t do exotic dancing; and would feel ashamed and disgraced it they did.
Has Barber ever encouraged President Brodhead or Dean Wells or anyone else at Duke to condemn those racists?
During all of Barber’s talking about the case at news conferences, at forums and in pulpit sermons has he ever expressed even a few words of solidarity and comfort to Reade Seligmann and his family?”
There is more I could say but this post is getting long.
I’d like to hear Barber preach again sometime. His high intellect and theological training suggest he’s capable of a profound sermon that illuminates the heart of God. Today, for all his invocation of religious texts and beliefs, Barber merely delivered “the latest” from NC’s NAACP.
If Barber preaches again in Duke Chapel,I have a sermon topic and title suggestion: "False witness: Why God said it was sinful."
Posted by JWM at 7:53 PM 10 comments
Sheehan knows she knows
Will Raleigh News & Observer columnist Ruth Sheehan do what she demands others to do: “Speak honestly and admit when you wrong?
Let’s see.
______________________________________________
Dear Ms. Sheehan:
Ten months ago you wrote a column (“Team’s Silence is Sickening”) savaging 46 Duke students for doing nothing more than following the advice of their parents and attorneys. You began:
Members of the Duke men's lacrosse team: You know.After that, your column got even worse.
We know you know.
Whatever happened in the bathroom at the stripper party gone terribly, terribly bad, you know who was involved. Every one of you does.
And one of you needs to come forward and tell the police.
Do not be afraid of retribution on the team. Do not be persuaded that somehow this "happened" to one or more "good guys."
That was March 27, 2006.
Later that day, for the first time, Durham DA Mike Nifong spoke publicly about the students.
Like you, Nifong attacked them in terms that reminded thoughtful citizens of how the late Sen. McCarthy attacked people and denigrated their constitutional rights.
Most people initially endorsed what you and Nifong were saying.
Others, such as Duke’s president, Richard H. Brodhead, calculated their best course was to say nothing critical of you or Nifong.
Instead, Brodhead-types made statements similar to what President Brodhead himself said shortly thereafter:
”Whatever they did was bad enough.”But as the public learned more about the students and Nifong, it got harder to convince people that “Whatever they did was bad enough.”
By June sensible people recognized the truth of what Duke Law professor James Coleman said in his letter to the N&O:
According to the police account of the identification, however, the police officer who presided over the proceedings told the alleged victim at the outset that he wanted her to look at people the police had reason to believe attended the party.You knew Coleman was describing a frame-up. You knew we knew.
Thus, the police not only failed to include people they knew were not suspects among the photographs shown the woman, they told the witness in effect that there would be no such "fillers" among the photographs she would see.
This strongly suggests that the purpose of the identification process was to give the alleged victim an opportunity to pick three members of the lacrosse team who could be charged. Any three students would do; there could be no wrong choice.
So a few days later you wrote a column blaming Nifong for your Mar. 27 column:
”To think that for a brief moment I [,Raleigh News & Observer columnist Ruth Sheehan,] actually pitied Nifong for the attacks on his handling of the case. What a joke.But, Ms. Sheehan, your Mar. 27 “Team’s Silence is Sickening” column appeared BEFORE Nifong started publicly attacking the students. It went online shortly after midnight; and a print version was delivered to Durham driveways around 5 A.M. Nifong had plenty of time to read it before he first spoke to the press later that day.
Nifong is the one who described this thing in such incendiary terms from the start that it was impossible to ignore.
All of the above leads to two obvious questions:
1) Considering he didn't speak publicly until after your column appeared, aren't you misleading readers when you tell them all the slimes in your Mar. 27 were based on what he said?
or
2) Did Nifong or someone you trusted would tell you accurately what he was saying provide you with “background information” BEFORE you wrote your Mar. 27 column? In that case, while you’d still bear the heaviest responsibility for the column, you’d have some grounds for telling readers Nifong was also to blame for it.
Please answer the questions.
You know the answers. You know you know.
Just so we’re absolutely clear about Nifong: I’ve said for months he should be disbarred and tried. But odious as he is, he shouldn’t be blamed for your enablements or for those of others.
Finally, at your Metro Blog you posted some of my writing and linked back to my blog. While that usually calls for a "thank you," I want instead to urge you to do some things that will be very important and helpful to many innocent people who’ve suffered great injustices.
Please retract both your Mar. 27 and your Apr. 3 “Lacrosse team out of control” columns. Then apologize to the students, their families, Coach Pressler and his wife and young children. An apology is also owed your readers.
If you do those things unconditionally and free of any blaming of others, you will have provided what restorative justice you can to those most injured by the witch hunt to which your columns made such a significant contribution.
You will also have given your readers some assurance that truth, justice and their trust are important to you.
And you will have acted as you often tell us you want others to act, including your three young sons.
Sincerely,
John in Carolina
www.johnincarolina.com
Posted by JWM at 11:07 AM 17 comments
Saturday, January 27, 2007
Even better now
Last September I posted: “Duke lacrosse: Lots of good posts.”
I said a few words about and linked to posts by the usual suspects – Durham-in-Wonderland, Johnsville News and Liestoppers.
I did the same with posts by Bill Anderson (It’s the classic “Duke’s Reichstag Fire."), Mike Gaynor, and Melanie Sill at the Editors’ Blog who was attempting to explain away the N&O's inadequate reporting on DPD Sgt. Mark Gottlieb's very troubling treatment of Duke students.
I re-read those posts this morning. The passing of time has left them better now than in September.
For example, a Liestoppers post featured Durham Herald Sun editor Bob Ashley in LS’s Meet the Enablers Series. Here’s Bob talking about H-S Hoax news reporting:
“We've treated that part of the story, quite frankly, much like The New York Times has.”Funny then; funnier now.
Here’s another:
“We've tried to consistently remind that all the facts aren't out, and that the defense attorneys are releasing just what fragments of the total evidence they choose to make public."That was Bob during the DA election campaign. If anyone couldn’t see how Bob was spinning for Nifong then, I hope they can now.
I’m reposting “Duke lacrosse: Lots of good posts” so you can access and enjoy those "better now posts."
I’d love to hear your reactions, especially from those of you who read the posts last September.
John
____________________________________________________
William Anderson reminds us of what much of Duke campus was like last Spring. He tells us how and why it was that way.
Attorney Mike Gaynor is calling on the accuser to come forward; tell the truth; and end the hoax and the injustices and miseries its spawned. Key graf:
The Duke case should be put out of its misery, so the undeserved misery of the Duke Three and their families and friends can be alleviated, they can move on with their lives, and the people of Durham County can do what they need to do.I hope it happens, Mike, but I'm not holding my breath.
Liestoppers has two posts up today. One is “Let the Great Axe Fall.” I’ll bet you can guess whose head they want. Liestoppers' Meet the Enablers Series has a very deserving “honoree” today: Durham Herald Sun Editor Bob Ashley.
Besides serving as Liestoppers Enabler “honoree,” Ashley’s doing double duty today serving as KC Johnson’s “piñata of the day.” Here’s part of what KC says:
In the lacrosse case, Ashley has failed at performing the basic journalistic task of speaking truth to power–and in an affair where the representatives of "power" desperately need rebuke. But he’s not a very good propagandist, either. His paper’s columns and articles are either comically heavy-handed (as in the editorial praising Chalmers’ alleged openness) or unintentionally helpful to critics of Nifong and Gottlieb. No wonder the Herald-Sun’s circulation figures continue to plunge. Hilarity on the news and editorial pages, whether intended or not, isn’t a good selling point.You may be asking: It there any life left in Ashley’s H-S. Johnsville News offers its answer: “Duke Case: Death Spiral for The Herald-Sun”
The Herald-Sun may be another casualty of the Duke rape hoax. The case has been an acid test for North Carolina journalists. It looks like the acid from this case may peel away the remaining dead flesh from the corpse of The Herald-Sun.When Bob Ashley first took over as H-S editor in December 2004 he said to me: “Give me some time, John. I’ll show you what I can do with this paper.”
I did; he has.
One final link is to the Raleigh N&O's Editors' Blog post "Duke lacrosse latest: Gottlieb profile." Scroll down and take a look at what reader/commenters are posting on the thread.
Posted by JWM at 1:52 PM 3 comments
Friday, January 26, 2007
The Churchill Series – Jan. 26, 2007
(One of a series of weekday posts on the life of Winston S. Churchill.)
The General Charles De Gaulle Foundation is a non-political, tax exempt organization dedicated to preserving General de Gaulle’s memory. The foundation’s site contains an essay on the complex and often tempestuous relationship between de Gaulle and Churchill.
Here’s a portion of that essay. The portion begins with a mention of their first meeting on June 9, 1940. Churchill had been PM for just a month. He had gone to France to coordinate military strategy and encourage the French government to remain in the war as a fighting ally. But defeatism among most French leaders was much stronger than Churchill had suspected. Just days after his visit the French declared Paris an open city and began armistice talks with the Germans:
From their very first meeting on 9 June 1940, a spark was struck between the two men. Churchill saw immediately that General de Gaulle refused all thought of ceasing the fight: he believed in "l'idée De Gaulle" (the De Gaulle idea), saw in him "l'homme du destin" (the man of destiny), for he felt that the patriotism of this man was of the same stuff as his own.You can read the entire essay here. Also, I think you’ll enjoy looking around the site.
Hence his courageous decision, against the advice of his own government, to support the leader of the Free French by allowing him access to the BBC and recognizing him as his partner in the struggle to defeat Germany and Nazism (28/06/1940).
The mutual esteem between the two men was nonetheless founded on a different perception of the other, arising from their culture and their respective situations. Churchill was very familiar with the history of France and had great admiration for it ; he was an undoubted Francophile, although he occasionally showed a certain condescension which never failed to irritate his ally.
The education the General had received, fed through both family tradition and his schooling on images of Joan of Arc and Napoleon or memories of Fashoda, did not incline him towards friendship for "Albion" and the Anglo-Saxons.
He nonetheless recognized the British virtues of courage, discipline and fair play, and acknowledged the great political and diplomatic experience of Churchill, his senior. He showed on numerous occasions his gratitude to the King and to the people of Britain for the warm welcome they extended to himself and to the free French.
Have a nice weekend. I hope to see you next week.
Posted by JWM at 11:50 PM 0 comments
Brodhead’s BA
“The facts kept changing. Every day we learned new things that no one knew the day before. Every day we were being urged to speak with certainty about facts that were full of great uncertainty at that point. Our policy all along was to act on the basis of the things we knew for sure and to withhold action and decision on the things we didn’t know for sure.”
Duke University President Richard H. Brodhead speaking to the late CBS newsman Ed Bradley during a 60 Minutes interview aired Oct. 15, 2006.
"Once the situation existed, it had to be dealt with. I'm really not immune to self-criticism in any way, I believe we've handled this as straightforwardly and honorably as we could have, given the extraordinary nature of the situation and the changing nature of the facts."
President Brodhead to Chronicle reporter Rob Copeland during Q&A published Jan. 22, 2007.
Those are two versions of President Brodhead’s basic alibi (BA) for his actions and failures to act last spring following false accusations by a hoaxer known as "Precious."
Now an excerpt from an N&O story today reporting on a panel discussion yesterday at Duke Law School:
[American University Law professor Michael] Tigar said, Nifong should not have derided the players for invoking their Constitutional right to counsel -- a hallmark of the justice system.No, Nifong shouldn’t have done that. All of us, including Brodhead, knew that at the time. But Brodhead decided in March to say nothing critical of Nifong.
Brodhead also knew the players had cooperated with police. But when Nifong, the N&O and others attacked the players with false charges of cover-up and stonewalling, Brodhead said nothing to correct the false charges.
When faculty-members, students and others swarmed about the lawn in front of his office the night of March 29 waving “Wanted” and “Vigilante” posters and targeting the players with threats of physical harm, Brodhead once again said nothing. Nor did he say anything when Duke’s faculty Group of 88 used a full-page ad in The Chronicle to, among other things, tell the protestors: “Thank you for not waiting”
Brodhead excuses his silences with his BA that includes:
“The facts kept changing. Every day we learned new things that no one knew the day before.”But fact’s don’t change. The Constitution’s been the nation’s law for more than 200 years. Brodhead knew the players had cooperated with police. And he knew the “wall of silence” lie was enabling hateful people and endangering the players. Yet he remained silent.
The protesters who targeted the players on Duke’s campus March 29 took over a previously planned event: Take Back The Night, an annual march against violence.
On Apr. 2 the N&O published a letter from one of the TBTN organizers who said in part:
As one of the organizers of the March 29 Take Back the Night (TBTN) march and speak-out at Duke University, I want to clarify that we did not plan, nor do we endorse, the distribution of names and pictures of members of the Duke men's lacrosse team.The letter writer, Geoffrey Lorenz, recognized he had a duty to speak out about the events on campus March 29. Brodhead had a much greater duty to speak out. Does anyone doubt Brodhead knew that then and knows it now?
The distribution of the pictures, the targeting of the lacrosse team, and the violence implicit in the defacement of the pictures are nothing less than violations of the space that TBTN exists to create. The event is neither a protest of the kind we've witnessed recently, a forum for accusation nor a place to target and defame. That some attendees tried to make it so is saddening and not at all in the spirit of the event.
I can’t accept Brodhead’s BA.
I think Duke needs a new president.
What do you think?
Posted by JWM at 3:04 PM 11 comments
A dam burst in Durham
Blogger and Duke Mom Betsy Newmark says:
I can't imagine that Nifong won't be disbarred after this. I wonder if he'll still get a pension once he has been disbarred. If I were in the Durham government, I'd want to quick pass a provision that would deny him any pension if he is disbarred.New trials for people convicted in prosecutions run by Mike Nifong?
They can use that money for the legal expenses the county is going to have not only defending themselves from any suit that the lacrosse players might bring but also from those who had been convicted in prosecutions run by Mike Nifong and now will ask for new trials. Especially if there was any DNA evidence involved. How can anyone have any faith in any other prosecution that this man conducted now that it is so clear about how easily he corrupted the whole procedure in this case? (bold mine)
Betsy's right, isn't she?
It's going to be a dam burst.
Be sure to read the rest of Betsy's insightful post, "Nifong hoist by his own petard."
Posted by JWM at 10:12 AM 2 comments
Thursday, January 25, 2007
The Churchill Series – Jan. 25, 2007
(One of a series of posts on the life of Winston S. Churchill.)
Lady Violet Bonham Carter first met Churchill when she was 19.
In Winston Churchill: An Intimate Portrait she tells us about that first meeting with Churchill whom she soon grew to love. He did not return her love, but they formed a deep friendship that lasted the rest of his life. Lady Bonham Carter was one of the few people outside the family permitted to visit Churchill’s bedside in the days just before his death on Jan. 24, 1965 :
I first met Winston Churchill in the summer of 1906 at a dinner party to which I went as a very young girl. […]
I found myself sitting next to this young man who seemed to me quite different from any other young man I had ever met. For a long time he remained sunk in abstraction. Then he appeared to become suddenly aware of my existence. He turned on me a lowering gaze and asked me abruptly how old I was.
I replied that I was nineteen. “And I,” he said almost despairingly, “am thirty-two already. Younger than anyone else who counts, though,” he added, as if to comfort himself.
Than savagely: “Curse ruthless time! Curse our mortality. How cruelly short it the allotted span for all we must cram into it!” And he burst forth into an eloquent diatribe on the shortness of human life, the immensity of possible human accomplishment. […]
[He did so] in a torrent of magnificent language which appeared to be both effortless and inexhaustible and ended up with the words I shall always remember: “We are all worms. But I do believe that I am a glowworm.”
By this time I was convinced of it - my conviction remained unshaken throughout the years that followed. (pgs. 3&4)
Posted by JWM at 11:50 PM 0 comments
Five for every “thank you” list
Yesterday the Raleigh N&O reported:
Durham District Attorney Mike Nifong withheld DNA evidence in the Duke lacrosse case and then lied about it to judges and the North Carolina State Bar, according to a complaint filed today by the bar, which licenses and regulates lawyers. […]The news came ten months to the day the N&O “broke the Duke lacrosse story” with a maliciously biased “news report” claiming the False Accuser was “the victim” and framing Duke’s Men’s lacrosse players as her victimizers.
The test results from DNA Security of Burlington found DNA from at least four unidentified men in and on the accuser and excluded the entire lacrosse team as the source.
The bar's complaint said Nifong hid these results from defense lawyers, who repeatedly asked for all DNA test results. Nifong then lied to the court, either on paper or in direct comments to a judge, on five occasions, the complaint said.
Yesterday was a day for the innocent. It “belonged” to the players – all of them – and their families and special friends who’ve endured and pressed on in the face of monumental bigotry and injustices. We can be confident that it is only one of many such days that will now come their way.
Publicly they’ve shown only grace under pressure; their private pains we can only guess at.
With so many players, family members, close friends, Coach Pressler and his family, all surely giving thanks yesterday, there must be hundreds of “thank you” lists out there, but they’re not all the same.
The names of many former teachers are no doubt on a lot of lists but there are different teachers on different lists. It’s the same with hundreds of other people who’ve helped one or a few of the players they knew around town or one the families that live down the block.
So we have the different lists.
But I’ll bet on this: all the lists-makers will agree that the following five deserve a place on all the “thank you” lists:
Duke's 2006 Women’s Lacrosse team led by coach Kerstin Kimel had it right from day one: “Innocent.” They kept saying it in the face sexist derision from many in media and others who call themselves “women’s rights advocates.” The 2006 Women and Men laxers will stand in Duke’s memory as the first groups to tell us the hoax was a hoax.
In April National Journal columnist Stuart Taylor let readers and frenzied media colleagues know:
“[T]he evidence that perhaps no Duke lacrosse player committed rape should make a lot of people ashamed of themselves: District Attorney Mike Nifong, the Durham police, many in the media, politically correct Duke professors, spineless Duke administrators, and others.”Professor James Coleman chaired a committee that produced a fair assessment of the team at the height of the witch hunt. Then he spotlighted the frame-up: “Any three students would do; there could be no wrong choice.”
NY Times columnist David Brooks had the grace and character to tell his readers on May 28:
But now that we know more about the Duke lacrosse team, simple decency requires that we return to that scandal, if only to correct the slurs that were uttered by millions of people, including me.In more than 300 blog posts, professor Robert KC Johnson has made extraordinarily effective use of the scholar's skills to expose the falsehoods, hypocrisies and failures of duty that made the witch hunt and its injustices possible. Rightly critical of the players’ “party conduct,” Johnson’s humanism and faith in the academy brought him to their struggle for fair treatment after almost all their own professors abandoned them. Among those who have "done battle in the public square,” Johnson is primus inter pares.
Posted by JWM at 11:16 AM 16 comments
Wednesday, January 24, 2007
The Churchill Series – Jan. 24, 2007
(One of a series of weekday posts on the life of Winston S. Churchill.)
First, a message to series reader Corwin: Yes, I believe it was you who put me on to the “glowworm” incident which I’ll post on in a day or two. Thank you.
Today is the 43rd anniversary of Churchill’s death at his London home following a stroke two weeks before. He was age 90.
The following is part of the tribute Cambridge historian David Reynolds paid Churchill at the close of his In Command of History: Churchill Fighting and Writing the Second World War. Churchill’s physician, Lord Charles Moran, is the source of the quote Reynolds used:
Three days lying in state in Westminister Hall, as thousands queued across Lambeth Bridge to pay their respects. The coffin drawn on a gun carriage to St. Paul’s, where the monarch – against all protocol – awaited her subject. And the final journey by rail to Bladon, where, “in a country churchyard, in the stillness of a winter evening, in the presence of his family and a few friends, Winston Churchill was committed to English earth, which in his finest hour he had held inviolate.” (p. 531)
Posted by JWM at 11:50 PM 1 comments
Durham faces suits
Under the lead “Don’t hurt Durham” this letter appears in the Jan. 24 Durham Herald Sun.
I hope that the Duke lacrosse families do not agree with the opinion of letter writer Kelly Bowling and sue the City of Durham. Bowling and the Duke families need to realize that it's the taxpayers of Durham who will foot the bill of any civil award, who are already among the most taxed citizens in the state, and most of whom had no say in this prosecution.I hope someone who knows T. Abashian will call my response letter to Abashian’s attention:
A lot of us didn't vote for Mike Nifong, nor support his handling of the case once the facts began to emerge. And most, if not all of us, are ready for this fiasco to be over.
I find it difficult to believe that these three young men with college educations from one of the finest institutions in the country and the support of successful families cannot overcome this incident and go on to lead full and productive lives.
Will anyone outside of Durham even remember their names a year or two from now?
Egregious mistakes were made by the DA's office, but the hard-working citizens of Durham should not have to pay for them.
Once the remaining charges are dropped, the best thing for everyone is to just move on.
T. ABASHIAN
Durham
Dear T. Abashian:
Per your letter in today’s H-S.
I don’t doubt “that these three young men [can] go on to lead full and productive lives.” People who have suffered great injustices often do.
That they do is testimony to the human spirit at its best. But that in no way excuses injustice and those responsible for it.
Like you, I’m a Durham resident who winces at our tax burden, made heavier than it need be because our city government is one of the state's most profligate and poorly managed governments.
But unlike you, I don’t think “[o]nce the remaining charges are dropped, the best thing for everyone is to just move on.”
Just moving on will be the best thing only for people like DA Mike Nifong, certain Durham police officers, and their enablers in city government, media and at Duke.
But it won't be the best thing for Durham. And it certainly wouldn’t be the right thing, either.
The people of Durham and those who come to our city to study, for health reasons or just to visit are entitled to justice. When they don’t receive it, they have a claim on the city.
And so do all of us who have a right to expect our sworn officials and officers to fulfill their oaths to act justly.
Rather than pooh-poohing those who may bring suit against the city, I hope you’ll instead follow closely what the suits, if filed, reveal.
We need to learn all we can about what went on within the DA’s office, the DPD, our city government, and among Durham’s elected officials following the events of March 13/14 at 610 N. Buchanan Blvd, and the false accusations the woman made a few hours later at Duke Hospital.
The more we learn, the better positioned we’ll be to punish those who did wrong, attempt to fix what needs fixing, and acknowledge and empower those who did right.
Near the end of your letter you ask rhetorically: “Will anyone outside of Durham even remember their names a year or two from now?”
I sure hope so. If we don’t, Durham will be set up for more injustices of the kind that certain officials and officers, news organizations and many at Duke have inflicted on the innocent and the community for the past ten months.
John in Carolina
Durham
Posted by JWM at 5:08 PM 9 comments
Mar. 24 - The N&O begins to frame
Ten months ago today, the Raleigh News & Observer "broke" the Hoax story. ("DNA tests ordered for Duke athletes. Lacrosse team reports to lab in rape inquiry," Mar. 24)
The N&O's story makes no mention of Durham DA Mike Nifong who didn't begin speaking publicly about the case until Mar. 27.
But if you read the N&O's story and the rest of this post, you'll see the N&O was already on Mar. 24 telling readers the woman was "the victim" and framing the lacrosse players as her victimizers. The N&O would continue for weeks relantlessly and shamelessly framing the Duke lacrosse players.
When Nifong began speaking publicly about the case he knew he had only to recall and restate what the N&O was already telling the public and the rest of media.
The N&O is the largest and most influential news organization in the Duke/Durham area.
What follows is from a June 12 JinC post: "Duke lacrosse: Look at the first newspaper report"
Melanie Sill, the Raleigh News & Observer’s executive editor for news, has done a lot of cluck-clucking about how The N&O “broke the story” we’ve all come to call the Duke lacrosse case. And she's right about that.
Now let’s take a look at how, on Mar 24, the N&O broke the story under the headlines:
DNA tests ordered for Duke athletesThe N&O began:
Lacrosse team reports to lab in rape inquiry
Durham police had 46 members of the Duke University lacrosse team DNA-tested Thursday in the suspected gang-rape of a woman at an off-campus party last week.As the story moves along, you notice statements like:
Police think at least three of the men could be responsible for the sexual assault, beating, robbery and near-strangulation of one of two women who had an appointment to dance at the party March 13, according to a search warrant.
A search warrant returned Thursday details the attack the victim described to police.But the search warrant didn’t detail “the attack the victim described.”
The search warrant only contained details the accuser gave police about an alleged attack.
Why didn't the N&O tell readers that? And “victim?” Where did that come from, you ask?
The N&O explained:
It is The News & Observer's policy not to identify victims of reported sex crimes.The N&O didn’t say how it knows someone reporting a sex crime is a victim; or whether it just goes ahead and grants victim status and anonymity to anyone reporting what the person says was a sex crime.
But regardless of how The N&O decides such things, the effect of its granting victim status to the accuser was to frame the Duke lacrosse players as the victimizers.
The N&O did that before its readers were even halfway through the very first story they’d read on the Duke lacrosse case.
The N&O went on to say such things as:
” The victim was pulled into a bathroom, and three men held her down, sexually assaulting and sodomizing her, the warrant says. She was kicked, hit, strangled and beaten, she told police.”The N&O worked very hard to get “victim” fixed in readers’ minds.
and
“They also looked for artificial fingernails painted with red polish, apparently lost in the victim's struggle.
All told the N&O referred in its story to the accuser as “the victim” or used the possessive “victim’s” a total of 7 times.
Why did The N&O work so hard to present the accuser as a victim? What did the N&O know that justified doing that?
The N&O’s public editor, Ted Vaden,told me in a phone conversation he wouldn't answer that question because: “Frankly, John, there isn’t time to answer every question someone asks, and I’m not going to answer that one.”
If Vaden had answered my question I'd have gone on and asked him whether anyone at the N&O or the McClatchy Company, its owner, ever considered how casting the accuser as “the victim” was framing the Duke lacrosse players?
Here's something else we should all be asking: Why didn’t the N&O tell its readers that the three lacrosse players who rented the house where the accuser said she was gang-raped voluntarily gave statements to the police without counsels present; voluntarily went to Duke Medical Center and submitted to “rape kit” tests; and offered to take lie detector tests?
That all happened days before the N&O broke the story.
It belonged in the story, didn't it?
When you look at the N&O’s “we broke it” story, it’s not hard to understand why the story played out for months the way it did; and why so many decent people were fooled.
But that doesn’t explain why the N&O ran the kind of story it did.
Posted by JWM at 1:01 PM 4 comments
"Reading" messages in Durham
Politicians understand the art of the indirect message. They know that when one of their own says something like "He knows best whether or not he should run. I'm looking forward to hearing what he decides" the pol really means: "That guy shouldn't run."
We simple citizens know something about politicians' indirect messages, too, don't we?
With the foregoing in mind, let's look at some of the Durham Herald-Sun's Jan. 17 story, "Has Peterson crossed the line?" and then "read" a few of the messages some Durham city council members sent to citizens, including two of Durham's most prominent citizens:
Tuesday's City Council vote on the rezoning of Duke University's Central Campus may have put a permanent kink in the council's relationship with one of the Durham political scene's most persistent personalities.Just another Durham City Council meeting, you ask?
Victoria Peterson, a local activist and perennial candidate for elective office, was the only person who spoke against the rezoning. She felt the council's wrath when she essentially argued that officials should reject the application in retaliation for the university's role in the Duke lacrosse sexual-offense case.
Peterson said rape and other crimes on and around Duke's campus are out of control, and she blamed it on Duke's students.
"Because it's Duke with their money and influence, you want to overlook a lot of the stuff they've done," she said. "They've embarrassed this community."
But Peterson's comments -- which came after activists from two neighborhoods surrounding Duke had endorsed the rezoning -- didn't sit well with the council. One member, Eugene Brown, interrupted with the word "enough," and Mayor Bill Bell asked Peterson to stick to the merits of the application.
When she finished, another councilman, Howard Clement, rebuked her.
"What has been said is not true," he said. "While there are issues on Duke's campus with respect to student behavior and issues on [N.C. Central University's] campus with respect to student behavior, to just grossly place those facts and issues as the overriding issue is totally inappropriate."
But Peterson continued to heckle council members as they prepared to vote, prompting Bell to warn that if she spoke again, he'd order her to leave the council chamber.
That quieted Peterson for a moment, but the confrontation resumed as soon as Bell adjourned the meeting, Peterson quarreling openly with council members Cora Cole-McFadden and Mike Woodard in front of a reporter and between six and 12 city administrators.
Both council members made their anger plain. Cole-McFadden -- who in 2005 crushed Peterson's most recent bid for elective office by 76-24 percent --- called the activist "a liar" to her face.
Woodard added that he didn't appreciate seeing Peterson in television news reports about the lacrosse case "spewing lies and venom," and marching with a hate group, the New Black Panther Party, that came to Durham last spring to picket the Duke campus.
Peterson was not deterred. "You guys kiss Duke's butt," she said.
Well, yes and no.
Yes, in that there's much nonsense and name-calling at Durham city council meetings.
No, in this sense: At city council and other public meetings Victoria Peterson is regularly every bit as reckless as she was at this council meeting; but the council or board or panel members she's addressing regularly ignore her.
Recall, for example, that at a public forum in April at NC Central University Peterson made the totally unsubstantiated charge the accuser's test results had been tampered with at Duke Hospital. The forum panel ignored her.
So why did she get so much "attention" at this last council meeting? Why wasn't she ignored as she usually is when she rants?
Because, IMO, council members wanted to send messages for everyone to "read."
Council members' message to DA Mike Nifong: "Yes, Mike, we know she was your election campaign co-chair and is now your most vocal supporter. And sure, most of us are fellow Democrats who said not a word critical of you before the election. In fact some of us publicly praised your handling of the Duke lacrosse case. Mayor Bell even contributed to your primary campaign fund and showed up at one of your campaign functions.
But things change, Mike.
So we're doing something we don't usually do: slam Peterson.
It's the easiest way we can think of to start putting distance between us and you."
Members' message to voters: "We've had concerns about what Nifong's been doing but, just like Duke's President, Dick Brodhead, we've been reluctant to interfere in the legal process. But we'll tell you this: the other night after the council meeting we said to Nifong's campaign co-chair ....."
Let's read one more message. It's from council member and Duke administrator Mike Woodard. It's meant for wide distribution among Duke alumni and Durham citizens: "Hi, everyone! Did you all notice the H-S reported I told Victoria Peterson I didn't ‘appreciate seeing [her] in television news reports about the lacrosse case 'spewing lies and venom,' and marching with a hate group, the New Black Panther Party, that came to Durham last spring to picket the Duke campus? President Brodhead feels the same way."
What should we all do now that we've "read" the messages?
You'll decide for yourselves but I'll offer one piece of advice based on what I know about Brodhead and "the Brodhead senior administration team:" Don't ask why Woodard wasn't saying publicly last spring what he just said a few days ago. And, of course, don't ask why Brodhead didn't say something like that to Peterson last spring.
In fact, don't even think of asking Brodhead or Woodard why they didn't say to Peterson even a week before the November election what Woodard just said to her.
Brodhead wants us all to "look forward." I'm sure Woodard and the rest of the council do too.
And we can all "read" their message, can't we?
Posted by JWM at 7:18 AM 4 comments
Tuesday, January 23, 2007
The Churchill Series – Jan. 23, 2007
(One of a series of weekday posts on the life of Winston S. Churchill.)
In Winston Churchill and His Inner Circle, Sir John “Jock” Colville, Churchill’s private secretary during both his premierships and trusted friend afterwards, writes about a remarkable woman who fell in love with Churchill. He did not reciprocate her love, but they formed a friendship that lasted until his death almost sixty years later:
”Another woman who had been in love with Churchill before he married, though he was never physically in love with her, was Violet, daughter of the Liberal Prime Minister Herbert Henry Asquith. She had her father’s intellectual gifts and was hard to match as a public speaker.I’ve read Winston Churchill as I Knew Him. It’s an excellent book.
She was an eager conversationalist: some thought too eager, for she tended to feel so strongly in the cause she happened to be advocating that she would advance on her prey unrelentingly and drive him or her back into the fireplace. I myself once had the back of my trouser legs badly singed.
There were those who thought that in his early days as a Cabinet minister Churchill used her affection somewhat unscrupulously in order to maintain access to her father, the current fount of power. No doubt Churchill did find the association useful, but he was genuinely enthused by the vigor of Violets’ mind, even thought, at any rate in later years, he seldom agreed with her views.
Nobody interested in politics could fail to find her fascinating. Churchill saw much of her toward the end of his fife and the friendship which had begun in early youth endured untainted until extreme old age. Nor has a more truthful and perceptive book been written about him than Winston Churchill as I Knew Him, be Lady Violet Bonham Carter. (pg. 145)
Posted by JWM at 11:50 PM 1 comments
Blogger problems - test post
I hope you read this post.
That will mean Blogger has fixed some tech problems.
John
Posted by JWM at 10:09 PM 0 comments
When the LA Times makes sense
I give it credit.
An LAT editorial today begins:
Who knew that in her spare time, Assemblywoman Sally Lieber (D-Mountain View) has been glued to her television, riveted by episodes of "Supernanny"?The rest of the editorial is here.
On the program, British nanny Jo Frost marches into chaotic homes and teaches clueless, overwhelmed parents how to discipline their little hellions, kindly but firmly. (Frost never spanks.) The children eventually get straightened out, the parents eventually relax, and everyone is happy.
Lieber apparently wants to be the Jo Frost for all of California's children. In a trial balloon that could remove all metaphor from the phrase "nanny state," the assemblywoman announced plans last week to introduce legislation that would make it illegal for parents to spank their own children under the age of 4. Convicted fanny-slappers would face up to one year in jail or a $1,000 fine.
Lieber contends that a spanking ban would end the "ridiculous situation of having our law saying there's justifiable beating of children." But our laws say no such thing.
There are existing statutes against beating children. Teachers, peace officers and healthcare professionals (among others) are all mandated to report even suspected cases of child abuse that they come across.
Lieber can't seem to distinguish between a swat on the behind and actual abuse. The first is none of the state's business; the second already is.
To state what should be obvious, spanking does not typically cause more irrevocable harm to children than splitting up their families by hauling their parents off to the slammer. One shudders to imagine how such a ban would be enforced.[…]
“Lieber can't seem to distinguish between a swat on the behind and actual abuse. The first is none of the state's business; the second already is.” I agree. I’m just surprised and delighted the LAT would be so sensible.
Caution to LAT editorial writers: I like what you said today but be careful. A few more editorials like today’s could get you sent to PC time-out.
Posted by JWM at 10:34 AM 1 comments