Thursday, August 17, 2006

Duke lacrosse: KC Johnson “moves” to Durham-in-Wonderland

Historian, professor and blogger Robert KC Johnson has moved to Durham-in-Wonderland where he’ll continue the outstanding Duke lacrosse blogging he began at Cliopatria.

Here’s part of KC’s first Duke lacrosse post, Duke News (April 16):

In the latest in what has seemed a poorly managed investigation, the Durham police gained entry, without warrants and apparently without the assistance of the Duke police, to Duke dorms and attempted to interrogate several lacrosse players, who all sides knew had lawyers.

When asked about the matter Friday, Brodhead said he didn't know enough about the issue to comment, and hasn't said anything since.
With his concerns about “a poorly managed investigation” and President Brodhead’s silence, KC was ahead of most people.

Back on April 16 hardly anyone on the Duke faculty was expressing any concern about what Nifong and the police were doing. And few have publicly expressed any concern since, although many now want me to know when we talk face-to-face that they had “grave concerns very early.”

Back on April 16 the editorial writers at the Raleigh News & Observer and the Durham Herald Sun had no problems with the investigation. In fact, they still don’t.

Both papers continue to support Nifong in his determination to prosecute three Duke students whose indictments were the results of investigative travesties that included a photo ID procedure in which the accuser was told she would be looking only at pictures of students who had been at the party.

Duke Law Professor James E. Coleman, Jr understood the purpose of that travesty: “Any three students would do; there could be no wrong choice.”

President Brodhead has found nothing critical to say about Nifong. Brodhead hasn’t questioned any of the investigative travestes that included a photo ID that most people would see as a frameup. Throw the indictments out? Brodhead’s told the Friends of Duke University that he’s looking forward to the students having a chance to prove their innocence at trial. (Yes, it is supposed to work the other way.)

Brodhead may be silent but KC has continued to speak out on many aspects of the Duke lacrosse hoax. His posts are carefully researched, organized, and literate.

There’s something I especially like about KC’s posts: He can skewer hypocrites, especially ones from the academy. Look how KC responded to Duke’s Professor Karla Holloway when she recently indulged in some PC preening in a letter to the Herald Sun :
Holloway, who is currently chair of the Race Subcommittee of President William Brodhead’s Campus Cultures Initiative, complained about “the athletic spaces of Duke where it has become painfully clear that for some, the rules of the game are different.”

Duke, she proclaimed, is a campus beset by the “problematic issues of race, respect, and equity” (it’s worth remembering, as I’ve noted before, that Group of 88 members are talking about a campus where a department chair could jokingly explain away the faculty’s overwhelming ideological imbalance by noting, “If, as John Stuart Mill said, stupid people are generally conservative, then there are lots of conservatives we will never hire.”)

It might be that the Duke Chronicle was wrong when it chastised the Group of 88 for "listening" to a handful of students while ignoring the "several thousand others of us” undergrads who disagreed that “Duke breeds cultures of hate, racism, sexism and other forms of backward thinking.” But at this stage, the campus newspaper has more credibility on this issue than someone who signed the Group of 88's statement.

Holloway continued on how difficult this entire process has been for her. “Of course you want a chance to make your campus better,” she recently told the Herald-Sun, "but at what cost? When you are serviced to fix the problem and you are also the victim, it’s a double duty.”

Holloway holds an endowed chair in English. Moreover, I’m a bit dubious about how anyone who joined what David Brooks has termed Durham’s “witch hunt” by signing the Group of 88’s statement defines “victim.”

Holloway also informed Herald-Sun readers that “her committee has been working hard all summer, fully informed by many documents, including those from the President's Council on Black Affairs, the Duke University Black Alumni, as well as students, administrators and faculty members.”

Yet today, when people e-mailed Holloway to ask about her letter, they received the following reply:
Thank you for your message. However, I will be away from the office and will not be reading email regularly until August. Until that time, the most reliable way to reach me is to post your correspondence . . . If your message is urgent or time sensitive, please contact the English Department Office.
Perhaps Holloway’s subcommittee isn’t working all that hard on campus this summer. (But then again, it doesn’t need to do so, since its conclusions appear to have been laid down by the Group of 88's statement.)

Or perhaps Holloway is simultaneously toiling away on campus this summer while she’s out of her office and not answering her email until August—just as one of Nifong’s targets, Reade Seligmann, was simultaneously committing a crime while he was videotaped at an ATM machine a mile away. The last three months have shown that the law operates differently in Durham; perhaps physics does as well.
Keep it up, KC. You do great work.

And welcome to Durham in Wonderland. Our town needs more folks like you.

Ruth Sheehan helped me learn today

A friend sent the following one-word comment on Raleigh News & Observer news columnist Ruth Sheehan's latest:

dreck
Dreck? I knew it couldn't be good, but just what did it mean?

Well, off to the dictionary to learn.
_____________________________________

dreck

n : merchandise that is shoddy or inferior [syn: schlock, shlock]


Source: WordNet ® 2.0, © 2003 Princeton University
_____________________________________

I'll bet there are already speech therapists out there thinking to use the following exercise with patients working on the sibilant s sound.

On Southport's sandy, sunny, sloping shores, she saw Sheehan's schlock in the Raleigh N&O.

So it's possible some good can come from a Ruth Sheehan column, but we have to work pretty hard to make it happen, don't we?

Wednesday, August 16, 2006

The Churchill Series - Aug. 16, 2006

(One of a series of weekday posts on the life of Winston S. Churchill.)

Churchill lost a good many political battles. One of his defeats occurred in November, 1922, when he lost his parliamentary seat in Dundee, Scotland in the November 15th General Election.

The reasons for Churchill's defeat were many and complex. I'll say something about them tomorrow. Today I’ll mention only one of them: Churchill's inability to actively campaign until the last few days before election because he was recovering from an appendectomy, a surgical procedure which in those days required an extended convalescent period.

While he convalesced in London, Churchill’s banner was carried in Dundee by Clementine and some friends. Churchill wrote to Clementine on November 6th. He mentions Sarah , their fifteen year old daughter, and “your kitten,” their seven week old baby, Mary.

[Dr.] Hartigan examined Sarah this morning and said she had had a little cold behind the nose which would naturally cause a certain irritation in the ear, and that there was no connection whatever between this and the glands. [Sarah suffered from tubercular glands. – JinC] Her temperature is normal and she is quite all right. We are, however, keeping her indoors for a day or two as a precautionary measure. …

I do hope you were not too tired by your long journey. I felt it was a great effort for you to cart yourself and your kitten all that way last night.

Jack [Wodehouse, a friend. – JinC] telephoned this morning that you were all right and were addressing a meeting this evening. Do take it easy. The mere fact of your presence will I am sure be highly beneficial. …
Clementine was quite a woman. That train trip to Dundee with a seven-week old must have taken about 12 hours. And look what her daughter Mary would later tell us happened once she got there :
Clementine flung herself into the front line, making spirited speeches at packed rowdy meetings. General Spears reported to Winston on the bitterness and violence of the campaign: At one meeting, Clementine, wearing a string of pearls, had been spat upon by women. Spears commented admiringly: “Clemmie’s bearing was magnificent – like an aristocrat going to the guillotine in a tumbrel.”
Quite a woman, indeed.
__________________________________________________________
Speaking for Themselves: The Personal Letters of Winston and Clementine Churchill, edited by their daughter, Mary Soames. (p. 264)

Duke lacrosse: Is 60 Minutes planning a “blockbuster?”

Yes, says attorney, columnist and blogger Michael Gaynor:

"60 Minutes" premiered on September 24, 1968. Its website promotes the show as "the CBS News magazine providing a blend of hard-hitting investigative reports, interviews, feature segments and profiles of people in the news" and "the most successful broadcast in television history." The current plan is for its thirty-ninth season to begin with a blockbuster expose on the Duke case.

Mike Nifong, make a note: as of now, on September 24, 2006, an inevitable hour of infamy finally will follow your undeserved and disgraceful fifteen minutes of fame and you will realize that your short-term political gain from your deplorable (political) decision to prosecute (and persecute) the Duke Three was NOT worth it.
Gaynor suggests issues, actions and motives 60 Minutes could very likely explore (well, really, expose) before he closes with a strong statement of what he thinks will be the outcome of the 60 Minutes “blockbuster” he’s predicting:
Politics has been defined as the art of the possible, and few politicians are saints. When one party dominates [as it does in Durham], the local establishment may do some despicable things in the arrogant belief that it can get away with it. Often, unfortunately, that turns out to be true.

Sometimes, fortunately, it doesn't. It finally will be obvious to all but the oblivious that there was no kidnapping, or rape, or sexual offense, but there was a false accusation and an opportunistic prosecutor fighting for his job.
Michael gave me a heads up on his column, which he posted a few hours ago.

I emailed Michael asking for more information that will confirm that 60 Minutes is planning the story.

Right now, the 60 Minutes report needs to be in our “Unconfirmed” column.

But I sure hope what Michael’s reporting is true.

The more people learn about “the Duke lacrosse case,” the more they realize it began with a wildly improbable, vicious hoax that was hyped to the point of hysteria by the Duke area’s major news organization, The McClatchy Company’s Raleigh News & Observer.

On March 24, the N&O “broke” the story with a front-page report that seven times referred to the accuser as “the victim” or with the possessive “the victim’s” without ever once preceding any of them with a conditional qualifier such as “alleged.”

For weeks thereafter, the N&O and much of the rest of MSM which “lazed along” with its biased, inaccurate and inflammatory “reporting,” savaged the Duke students and shamelessly exploited race, class and gender issues.

With a few honorable exceptions, Duke’s trustees, its President, Richard H. Brodhead, his loyal “administrative team” and the faculty have remained silent as injustice after injustice has been inflicted on Duke students, and the community has been endangered by hateful people and groups emboldened by Nifong, the N&O and the Duke-Brodhead profile in cowering.

The N&O was so emboldened by April 2 that it published and distributed that day a version of the infamous "vigilante" poster. It did that just weeks after it refused to publish any of the Danish cartoons that were upsetting to its Muslim readers.

By April 17, the situation had become so dangerous that even Brodhead realized something needed to be done. He joined with NC Central University Chancellor James Ammons and Durham Mayor Bill Bell to take out full-page newspaper ads calling for community calm and asking people to allow the law to take its course.

If a 60 Minutes “blockbuster” is, in fact, a go for September 24, it will appear not just on 60 Minutes’ 40th Anniversary program, but also on the 6th month Anniversary of the N&O’s March 24th “seven times she’s a victim” story.

It’s hard to see how 60 Minutes, on September 24th, could ignore what the N&O did in its March 24th story and avoid discussing the effect such "reporting" could have on someone like Nifong, who was then in the midst of a hotly contested election.

A final thought:

On September 8, 2004, CBS, Dan Rather and 60 Minutes ran the phony Texas Air National Guard story; and then for days afterwards told everyone how the bloggers were getting it all wrong,

Two years later, if 60 Minutes runs a Duke lacrosse story, I don’t know how much it will get right.

But I know 60 Minutes knows if it runs the “blockbuster,” the bloggers will be sitting out there in their pajamas, watching and ready to report.

Stay tuned for updates.

And don't forget to take a look at Gaynor's column.

This made me smile

I told my wife: "One of the reasons I love you is you put up with so much of my nonsense."

She arched an eyebrow and said: "I put up with all your nonsense."

She's right.

Duke lacrosse: Inquiry to a Duke Vice President

Readers' Note: John F. Burness is Senior Vice President for Public Affairs and Government Relations at Duke University. According to his bio description Burness "oversees the coordination and management of communication programs and strategies with the university's various publics."

I just sent him the following email. I'll let you know what I hear back.

John
__________________________________________


Dear Mr. Burness:

I blog as John in Carolina and hold two degrees from the university.

I've posted often on what's called "the Duke lacrosse case" (actually an extremely harmful hoax), typically on the biased and inflammatory media coverage, especially that of the Raleigh News & Observer.

At the DU website I just entered "duke lacrosse" in the search box.

Below are the first two "hits." Both took me to a main page - Duke .>>> News & Communications - which link to statements, articles, etc.

I've two questions I hope you'll answer:

1) Why was the head: Duke University Duke Lacrosse: Information on Sexual Assault... used in the first place?

2) Why does the university continue to use it now ?

Thank you for your attention to my questions.

Sincerely,

John

www.johnincarolina.com
______________________________________________

Duke University | Duke Lacrosse: Information on Sexual Assault ...
... the year winner whose teams won eight conference championships at Hofstra University, was announced as the new head coach of the Duke's men's lacrosse team at ...
http://www.dukenews.duke.edu/mmedia/features/lacrosse_incident/?WT.cg_n=Lacrosse%20Group - 19k - 2006-08-15 - Cached

Duke University | Duke Lacrosse: Information on Sexual Assault ...
... the year winner whose teams won eight conference championships at Hofstra University, was announced as the new head coach of the Duke's men's lacrosse team at ...
http://www.dukenews.duke.edu/mmedia/features/lacrosse_incident/ - 19k - 2006-08-15 - Cached

Tuesday, August 15, 2006

The Churchill Series – Aug. 15, 2006

(One of a series of weekday posts on the life of Winston S. Churchill.)

In July, 1888, as the thirteen year old Winston Churchill was ending his first term at Harrow, his housemaster, H. O. D. Davidson, wrote a report letter to Winston’s mother. Davidson said Winston was not :

in any way willfully troublesome; but his forgetfulness, carelessness, unpunctuality, and irregularity in every way, have really been so serious, that I write to ask you, when he is at home, to speak very gravely to him on the subject.

When a boy first comes to a public school, one always expects a certain amount of helplessness, owing to being left to himself so much more in regard to preparation of work &c. But a week or two is generally enough for a boy to get used to the ways of the place.

Winston, I am sorry to say, has, if anything, got worse as the term passed. Constantly late for school, losing his books and papers and various other things into which I need not enter – he is so regular in his irregularity that I really don’t know what to do; and sometimes think he cannot help it.

But if he is unable to conquer this slovenliness (for I think all the complaints I have to make of him can be grouped under this head, though it takes various forms), he will never make a success of a public school. …

As far as ability goes he ought to be at the top of his form, whereas he is at the bottom. …

I have written very plainly to you, as I do think it very serious that he should have acquired such phenomenal slovenliness. …
Well, we know how it all turned out, don’t we?

Two items:

A hat tip to Housemaster Davidson for seeing past the problematic behavior and recognizing Churchill’s inherent ability: “he ought to be at the top of his form.” During Churchill’s childhood and youth, many people wrote him off as a dullard, the most important of them being his father, Lord Randolph.

Were you thinking as you read the letter: “Today, a teacher would be telling Jennie Churchill, ‘I think Winston may be LD. You ought to have him evaluated. We’re probably expecting too much of him?’”
__________________________________________________
Ted Morgan, Churchill: Young Man in a Hurry, 1874-1915. (p.45)

Duke lacrosse: A major post at Johnsville News

Today Johnsville News posted a detailed analysis of the accusser's claims of robbery and Nifong's treatment of them.

The post, "Duke Case: Poof...the Grubby Thievery Disappears," on first reading looks to be another example of Johnsville's suburb attention to detail and reasoning.

I've noted only one small error so far which I'd have emailed Johnsville about if I knew an address. Johnsville a couple of times refers to statements the accusser made in the N&O's Mar. 25 interview as being made in a Mar. 24 story.

I urge you to give the post a look.

I plan to comment on it further tomorrow.

The Raleigh News & Observer made me an offer

Readers’ Note: What I’m about to say will shock many of you who know I’m often critical of the McClatchy Company’s liberal trending left Raleigh News & Observer.

I’ve been invited to join the N&O’s editorial staff.

The offer came from the N&O’s executive editor for news, Melanie Sill, who wrote:

If you'd like to take part in our front-page meetings, held weekdays at 4:30 p.m., contact Becky Beach at bbeach@newsobserver.com or 829-8949.
Melanie placed her offer at the bottom of her column in Sunday’s paper, so that it could be delivered directly to my driveway.

Although I’m eager to help the N&O and believe improving the paper will be easy, I think I should ask Melanie some questions before accepting her offer.

I’d hate to get a few weeks into the job and find out that my ideas for improving the N&O didn’t fit with what the editors wanted to offer readers.

So I decided to write Melanie a letter, which is below this note. I welcome your comments.

I posted the letter on the thread of a post at the Editor Blog where Melanie also made her offer.

A final item: I’m under the impression that many of you may also have been invited to join the N&O’s editorial staff.

I hope you’ll give your offers some thought and perhaps write your own letters asking Melanie any questions you may have. I’ve put a link to the Editor's Blog post and thread at the end of my letter.

John
_______________________________________________________________

Dear Melanie:

Thank you for your offer of a position on your front-page editorial staff.

Before accepting, I want to ask a few questions:

We’re just a little more than a week away from the five-month anniversaries of the N&O’s publication on Mar. 24 of the story which “broke” what was then called “the Duke lacrosse case” (really an extraordinarily harmful hoax) and your Mar. 25 publication of the interview with the accuser who the N&O said was granted anonymity because that was what the N&O did for “victims of sex crimes.”

Both stories were, as you know, front-pagers.

Would you and the other editors agree if I suggested that on Aug. 24 we run a front-page story explaining why in our Mar. 24 story we seven times referred to the accuser as “victim” or with the possessive “victim’s” never once preceding them with a conditional qualifier such as “alleged?”

I know you’ve told readers what we did was “common practice”, but it's not, as evidence from our own N&O archives and reference to other newspapers make clear.

And while we’re explaining to readers why we cast the accuser as “the victim” and framed the lacrosse players as her victimizers, what would you and the other editors say to a front-page apology to the players, their families, and our readers?

If you can’t say how the other editors would feel about an apology, I can understand that.

But are you OK with making an apology?

I’ll help you write one and we can show it to other editors. If they won’t go along with it, you can always make the apology here at the Editor’s Blog.

What if I suggested that on Aug. 25 we publish the full, unedited transcript of the Mar. 25 interview with only the accuser’s ID material removed? Many readers have said doing that could help with our credibility problems.

You know that Mike Nifong didn’t start speaking publicly about Duke lacrosse until Mar. 27. I'd like to interview Nifong and ask him what he thought of our Mar. 24 and 25 stories?

Nifong was campaigning for office then, and I’m sure he read those stories and gauged their effect on public opinion in Durham.

I could also ask Nifong what he thought of Ruth Sheehan’s “Shut down the team” column. We published Ruth's column on the morning of Mar. 27.

I’ll bet Nifong read it before he gave his first interviews later that day. Political candidates always want to know what's in the morning papers before they meet with media.

I’ll ask Nifong if his ridiculing of the players and calling them hooligans for doing no more than following the advice of their counsels in his Mar. 27 interviews wasn’t influenced by Sheehan’s savaging of them that morning for doing the same thing.

Somehow, Melanie, a lot of the public is getting the idea that Nifong started the witch hunt. We need to let the public know about all the N&O did before Nifong began his part of the witch hunt.

What about a front-page series:"THE N&O LED AND NIFONG FOLLOWED?"

Thank you for your attention to my questions.

John
www.johnincarolina.com
____________________________________________

Editor's Blog post thread.

Monday, August 14, 2006

The Churchill Series – Aug. 14, 2006

(One of a series of weekday posts on the life of Winston S. Churchill.)

In Franklin and Winston: An Intimate Portrait of an Epic Friendship Jon Meacham provides a beautifully written account of Churchill’s March, 1946 visit to the grave of President Franklin D. Roosevelt. The grave is in a small garden a few hundred feet from the Hyde Park house where Roosevelt was born, and which remained his home throughout his life.

Meacham (pgs. 361-362):

Eleanor met Churchill and Clementine, and they walked to the garden. The former prime minister stood, hatless, staring at his friend’s grave. Watching Churchill, Eleanor “felt sure that he was thinking of the years when he and my husband had worked in such close cooperation to win the war.”

Only the clicks of newsmen’s cameras capturing the scene broke the silence as Churchill contemplated the white tombstone and the flowers before it. “I think it was a day of great emotion for Mr. Churchill,” Eleanor wrote. “Besides the respect he had for my husband as a statesman, which made it possible for them to work together even when they differed, he also had a real affection for him as a human being, just as my husband had for him.”

For three minutes Churchill said nothing, his hands in his overcoat pockets. Franklin Roosevelt had been perhaps the most complex human being he had ever known – difficult and demanding and frustrating, but compelling and warm and sparkling. Dark and light, mixed up together.

This made me smile

At the Raleigh News & Observer public editor Ted Vaden’s misnamed Readers’ Corner blog we find this amusing and true comment by Daryl Baker:

Getting an accurate story at the N&O seems to be akin to winning the big prize in the "North Carolina Education lottery".

Duke lacrosse: N&O columnist makes false statement, slimes players

Readers Note: Dennis Rogers is a news columnist for the Raleigh News & Observer, the newspaper whose biased, inaccurate and inflammatory coverage of the Duke lacrosse story did so much to turn what should have been a fair, thorough police investigation into a witch hunt that's included investigative and legal travesties that have harmed innocent people and the community.

Some people believe the N&O has now ceased its outrages as the public has begun to realize "the Duke lacrosse case" is based on a hoax that certain individuals and groups have used to advance their interests and agendas.

But while the N&O has cut back on the frequency of its outrages, it still engages in them.

A very recent example is Rogers’ Aug. 12. news column in which he made a statement about the players that he and his editors had to know was false. Rogers immediately followed his false statement with an outrageous slime of the players.

I decided to write the following electronic letter to the N&O’s executive editor for news, Melanie Sill, who says news columnists “are under my watch.”

Sill has also told readers (scroll to seventh comment dated 9/21/05 at 12:32):

News section columnists are held to the same standards as news reporters in terms of ethics, news gathering and so forth. They could be fired for the same reasons reporters could be fired -- violating N&O standards in any of a variety of areas, ranging from plagiarism to professional behavior lapses.

John
_________________________________________

August 14, 2006


Melanie Sill
Executive editor for news
Raleigh News & Observer
Raleigh, North Carolina

Dear Melanie:

In Dennis Rogers’ Aug. 12 news column he tells readers :
The lacrosse players say, nope, they don't remember a thing. I can appreciate that, having been to college parties where the details are still hazy. Unless something happened. In that case, I clearly recall being in a Laundromat at the time in question, your honor.
Rogers’ statement, “The lacrosse players say, nope, they don’t remember a thing.,” is false.

Rogers, his editors, you and I all know the statement is false.

The three indicted players have provided detailed accounts of their actions the night of March 13/14.

David Evans voluntarily provided a statement to police on Mar. 16 when he also voluntarily agreed to go to Duke Hospital to submit to rape kit testing. He also volunteered to take a police administered lie detector test. There are many witnesses ready to substantiate his detailed statement.

Reade Seligmann, through his attorney, has provided cell phone records, a time-stamped ATM receipt, a time-stamped ATM photo, a time-stamped food purchase receipt, a cab driver witness, teammate witnesses, and timed Duke dorm entry card data. That evidence, along with a statement by Seligmann, establishes a minute-by-minute account of what he was doing during the only time in which the alleged brutal gang-rape, beating, robbery and strangulation claimed by the accuser could have taken place.

Collin Finnerty’s attorneys say they have documentation and witnesses to his actions during the time in question that provide evidence as detailed and strong as that of Seligmann’s.

Other lacrosse players who were at the party have provided and signed detailed statements.

The lacrosse players have even provided, through their attorneys, numerous time-stamped photos of the party, including ones of the accuser.

However, everything the players have done to detail their actions that night didn’t stop Rogers, his editors and the N&O from making what you all knew was a false statement :
The lacrosse players say, nope, they don't remember a thing.
Rogers, his editors and the N&O weren’t satisfied with making a deliberately false and malicious statement.

They went on to deliberately and maliciously slime the Duke students by insinuating they are not truthful regarding their activities during the critical time the evening of Mar. 13/14 when the alleged felony crimes would have to have occured :
I can appreciate that, having been to college parties where the details are still hazy. Unless something happened. In that case, I clearly recall being in a Laundromat at the time in question, your honor.
Do Rogers and the N&O offer any evidence for their insinuation the players are lying? Of course not! N&O standards don't require any.

Melanie, at the Editor's Blog on the thread of this post you told N&O readers:
News section columnists are held to the same standards as news reporters in terms of ethics, news gathering and so forth. They could be fired for the same reasons reporters could be fired -- violating N&O standards in any of a variety of areas, ranging from plagiarism to professional behavior lapses.(bold added)
As a regular N&O reader who’s followed closely your Duke lacrosse coverage, I don’t question that Rogers’ false statement and sliming meet N&O standards.

Nevertheless, I think the N&O owes its readers a correction and explanation for what Rogers, his editors and the N&O did.

Also, as a matter of minimal decency the Duke students are owed the correction and explanation as well as an apology for Rogers’ column and so much else the N&O has done to harm their lives.

Finally, Melanie, I want to make a suggestion. Raise the N&O’s standards for reporters, news columnists and editors, including you. At present, your standards are disgracefully low as Dennis Rogers’ column demonstrates.


Sincerely,

John
www.johnincarolina.com

cc: Dennis Rogers

Ted Vaden, public editor

Sunday, August 13, 2006

These made me smile

Coming back to North Carolina, home and my family.

Also, a question another traveler asked:

”Have you read 'Into the Deep, Dark, Mysterious Forest' by Hugo First?”
Well, no, I hadn’t.

But I definitely plan to read First’s book, which I think is either his second or third.

Meanwhile, I’m reading other very scary stuff by Raleigh News & Observer editors Melanie Sill and Ted Vaden.

See you tomorrow.

John

Duke lacrosse: Raleigh N&O’s public editor’s double copout

It was widely expected Raleigh News & Observer public editor Ted Vaden would follow the N&O company line regarding a single dating error in reporter Joe Neff’s excellent 3,700 word story, "Lacrosse files show gaps in DA's case."

Neff’s story detailed procedural irregularities and very likely “forced” evidenced that were part of DA Mike Nifong’s pursuit of indictments against three Duke lacrosse players. (“Any three studentswould do; there could be no wrong choice.” as Duke Law Professor James Coleman has said.)

As blogger such as KC Johnson and Liestoppers have demonstrated, once the dating error is corrected, Nifong’s investigative conduct actually looks even more suspect.

But the N&O has ignored all of that. It’s spent the last week trying to convince the public Mike Nifong isn’t such a questionable fellow after all, and the single dating error is a huge deal.

The N&O’s been acting like it was March and April again when it was telling readers the accuser was “the victim” and distributing more than 160,000 copies of its infamous “vigilante” poster.

Vaden’s column today will gladden the hearts of all the reporters and editors who have worked so hard to cast the accuser as a young dancer, student and mother brutally beaten, gang-raped and strangled by three lacrosse players while their teammates stood by and then later refused to help principal investigator Sgt. Mark Gottlieb identify their rapist teammates.

But Vaden’s column will disappoint people who agree with Coleman that Nifong needs to step aside and let an ethical special prosecutor take over the case, something that would allow for a review of the actions Neff reported on in his story.

Vaden ignores the issues Coleman has raised and that Neff’s story substantiated. Vaden ignores the information KC and Liestoppers provided.

VADEN’S COLUMN IS A COPOUT ON THE SUBSTANCE AND IMPORT OF NEFF’S STORY.

And it’s not Vaden’s only copout this week. He did a double copout this week as you'll see when you read the following comment which I’ve just left at his blog.

I also plan to leave the comment of the thread of Vaden’s Sunday column once he posts it.
________________________________________________

Dear Ted,

I just finished reading your Sunday column. I made some initial comments in this post:

http://johninnorthcarolina.blogspot.com/2006/08/duke-lacrosse-raleigh-nos-public.html

I plan to post further on your Sunday column in a few days. I’m traveling now so blogging is difficult.

However, it’s important you look at the following again. It does not relate to Neff's excellent story.

Instead it relates to a part of the N&O's biased, inaccurate, and inflammatory Duke lacrosse coverage which helped turn what should have been a thorough and fair police investigation into a witch hunt followed by investigative and legal travesties.

In the Mar. 24 story in which the N&O "broke" the lacrosse case, the N&O seven times referred to the accuser as "the victim" or with the possessive "victim's," never once preceding any of them with the conditional qualifier "alleged."

Why did the N&O make the deliberate decision to tell readers seven times that the woman was the victim?

Doing that cast the people she was accusing - the Duke lacrosse players - as those who victimized her by gang-rape, assault, robbery, and strangulation.

Why did the N&O decide to frame the players that way?

I’ve asked you these questions before, Ted, but you refuse to answer. And I’m not aware of a single word of criticism you’ve made in your column about the N&O seven times referring to the accuser as the victim.

Exec editor for news Melanie Sill has told readers the N&O’s calling the accuser the victim is routine practice.

That’s not true.

Ted, I did a customized search of the N&O’s archives for the month of January, 2006, using only the entry word “rape.” I found many articles but not one in which a rape accuser was ever just called “the victim” during the investigative or pre-adjudication phase of a case in which the rape charge was disputed.

I’ve now read in the NY Times stories totaling over 7,000 words concerning the Duke lacrosse matter. Not once did the Times refer to the accuser as victim, even with a conditional qualifier such as “alleged.”

No doubt the Times is doing what a newspaper editor told me his paper does in cases where a rape is alleged: “We try to use ‘the accuser’ or “the woman.’” He went on to say avoiding the use of “victim” when a rape charge is disputed pre-adjudication was a matter of fairness to the accused.

Just the other day, Ted, I sent you another post containing all of the information in this email and more.

I invited your reply and offered to publish it in full at JinC.

Recall I ended the post:

Please speak to the N&O's exceptional and deliberate treatment given both the accuser and the lacrosse team in your Mar. 24 article.

Please also tell us how Editor Sill’s statement fits with those journalistic ethics you often write about.

I'll publish your response in full.
Here for JinC readers’ information is the email response you sent me:
John:

As you note, Melanie Sill is the person here who made the comment about "victim" being used routinely. I don't believe I have done so. I suggest you take up your inquiry with her.

Ted Vaden
You copped out, Ted.

Your copout to my questions is similar to your copout today in your Sunday column.

What happpens now, Ted?

Do you write a column saying you won't comment further on Duke lacrosse matters until you've "heard all the evidence at the trial?"

Sincerely,

John
www.johnincarolina.com

Saturday, August 12, 2006

Talking with JinC Regulars and Reader/Commenters – Aug. 12, 2006

New Readers’ Note: This is a post in the old web log tradition of notes and “thinking our loud” with others who know what you’re about.

I do JinC Regulars posts often. Lately I’ve included reader/commenters in the Regulars posts because the number of commenters has grown and, while I read every comment, I can no longer get back to each individual.

In the Regulars posts I try to let reader/commenters know I’m “paying attention.” An example of that is the main item in the post below.

John
___________________________________________

Folks,

For weeks many commenters have been asking questions such as: “Doesn’t the N&O have some liability for what it’s done in the Duke lacrosse case?” and “The N&O just can’t publish the “vigilante” poster and then just walk away from it, can it?”

I’ve not answered those questions. But I haven’t ignored them, either.

I’ve been talking to attorneys who are expert in First Amendment and libel law as they apply to newspapers. I’ve also talked about those same matters with journalists I respect.

Remember I’m not an attorney and I don’t consider myself a journalist.

Now a few thoughts re: the liability questions

Bottom line: In America it’s awfully hard to hold newspapers or other MSM news organization responsible for actions that in other democracies, the United Kingdom for instance, would be libelous and result in severe penalties.

But awfully hard and nearly impossible doesn’t mean impossible.

I’ve been told by people who are usually right about things that a number of people who love those Duke students who were slimed, endangered and, in my opinion, libeled by the N&O already have attorneys and researchers looking at everything the N&O did to twist what should have been a fair, thourgh police investigation into a witch hunt

What needs to be done to make a libel charge against a newspaper stick?

Everyone kept bringing up the same phrase “deliberate maliciousness.” It’s not enough that a newspaper prints something false; or prints a lot about someone that’s false; on keeps printing false or biased stories about a group. To sustain a libel charge you have to prove the newspaper deliberately set out with malicious intent to harm (libel).

You also have to prove that what the newspaper did, in fact, harmed the person or group. If no one takes what a newspaper says seriously, no harm is done, it can be argued.

I’ll be saying more about the N&O and the question of libel in a few days. This is a start.

I hope some of you who are journalists or attorneys comment as well as the rest of you.

BTW – On the matter of deliberateness, you’ll notice the word “deliberate” has recently been appearing more often in some of my N&O posts. Part of the reason for that is journalists I’ve talked with have made me aware of just how deliberate were some of the terrible things the N&O did.

Example: The Mar. 24 “broke the case” story seven times used “victim” or the possessive “victim’s” with no conditional qualifier. Two reporters are bylined on the story. So you might say, “Wow, they must have done that deliberately.”

But wait. There are editors who are supposed to catch errors and decide if what’s said in an article is as accurate as possible; is consistent with the papers news reporting standards; and conforms to those journalism ethics N&O exec editor for news Melanie Sill and public editor Ted Vaden are always talking about.

(Folks, I’m traveling now and must end this right now.

To be continued very soon, tonight I hope, assuming Muslim extremists don’t interrupt my travel plans.

John

Friday, August 11, 2006

The Churchill Series - Aug. 11, 2006

(One of a series of weekday posts on the life of Winston S. Churchill.)

I promised yesterday to illustrate Churchill's loyalty to friends with a story about his care for a person he never would have called a "friend" but whose service to Churchill placed him within a special category that included his friends to whom he was intensely loyal.

The person is Walter Thompson, for many years Churchill principal bodyguard.

In the early 30s Churchill learned that Thompson, who first became his bodyguard about 10 years before, had not been promoted in all that time by Scotland Yard. Wasn't that unusual, Churchill asked Thompson? What explained that?

Thompson feigned ignorance.

But Churchill wasn't to be put off. He pursued his questions with the Yard. He learned that Thompson had sat for promotion exams and done exceedingly well. But he lacked the range of experience an officer was expected to have for promotion. His years had been spent protecting Churchill.

This was all news to Churchill, although Thompson was well aware of why he hadn't been promoted. But as Thompson explained to his wife, Churchill was a great man who might some day be called upon to save the country. It was a privilege and duty to guard him.

For his part, once Churchill learned of the reason Thompson had failed of promotion, he began a two year campaign to reverse matters. It’s difficult to get a large organization to change or override policy, especially a policy that has some sense to it. Surely before a Scotland Yard officer is promoted he or she ought to do more than just bodyguard work.

But Churchill didn't want Thompson and his family to suffer any more on his account than they were doing already with Thompson's strange hours, frequent long trips away from home, and always dangerous work.

Churchill wrote letters, requested and was granted interviews with the Yard's top executives, and had an occasional "word" with people in the Home Office to which Scotland Yard reports. All of this was unknown to Thompson.

How did it all come out?

At the end of two years, Thompson became Detective-Sergeant and eventually a Detective-Inspector.

Thompson retired from the Yard in the late 30s and opened a grocery business. But the day after Churchill was appointed First Lord of the Admiralty, he received a call from Churchill.

Thompson rejoined the Yard, and from then until the end of the war he resumed guarding the man whose destiny he foresaw and whose life he felt he was privileged to protect.
______________________________________________
The material in this post is drawn from Tom Hickman's Churchill's Bodyguard.

Duke lacrosse: Two emails to Raleigh public editor Ted Vaden

Readers' Note: I sent a post the other day to Raleigh News & Observer public editor Ted Vaden. I said among other things he'd had no problem with the N&O's publication of the infamous "vigilante" poster.

Although, as JinC Regulars know, I've sent Vaden many posts theses past months criticizing N&O coverage of the Duke lacrosse hoax and injustices and asking for him to respond, I haven’t heard back or have been told by phone “I’m not going to answer you, John.” He’s said that even when I offered to publish in full here his responses.

But my remark the other day about the vigilante poster drew an almost immediate response from Vaden who pointed out he’d called the N&O’s publication of the “vigilante” poster “inappropriate.”

I’ve sent Vaden two emails you’ll read below.

John
_______________________________________________________

Dear Ted:

You did say the publication of the “vigilante” poster was inappropriate.

I apologize for my error.

I’m traveling now so blog work is tough. However, when I get home Sunday, I’ll go back to the post where I made the error and put a correction at its top.

I’ll send you a link to the post once I’ve made the correction.

Again, my apology.

Sincerely,

John
www.johnincarolina.com

______________________________________________________

Dear Ted:

By now you’ll have received my apology for my mistake in saying your were OK with the N&O’s publication of the infamous “vigilante” poster which served no purpose but to slime and endanger the players by provoking as vigilante posters always do irresponsible individuals and hate groups.


One good think my error accomplished was it got a response from you. I’d almost given up hope of ever getting another one from you.

Now that you are back in response mode and you’re satisfied, I hope, with what I’m doing to correct my error, will you now please respond to the portion of my post that referenced the N&O’s Mar. 24 story?

I said in the same post that drew your “vigilante” response:

Ted doesn’t like it when you call up and ask, for example, why in its Mar. 24 story that “broke” what we know is the Duke lacrosse hoax, the N&O keep calling the accuser “the victim” without ever using a conditional qualifier such as “alleged.”
As you know, the N&O never qualified any of its seven "victim" descriptions with the customary "alleged" or "reported."

The N&O's decision to seven times describe the accuser as a victim in that story that “broke the Duke lacrosse case” presented the accuser as a victim and began the deliberate N&O process of framing the Duke lacrosse players as her victimizers. By doing that, the N&O was grossly unfair to the lacrosse players and misled its readers.

The N&O has falsely told readers its “routine” to do what the N&O did. Here’s exec editor for news Melanie Sill responding to a reader at the Editor’s Blog :
Yes it's fairly routine for us to use the word "victim" in crime reports in describing the person who made the report. Sometimes it's amended "reported victim" or simply more descriptive. People report crimes, but police and law enforcement officials bring charges. […],
After reading Sill’s response, I called an editor at another paper. What’s his papers policy on using “victim” without qualification in a case like Duke lacrosse?

The editor said, “We’ve tried to stay away from ‘victim. We’ve mostly used ‘accuser;’ sometimes ‘dancer;’ that kind of thing.”

I asked if the editor was sure his paper didn’t at least sometimes use just “victim”

“I can’t say for certain it didn’t happen. But if it did, it got by us. If you can find where we did, we’ll make a correction.

We don't want to use ‘victim’ in this kind of circumstance. It's not fair to the other person or persons.”

Ted, I have Times Select so recently I went to the NY Times archives and read five Duke lacrosse articles, each of more than one thousand words.

None of the five articles used the term “victim.” Instead, terms such as “woman,” “dancer,” and most often, “accuser” were used.

In his recent letter to the N&O, Duke Law Professor James E. Coleman Jr. referred to the accuser five times as "victim," but in each case preceded it with "alleged."

Ted, I did a customized search of the N&O’s archives for the month of January, 2006, using only the entry word “rape.” I found many articles but not one in which a rape accuser was ever just called “the victim” during the investigative or pre-adjudication phase of a case growing out of the accusation.

Please speak to the N&O's exceptional and deliberate treatment given both the accuser and the lacrosse team in your Mar. 24 article.

Please also tell us how Editor Sill’s statement fits with those journalistic ethics you often write about.

I publish your response in full.

Thank you.

Sincerely,

John
www.johnincarolina.com

Thursday, August 10, 2006

The Churchill Series – Aug. 10, 2006

(One of a series of weekday posts about the life of Winston S. Churchill.)

Readers Note: One of you left a kind comment on yesterday's post thread to which I've responded there.

John
_________________________________________

Churchill ended My Early Life with the oft-quoted remark the he "married and lived happily ever after.”

Certainly he and Clementine had a wonderful fifty-seven year marriage filled with love and care in good and bad times.

But their marriage had its moments, too. Sometimes things got very testy. One reason was Churchill's choice of friends.

Clementine approved of most of them but there were some – Brendan Bracken and Lord Beaverbrook were two – who for years she wished Churchill would cast aside. But he wouldn't.

Worse for Clementine, despite her protestations, he'd often invited them as overnight guests at Chartwell.

Why wouldn’t he give in to Clementine? Or at least put a little "distance" in certain friendships?

Violet Bonham Carter, Churchill’s friend for almost sixty years, gives us her answer :

His friendship was a stronghold against which the gates of Hell could not prevail. There was an absolute quality in his loyalty, known only to those safe within its walls. Their battle was his own. He would concede no inch of ground, no smallest point against them. In a friend he would defend the indefensible, explain away the inexplicable – even forgive the unforgivable.
Most of us recognize the Churchill Bonham Carter describes as the same Churchill we respect and honor.

The dogwoods, azaleas and redbuds are still beautiful here. I hope it's nice where you are, too.

Have a good weekend.

John
________________________________________________
Violet Bonham Carter, Winston Churchill: An Intimate Portrait. ( pgs. 116-117)

Talking with JinC Regulars and Readers – Aug. 10, 2006

Traveling so this is “in-between” and short.

You’ll see I picked up and posted following the prompts many of you gave me re: Liestoppers. Thanks again.

Thanks also for the heads-up on Estrich’s 180. More on that this weekend.

Thanks for all the heads up you folks give me. You help keep me smart. No, “You help keep me less dumb” is more like it.

You’ll see that now that that traffic at JinC has picked up and some “key players” on the DL hoax and a few national writers are visiting often, some other folks who write columns and blogs have taken to dropping whole columns or posts onto the comment threads.

As a one time only, “here’s what I’m about” promotion, let’s see for now how things work.

But as anything more than that, "No." Please respect the purpose of the comment threads.

A few of you have asked how I can wish people like the accuser and Ted Vaden well. That’s a good question that deserves a thoughtful answers. I’ll put another Talking with JinC …. post up tonight with my answer. I need time to put my answer together.

For now bear this in mind: In the cases of the accuser and Vaden, I’ve been careful to say I wish them well in the personal portion of their lives.

It’s must rush time. Sorry to be abrupt. Back tonight after 11 p.m.

Two simple questions for Democrats and MSM

CNN is reporting:

The United States on Thursday raised its terror threat level after British police said they had arrested more than 20 suspects in a major terrorist plot to blow up passenger jets flying between the United Kingdom and the United States.

The foiled plot was "intended to be mass murder on an unimaginable scale," London's Metropolitan Police Deputy Commissioner Paul Stephenson said.

The intelligence that uncovered the plot "makes very strong links to al Qaeda," a senior U.S. administration official told CNN.

The plot involved hiding masked liquid explosives in carry-on luggage, a U.S. government official told CNN.

One government official said the terrorists had hoped to target flights to major airports in New York, Washington and California, all major summer tourist destinations.

"They were not yet sitting on an airplane," but were very close to traveling, a senior U.S. counterterrorism official told AP. […]
QUESTION FOR DEMOCRATS AND MSM: Now do you believe America and the rest of the civilized world is at war?

Are you finally ready to stop sneeringly referring to our government’s efforts to protect us as "part of Bush's 'war on terrorism?'"

Some truth about Liestoppers.com

The other day I forget to mention Liestoppers.com among the blogs helping “shine the lights” on just what’s been happening in Durham.

Liestoppers is doing a fine job of helping expose the hoax followed by a witch hunt followed by “burnings” such as the forced resignation of former Duke Men’s lacrosse coach Mike Pressler, the circulation of CrimeStoppers’ Wanted posters and the Raleigh News & Observer’s notorious “vigilante” poster, and the indictments of the innocent Duke students following a series of investigative, and very likely illegal, travesties.

Liestoppers often brings a touch of humor, including parody to its work as it does in this Aug. 9 post announcing some important news regarding election opposition to Nifong :

With hope that this is just the first of several upcoming trials for Mr. Nifong, it appears that proceedings have begun today in the Court of Public Opinion otherwise known as Durham County, North Carolina.

This afternoon, both [Republican] Steve Monks and the Committee to Recall Nifong - Vote Cheek declared intentions to challenge Mr. Nifong this fall.

Herald Sun

"Conceding that he desperately needed to boost his name recognition, local Republican Party Chairman Steve Monks ended weeks of speculation Wednesday by saying he will run as an unaffiliated write-in candidate for district attorney in November.

The Committee to Recall Nifong - Vote Cheek filed with the Durham County Board of Elections as a Political Action Committee according to Committee spokesperson Beth Brewer. Mrs. Brewer indicated that a formal statement would be released Monday. The Committee to Recall Nifong - Vote Cheek may be contacted at 919.310.1147 or bbrewer@recallnifong.com.

At issue in this trial by election will be Mr. Nifong’s conduct over the course of his brief occupation of the District Attorney’s office. Will the jurors known as Durham County registered voters find Mr. Nifong guilty of betraying justice and public trust in this trial by election?

Will these jurors be asked to consider additional charges against Defendant Nifong such as:

1. Placing persecution before investigation
2. Jumping to false conclusions
3. Improper self insertion into lineup procedures
4. Impersonation of a DPD Chief Investigator
5. Conduct unbecoming a District Attorney by temper tantrum and foot stomp
6. Menacing by verbal assault
7. Inciting racial and social division in their community
8. Electioneering
9. Misappropriation of Public Trust
10. Indecent exposure of Durham County to Civil Lawsuits
11. Hijacking the District Attorney‘s office for his own personal fiefdom

Will the voting jurors of Durham County find Mr. Nifong guilty of incompetence? …
Well, the “attorneys” a Liestoppers have certainly presented a very good case so far.

One JinC worry: Steve Monks splitting the “jury vote,” and thereby helping allow Nifong to “go free” to inflict on the rest of us in Durham four more years of “Nifong justice.”

If that happens, I’ll move to Raleigh, even if that means I’ll have to live next door to the News & Observer.

Keep looking in on Liestoppers.

And thanks Regulars and Readers for reminding me about Liestoppers.

Wednesday, August 09, 2006

The Churchill Series - Aug. 9, 2006

(One of a series of weekday posts on the life of Winston S. Churchill.)

In the early summer of 1906, Lady Wemyss hosted one a small dinner party. The guests included a bright, charming nineteen year old, Violet Asquith, daughter of Herbert Asquith, then Chancellor of the Exchequer, and soon to be Prime Minister. Violet was seated next to a thirty-two year old Member of Parliament, Winston Churchill, the son of a former Chancellor of the Exchequer, Lord Randolph Churchill.

Violet tells us about the evening:

I found myself sitting next to this young man who seemed to me quite different from any other young man I had ever met. For a long time he remained sunk in abstraction.

Then he appeared to become suddenly aware of my existence. He turned on me a lowering gaze and asked me abruptly how old I was. I replied that I was nineteen.

“And I,” he said almost despairingly, “am thirty-two already. Younger than anyone else who counts, though, “he added, as if to comfort himself.

Then savagely: “Curse ruthless time! Curse our mortality. How cruelly short is the allotted span for all we must cram into it.” And he burst forth into an eloquent diatribe on the shortness of human life , the immensity of possible human accomplishment – a theme so well exploited by the of all ages that it might seem difficult to invest it with a new and startling significance .

Yet for me he did so, in a torrent of magnificent language which appeared to be both effortless and inexhaustible and ended up with the words I shall always remember: “we are all worms. But I do believe that I am a glowworm.”

By this time I was convinced of it – and my conviction remained unshaken throughout the years that followed.
The young Violet Asquith, who later became Violet Bonham Carter, and Winston Churchill began a remarkable friendship that night. They remained friends for the next fifty-nine years until Churchill died on January 24, 1965.

Bonham Carter paid a last visit to the Churchill shortly before he died. She surely thought of that summer evening in 1906 when a young man told her he was "a glowworm," something she never doubted and lived to see History confirm.
__________________________________________________
Violet Bonham Carter, Winston Churchill: An intimate Portrait. (p. 3)

Talking with JinC Regulars and Reader Commenter - Aug. 9, 2006

I'm touched, informed and uplifted by your support and comments.

I'm also racing for the airport.

If you look at the recent posts you'll see where you can take you talents and care and put them to good use.

The N&O needs to here from you. There are people there still trying to prop up Nifong. They and some others in media don't want, in my opinion for more of the public to learn that DL is a hoax, followed by injustices and propped up now by bias and special interest ideologues and their silent enablers.

Sorry I didn't get Liestoppers and Lew Rockwell post done. I will late tonight. Both blogs are doing great work as are a growing number of blogs who are joining us.

Some news tonight but it will go up late.

Look for another of these "Talking etc. post by tomorrow A. M.

A hat tip to you all.

BTW - Don't miss the Aug. 8 Churchill Series post.

This unproofed.

John

Duke lacrosse:KC Johnson as Raleigh N&O public editor

The current Raleigh News & Observer public editor is Ted Vaden, a career N&O employee who applauded the N&O's refusal to publish any on the Danish cartoons and then a few weeks later had no problem with the N&O’s publication of the infamous “vigilante” poster.

Ted doesn’t like it when you call up and ask, for example, why in its Mar. 24 story that “broke” what we know is the Duke lacrosse hoax, the N&O keep calling the accuser “the victim” without ever using a conditional qualifier such as “alleged.”

Vaden writes a Sunday column a friend of mine calls the “Gosh we’re great but they don’t know it” column.

Vaden's says at his blog that he's going to write this Sunday's column on the small dating error in reporter Joe Neff’s 3,700 word story exposing some of DA Mike Nifong and certain police investigators procedural violations and very possibly illegal actions (Neff does not come right out and say certain actions were illegal. - JinC)

You can read what Vaden is saying so far at his blog here.

While I wish Vaden well personally, it's too bad the N&O doesn't have a public editor like historian and blogger KC Johnson.

If KC was the N&O’s public editor imagine your shock when you opened the N&O as read something as fact-filled, well-written and carefully reasoned as what KC's just posted:

Timelines are unusually significant in the Duke lacrosse case. Sunday’s N&O article by Joseph Neff, and subsequent correction of the date of a key memo whose existence Neff first revealed, provides more timeline clues. For the first time, it seems more than plausible to suggest that D.A. Mike Nifong’s misbehavior extended beyond procedural misconduct.

Thanks to the N&O, a new timeline of the case’s investigation exists. Dates of items first publicly revealed from the Neff exposé are bolded.

March 16: Operating under the assumption that, as the accuser had claimed, her attackers were named Matt, Adam, and Brett, the Durham police constructed a photo lineup array. The lineup loosely conformed to Durham’s guidelines (which are among the state’s weakest): the accuser was told that her attackers might or might not be in the array, and she was shown five “filler” photos for every suspect.

These “filler” photos, however, were of other lacrosse players, not people uninvolved with the case, as the guidelines suggest. (The photos came from the Duke lacrosse website.) Since the team had two students named Matt, the accuser looked at four arrays of six photos each. She identified no one as her attacker. (blod JinC)

March 21: When the accuser returned to the police station to pick up some of her other items, she was shown two more six-player arrays. The accuser identified no one. That outcome should have come as little surprise to the police.

In extraordinarily vague terms, she had described one of her attackers as “chubby” and said a second weighed about 270 pounds. Duke’s lacrosse team, an elite Division I athletic squad, had no “chubby” players, nor did any of its players weigh anything close to 270 pounds.

March 23: Nifong’s office obtained a court order for all 46 white players on the team to submit DNA samples. The motion neglected to inform the court that the accuser had failed in photo lineups to identify as her attackers at least 36 players on the team, including at least two (Reade Seligmann and Dave Evans) she ultimately would select.

With the wording of the order, authorities abandoned their March 16 belief that Adam, Matt, Matt, and Brett were their targets; now all 46 white players were suspects. At the time, Nifong promised, “The DNA evidence requested will immediately rule out any innocent persons, and show conclusive evidence as to who the suspect(s) are in the alleged violent attack upon this victim.”

March 27-28: In his first public comments on the matter, Nifong repeatedly expressed confidence—in interviews with MSNBC and with North Carolina stations WRAL and NBC-17 —that the DNA evidence produced by the court order would solve the case.

March 29: In an interview with the N&O that was published March 30, Nifong suddenly and dramatically reversed course on the significance of DNA to the case. He now suggested that the attackers could have used condoms—even though the accuser had denied her alleged attackers used condoms, which the district attorney would have known had he read his own file before speaking out publicly. "How does DNA exonerate you?,” mused Nifong. “It's either a match or there's not a match. If the only thing that we ever have in this case is DNA, then we wouldn't have a case.

He no longer mentioned a relationship between the return of the DNA results and closing out the case, and offered no public explanation for his new viewpoint.

March 31, 12.23pm: In a meeting with the two chief police investigators on the case, Nifong ordered a second photo lineup. Only this time, he told the officers, they were to ignore Durham’s procedures and these Nifong-mandated procedural irregularities “strongly suggest[ed] that the purpose of the identification process was to give the alleged victim an opportunity to pick three members of the lacrosse team who could be charged. Any three students would do; there could be no wrong choice.”

April 4, 11.29am: The accuser’s procedurally flawed photo ID session began. Eventually, the accuser identified four players, of whom Nifong charged three. (He couldn’t charge all four, since none of the accuser’s myriad stories had cited an attack by four players, though she had claimed at one point that five had attacked her.)

Nifong has never publicly explained how he chose the three that he did; the accuser said she was 100% certain that Seligmann “sort” of looked like a person who attacked her, while she commented, after seeing a photo of Evans, to be 90% certain that the photo resembled someone with a mustache who attacked her. Evans has no mustache.

April 4, 3.59pm: Police Investigator Michelle Soucie memorialized a conversation in which she gave Nifong price quotes for DNA tests at a private lab. In his pre-primary publicity barrage, Nifong had never suggested that he would request a second round of tests: he had stated, repeatedly, that he would indict based on the results from the state lab. Indeed, the fact that the prestigious SBI lab handled his request on an expedited fashion suggested that its word would be definitive.

Nifong’s only motive for seeking a second round of tests, of course, was bad news from the SBI. In short, sometime before 3.59pm on April 4, the district attorney knew that the first DNA tests would all come back negative. Alas, the N&O, since it dated the memorandum incorrectly in an error unrelated to the content of the story as a whole, has removed this document from its website.

April 10: Nifong supplied the DNA test results to defense attorneys, who publicly announced that all 46 were negative.

This timeline reveals an investigation whose basic evidentiary goal veered dramatically whenever findings contradicted the district attorney’s public theories and political needs. The theories drove the search for evidence; the finding of evidence had no impact on the theories. As a result, the inquiry divided into three, distinct, segments.

First, from March 14 through March 21, the police employed standard tactics, showing the accuser a photo lineup that, more or less (less, in this case), conformed to the spirit of city guidelines. The accuser identified no one; her descriptions of at least two of her alleged assailants did not resemble anyone on the team.

The second stage began sometime between March 21 and March 23, when Nifong seized control of the case. The district attorney argued now that DNA, not results from a photo lineup, would provide the key evidence, and obtained an extraordinarily broad court order to get the evidence he wanted.

Then, no later than the morning of March 31, Nifong completely reversed himself: a photo lineup, not DNA, would supply the key evidence—even though, just 10 days earlier, he had gone to the court on the grounds that DNA, not photos, would make his case.

In the new reality, moreover, authorities would simply pretend that the first photo lineup had never occurred. To ensure that someone would be picked that he could indict before the May primary, the district attorney ordered the police to conduct a lineup that violated Durham’s procedures by consisting solely of suspects, and by telling the accuser of this fact.(bold JinC)

The transition from phase one of the investigation to phase two—i.e., from reliance on photo IDs to the mass gathering of DNA evidence—was irregular: the courts generally frown on demanding DNA solely on the basis of group membership. As Durham attorney Alex Charns noted at the time, “I can't imagine a scenario where this would be reasonable to do this so early in the investigation. It seems unusual, it seems over-broad, and it seems frightening that they're invading the privacy of so many people." To interpret Nifong’s actions in the most favorable light to the district attorney, perhaps he wished to give every conceivable benefit of the doubt to the accuser.

There can be, however, no benign explanation for the transition from stage two (DNA as the inculpating evidence) to stage three (back to photos, but with a lineup that violated all procedures).

The question, therefore, becomes when, and especially why, Nifong made this decision. The Soucie memo confirms that the district attorney had word of the negative DNA results at least six days before they were publicly revealed. How much earlier had he gained access to this information? Did he know of the likely negative outcome on March 29, when he inexplicably started to downplay the significance of DNA in his public statements?

Regarding the negative DNA tests, the question is: what did Nifong know, and when did he know it?

Specifically, why, on March 31, did he order the Durham police to orchestrate a second lineup that violated their own procedures in virtually every way, even though they had already conducted a lineup whose results he ignored? Did he do so in response to a heads-up that the DNA tests he had promised would “show conclusive evidence as to who the suspect(s) are in the alleged violent attack” instead produced no matches? If so, he dangerously abused his authority, in a manner well beyond his (by now routine) violations of the state ethics code.

It’s unlikely that the [Durham]Herald-Sun, whose ardently pro-Nifong editorial stance has recently seeped into its news coverage, will explore these matters; and, from the look of things, the Herald-Sun is the only media outlet to which Nifong speaks.

Perhaps, in any case, the questions of what Nifong knew and when he knew it are more appropriate for federal authorities to ask. It’s high time they did so.
High time, indeed.

I hope N&O public editor Ted Vaden and editorial page editor Steve Ford read KC's post and then, instead of continuing the N&O's editorial policy of "Leave it to Nifong," call for his replacement and a federal investigation?

The players and their families deserve no less. So do all the rest of us in North Carolina who care about the proper administration of justice.

It's time the N&O got with us.

Ted Vaden's email: ted.vaden@newsobserver.com

Steve Ford's email: sford@newsobserver.com

Tuesday, August 08, 2006

The Churchill Series – Aug. 8, 2006

(One of a series of weekday posts on the life of Winston S. Churchill.)

In the early summer of 1906, Lady Wemyss hosted one a small dinner party. The guests included a bright, charming nineteen year old, Violet Asquith, daughter of Herbert Asquith, then Chancellor of the Exchequer, and soon to be Prime Minister. Violet was seated next to a thirty-two year old Member of Parliament, Winston Churchill, the son of a former Chancellor of the Exchequer, Lord Randolph Churchill.

Violet tells us about the evening:

I found myself sitting next to this young man who seemed to me quite different from any other young man I had ever met. For a long time he remained sunk in abstraction.

Then he appeared to become suddenly aware of my existence. He turned on me a lowering gaze and asked me abruptly how old I was. I replied that I was nineteen.

“And I,” he said almost despairingly, “am thirty-two already. Younger than anyone else who counts, though, “he added, as if to comfort himself.

Then savagely: “Curse ruthless time! Curse our mortality. How cruelly short is the allotted span for all we must cram into it.” And he burst forth into an eloquent diatribe on the shortness of human life , the immensity of possible human accomplishment – a theme so well exploited by the of all ages that it might seem difficult to invest it with a new and startling significance .

Yet for me he did so, in a torrent of magnificent language which appeared to be both effortless and inexhaustible and ended up with the words I shall always remember: “we are all worms. But I do believe that I am a glowworm.”

By this time I was convinced of it – and my conviction remained unshaken throughout the years that followed.
The young Violet Asquith, who later became Violet Bonham Carter, and Winston Churchill began a remarkable friendship that night. They remained friends for the next fifty-nine years until Churchill died on January 24, 1965.

Bonham Carter paid a last visit to the Churchill shortly before he died. She surely thought of that summer evening in 1906 when a young man told her he was "a glowworm," something she never doubted and lived to see History confirm.
__________________________________________________
Violet Bonham Carter, Winston Churchill: An intimate Portrait. (p. 3)

Duke lacrosse: Raleigh N&O correction is wrong

Readers' Note: Raleigh News & Observer reporter Joe Neff's story, "Lacrosse files show gaps in DA's case," has been widely praised for it exposure of actions by DA Mike Nifong and certain Durham police investigators that violated proper investigative procedures and very likely violated the law as well, although Neff's does not come right out and say that.

Neff's 3,700 word story contains one small error which you'll read about below.

Based on that error, the N&O today issued a correction which was the right thing to do. But the N&O then used that correction to undercut the major thrust of Neff's story. That wasn't the right thing to do.

The N&O appears to be unable to consistently and fully tell readers the truth about the Duke lacrosse hoax which it helped turn into a witch hunt with a series of grossly inaccurate, biased and inflammatory stories that cast the accuser as the victim and the lacrosse players as her gang-rape victimizers.

A JinC reader has just made this comment:

The top editors inside the N&O are biased against the Duke students. By overreacting to an error in Neff's otherwise excellent story, they have made Neff's error look worse than it actually is and show an ignorance of the facts of the case. Once again, shame on the N&O and its top editors.
I think the reader has it right.

I just left the following comment at N&O executive editor for news Melanie Sill's McClatchy Company sponsored Editor's Blog. I hope many of you will go there and make your own comments.

John
____________________________________________


Dear Melanie:

Regarding DPD Inv. Michelle Soucie's memorandum of April 4 which the N&O incorrectly reported as being written on April 17 you say:

"The error means the lead illustration on the story does not have the significance we thought it did. We have removed the illustration from our Web site."

In a front page correction today the N&O says in part: “This error changes the implication of the first five paragraphs of the story: that the conversation between Nifong and Soucie was an example of the words and actions of police and persecutors outpacing the facts in the file.”

No it doesn’t change "the implication of the first five ...."

Here’s part of what the distinguished historian and blogger Robert KC Johnson just said in his post, “The Soucie Memo”

http://hnn.us/blogs/entries/28991.html

Johnson says: -- The words of the correction were poorly chosen. For, in fact, as Neff’s original article claimed, “the conversation between Nifong and Soucie was an example of the words and actions of police and prosecutors outpacing the facts in the file.”

Before April 4, Nifong gave dozens of interviews to the state and national media commenting with certainty on the “events” of the “rape.” Here are three typical examples of his remarks:

March 29, MSNBC:“The circumstances of the case are not suggestive of the alternate explanation that has been suggested by some of the members of the situation. There is evidence of trauma in the victim’s vaginal area that was noted when she was examined by a nurse at the hospital.”

March 29, WRAL: “My reading of the report of the emergency room nurse would indicate that some type of sexual assault did in fact take place.”

March 30, CBS News: "The victim was examined at Duke University Medical Center by a nurse who was specially trained in sexual assault cases. And the investigation at that time was certainly consistent with a sexual assault having taken place.”

Yet, days after Nifong made these and other similar statements, Soucie recorded the following, according to the memo the N&O uncovered: "Mike Nifong stated that: Also need documentation on escort service and how they do business. Need to nail down what victim did on the day before arriving at 610 N. Buchanan so we can show that she did not receive trauma prior to the incident—with witnesses."

Neff’s original conclusion is correct: Nifong “had said repeatedly on national television that he was certain the dancer had been raped.

Yet the prosecutor was still trying to rule out other explanations for the vaginal swelling a hospital noted in its examination of the accuser. The words and actions of police and prosecutors had outpaced the facts in the file, and not for the first time.”

This memo, in short, is the clearest example to date of misconduct by Nifong in his public remarks.

Not only was he violating the state bar’s prohibition against statements “that have a substantial likelihood of heightening public condemnation of the accused,” he was, to put it bluntly, dissembling.

KC Johnson says a lot more in the post, all of it consistent with what Neff said and, if anything, even more damaging to what shreds are left of the "case" and Nifong's reputation.

Melanie, There’s a lot more to the post. I hope you and other N&O editors read it.

The N&O needs to issue an immediate front page correction of today’s erroneous correction.

I’ll be asking public editor Ted Vaden to read KC’s post after which I hope he also requests a correction of today’s erroneous post.

While we’re on the subject of KC, why haven’t you interviewed him for a major story?

Not only is KC one of America’s most distinguished historians, he’s published extensively on the Duke lacrosse hoax, including the many procedural errors and false statements made by DA Nifong and some Durham police investigators.

You’ve published many statements and op-eds by members of the now discredited, widely ridiculed Duke faculty Group of 88 and other academics of similar liberal/leftist ideological bent.

I think your sensible readers would welcome an interview story featuring someone like KC Johnson. And a little change might be good for the N&O.

Thank you for providing a means for me to comment.

John
www.johnincarolina.com

Duke lacrosse: Neff’s story looks even stronger now

Today’s Raleigh N&O has a front page correction of a dating error in reporter Joe Neff’s Sunday, Aug. 6, story, "Lacrosse files show gaps in DA's case."

Neff said a memorandum by Durham PD Inv. Michelle Soucie was written on April 17. In fact, the memorandum was actually written of April 4.

In its correction, "Story on Duke case erred on DA's order,"the N&O says:

“This error changes the implication of the first five paragraphs of the story: that the conversation between Nifong and Soucie was an example of the words and actions of police and persecutors outpacing the facts in the file.”
No, the dating error doesn’t do that. As historian and blogger KC Johnson points out :
“[I]n fact, as Neff’s original article claimed, “the conversation between Nifong and Soucie was an example of the words and actions of police and prosecutors outpacing the facts in the file.” (bold KC’s)
Look at just some of what KC lays out to contradict the N&O's correction and demonstrating that Neff's article is far more damning of Nifong's conduct than many people, including me, realized. An excerpt from KC post, “The Soucie Memo:”
Neff made a rare error, however, in the story, inaccurately describing a memorandum by Durham PD Investigator Michelle Soucie as having been penned on April 17, when actually the memo was written on April 4. The N&O promptly issued a correction.

The error, however, meant only that Neff’s story was excessively kind to Nifong, and affected none of the story’s conclusions. The material in the excerpted portions of the Soucie memo, in combination with other facts and documents already publicly available, reinforces the pattern of this case: the more material released, the more indefensible Nifong’s behavior appears.

The previously unreleased Soucie memorandum brought four items to light. In its correction statement, the N&O writes that the corrected date for the memorandum (from April 17 to April 4) “changes the implication of the first five paragraphs of the story: that the conversation between Nifong and Soucie was an example of the words and actions of police and prosecutors outpacing the facts in the file.”

The words of the correction were poorly chosen. For, in fact, as Neff’s original article claimed, “the conversation between Nifong and Soucie was an example of the words and actions of police and prosecutors outpacing the facts in the file.”

Before April 4, Nifong gave dozens of interviews to the state and national media commenting with certainty on the “events” of the “rape.” Here are three typical examples of his remarks:

March 29, MSNBC:“The circumstances of the case are not suggestive of the alternate explanation that has been suggested by some of the members of the situation. There is evidence of trauma in the victim’s vaginal area that was noted when she was examined by a nurse at the hospital.”

March 29, WRAL: “My reading of the report of the emergency room nurse would indicate that some type of sexual assault did in fact take place.”

March 30, CBS News: "The victim was examined at Duke University Medical Center by a nurse who was specially trained in sexual assault cases. And the investigation at that time was certainly consistent with a sexual assault having taken place.”

Yet, days after Nifong made these and other similar statements, Soucie recorded the following, according to the memo the N&O uncovered: "Mike Nifong stated that: Also need documentation on escort service and how they do business. Need to nail down what victim did on the day before arriving at 610 N. Buchanan so we can show that she did not receive trauma prior to the incident—with witnesses."

Neff’s original conclusion is correct: Nifong “had said repeatedly on national television that he was certain the dancer had been raped. Yet the prosecutor was still trying to rule out other explanations for the vaginal swelling a hospital noted in its examination of the accuser. The words and actions of police and prosecutors had outpaced the facts in the file, and not for the first time.”(Bold added)

This memo, in short, is the clearest example to date of misconduct by Nifong in his public remarks. Not only was he violating the state bar’s prohibition against statements “that have a substantial likelihood of heightening public condemnation of the accused,” he was, to put it bluntly, dissembling.

Shortly after he dismissed “the alternate explanation” for the accuser’s alleged injuries (which, as things turned out, were far less severe than the D.A. claimed) to MSNBC, Nifong admitted to Soucie that he wasn’t sure if an “alternate explanation” did exist—namely, that “what [the alleged] victim did on the day before arriving at 610 N. Buchanan” could explain her trauma.

Neff’s words—“the words and actions of police and prosecutors had outpaced the facts in the file”—are charitable in describing the misconduct here.

The N&O obviously had to issue a correction regarding the date of the Soucie memorandum, pointing out that it was written before Nifong sought indictments. But, contrary to the insinuation of the correction text, the memo’s earlier date actually raises more questions about Nifong’s conduct, rather than weakening any of the article’s conclusions.

Three matters are immediately apparent.

First, the order contained in the Soucie memo had one immediate effect: the obtaining of the statement of Jarriel Johnson, the figure generally described as the accuser’s “driver.” Johnson provided his statement to police two days after Nifong instructed Soucie “to nail down what victim did on the day before arriving at 610 N. Buchanan.”

Unfortunately for the district attorney, however, Johnson’s affidavit - reproduced at page 27 of this motion (I was unable to access the motion - JinC)- provided no help in showing “that [the accuser] did not receive trauma prior to the incident.”

Johnson revealed that the accuser had engaged in a variety of private “events” in the hours before the lacrosse party, including at least one that involved use of a vibrator. As Liestoppers blog explained yesterday, “While Nifong instructed DPD to find witnesses to show that the accuser's nether region was unswollen, instead they found him Jarriel Johnson whose description of accuser's activities seemed to do the exact opposite. Nifong asked for proof that the swelling couldn't have been caused by the accuser's escort service activities, and instead found proof that it could very well have.”

Yet [Nifong] sought indictments anyway. The correct dating of the Soucie memo thus shows Nifong’s closed-mindedness to any evidence contradicting his theories as early as April 6. So much for his duty, under the state bar’s ethics code, to serve as “a minister of justice.”
There is a lot more in KC's post, all of it just as devastating to Nifong's "case."

When you finish KC's post, I hope you agree that the N&O needs to correct today's correction. As the N&O's correction now stands, it tells readers something KC's post demonstrates is not true.

I'm going to make a comment at the N&O exec editor for news Melanie Sill's Editor's Blog. I intend to ask Sill to read KC's post and than prepare a much needed correction of the N&O's erroneous statement today that a simple dating error:
“changes the implication of the first five paragraphs of the story: that the conversation between Nifong and Soucie was an example of the words and actions of police and persecutors outpacing the facts in the file.”
I'll also will request the N&O conduct and publish a major interview with KC.

I hope many of you do the same.

Throughout the Duke lacrosse hoax the N&O has served readers anonymous interviews with the woman it called "the victim" and some of her family members. It's also served up interviews and op-ed columns from members of the now discredited and widely-ridiculed Duke faculty Group of 88.

The N&O should now give readers something very different: a major story/interview with a distinguished historian who's remarkably well-informed about Nifong's actions and how they violated investigative procedures and bar association ethics and guidelines.

If you want to email Sill it's: melanie.sill@newsobserver.com

N&O's public editor Ted Vaden's email is: ted.vaden@newsobserver.com

I hope you all make your voices heard.

Monday, August 07, 2006

No Churchill Series post - Aug. 7, 2006

Folks,

I'm sorry there'll be no Churchill Series post today.

It's the workload.

I'll be posting tomorrow.

I hope you all visit.

Best,

John

Duke lacrosse: KC Johnson operates on DA Nifong

Some surgeons use laser instruments to cut and dissolve tissue.

I kept thinking about that as I read KC Johnson’s latest post: “Boasting of Closed-Mindedness.”

If you’ve scrubbed, you’re welcome to join the rest of us who in a few minutes will go into the O.R. to observe KC.

According to the schedule, when we enter KC should be making a few, quick, final cuts into Duke President Richard H. Brodhead’s large spineless area. Brodhead is under general anesthesia, so of course he can’t say anything about Duke lacrosse.

KC will next turn to the patient scheduled for major surgery today, Michael Nifong of Durham, North Carolina. For part of the operation KC will team with another fine surgeon who recently joined us, Jason Trumpbour of Friends of Duke University.

Patient Nifong has been rushed to surgery because of severe credibility problems and hemorrhaging indictments. Most people think Nifong is a hopeless case, but with surgeons like KC and Trumpbour, I guess we can always hope.

Let’s go in.

Look, there’s KC. And Trumpbour will join KC once he's finished putting on his gloves and mask :

Duke president Richard Brodhead—having declined to protest a system in which local authorities refuse to follow their own procedures when investigating his own institution's students—now has publicly claimed that three Duke students will have the opportunity “to be proved innocent” in a situation that “only the criminal justice system can resolve.”

In the Alice-in-Wonderland world that is Durham justice, such sentiments, which turn American judicial philosophy on its head, are all too common—as in a peculiar editorial from the Durham Herald-Sun, which praised D.A. Mike Nifong for stating at a recent press conference,“I have not backed off from my initial assessment of the case.” This comment provided a “boost of confidence” to those, like the Herald-Sun editorial board, who support Nifong.

Following up on several posts from John in Carolina, which have raised serious doubts about the Herald-Sun’s journalistic integrity, a recent letter to the editor by Friends of Duke University spokesperson Jason Trumpbour eviscerated the editorial. As Trumpbour noted, the editors “stated that Nifong ‘still believes he has a good case’ and find that significant for some reason. Yet, Nifong apparently lacks the courage of those convictions.

After ramrodding evidence through a hopelessly backlogged SBI crime lab and racing to get indictments before the election, Nifong is now trying to postpone the day of reckoning until next spring. Nifong refused to even look at any of the exculpatory evidence proffered to him by the defense.

This action violated North Carolina Rule of Professional Conduct 3.8 which prohibits a prosecutor from avoiding ‘pursuit of evidence merely because he or she believes it will damage the prosecutor's case.’ In hiding his eyes from that evidence, Nifong abdicated the responsibilities of the office to which he was appointed and should have no further claim to it.”
Isn't that great work Drs. Johnson and Trumpbour are doing!

You can watch the rest of "the operation" here.

I'm sorry but I have to go now. I want to watch some JinC Regulars do out-patient truth implants at the Editor's Blog clinic.

Come over later and watch some of that here.

Before you go, a final word: Blog "medical" ethics require that I tell you KC and Friends of Duke University frequently link to JinC