Tuesday, November 25, 2008

N&O reporter’s falsehoods undermine editors’ “police report” claim

The Raleigh News & Observer’s now discredited March 25, 2006 story headlined ---

Dancer gives details of ordeal

A woman hired to dance for the Duke lacrosse team describes a night of racial slurs, growing fear and, finally, sexual violence ---

trashed the lacrosse players and provided the script for the bogus crime story used in the attempt to frame for gang rape and other felonies three transparently innocent Duke students.

Durham’s DA at the time, Mike Nifong, subsequently disbarred and jailed for some of his actions in the framing attempt, began publically shilling the N&O’s bogus story two days after its publication when he first spoke publicly about the case.

Just as the N&O had done, Nifong used the accuser’s false claim she was a victim of racial slurs barked at her inside the house where the party was held to inflame public sentiment against the players.

The N&O’s bogus “night of racial slurs, growing fear and, finally, sexual violence” story began:

The woman who says she was raped last week by three members of the Duke University lacrosse team thought she would be dancing for five men at a bachelor party, she said Friday. But when she arrived that night, she found herself surrounded by more than 40.

Just moments after she and another exotic dancer started to perform, she said, men in the house started barking racial slurs.

The two women, both black, stopped dancing.

"We started to cry," she said. "We were so scared." ...
Many readers immediately challenged the accuracy and fairness of the N&O’s story, especially the interview with the accuser whom the N&O granted anonymity because of what it said was its policy of granting anonymity “to victims of sex crimes.”

Top N&O editors claimed then and now continue to claim the N&O only published material from the interview already in a police report (some editors have used the plural “police reports”).

This from N&O public editor Ted Vaden’s
Arp. 2, 2006 column
…
But let's talk more about the anonymous interview. [Editor Linda] Williams said editors and the reporter discussed the fairness issue at length before interviewing the woman and publishing the story.

The governing decision, she said, was to print only information from the interview that conformed with the police reports. "We limited for publication the statements from the woman that were in line with what she said in the police report," Williams said. (all emphases added) …

In this case, as Williams pointed out, the story used only information from the interview that corroborated the public record, so it didn't add new facts.

The added matter was the emotional content -- the crying mother of two -- that gave a human dimension to the police reports. …
Vaden’s claim that the accuser was allowed to repeat “only information from the interview that corroborated the public record ” was demonstrably false when he made it.

The N&O’s March 25 story, for example, quoted the accuser saying her father had come to visit her in the hospital and that his visit was a major part of the impetus for her reporting she’d been raped. But he never visited his daughter in the hospital. And no police report ever said he did.

The same goes for the N&O’s “barking racial slurs” report.

No one – not the N&O, Nifong, Durham Police or frame-up enablers at Duke - has ever produced a police report recounting the “barking racial slurs” claim.

When the NC Attorney General and members of his staff examined the entire case file, they found no such police report.

Even the reporter who conducted the interview, Samiha Khanna, hasn’t claimed the “barking racial slurs” portion of the interview was based on material contained in a police report.

As a matter of fact, on Apr. 4, 2006 she was quite clear it wasn’t.

On that day Khanna was the guest on newsobserver.com’s On Live Q&A, the full text of which is
here.

Only the first question and Khanna’s answer deal with the matter of whether interview material published by the N&O was restricted to what was already in a police report(s).

You’ll see Khanna’s answer makes clear that with regard to the “barking racial slurs” claim it was not.

Here the first question and Khanna’s answer in full - - -

Moderator: A reader writes: "Why was the alleged victim granted anonymity in your interview? I understand the policy of not identifying alleged victims of sexual assault, but that is different than letting them make their accusations publicly behind a veil of secrecy. Particularly absent any criminal charges. I doubt you would have let a lacrosse team member make accusations against the victim anonymously, as a protected source. Or would you have allowed that?"

SK: This is an issue that we discussed at length among the top editors of the newspaper. Being that we had given members of the lacrosse team, their parents, and leaders in the athletic department an opportunity to address these allegations, we had a responsibility to give the alleged victim the opportunity to tell her story as well.

In interviewing her anonymously, we were careful to weigh each statement she made on the position that it might allow her to speak more freely than if she used her name. Therefore, we were careful not to allow her to make wide-spread allegations of any kind.

The only part of her story that was different than what police had already released was the racial aspect. We were able to use the statements she made about racist terms being shouted at her because that was corroborated by other sources -- people who gave their names -- who heard the same thing. (emphasis added)

Khanna’s claim that “the only part of her story that was different than what police had already released was the racial aspect” is false.

The story, you’ll recall, reported her father visited her in the hospital. He didn’t and no police report contained language saying he did.

With regard to the false accuser, Crystal Mangum, being the victim of “men in the house … barking racial slurs” at her and the second dancer, Khanna makes another false claim when she asserts: “We were able to use the statements she made about racist terms being shouted at her because that was corroborated by other sources -- people who gave their names -- who heard the same thing.”


Italic
No one who was inside the house that night, including the second dancer, has ever corroborated Crystal Mangum’s false claim and the N&O’s report of men barking racial slurs at the two dancers.

Quite the contrary, those who were inside the house insist the barking of racial slurs did not happen.

When Khanna said “the barking racial slurs” claim had been “corroborated by other sources -- people who gave their names -- who heard the same thing,” she was either delusional or outright lying.

The only value I see in Khanna’s false statements is they further undermine the repeated claims of N&O editors that they restricted the interview portion of the March 25 story to statements/material that were/was already in police report(s), and therefore already part of the public record.

This weekend I’ll review as much of the pertinent record as I can including items such as this post: Did the Raleigh N&O fake "a police report?"

I want to be as diligent and as informed as I can be before I call the N&O out for what the paper appears to have done: falsely claimed to have relied on a police report the N&O knew didn’t exist.

Some of you may be thinking I should be fact checking with the N&O.

I’ve been doing that for over 2 years. I’ve contacted various reporters and editors many times on the matter. You’ll see in the post above an email I sent in October to Vaden. I sent that email again yesterday.

In neither case have I heard anything back from Vaden and in no case have I heard anything from anyone else at the N&O concerning "the police report."

As we go forward, keep this in mind : In North Carolina, as in most states, police crime investigation reports are public records.

That makes it a very easy matter for a reporter or editor claiming to have relied on a police report to cite the report.

The N&O’s failure to cite a police report(s) to corroborate the “barking racial slurs” portion of its Mar. 25, 2006 story is telling.

Monday, November 24, 2008

The Churchill Series - Nov. 24, 2008

(One of a series of weekday posts about the life of Winston S. Churchill.)

When using his initials Churchill commonly signed "WSC." But some political foes and others who considered themselves wits took delight in playing on the commom British expression for toilet, "WC."

Thus when Churchill was defeated in the 1925 general election, one newspaper said it was sure the members of the new parliament could manage "with one less WC." Churchill took it in stride.

On occasion he would even make a WC remark at his own expense, as he did in February, 1940 while on a destroyer returning to England from France.

There were some mines in the ship's path. Guns were fired to destroy them. The gunfire churned the water and set some debris from a sunken ship floating past the destroyer.

Among the debris was a lavatory door. Churchill looked at it and said with a grin to those beside him, "That door has my initials on it. They must have known I'd be aboard." ___________________________________________________ Tom Hickman, Churchill's Bodyguard. (p. 88-89)

Palin needs to learn from Reagan

I guess most of you have seen the video or at least heard about Gov. Sarah Palin and her turkey farm visit. For those who haven’t, here’s the video:



Before showing the video, the Democrats at MSNBC decided to advise parents they might not want their children to see it. They also fogged out the decapitations of the turkey’s which were going on in the background.

That from a cable network which for years has telecast with no parent advisories horrific scenes of human carnage in Iraq and other parts of the world.

Then we have the NY Times editorial board which now has its own blog, The Board, at which the editors opined: - - -

We’ve differed with Sarah Palin a great deal on substance. We don’t agree with her hardline approach to the Iraq War, her harsh anti-government rhetoric, and her style of negative campaigning.

But we also worry a bit about, how should we put it, the persona she has brought with her to national politics. We did not care at all for the swipe she took against community organizers at the Republican National Convention.

And then there’s this. You don’t have to be a huge animal lover to question why Governor Palin chose to be interviewed — while issuing a traditional seasonal pardon of a turkey — while turkeys were being executed in the background.

Folks, right after Palin made her impressive debut at the GOP convention, I said the overwhelmingly Dem MSM would set out to destroy her any way they could, lest she become a force in American politics.

What we’re seeing from the likes of MSNBC and the NYT’s editorial board is not concern for children and turkeys.

We’re seeing their “political death to Palin by a thousand cuts” strategy in action: attack Palin any time, any way.

I think Palin knew beforehand how the liberal/leftist MSM would “play” the interview. She even says during it she’ll probably be criticized “for doing this.” And she smiles when she says it.

I’m not ready to say Palin is “a future Reagan.”

But I’ll say this: Reagan understood he’d never get fair treatment from most of MSM.

Sure he was a very smart man, a skilled union leader, an extraordinarily gifted public speaker who wrote many of his own speeches, and a successful and popular two-term governor of the largest state in the Union.

But most MSM presented him as a lazy “B-movie actor” and “an amiable dunce.”

Reagan learned to laugh off the MSM politicking, smile and talk about what’s important.

I saw Palin do something like that in turkey farm video. She smiled and wasn’t at all defensive that she’d be the one in her family cooking the turkey. She seemed to relish telling the reporters that.

And as Reagan would have done in similar circumstances, Palin for the most part talked about things important to Americans – the economy, the safety of our troops in Iraq, the price of oil, and its impact on her state’s budget.

MSNBC, the NYT edit board and others overlooked all of that in order to inflict “a cut” on Palin.

In the future, when the turkey farm interview is brought up, I hope Palin reminds people of the important things she talked about during the interview and ever so gently, with a Reagan-like twinkle, adds that she doesn't remember much of what the turkeys said at the time.

Hat tip: Ed Morrissey

Sunday, November 23, 2008

Raleigh N&O’s print circulation drops

First, some background to this post - - -

The McClatchy Company’s liberal/leftist Raleigh News & Observer has not in recent years consistently reported in the print edition (or as far as I know at its online site, either) the paper’s circulation numbers as provided by Audit Bureau of Circulations.

The ABC, considered the “gold standard” for determining newspaper’s circulations, reports twice yearly circulation numbers for a sixth month period. The two periods are Oct. – Mar and Apr. – Sept.

Using the N&O’s archives I couldn’t find, for example, any news story reporting ABC numbers for either of the two most recent ABC reporting periods (Oct. ’07- Mar ’08 and Apr. ’08- Sept. ’08).

A journalist friend helped me access and navigate the ABC site. The friend showed me how to call up a list of North Carolina newspapers with their circulations for the period Apr – Sept. 30, 2008. I’ve pasted that list at the end of this post.

I also located an N&O story from May 1, 2007 that reported ABC numbers for the period from Oct – Mar. 31, 2007. (See here. Circulation numbers I cite are found in the chart which accompanies the story.)

Using numbers from the two documents and rounding to the nearest thousand, I can report:

According to the ABC for the six-month period Oct-Mar, 31, 2007, the N&O had a daily circulation (M-F) of 177,000; for the six-month period Apr-Sept. 30, 2008, the N&O had a daily circulation (M-F) of 159,000.

Thus, during the year-and-a-half-year period (Mar. ’07 to Sept. ’08) reported on here, the ABC found the N&O’s daily circulation had declined by 18, 000, which represents a daily (M-F) circulation decline of just over 10%.

Also according to the ABC, during the same year-and-a-half-year period the N&O’s Sunday circulation declined from 213,000 to 206,000. The circulation loss of 7, 000 represents a percentage decline of just over 3%.

Some perspective on those circulation losses:

Keep in mind we commonly consider circulation in year-over-year terms, while these circulation numbers cover a year-and-a-half-year period.

That said, the circulation declines reported here have to be very, very troubling to anyone who wishes the N&O well.

During the same time period considered here, population growth in the N&O’s circulation area has been strong (statistical data on recent growth are not yet available. County planners and real estate people I spoke with for this post agreed a combined estimate of population growth per annum of 3% for Johnson, Wake, Durham and Orange Counties which include the N&O’s major circulation area is a reasonable estimate).

The N&O has no real newspaper competitor. The closest to one is the Durham Herald Sun.

During the same time period looked at here and again using ABC numbers, the H-S daily and Sunday circulations each dropped from 37, 000 both daily (M-F) and Sunday to 30,000 (daily) and 29,000 (Sunday).

Since few people here have ever subscribed simultaneously to the H-S and N&O, the H-S’s loss of readers presented the N&O with a splendid opportunity to pick up a good number of those 7,000 (daily) and 8,000 (Sunday) former H-S readers.

For almost four years as the H-S’s circulation has been both daily and Sunday more than 20,000 the N&O has made a major efforts to sign those former H-S readers up.

I’ll say more about how successful the N&O has been signing up those 20,000 or so former H-S readers in a future post. I mention them here only to add to the perspective you can bring to the N&O’s circulation declines.

Look for another post in a day or so on the N&O’s circulation situation.

In the meantime, those of you interested in Man’s capacity for self-deception may want to read this Mar. 30, 2008 post: N&O says it’ll be “greater than ever.”


US NEWSPAPER - SEARCH RESULTS


Search Type: United States

Circulation averages for the six months ended:
9/30/2008

State: North Carolina

Selection: No city submitted (Contains)

Sort By: Title ASC

Results Found: 61



Preliminary figures subject to audit as filed with the Audit Bureau of Circulations.
* Total Circulation = Total Average Paid Circulation



Publication Name

Frequency

Circulation Type

Total Circulation*

Filing Status

ADVANCE, ELIZABETH CITY (PASQUOTANK CO.)

E (M-SAT)

DLY

9,990


ADVANCE, ELIZABETH CITY (PASQUOTANK CO.)

SUN

DLY

9,811


CARTERET COUNTY NEWS-TIMES, MOREHEAD CITY-BEAUFORT (CARTERET CO.)

WED & FRI

WKL

9,515


CARTERET COUNTY NEWS-TIMES, MOREHEAD CITY-BEAUFORT (CARTERET CO.)

SUN

WKL

10,924


CITIZEN-TIMES, ASHEVILLE (BUNCOMBE CO.)

AVG M (M-F)

DLY

49,729


CITIZEN-TIMES, ASHEVILLE (BUNCOMBE CO.)

SUN

DLY

56,621


CITIZEN-TIMES, ASHEVILLE (BUNCOMBE CO.)

SAT M

DLY

44,489


DAILY NEWS, WASHINGTON (BEAUFORT CO.)

M (M-SAT)

DLY


N/F

DAILY NEWS, WASHINGTON (BEAUFORT CO.)

SUN

DLY


N/F

DISPATCH, HENDERSON (VANCE CO.)

SUN

DLY

7,461


DISPATCH, HENDERSON (VANCE CO.)

M (TUE-SAT)

DLY

7,274


DISPATCH, LEXINGTON (DAVIDSON CO.)

E (M-SAT)

DLY

9,728


ENQUIRER-JOURNAL, MONROE (UNION CO.)

M (TUE-SAT)

DLY

7,666


ENQUIRER-JOURNAL, MONROE (UNION CO.)

SUN

DLY

7,934


ENTERPRISE, HIGH POINT (GUILFORD CO.)

M (M-SAT)

DLY

18,693


ENTERPRISE, HIGH POINT (GUILFORD CO.)

SUN

DLY

21,632


GAZETTE, GASTONIA (GASTON CO.)

SAT M

DLY

27,064


GAZETTE, GASTONIA (GASTON CO.)

AVG M (M-F)

DLY

26,979


GAZETTE, GASTONIA (GASTON CO.)

SUN

DLY

29,454


HERALD, SANFORD (LEE CO.)

SUN

DLY

8,645


HERALD, SANFORD (LEE CO.)

M (TUE-SAT)

DLY

8,758


HERALD-SUN, DURHAM (DURHAM CO.)

SAT M

DLY

24,965


HERALD-SUN, DURHAM (DURHAM CO.)

SUN

DLY

30,192


HERALD-SUN, DURHAM (DURHAM CO.)

AVG M (M-F)

DLY

29,449


JOURNAL, WINSTON-SALEM (FORSYTH CO.)

SUN

DLY

89,645


JOURNAL, WINSTON-SALEM (FORSYTH CO.)

SAT M

DLY

81,332


JOURNAL, WINSTON-SALEM (FORSYTH CO.)

AVG M (M-F)

DLY

76,461


MOUNTAINEER, WAYNESVILLE (HAYWOOD CO.)

MON, WED & FRI

WKL


N/F

NEWS & OBSERVER, RALEIGH (WAKE CO.)

SUN

DLY

205,654


NEWS & OBSERVER, RALEIGH (WAKE CO.)

SAT M

DLY

165,255


NEWS & OBSERVER, RALEIGH (WAKE CO.)

AVG M (M-F)

DLY

158,573


NEWS & RECORD, GREENSBORO (GUILFORD CO.)

AVG M (M-F)

DLY

77,587


NEWS & RECORD, GREENSBORO (GUILFORD CO.)

SUN

DLY

97,177


NEWS & RECORD, GREENSBORO (GUILFORD CO.)

SAT M

DLY

78,295


NEWS HERALD, MORGANTON (BURKE CO.)

M (M-F)

DLY


N/F

NEWS HERALD, MORGANTON (BURKE CO.)

SUN

DLY


N/F

NEWS-ARGUS, GOLDSBORO (WAYNE CO.)

SUN

DLY

20,617


NEWS-ARGUS, GOLDSBORO (WAYNE CO.)

E (M-F)

DLY

17,817


NEWS-TOPIC, LENOIR (CALDWELL CO.)

M (TUE-SAT)

DLY

8,352


NEWS-TOPIC, LENOIR (CALDWELL CO.)

SUN

DLY

8,014


OBSERVER, CHARLOTTE (MECKLENBURG CO.)

SUN

DLY

252,300


OBSERVER, CHARLOTTE (MECKLENBURG CO.)

AVG M (M-F)

DLY

193,577


OBSERVER, CHARLOTTE (MECKLENBURG CO.)

SAT M

DLY

219,883


OBSERVER, FAYETTEVILLE (CUMBERLAND CO.)

AVG M (M-F)

DLY

58,758


OBSERVER, FAYETTEVILLE (CUMBERLAND CO.)

SUN

DLY

64,177


OBSERVER, FAYETTEVILLE (CUMBERLAND CO.)

SAT M

DLY

59,583


POST, SALISBURY-SPENCER-EAST SPENCER (ROWAN CO.)

M (M-SAT)

DLY

21,389


POST, SALISBURY-SPENCER-EAST SPENCER (ROWAN CO.)

SUN

DLY

21,886


RECORD & LANDMARK, STATESVILLE (IREDELL CO.)

SUN

DLY

16,545


RECORD & LANDMARK, STATESVILLE (IREDELL CO.)

M (M-SAT)

DLY

13,269


REFLECTOR, GREENVILLE (PITT CO.)

SAT M

DLY

18,746


REFLECTOR, GREENVILLE (PITT CO.)

SUN

DLY

21,378


REFLECTOR, GREENVILLE (PITT CO.)

AVG M (M-F)

DLY

20,709


STAR-NEWS, WILMINGTON (NEW HANOVER CO.)

SUN

DLY

52,216


STAR-NEWS, WILMINGTON (NEW HANOVER CO.)

AVG M (M-F)

DLY

45,681


STAR-NEWS, WILMINGTON (NEW HANOVER CO.)

SAT M

DLY

45,869


TELEGRAM, ROCKY MOUNT (EDGECOMBE & NASH COS.)

SUN

DLY

15,880


TELEGRAM, ROCKY MOUNT (EDGECOMBE & NASH COS.)

M (M-SAT)

DLY

13,261


TIMES-NEWS, HENDERSONVILLE (HENDERSON CO.)

SUN

DLY

16,893


TIMES-NEWS, HENDERSONVILLE (HENDERSON CO.)

SAT M

DLY

16,245


TIMES-NEWS, HENDERSONVILLE (HENDERSON CO.)





I laughed out loud

(This was posted Saturday)

I couldn't find a URL for the following a dear friend sent with the heading:

TRULY THE GREATEST GENERATION - - -
"I've often been asked, 'What do you folks do to keep busy, now that you're retired?'"

Well...I'm fortunate to have a few friends who have chemical engineering backgrounds, and one of the things we enjoy most is turning beer, wine, scotch, and vodka into urine.

And, we're pretty damn good at it, too!

“Free lunch” with “tips” for Nancy, Barney & Chris

During the recent campaign President-elect Obama played Robin Hood. He’d tax “the rich” (the 5% making over $250 thousand per year) so he could give all the money collected to the other 95% of Americans.

Obama and Speaker Nancy Pelosi, Congressman Barney Frank, Senator Chris Dodd and others of “Robin’s band” would decide how best to distribute the new tax revenues.

Obama’s opponent, Sen. McCain didn’t play the Sheriff of Nottingham. But he didn’t do much to remind American’s who really pays for the Robin Hood tax policies Obama and the Dems favor, either.


But in the Times of London
Jamie Whyte does a suberb job explaining who pays and why - - -

Children are selfish. Not because they are unkind (though many are) but because they believe in cost-free transfers. They do not understand that providing the toys and other amusements they demand imposes a cost on their parents.

Children live in a fantastical world where Barbie dolls and trips to the zoo can be delivered without depriving their parents of something they might have enjoyed, such as a bottle of wine or a few extra hours off work.

Learning that cost-free transfers are impossible is an important part of growing up, and parents usually make sure it happens quickly. Most of us learn that there is no such thing as a free lunch long before we have ever picked up a bill.

Except when it comes to public policy.

Encouraged by politicians, many adults indulge the infantile fantasy that the Government can bestow gifts on us while imposing costs on no one.

No one asserts this plainly, of course; that is never how nonsense is promoted. As usual, the fantasy is insinuated by a special way of talking.

Politicians and commentators demand that corporations, markets or societies carry various burdens, never pausing to note that the cost must ultimately fall on the individual people who make up these abstract entities.

During the presidential campaign, Barack Obama derided John McCain's plan to lower the corporate tax rate, claiming this would mean tax breaks for “some of the richest companies in America”.

To an economic child, taxing companies sounds like an obviously good idea. Who cares about companies? Can a company be hungry, homeless, uneducated? Will you put the interests of these wealthy inhuman entities ahead of real, flesh and blood people, many of whom are struggling to make ends meet?

But companies cannot be rich or poor; only the people who own them or work for them can be. Nor can the cost of taxation fall on a company; it must ultimately fall on the company's owners, employees or customers. Before you can tell whether corporate tax is a good idea, you need to understand who bears the cost and how it affects their behaviour.

Once you do, it turns out that taxing companies is a bad idea.

Research shows that the cost of corporate tax falls more or less evenly across a company's shareholders (in lower dividends), employees (in lower wages) and customers (in higher prices). So, in terms of the “social justice” so beloved of the Left, corporate tax is no better than a combination of income and sales taxes.

But, in terms of efficiency, it is worse. Research also shows that corporate tax has a greater “deadweight cost” than both income and sales taxes, because it discourages the allocation of resources to productive uses - in other words, it discourages investment.

There’s more before Whyte closes with - - -

When it comes to bearing costs, there are no companies or markets or other aggregations of people. Costs are always borne by individuals.

That is what Margaret Thatcher meant when she denied the existence of society: “They're casting their problem on society. And, you know, there is no such thing as society. There are individual men and women, and there are families. And no government can do anything except through people.”

Denying people morally convenient fantasies makes them angry. That is why Baroness Thatcher's simple observation has always caused such outrage and why David Cameron's new, pandering Conservative Party has repudiated it.

It is a shame they are not capable of more honesty.

Many people today wish to offload rather than repay their debts. No one should indulge the fantasy that this can be achieved without imposing the cost on other individual men and women.

Whyte’s entire column’s
here.
***************************************************************

Comments:

There’s nothing Whyte says that isn’t true and hasn’t been demonstrated and proven time and again.

But, as he says, some people don’t want to learn reality; it’s too comfortable, at least in the short run, indulging in fantasy.

Then there are all the people who don’t get much chance to learn economic realities. In many high school and college classrooms the truths Whyte presents are presented as “heartless,” “a throwback to imperialism” and “capitalistic greed.”

Here’s one of the comments on Whyte’s column thread which goes along with that- - -

WHAT A WONDERFUL READING!!!

I wish i had a lecturer like this during my uni times .... *sigh*

Dominik von Muehlberg, Cologne, Germany

What's Duke Research for? (Post 1)

(This was posted Saturday)

I recently posted in response to Duke University’s invitation to alumni to subscribe to a new online magazine, Duke Research, which each month will report on various research projects, questions and events of interest to faculty and others, and related matters at Duke. (See Making Duke Research a "must read")

I said I’d be sure to subscribe if Duke Research reported on questions relating to the Duke lacrosse case.

On a Duke Basketball Report forum thread, killerleft commented and linked to my post.

Killerleft said that while he disagreed with me on most topics I write about, he thought the questions I’ve raised (as have many others) are important.

He’s concerned the university has not been more forthcoming about its actions and inactions in the Duke lacrosse case. (See
his post here and my “thank you” post here)

Killerleft's post drew comments, a few of which I want to respond to here. I’ll also be contacting the DBR moderator to discuss how best to share my responses at DBR.

Now, in its entirety and first in order on killerleft’s post thread is the first of the comments I’ll be responding to in the next few days.

From a DBR commenter self-IDing as Allenmurray - - -

There is no more lacrosse forum.

More importantly, I think it a real shame that johninnorthcarolina felt the need to do this. I don't really care how he feels about the lacrosse case - but connecting it to a new Duke Research publication was pretty tangential.

He used a new effort by the University to leap into a topic of his own choosing when the two have no relationship at all. If he wants to write about the lacrosse case - good for him.

But there is no reason to make the incredibly dumb leap that he made between that and a new publication put out by the university.

He could just as easily have begun his blog by saying, "Duke basketball, not for me until . . ." , or "Duke University Blvd.? I'm not driving on that road until . . . "


I wonder whether Allenmurray visited
Duke Research’s Web site before commenting.

Those of you who’ve visited there know it displays prominently on
its home page a picture of the head and shoulders of Rodin's The Thinker beside the link: Duke Research Survey: Tell us what you think.

Among other things, the survey asks readers to share their interests and invites us to offer story topic suggestions. You can view and complete the survey
here.

Duke faculty, staff and students have extremely varied professional interests. People at Duke have discussed and researched topics as diverse as the creation of the gargoyles that adorn the Chapel and factors that heighten students' risk of becoming crime victims.

So what could possibly be wrong with suggesting Duke Research consider critical questions relating to one of the most important, and arguably one of the most disgraceful, series of events in the university’s history?

I can understand why Duke’s trustees, President Brodhead and those who were members in Spring 2006 of “Dick’s senior team” won't answer questions regarding Duke’s actions and inactions in response to events spawned by the lies of Crystal Mangum, and the attempt to use them to frame and send to prison for gang rape and other felonies transparently innocent Duke students.

But I have trouble understanding why any reasonable person would think asking that Duke Research report concerning those questions is “pretty tangential.”

It’s not! It’s spot on!

Duke Research has a monthly feature called
Ask the Expert. Each month a Duke expert is asked 5 questions.

December’s expert is Political Science Professor Paula McCain. She answers questions relating to President-elect Obama’s recent victory, race as a factor in the election, and the future of the Republican Party.

I plan to propose to Duke Research that it occasionally select an expert who would respond to questions relating to the lacrosse case. For example, why no one in a Duke leadership position spoke out on May 18, 2006 when racists shouted physical threats at Reide Seligmann outside the Durham Courthouse, and then again inside the courtroom including shouting death threats at Seligmann in the courtroom?

Allenmurray ends his comment saying I could “just as easily” have begun my post with either of two analogies he offers: "Duke basketball, not for me until . . ." , or "Duke University Blvd.? I'm not driving on that road until . . . "

But I couldn't because Allenmurray’s analogies are absurd.

I would never “just as easily” begin my Duke Research post with “Duke basketball, not for me until …” because I, like you, know the Duke basketball program has no responsibility to discuss, research and report to us regarding the Duke lacrosse case.

But Duke Research? That's a different matter.

As for my using "Duke University Blvd.? I'm not driving on that road until . . . " to begin, I’m sure just about all of you will agree that’s so absurd as to be its own refutation.

As I said at the start of this post, I’ll post again responding to other comments on the DBR killerleft thread.

AP/ Jesse Jackson post follow-up suggestions

(This was posted Saturday)

In AP covers up for Jesse Jackson I noted some significant omissions and misstatements in an AP story which referenced Jesse Jackson’s “caught on tape” remarks that Sen. Barack Obama talked down to black people, something Jackson said made him so mad he wanted to rip Obama’s testicles off.

There’s much more covering up and/or spinning in that AP story, just as there was a great deal of both by most MSM at the time Fox news broke the story of Jackson/testicles remarks.

Example: Civil rights leader Jackson didn’t say Obama talked down to “black people;” he used the plural form of the n-word. There’s more on that with links at this LA Times blog.

Some MSM stories at the time of Jackson’s remarks noted what had precipitated Jackson’s anger at Obama was the Senator’s Fathers Day sermon in which he talked about the failure of many black men to adequately meet their responsibilities as fathers. Among other things, Obama said:

But if we are honest with ourselves, we'll admit that what too many fathers also are is missing - missing from too many lives and too many homes. They have abandoned their responsibilities, acting like boys instead of men. And the foundations of our families are weaker because of it. . . .

Yes, we need more cops on the street. Yes, we need fewer guns in the hands of people who shouldn't have them. Yes, we need more money for our schools, and more outstanding teachers in the classroom, and more afterschool programs for our children. Yes, we need more jobs and more job training and more opportunity in our communities.

But we also need families to raise our children. We need fathers to realize that responsibility does not end at conception. We need them to realize that what makes you a man is not the ability to have a child - it's the courage to raise one.
But what percent of the stories reporting Jackson’s admission Obama’s sermon made him so angry mentioned why it very likely did?

Jackson fathered an out-of-wedlock child in 1998. The mother was a member of Jackson’s Operation Push.

At the time of the child’s birth and for almost two years thereafter, Jackson and his aides covered-up what he did. A la John Edwards, another man was said to be the child’s father.

Again a la John Edwards, the National Enquirer got confirmation of the Reverend’s “love child” and was about to break the story.

It was then that Jackson and his aides decided unEdwards-like to get out front on the story with a damage control press release acknowledging Jackson's paternity and dealing with some of the questions it raised.

You can read more in this CNN story and this BBC story. The CNN story reads like Jackson wrote it. You catch that right away from CNN’s headlines:

Jesse Jackson admits to fathering child out of wedlock

Family is offered prayers, seeks privacy
Obama delivered his Fathers Day sermon before a large, mostly black congregation at a prominent church on Chicago’s South Side.

That’s right in the area where Jesse Jackson used to be the best known and most powerful black political leader.

While most Americans have never known or have forgotten Jackson fathered a child out of wedlock, most blacks that I know are well aware of it.

It’s easy to understand why Jackson would have been hypersensitive to what Obama was saying about absentee fathers.

Jackson's "love child," a girl now about10, at last report lives in California.

The Rev's work takes him to so many places he doesn’t have much time to spend with her, especially as he’s busy spending what family time he has with his wife and his children by her.

I’m planning a major post on MSM coverage/non-coverage of Jackson’s remarks.

One approach I’m thinking to take is to compare how MSM treated Jackson and his remarks with how they treated Gov. Sarah Palin on any number of issues.

Another approach is to compare press treatment of Jackson’s and Edwards’ extra marital affairs.

Still another approach I’ll post on tomorrow is to use MSM cover-up and minimizing for Jackson to raise questions about how such covering up and minimizing has enabled Jackson to pursue a career in which he’s damaged the fabric of America’s civil life.

I'd appreciate any suggestions you have about how best to post on MSM coverage/noncoverage of Jackson's angry, threatening remarks directed at Sen. Obama.