Friday, July 14, 2006

Is the Raleigh News & Observer about to

disclose the locations of all speed traps used by the City of Raleigh police?

The N&O’s unbelievable executive editor for news, Melanie Sill, is being urged to have the N&O do just that by a reader at the Editor’s Blog where Sill regularly ducks readers' questions.

On the thread of a post in which Sill cheers the New York Times’ disclosure of national security secrets we find:

Comment from: Locomotive Breath [Visitor]

07/13/06 at 10:21
Ms. Sill,

Would you please investigate and then start publishing the location of all police speed traps in the City of Raleigh? I like to go fast and I know they're out there looking for me I just don't know where.

I can't think of any reason why you shouldn't subvert the police in their perfectly legal attempt to prevent me breaking the law and endangering other people. After all, the police are also monitoring the speed of law-abiding drivers and the general public has the right to know when and where they are being monitored.

Thanks for your cooperation.
I'm guessing Locomotive Breath, a very sensible person who sometimes comments here, really doesn't drive too fast. None of us should. I'll bet LB was just trying to help Melanie understand how strongly some citizens feel about the secret actions of an armed, uniformed group of government agents who - let's face it - are spying on us all every day.

Melanie should get right on the speed trap location story. After all, she's the one who said further up the same thread where LB commented :
The idea of our democracy is that citizens get to decide how we want government to operate, not the reverse. An independent press (print and electronic) serves citizens by informing them.
Doesn't that sound like the N&O is going to disclose the speed trap locations?

I mean, how can we decide how the police should operate the speed traps when we don't even know where they are?

I hope the N&O disclosures tell us a lot more besides locations. I'm hearing reports that at least some police officers enter the speed traps without first getting warrants. That's scary.

It looks like the N&O won’t get a Pulitzer for its slime and frame Duke lacrosse coverage. Maybe it will for its speed trap story.

I can't wait for tomorrow's N&O.

Nice comment, LB.

Thursday, July 13, 2006

The Churchill Series – July 13, 2006

(One of a series of weekday posts on the life of Winston S. Churchill.)

On August 3, 1929 Churchill, still a member of Parliament but out of Cabinet office following the Conservative’s defeat in the recent general election, said from Southampton bound for a two month trip to Canada and America. He was accompanied by his eighteen year old son, Randolph, his brother, Jack, and Jack’s son, Johnny.

Clementine was to also have accompanied him but she had a tonsillectomy just before the trip. Her physician strongly advised she remain in England to recover. Churchill was keenly disappointed.

But as was typical of him he made the best of the situation. That included writing a series of letters to Clementine so she could "share" the trip with him. He wrote the first letter a few hours after his ship left Southampton:

All departures from home – even on pleasure are sad. The vessel drifts away from the shore & an ever-widening gulf opens between one and the citadel of one’s life and soul. …

You are quite right not to make plans till you feel yourself again. But then surely there are lots of delightful alternatives. … Do not exclude the USA.

We are plodding across a calm Channel & this goes to you from Cherbourg.

I expect to do a lot of work – Certainly 2 articles before landing & to read copiously into Marlborough. …

Send me a wireless to mid-ocean to tell me how you are getting on.

With tender love
Your devoted
W
X X X X X
On August 8, with the ocean crossing nearing its end, Churchill writes:
We have had a wonderfully good passage with only one day of unpleasant motion. …

The boys were called by the Captain at 6:30 a.m. to see a large iceberg – 150 ft. high – which passed at no great distance. They did not, however, wake me, which was a pity. …

There is a fine swimming pool on board where the youth of both sexes play water polo. I stick to the hot water. …
What thoughts passed through your mind as you read those parts of the letters?

I thought of the two sentences beginning “All departures from home …” and admired as always Churchill’s descriptive power.

“Send me a wireless to mid-ocean…” Today they’d be calling each other on their cells.
And we very proberbly wouldn't have the letters.

The 150 ft. iceberg. Churchill and everyone else on board must have thought of the Titanic. It went down less than 20 years before; he knew many of those who perished.

In tomorrow’s post, Churchill and his party – he called it the “troupe” - arrive in Quebec. He’ll tour the city and take a drive in the countryside. He tells Clementine all about it. Then the troupe heads for Montreal and points West.
____________________________________________________________
Speaking for Themselves: The Personal Letters of Winston and Clementine Churchill. Edited by their daughter, Mary Soames. (pgs. 334-336)

Talking with JinC Regulars - 7 -13-06

(One of a series of posts in the original web log tradition: notes and "thinking out loud." These posts will be most easily understood by regular visitors and are But others are welcome. John)

First item:

J is a self-described “semi-regular.”

J commented in response to “Duke lacrosse: Police investigation questions. (Post 1)”

J provided a number of questions concerning the DL police investigation. If you haven’t read them, I hope you do.

J’s questions, asked in a matter of fact, on point, and brief form reveal considerable knowledge of the DL investigation and suggest the investigative background J claims is bona fide.

I promised J I’d give the questions a very close look, ask some clarifying questions, and then build a post on them. I didn’t do that.

My apologies, J.

I’ll review your questions this weekend, and post a response on the thread by Sunday morning.

In the meantime, I hope J and everyone else feels free to comment on the thread.

On another matter:

Did you all see the Durham Herald Sun’s July 8 story on Charns/CrimeStoppers?

I was glad new media attention is being paid to Charns’ request for a public apology by Dur. City and Police for the CrimeStoppers flyer telling the community the Duke lacrosse players weere multiple felony criminals. Also, to his request for an official investigation into its production and distribution.

That said, I had trouble following the sequence and substance of correspondence between Charns and public officials which the H-S discussed.

So I called Charns to nail down who has written what to whom when.

Bottom line: Charns agreed to let me sit down in his office and go through the public correspondence making notes and photo-copying as I wish, with the understanding I will share what I learn with you.

I’ll very likely do that sometime next week and pass on data to you ASAP.

Thank you, Alex.

Charns and I also agreed we’d refer to posters/flyers produced by CrimeStoppers as “Wanted” posters/flyers. We’re also going to refer to posters/flyers with the face photos of 43 Duke lacrosse players as “vigilante posters.”

It was a “vigilante poster” that the Raleigh News & Observer published on Apr. 2 with no reference to its source or any explanation for why it was published after warnings that doing so would endanger the players. Also, the N&O didn’t even mention its “vigilante poster” in the story it accompanied.

Something isn’t right, folks. The act of publishing the poster stunk. Now the N&O's refusal to explain why it published such an inciteful phote without even referencing it in the news story it was supposed to "support and explain" stinks like a 1000 acre hog farm.

I hope you’ll continue to ask N&O exec news editor Melanie Sill why the N&O published the “vigilante poster” and how it “got into” the N&O newsroom and was approved for publication. Lots of stories about that are going around all three corners of the Research Triangle.

Final item:

KC Johnson’s latest post is extraordinary. Here’s part of what Betsy Newmark says about it:

Historian Robert K. C. Johnson has done a great bit of research to answer a question that I've been wondering about.

We know that there have been a lot of questions about the procedure used in the lineup that led the woman in the Duke lacrosse story to identify three of the players.

Under orders from Mike Nifong, the police presented her with pictures of only the team's players with no filler photos. The police told her that she was just going to see pictures of men who were at the party. All this violates the procedures that were adopted in 2003 by the Actual Innocence Commission (AIC).

“b) The individual conducting the photo or live lineup should not know the identity of the actual suspect. This is called a double-blind procedure and addresses misidentifications resulting from unintentional influences from those conducting the identification procedure.”

”c) Witnesses should be instructed that the suspect may or may not be in the lineup.”

”d) A minimum of eight photos should be used in photo identification procedures.”

I had wondered how anomalous Durham's lineup procedure was for North Carolina.

Well, K.C. has done that research by communicating with district attorneys and police departments across the state to ask them simply what procedures they use in lineups.

And, no surprise, they ALL follow guidelines similar to what the AIC guidelines recommend.
That’s right, Betsy and JinC Regulars, all but one.

KC’s research and conclusions are just what the N&O likes to tell people it “digs up” and reports on.

So why didn’t the N&O do any of that?

Putting that very important question aside for now, why isn’t the N&O interviewing KC ?

Why isn’t any “news organization” in North Carolina interviewing KC Johnson, one of America's outstaning historians?

And why aren’t North Carolina news organizations asking NC Attorney General Roy Cooper questions about AIC and the conduct of his fellow Democrat , Durham DA Mike Nifong?

It can’t be that Cooper isn’t available to the press. He wants to be the next Governor. He’s “currying” the press right now.

So why isn’t the press asking Cooper tough questions?

It makes you wonder, doesn’t it.

More soon.

Thanks for your continuing interest in JinC.

Johnsville News: Question and comments.

If you’re interested in the Duke lacrosse case, I hope you’re visiting The Johnsville News blog at least once a day. It’s the collection and commentary place for almost everything worth reading on the DL case.

Johnsville even links to me sometimes, but don’t let that stop you from going there.

Question: Does anyone know how I can make email contact with the folks there. I want to thank Johnsville for the links. I also often read something I want to comment on or ask Johnsville about.

From Johnsville’s lead post today, this example of commentary I want to respond to :

Samiha Khanna and Anne Blythe are the reporters who did the March 24th and 25th stories for The N&O. The March 25th story based on the interview with [the accuser] has to go down as one of the poorest jobs of professional journalism you will ever come across. Ms. Mangum spun a story that the News & Observer reporters and editors swallowed hook, line, and sinker.

Her story was totally believed and [the accuser] must have left the N&O reporter(s) in tears.
A few thoughts:

I agree the stories appearing below Khanna and Blythe’s bylines were, at best, lousy journalism. But was that because they don’t know how to do a good job or was their bias, inflammatory language and “endearing” presentation of the accuser deliberate?

Did the woman Khanna and Blythe repeatedly told readers was “the victim” actually fool them or were they going along?

Or did Khanna and Blythe have some doubts about her story but embraced and hyped it anyway because it fit with their preexisting attitudes toward white male athletes from “elite” schools playing “helmet sports?”

Are Khanna and Blythe practitioners of what we hear the J schools are increasingly turning out: Agenda journalists who think it’s their job to spin stories in terms of what they and others of the same ideological bent see when they look through their “prisms” at “issues of gender, class and race?”

If Khanna and Blythe are agenda journalists than their stories are, IMHO, best explained not be ineptness but by deliberate calculation.

For all that Khanna and Blythe did to poison public sentiment against the students, it’s only fair to acknowledge they didn’t act alone. Editors reviewed, corrected, and apporved the final versions of their copy. Editors did the story lay-outs and headlines. It was editors who ultimately decided on the content and placement of Khanna and Blythe’s articles (really prosecutorial statements) that appeared in the N&O.

A final word: There were a number of other N&O reporters whose stories are every bit as biased and inflammatory as Khanna and Blythe’s; and those stories also had editors going right on up to the N&O’s exec editor or news Melanie Sill who cheered them all on. She even now tells people how “proud” she is of what the N&O's reporters and editors did.

Another day at the N&O: The paper that tells readers they can believe its advertising slogan: “We’re fair and accurate.”

Duke lacrosse: Estrich undermines the legal system

Do you know Susan Estrich? She’s a former aide to Sen. Ted Kennedy and managed Gov. Mike Dukakis’ failed 1988 Democratic presidential campaign.

Estrich is currently Professor of Law and Political Science at the University of Southern California School of Law.

Estrich also writes a syndicated column. Her latest is “Another Team Rape.” It's a confused, error-filled ramble in which Estrich equates Duke lacrosse players who’ve denied felony crimes with another group of athletes who the press reports have admitted to acts which a court of law would very likely judge criminal.

Something else: Estrich demonstrates a stunning disregard – no contempt – for the rights of the accused and the role of attorneys’ in assuring our legal system is based on due process.

I decided to write the Dean of the Southern Cal Law School. My electronic letter follows.
________________________________________________________________

July 13, 2006

Spitzer, Matthew L.

Matthew L. Spitzer
Dean and Carl Mason Franklin Professor of Law and Political Science
The Law School
University of Southern California

Dear Dean Spitzer:

I'd like to call to your attention Professor Susan Estrich’s latest column, "Another Team Rape," which includes the following:

When six prospective members of the Fresno City College football team arrived at the Fresno, Calif., Police Station to be questioned about the alleged rape of an 11-year-old runaway, the only advice they had came from a lawyer whose son once played for the team.

For free, he told them that if they didn't do anything wrong, they should provide statements to the police -- and if they had done "something to be concerned with, even if it was consensual, or if they had done something to abet or aid, they might want to exercise their Fifth Amendment rights." This, according to the local paper.

The police do not always get roadmaps so easily. The Duke boys didn't give them statements. They don't give roadmaps to the police. They never talk to the police without having their own lawyers present.

Two men have already been arrested and are in custody. The Duke defendants are all out on bail.
Dean Spitzer, if I heard what Professor Estrich writes late at night in a barroom, I wouldn't be surprised.

But from a law professor writing for the public her remarks are shocking: she has many facts wrong and exhibits contempt for the rights of the accused and the role of attorneys’ in assuring our legal system is fair.

The “Duke boys” who lived in the house where the gang-rape is alleged to have occurred voluntarily gave police statements. They also voluntarily went to Duke Hospital and submitted to “rape kit” testing; offered to take lie detector tests; and helped the police identify and locate others who were at the party.

After they retained counsel, they and other members of the Duke Men’s lacrosse team were advised to remain silent while counsel sought to arrange for them to speak with police investigators and District Attorney Mike Nifong.

With regard to the players remaining silent, University of North Carolina School of Law Professor Ken Broun recently said: "Their attorneys advise them not to talk to police even if they're totally innocent, because of the possibility that things that you might say even if you're totally innocent in the case might be viewed differently by the person hearing them than you meant them."

Like many Americans, I was brought up to believe and cherish what Professor Broun said; and to abhor those who cast insinuations of guilt on others exercising Fifth Amendment rights. In fact, I was taught and believe that those who do cast such insinuations are engaging in McCarthyism.

I don't doubt that you are very concerned by surveys reporting a decline in the percentage of Americans expressing trust in the fairness of our legal system.

Professor Estrich’s column is an example of the kind of conduct that undermines trust in our judicial system. She ought to be censured for it.

I blog as www.johnincarolina.com. In a few minutes I’ll post there this letter along with some introductory commentary.

Should you care to respond to this letter, I’ll post your response in full along with a link to the post I’m about to put up.

Thank you for your attention to this letter.

Sincerely,

John
www.johnincarolina.com

Wednesday, July 12, 2006

No Churchill Series on July 12, 2006

Folks,

I'm very sorry I can't get a post done today.

There's a lot happening with regard to aspects of the Duke lacrosse case I often post on. I'm putting most of my blog time there today.

I'll be posting a Churchill Series post tomorrow.

Thank you for your understanding.

John

Did the Raleigh N&O withhold news of the Duke captains’ cooperation?

We now know that the three Duke lacrosse captains who rented the house at 610 N. Buchanan Blvd. voluntarily gave the police statements; submitted to “rape kit” testing; offered to take lie detector tests; and even helped police identify and locate others who were at the party.

But the Raleigh News & Observer’s Mar. 24 story reporting the lacrosse players had submitted to DNA testing - the story the N&O says “broke” the Duke lacrosse case - made no mention of the captains’ cooperation.

The N&O's Mar. 25 front-page, hugely sympathetic, anonymous “victim” interview story also said nothing about the captains’ cooperation. In fact, the N&O told readers authorities had "vowed to crack the team's wall of solidarity."

The N&O followed that with a statement that it granted anonymity to “victims of sex crimes," dispensing altogether with any qualifying “alleged," just as, in its Mar. 24 story, it said seven times the woman was "the victim" or used the possessive "the victim's," never qualifying any of the seven with “alleged.”

The N&O's Mar. 24 and 25 stories captured the nation's attention. People bought into its portrayal of the accuser as a hard working student and mother who was brutally gang-raped, beaten and strangled as she sought to earn money to support her two small children. They also bought into the N&O’s portrayal of the Duke students as her victimizers who were even then refusing to cooperate with police.

The N&O’s reporting in those and similarly biased and inflammatory stories it published the next few days so poisoned the public’s mind that when Ruth Sheehan's Mar. 27 N&O column ("Teams' silence is sickening") appeared, it was seen by many people as a righteous expression of "community outrage," instead of what we now know it to have been: a McCarthyite screed attacking the students for doing nothing more than following the advice of their counsels.

But what if the N&O had reported at least something about the captains’ cooperation with the police?

If the N&O had done that, would that have reduced the "community outrage" that reached such a pitch that the Mayor of Durham, the Chancellor of NC Central University, and the President of Duke University felt compelled to take full page ads in newspapers, including the N&O, calling on the community to remain calm and allow the justice system to work?

Certainly any news report about the captains’ cooperation wouldn’t have made any difference to people like Duke faculty's Group of 88, the Trinity Park pot bangers, the New Black Panthers, and most people who call themselves "victim's rights" and "civil rights" activists.

But a lot of normally sensible people who got swept up in the witch hunt hysteria would have paused if they'd known of the captains' cooperation. I think they’d have said something like the following to themselves and other sensible people: "Maybe there's more here. Let's hold off on judgment. The media are so often wrong. And the N&O has a terrible history of inflaming race, gender and class issues."

With what you’ve read so far in mind, let's turn now to Duke's student newspaper, The Chronicle.

On Mar. 21, three day before the N&O claims it "broke" the Duke lacrosse story, The Chronicle reported :

[Durham Police Sgt. Mark] Gottlieb said any man that attended the party March 13 would be a viable suspect but refused to go into further detail.

The residents of the house have been cooperative with DPD in locating any suspects, he added.
(Readers, You may be wondering how The Chronicle could report on the Duke lacrosse story on Mar. 21 if the N&O, as it claims, “broke” it on Mar. 24. I’ll deal with that question at the end of this post. Right now I want to get back to the matter of whether the N&O withheld from readers news of the captains’ cooperation. John)

A customized search of the N&O’s archives for the period 3/13/2006 through 3/24/2006 reveals that twice before Mar. 24 the N&O reported on events alleged to have occurred in the Buchanan Blvd. house the night of Mar. 13/14.

The first story appeared on Mar. 18; the second story appeared the following day. They are both brief, and they both report on statements by Sgt. Gottlieb.

Here’s the N&O's Mar. 18 story:
Woman reports sexual assault

Police were investigating a report of a rape on Buchanan Boulevard near the Duke University campus Friday. .. A young woman told police she visited 610 N. Buchanan Blvd. about 11:30 p.m. Monday and was assaulted by three men, according to police Sgt. Mark Gottlieb... Anyone with information is asked to call Investigator B.W. Himan at 560-4582, ext. 229
Now here's the N&O's Mar. 19 story:
Alleged rape was at party, police said

Police offered more details Saturday in the investigation of a young woman's report she was raped by three men at a party Monday near the Duke University campus.

The woman told police early Tuesday morning that she had gone to a house at 610 N. Buchanan Blvd. about 11:30 p.m. the night before for a party, said Sgt. Mark Gottlieb.

While at the party, she was raped by three men, she reported to police.

Gottlieb described the party as a mix of college students and non-students. In total, there were about 30 people there at the time, he said.

"It was an act where alcohol was involved," Gottlieb said.

It is The News & Observer's policy not to identify victims of reported sexual crimes.
Like its Mar. 24 and 25 stories, the N&O’s Mar. 18 and 19 stories say nothing about the captains’ cooperation.

Yet The Chronicle reported on at least some of that cooperation on Mar. 21 and cited Sgt. Gottlieb as its source; the same Sgt. Gottlieb the N&O cites as a source in its Mar. 18 and 19 stories. Why no mention in the N&O of cooperation by the captains?

I'll bet you agree it's fair to ask:
Didn’t Sgt. Gottlieb say anything about the captains’ cooperation to N&O reporters before the Mar. 18 and 19 stories?

And don't reporters routinely ask about the cooperation of people in whose homes crimes are alleged to have occured?

When did the N&O first learn about of the captains’ cooperation?

What was it the N&O learned?

When did the N&O tell readers what it learned?
What’s more, we should be asking:
When did the N&O first learn the captains had voluntarily given the police statements; voluntarily submitted to rape kit testing; offered to take lie detector tests; and helped identify and locate others who were at the party?

Whne did the N&O report that news to readers?
Those questions need answering, just as questions about the N&O’s publication of the infamous “vigilante poster” need answering.

I hope readers ask them at the Editor’s Blog where the N&O’s exec editor for news, Melanie Sill, is supposed to answer questions but has mostly been misleading readers when she's not ignoring there questions.

Sill should answer the questions asked here and others like: Who was the source of the "vigilante poster" the N&O published? Why did the N&O publish it only a few weeks after it refused to publish any of the Danish cartoons? Why was it OK to endanger the lacrosse players?

The N&O’s Apr. 2 story which accompanied the “vigilante poster” doesn’t even mention the poster. So what news purpose was served by publishing it? Many readers think it was just intended to slime the players.

Is the N&O ever going to apologize to the players and their families for publishing a poster that endangered the players?

The N&O’s executive editor for news, Melanie Sill, says she’s “proud” of the N&O’s Duke lacrosse coverage which she’s called “fair,” “accurate,” and “deep.”

But for all of that puffery, Sill’s refused to answer many questions readers are asking at McClatchy’s Editor’s Blog, the site where she supposed to answer those questions.

I hope readers keep asking questions at the Editor's Blog including :
When did the N&O start learning about the captains’ cooperation?

What did it learn?

And when did it report what it knew to readers?
Full disclosure: I no longer comment at the Editor's Blog following months of threats by Sill to bar me from the blog.

I don't think she had cause to bar me; I believe she was just bothered that I keep asking the sort of fact-based, evidence-supported questions I asked in this post.

But her repeated threats reached the point where they became harassment.

My hat is off to the many people at the Editor's Blog who are asking tough, informed questions.

I hope they keep it up.

Tuesday, July 11, 2006

The Churchill Series – July 11, 2006

(One of a series of weekday posts on the life of Winston S. Churchill.)

In the late summer of 1929, Churchill, out of office following the Conservative’s defeat in the recent general election, embarked on a three month trip across Canada and down the West coast of the United States. He was accompanied by his brother Jack and their sons, Randolph and Johnnie.

Clementine was supposed to accompany them. But just before the trip, she had a tonsillectomy. Her physician advised her not to make the ocean voyage and trip across Canada. In those days, a tonsillectomy and the recovery period carried more risks than they do today, especially for adults.

Churchill was keenly disappointed Clementine was unable to accompany him. He not only loved her company; he was eager for them to together see Canada and America and meet many of the countries’ most influential and famous citizens.

Faced with that disappointment, Churchill did what he usually did when disappointed: he made the best of the situation. In this case that meant writing Clementine a series of letters in which he described the sights, the people he met and a series of events, planned and unplanned.

The letters are remarkable for their detail, descriptive power, and assessments of many of the famous and not so famous people Churchill met. For example, it was on this trip that Churchill first met William Randolph Hearst, who was so impressed with Churchill that he offered him a contract to write a series of articles for the Hearst papers which Churchill eagerly agreed to do once he heard Hearst’s offering price.

I’m basing the next five Churchill Series posts on the letters he wrote Clementine during the trip. I hope you visit each day. Tomorrow we depart from Southampton aboard the Canadian Pacific steamship Empress of Australia bound first for Cherbourg and then out across the Atlantic

Go West, TIME, go West

Today the editors at Investor’s Business Daily say most of what needs to be said about Time’s cover story calling President Bush’s foreign policy initiatives failures and ridiculing him personally by characterizing him as a little figure who’s covered by a huge cowboy hat that leaves only his boots showing.

IBS begins it takedown of Time :

Has the Bush administration implicitly acknowledged the failure of its simplistic "cowboy diplomacy"? Time magazine thinks so, but don't take a cover story as gospel. […]

Time's editorial theologians build their case predictably: "A grinding and unpopular war in Iraq, a growing insurgency in Afghanistan, an impasse over Iran's nuclear ambitions, brewing war between Israel and the Palestinians — the litany of global crises would test the fortitude of any president."

There's a bit of schadenfreude and much faux sympathy in such journalistic stage-setting. Time's editors long ago abandoned the "American Century" vision of the magazine's founder, Henry Luce, who proposed a U.S. foreign policy that evangelized for democracy and freedom — which, like Bush's, too easily has been belittled by aspiring cosmopolitans as a schoolboy's "cowboy" fantasy.

Here's the mistake of these would-be sophisticates, itself touching in its simplistic misreading of history: They imagine "cowboy" to be a pejorative word, a caricature of a trigger-happy loner.

It's not. The word springs not only from America's best sensibilities but also from its inescapable world position. The U.S. remains the indispensable nation, the font of liberty and democracy.

Where Bush critics see a disastrous "go it alone" approach, wiser heads understand the need to assert leadership. And it is a canard that the administration has forsaken "coalition-building," that touchstone of liberal foreign policy. In Iraq specifically, the U.S. has led a multinational coalition, citing resolutions the United Nations enacted but showed no stomach for enforcing.

If there's an iconic moment in the legend of the West, it's when Gary Cooper, as the marshal in "High Noon," fails to rally the townspeople as they await the arrival of a murderous gang. Only when the lawman acts "unilaterally" do the citizens overcome their cowardice and restore the peace. […]

A long slog does not mean failure, even if journalistic rustlers rush to brand it as such in the administration's rawhide. A rattlesnake may spook a horse, the chuck wagon might bust a spoke, but that doesn't mean the drive can't be completed. […]

Bellicosity from North Korea, which Bush identified as part of an "axis of evil" shortly after 9-11, has persuaded Japan to seek a "cowboy" posture on our model. In 2003, U.N. Ambassador John Bolton, as assistant defense secretary, quietly initiated a 13-nation program to keep missile propellants out of Pyongyang's hands.

The successful covert program also denied Kim Jong-Il revenues from ballistic missile sales and blocked China from selling deadly chemicals to its little communist brother. Time magazine missed that story. You had to go to the Times of London to find it.

Cowboy diplomacy? Let's have more of it.
Time has missed quite a lot in the past too. It was a constant critic of President Reagan’s initiatives to strengthen America’s military and to pressure the old Soviet Union in order to bring down that “evil empire.” Time didn’t like those policies.

Come to think of it, partners, weren’t those Easterners at Time part of that MSM crowd that used to call Reagan a cowboy?

Some things don’t seem to change, do they?

Recommendations for Time:

Hire fewer leftists and liberals.

Stop writing the kind of stuff we expect to come out of the DNC's spin office.

Don'tx ridicule the President as a person. That's nasty.

And get out and spend some time with cowboys. Cowgirls too. The ones I’ve met have been wonderful people.
____________________________________________________
http://www.investors.com/editorial/IBDArticles.asp?artsec=20&issue=20060710&view=1

Monday, July 10, 2006

Talking with JinC regulars - 7-10-06

(One of a series of posts in the original web log tradition: notes and "thinking out loud." These posts will be most easily understood by regular visitors and are But others are welcome. John)

There won't be much talk in this Talking with JinC Regulars post.

I just want to tell you I'm sorry I don't have more posts up on matters of interest to us all.

I'll do better tomorrow when I'll post another Talking.

See you then and thanks for your understanding.

BTW - Did you all see Sunday's Durham Herald Sun story concerning attorney Charns and CrimeStoppers? If not, here's a link.

John
____________________________
Post URL:
http://www.heraldsun.com/durham/4-751031.html

The Churchill Series – July 10, 2006

(One of a series of daily posts on the life of Winston S. Churchill.)

from the time he was a small boy into old age, horses were a part of Churchill’s life. He rode ponies before he was five. He served as a cavalry officer in India and Africa. He jockeyed in steeplechases and participated in the famous cavalry charge at Omdurman. He was a skilled polo player who played into his late fifties. After WWII Churchill developed a small but very successful racing stable. His horses’ successes earned him membership in The Jockey Club.

All that is a fine background to what I think is the most amusing line to come out of the 1945 General Election campaign in which Churchill led the Conservatives. His daughter, Lady Mary Soames, who campaigned with her father during the election, tells us about it:

[The newspaper magnate] Max Beaverbrook was an extraordinary personality, arousing extremes of reaction in people. […]

[His friendship with Churchill] was much disapproved of by “top Tories”: in the 1945 election the tone of the Beaverbrook papers led to the quip the Max “wanted the jockey to win but not the horse.”
One of those who disapproved of Churchill’s friendship with Beaverbrook was Clementine who for years distrusted him. Lady Soames says that near the end of his life Clementine soften her attitude toward Beaverbrook, “succumbing gracefully to Max’s perennial charm and blandishments.”
______________________________________
Speaking for Themselves: The Personal Letters of Winston and Clementine Churchill. (Edited by Mary Soames) (p. 649)

Duke lacrosse: Durham Herald Sun news bias

Update 7-17-06: In the post below I refer to Jeffrey Bloxsom as gay. A reader said he isn't. I checked. Although he has been called gay in some news reports most other news reports I found guote his attorney as saying in and out of court that Bloxsom is not gay. I accept his statements as fact and regret my error. John
______________________________________________


If you still doubt there's media bias directed against the Duke lacrosse players, take a look at what the Durham Herald Sun offered its readers Monday evening, with a big assist from the liberal/leftist Associated Press.

At heraldsun.com there was a story headline and leads for paragraphs in capitals as follows:

Summary Box: Duke lacrosse player labeled 'instigator'

By The Associated Press
Jul 10, 2006 : 9:18 pm ET

DUKE PLAYER CHARGED: Duke lacrosse player Collin Finnerty, also charged with two team members with raping an exotic dancer, started a trial in the District of Columbia on an unrelated assault charge Monday. The trial is expected to conclude Tuesday.

PROSECUTION TESTIMONY: A witness said Finnerty, 19, of Garden City, N.Y., was the instigator who made homophobic comments at Jeffrey Bloxsom during a Nov. 5 fight that left two men with minor injuries.

DEFENSE CASE: Defense lawyers presented a wholly different picture of the incident, saying that Scott Herndon threw the first punch, to the back of Finnerty's head.
Note that the journalists at the AP and in the Herald Sun's newsroom headlined Finnerty as the "instigator" based on the testimony of Jeffrey Bloxsom, a gay who's accused Finnerty of making homophobic remarks. Finnerty and others involved in the incident dispute Bloxsom's allegations. But you wouldn't know that from the headline or what follows, would you?

Is there anyone reading this post who doesn't know that the bias represented in the headline:
Duke lacrosse player labeled 'instigator'
is typical of MSM?

I'm a Durham resident who thinks the Herald Sun's coverage of the Duke lacrosse case has been, in particular instances, superior to that of its much larger and better funded rival, the Raleigh News & Observer. And overall, I think it's been much better.

But now the Herald Sun gives us:
Duke lacrosse player labeled 'instigator'
when it could just as easily have headlined:
Duke lacrosse player disputes charges
or this:
In DC Duke lax case court hears two versions
I'll bet most of you are saying to yourselves: "The problem with the "In DC Duke lax case court hears two versions" healine is it doesn't help those accusing Finnerty. So it has to be discarded."

Well, I won't dispute that.

If you wish to contact the Herald Sun editor his name is Bob Ashley. His email:bashley@heraldsun.com
_______________________________________
Post URL:
http://www.heraldsun.com/state/6-751459.html

Duke lacrosse: Durham DA election update - 7-10-06

Readers’ Note: I live in Durham and support Lewis Cheek for Durham DA.

What you find here above the star line is straight reporting. What’s below the star line is opinion commentary.

John
____________

Confirming what was first reported here Saturday, Durham County Board of Election Director Mike Ashe today announced Durham County Commissioner Lewis Cheek’s name will be on the November ballot as a candidate for District Attorney.

From newsobserver.com:

County Commissioner Lewis Cheek will appear on the November ballot as a challenger to District Attorney Mike Nifong, elections officials say, even if the veteran Democratic politician decides not to run against the embattled prosecutor.
Ashe said Cheek’s name will be on the ballot regardless of whether or not he actively campaigns for the office.

Local TV station WRAL is reporting tonight that a Cheek representative has announced Cheek will hold a news conference tomorrow, Tuesday, at 9:30 a. m. No word on the purpose of the conference but is widely expected here in Durham that Cheek will announce he will actively campaign for the DA’s office.

Other news – In a letter to the editor of the Durham Herald Sun, attorney and Durham Republican leader Steve Monks, who unsuccessfully sought to get his name on the ballot to oppose current DA Mike Nifong, has made it clear he’ll only be a write-in candidate if Cheek doesn’t run. From Monks’ letter:
If [Cheek] doesn't run, I intend to submit myself as write-in candidate. Petition supporters have indicated that they want a choice; and isn't that what elections are about?

**************************************************************************************
Opinion commentary:

It’s a safe call that Cheek will announce tomorrow he’ll actively seek the DA’s office.

Why didn’t he do it today? Many of you know part of the answer: By waiting until tomorrow, Cheek has two days of headlines instead of one.

But I think there’s at least one other reason why Cheek didn’t announce today: He wants to arrange for family, friends and key supporters to be there.

Couldn't Cheek have arranged all that days ago, you may be asking.

Yes, he could have, but Durham’s still a small enough place that “the word” would have started getting around.

Bingo! Nifong’s supporters (there really are such people) would have said: “See, Cheek’s so presumptuous. He's acting like he's already on the ballot. That’s another reason you shouldn't vote for him.”

Better for Cheek to wait a day.

Here’s a pretty safe prediction: Before the race is over, Steve Monks will be actively supporting Cheek; and that’s likely to happen sooner rather than later.

I'll post another Durham DA election update within the next few days.

Duke lacrosse: Questions for a Duke Law prof

Readers' Note: As JinC regulars know, I often post correspondence because doing so can be the best means of letting readers know "what's going on." That's what's I'm doing here. John
______________________________________________

Professor Paul Haagen
Professor of Law
Duke School of Law

Dear Professor Haagen:

I blog as John in Carolina (www.johnincarolina.com) and have posted frequently on aspects of the Duke lacrosse case, including the Raleigh News & Observer’s coverage of it.

I want to ask you about remarks the N&O attributed to you and whether you knew how they would be used.

I’m referring to remarks which appeared at the end of the N&O’s Mar. 25 story,

DANCER GIVES DETAILS OF ORDEAL

A woman hired to dance for the Duke lacrosse team describes a night of racial slurs, growing fear and, finally, sexual violence.
(No qualifying quotation marks were used by the N&O.)
As you may recall, the N&O’s story contains much more than a report of an interview. In its formal structure and its selective use of relevant information, the story resembles a prosecutor’s summation to a jury about to decide a felony case, with the remarks attributed to you placed at the story’s end where, whether you intended them to or not, they suggest to readers why the Duke students might have committed the violent acts of which they are accused in the story.

Please allow me explain what I’ve just said. I want to make clear that my intention here is to provide an opportunity for you to say what you will about the remarks attributed to you before I post further concerning them.

In the Mar. 25 story readers were told authorities had vowed “to crack the team's wall of solidarity.” A DPD police officer was quoted: "We will be relentless in finding out who committed this crime." The N&O said it granted anonymity to “victims of sex crimes.” The N&O failed to inform readers of the lacrosse captains’ extensive cooperation with the police until they and their teammates were advised by counsels to remain silent. None of the defense counsels were quoted. You are the only attorney the N&O quotes.

With all of that in mind, here, in italics, is the part of a post ("Duke lacrosse: Seeking to avoid responsibility," June 19) I wrote which includes the remarks attributed to you as well as the questions they raised in my mind.
_____________________

The N&O ended its Mar. 25 story with this:

[Duke’s Paul] Haagen, a law professor who specializes in sports law, said studies show that violence against women is more prevalent among male athletes than among male students in general -- and higher still among such "helmet sports" as football, hockey and lacrosse.

"These are sports of violence," he said. "This is clearly a concern."

Prosecutors try to end their jury summations with something that helps the jurors understand why the accused would have committed the crime or crimes. They call it “the clincher.”

I don’t know if N&O reporters and editors have a name for their placement of Haagen’s remarks at the end of an interview in which the accuser “told her story.” (Well, one of them.)

I also don’t know whether Professor Haagen was told his remarks would be part of the accuser interview story or how they would be used. I plan to email him and ask. I’ll let you know what I hear back.

____________________

I hope you can see why I'd ask those questions as a matter of fairness to you.

Below my sign off are URLs for the N&O's Mar. 25 story and my June 19 post.

I look forward to your reply which I’ll post referencing this post and the June 19 post.

Sincerely,

John
www.johnincarolina.com
____________________________________________

URLs:
http://www.newsobserver.com/102/story/421799.html

http://johninnorthcarolina.blogspot.com/2006/06/duke-lacrosse-seeking-to-avoid.html

Sunday, July 09, 2006

Duke lacrosse: Police investigation questions (Post No. 1)

(One of a series of posts asking the Durham Police Department questions concerning its investigation of an alleged gang-rape, sodomy, strangulation and kidnapping at a house at 610 N. Buchanan Blvd. on the night of March 13/14.)

In connection with the investigation into the alleged crimes, the DPD has said the three students who leased the N. Buchanan house, all Duke University students and captains of its Men’s lacrosse team, initially cooperated with them.

DPD has said the three students provided its investigating police officers statements concerning the alleged crimes, assisted with a police search for evidence in the house, voluntarily went to Duke Hospital and provided DNA samples, and offered to take lie detector tests.

Question 1: Did DPD read the students their Miranda rights before the three students gave statements, helped with the search of their home, voluntarily submitted to DNA testing and offered to take polygraph tests?

JinC readers: Do you know if this question has been answered? If yes, by whom and where can I verify the answer?

Tomorrow I plan to contact DPD to find out what the department has to say about the question.

I’ll keep you informed.

Duke lacrosse: Durham DA election update –7-9-06

Readers’ Note: I live in Durham and support Lewis Cheek for Durham DA.

What you find here above the star line is straight reporting. What’s below the star line is opinion commentary.

John
_______________________

In an interview Friday, July 7, at 5 p.m. Durham County Board of Elections Director Mike Ashe said “sometime Monday afternoon [July 10], I expect to call the [DA] candidates and the media to let them know Lewis Cheek’s name will be on the ballot in November."

Ashe said that as of Friday afternoon the election board had reviewed "close to 5,500 signatures" and had validated “about 94% of them.” “That’s an unusually high validation rate," he added. "The few hundred signatures we couldn’t validate had the wrong address or the people weren’t registered.”

Ashe also confirmed that Cheek’s supporters had turned in “about 9,800” signatures as was first reported when the petition collection period ended at noon Friday, June 30. The heraldsun.com’s July 6 report that Cheek’s supporters had turned in “some 7,000 signatures” was an error.

Cheek needs 6,303 signitures to qualify for the ballot. Ashe said the election board would validate a "few hundred more" than the required number and then stop counting.

**************************************************************************
Opinion commentary:

Ashe is a very competent and direct person. You can "take to the bank" what he said.

In my last DA election post, I said Lewis Cheek is a fine candidate in his own right, but that certainly many people who signed his petitions did so because of Mike Nifong.

Nifong’s unconscionable behavior in the Duke lacrosse case has outraged many, including some who were his former supporters (more about them in a future post). People are asking: “If that’s what he does when the public eye is on him, what must he be like when people aren’t paying attention?” He’s got people stirred up and with good cause.

Nifong, the energizer.

How about that 94% signature validation rate? Does it tell us anything?

Yes, at least two important things: 1) The people who organized Cheek’s petition drive knew what needed to be done and did it very well under a tough deadline; and 2) Cheek's petition drive organizers provide him with a solid core of experienced and able people to help lead the many volunteers like myself who'll be "helping out" in the Fall campaign.

A candidate's petition drive is something like a team’s preseason exhibition games: you get an idea of what kind of team you’ll have when the season starts.

Cheek’s "team" had a very good "preseason."

I’ll try to post on the election again Monday night.

Addendum: Many of you now visiting JinC are Duke people scattered across the country and world. With you in mind, I want to pass on some sad news those of us here in Durham have just heard.

Mr. John McDonald, the 9th Street pharmacist, “milk shake maker,” and outstanding community citizen whose kindness generations of you will remember, passed away Friday at age eighty-five after years of declining health.

The Durham Herald Sun reported his death in a news story Saturday. Mr. McDonald’s obituary from the H-S is here.

I'll remember him as a skilled pharmacist and a kind, generous and wise man. RIP
___________________________________________________
Post URLs:

http://www.heraldsun.com/durham/4-750599.html

http://www.heraldsun.com//durham/4-750835.html

http://www.heraldsun.com/obituaries/#29946

Saturday, July 08, 2006

MSM and the public's view of the economy

Let's do a little one, two, three.

One is the Gallup Organization's latest report on the public's view of the current state of America's economy. Two is some information about the economy. Three looks at influences on the public's view of the current economy.

One: For decades Gallup has asked Americans:

How would you rate economic conditions in this country today -- as excellent, good, only fair, or poor?
Gallup then reports what it calls a Current Economic Situation Index. It obtains the index by adding the number of respondents rating the economy "excellent" or "good" and then subtracting from the excellent/good total the number of respondents rating the economy "poor." The difference is then converted to a precentage which is the index.

For 2000, the last year of the Clinton administration, the index averaged 64%. By 2002 the index had dropped to 10%.

The drop is understandable given that by 2002 the stock market bubble had burst, 9/11 had impacted the economy and the country was just begining to recover from a recession which, although short and shallow by historical standards, the Democratic dominated MSM had described in terms appropriate for the Great Depression.

But since 2002 the country has experienced strong, sustained economic growth. Shouldn't many more Americans be telling Gallup the economy is "excellent" or "good?"

Yes, but it isn't happening.

Gallup's Current Economic Index for 2005 was only 13%, a very slight increase from the 10% reported in 2002; and nowhere near the 64% reported in 2000. In early June Gallup reported the index stood at only 18%.

Now Two: Some information economist Lawrance Kudlow provides today in his Townhall.com column:
Did you know that just over the past 11 quarters, dating back to the June 2003 Bush tax cuts, America has increased the size of its entire economy by 20 percent?

In less than three years, the U.S. economic pie has expanded by $2.2 trillion, an output add-on that is roughly the same size as the total Chinese economy, and much larger than the total economic size of nations like India, Mexico, Ireland and Belgium. (bold added) […]

Since the 2003 tax cuts, tax-revenue collections from the expanding economy have been surging at double-digit rates, while the deficit is constantly being revised downward.

For those who bother to look, the economic power of lower-tax-rate incentives is once again working its magic. While most reporters obsess about a mild slowdown in housing, the big-bang story is a high-sizzle pick-up in private business investment, which is directly traceable to Bush's tax reform. It was private investment that was hardest hit in the early decade stock market plunge and the aftermath of the 9-11 terrorist bombings.

So team Bush's wise men correctly targeted investment in order to slash the after-tax cost of capital and rejuvenate investment incentives.

The move paid off. Investors now keep nearly 50 percent more of their after-tax capital returns -- an enormous increase that has resulted in a remarkably profitable and highly productive business sector. While the overall economy has grown by one-fifth since mid-2003, private business investment has expanded by 37 percent. […]

Wages are rising today, so we know domestic labor markets must be tightening, not softening. To wit, average hourly compensation has risen to 3.9 percent over the past year, while average weekly earnings have grown to 4.5 percent. In early 2004, these wage measures were only up 1.5 percent.
Now Three: With all that economic growth, why isn't Gallup economic index much higher than it is?

Kudlow supplies what I think is a big part of the answer:
Most in the mainstream media would rather tout the faults of American capitalism than sing its praises. And of course, the media will almost always discuss supply-side tax cuts in negative terms, such as big budget deficits and static revenue losses.[...]

[And MSM keeps as a]dirty little secret[the fact]that record low tax rates on capital are leading to continued job and income gains, as businesses continue to expand.[...]
Left leaning media organizations, whether in America or elsewhere, are going to have difficulty reporting on the success of the American economy because such success is a refutation of fundamental leftist beliefs.

But there's another reason why most MSM are having trouble reporting fairly and fully on our economic success: they're afraid President Bush will get much of the credit for the economy's success. So they keep the good news secret.

And that $2.2 trillion add-on to the U.S. economy in the last three years. That's another secret the leftist, Democratic dominated media has kept from us.

Requests to the New York Times and its media kind:

1) Start disclosing wonderful economic news.

2) Stop disclosing national security secrets.
__________________________________________________
Post URLs:

http://poll.gallup.com/content/default.aspx?ci=1609&VERSION=p

http://www.townhall.com/columnists/column.aspx?Url
Title=the_big-bang_story_of_us_private_business&ns=LawrenceKudlow&dt=07/08/2006
&page=full&comments=true

Friday, July 07, 2006

The Churchill Series – July 7, 2006

(One of a series of weekday posts on the life of Winston S. Churchill.)

Regular readers of this series know we’ve often smiled and laughed. Sometimes it’s been because of something Churchill said or did; sometimes it’s been something someone said about him. Recall Clementine Churchill’s explanation for why Churchill often left for the train station at the last minute and had to race to catch the train: “Winston’s a sporting man. He likes to give the train a chance.”

Today we won’t smile. We’ll see Churchill at age eighty attend the funeral of his closest friend, and then walk to his friend’s graveside for the final rites. Sad moments and joyous ones are part of a full life.

From Martin Gilbert :

The passage of Churchill’s remaining years was inevitably marked by the sadness of the death of close friends. In July 1957, his closest friend and confidant, Lord Cherwell, died; he was seventy-one years old, the same age as Clementine. Before the war it was with “Prof” that he had examined the weaknesses and inventions of Britain’s Defense policy. It was to him that Churchill had entrusted the secrets of Britain’s nuclear policy during both his wartime and peacetime Premierships.

[Churchill] went to Oxford for Cherwell’s funeral. “As he came up the aisle of Christ Church Cathedral,” one of the mourners later recalled, “the congregation rose spontaneously to their feet. After the service he drove to the cemetery. He walked in procession up the cemetery path. He walked beyond the path, advancing over the difficult tufts of grass, with unfaltering but ageing steps, onward to the graveside of his dear old friend.”
Later that year Churchill completed the fourth and final volume of his war memoirs. He died on January 24, 1965, following a massive stroke two weeks earlier.
_______________________________________
Martin Gilbert, Churchill: A Life. (pgs. 961-952)

Duke lacrosse: Questions for the Raleigh News & Observer

At Raleigh News & Observer’s Editor Blog readers have been expressing outrage at the N&O’s Duke lacrosse reporting which has helped make a terrible situation worse, including more dangerous. They're also asking N&O executive editor for news Melanie Sill some tough questions and pointing out important aspects of the story the N&O has chosen to ignore.

Here are examples of what readers are saying:

I have to read posters comments to find out that the False Accuser's boyfriend is in Jail, along with her Ex-husband, and her good friend. Murchison's Kin is now in Jail?
_______________

Nifong is a Democrat and a Media Darling and it seems the Media has absolutely no interest in uncovering this story.
_______________

Whose names are on the cell phone of the accuser? Could it be names of political, law enforcement or judicial personnel
______________

Here is a big Hint! Michael Cornacchiais, he is one of Finnerty attorney's and is a specialist in private & government corruption investigations. He was the chief investigative counsel under Paul Volcker for the investigation of the UN Oil-for Food Scandal and a former US Eastern asst District Prosecutor. You see him with Kevin Finnerty on many occasions, both in DC & Durham.
________________

After a week of silence Sill responded to readers today with a few PR type comments. Here’s part of her latest comment made 7/7 at 13: 27

I truly appreciate all of the comments, but I will be posting next week on new topics and unless we report a story that prompts another post on the case I will not be responding further to comments in this thread. Many of your questions are good ones to pose to key players in the case -- we'll report all that we know (according to our standards of verification and sourcing).(bold mine)
It’s a shame Sill won’t respond to many important questions. There’s so much readers want to know that she hasn’t told us

Why, for instance, did the N&O on Apr. 2 publish the “vigilante poster” knowing that doing so would only make things more dangerous for the players?

What was the purpose of publishing it anyway? The story it accompanies doesn’t even mention the “vigilante poster.”

You can read at the bottom of the poster photo that only 43 players are pictured on it because Duke removed from a website the photos of the other players.

That’s true enough. Duke pulled the other players’ photos because of concerns for their safety.

But for some reason the N&O decided not to tell that to readers. Why?

Sill talks about “our standards of verification and sourcing.”

What individual(s) or organization(s) was the source of the “vigilante poster?” What verification did the N&O do?

I’ve asked four people at the N&O those questions about sourcing and verification. No one has given me any answer other “You’ll have to ask someone else,” “I can’t tell you who worked on the story,” and N&O public editor Ted Vaden's response in a phone conversation: “I’m just not going to answer those questions. I’ve got to go now.”

I hope you visit the Editor’s Blog, read what Sill and readers have posted, and perhaps leave your own questions and comments.

Sill has said often that’s she’s “proud” of the N&O’s Duke lacrosse reporting.

Here’s a question we should all be asking her: “What’s to be proud of?”

Terrorism: London, New York and elsewhere

Today is the first anniversary of the London transportation bombings.

And this just crossed the Associated Press wire:

FBI disrupts New York transportation plot
The story begins:
Authorities have disrupted planning by foreign terrorists who wanted to attack the New York City-area transportation system, the federal government announced Friday.

The planning appeared to be in the early stages, and the tunnels and other transportation routes weren't believed to have ever been at serious risk.

"We have disrupted a terrorist network that was in the planning stages of an attack," the FBI and Department of Homeland Security said in a statement. […]
A few thoughts:

London and New York: “We’re all in it together.”

Madrid, Bali, Baghdad, Miami, Toronto, Amman, Paris and many other places: “We’re all in it together.”

So how about less talk from MSM, Democrats, and other Bush-bashers about “Bush’s so called war on terror.”

Surely even Bill Keller and Pinch Sulzberger, for all their partisanship and arrogance, must now realize it’s Civilization’s war against terror.

President Bush recognized that on 9/11 as did most Americans. It's time Keller, Sulzberger and those like them did too.

Keller, Sulzberger and so many in MSM and the Democratic Party need to stop enabling terrorists and help the rest of us win the war on terrorism.

Extremist Muslim ideology fuels the terrorism. The best people to counter the ideology are moderate Muslims.

Here in the states the Council on American-Islamic Relations could do a lot more to express its rejection of extremist ideology.

CAIR could do a lot more to promote the growth of toleration in the Muslim world by, for example, pressing the Saudi government to permit the open worship of other religions in that country.

I'd also like to see CAIR openly, loudly and repeatedly condemn the virulent anti-Semitism that’s a hallmark of much of the press in Muslim countries.
________________________________________
Post URLs:

http://news.yahoo.com/s/ap/20060707/ap_on_re_us/new_york_tunnels_plot_14;
_ylt=Arkk1zjm661kJExNXicy2oITv5UB;_ylu=X3oDMTBiMW04NW9mBHNlYwMlJVRPUCUl

http://www.cair-net.org/

Talking with JinC Regulars – July 7, 2006

(One of a series of posts in the original web log tradition: notes and "thinking out loud." These posts will be most easily understood by regular visitors and are But others are welcome. John)

I deleted a comment from one of you. It was a personal attack.

They’re not allowed, even by someone for whom I have respect and fond feelings.

Another comment matter - - -

Someone who’s recently begun commenting at JinC said Duke’s Professor of Cultural Anthropology Orin Starn was a signer of the faculty Group of 88’s “listening statement.”

It turns out Starn didn’t sign the very talky “listening statement.” He asked for a correction. Our new commenter made an apology ASAP. It was full and generous.

JinC reaction:

The new commenter showed class. I hope the person continues to comment here.

Message to Starn:

What about the apology you owe Coach K?

Also, do you remember the day Reade Seligman had to walk to the Durham County courthouse past racist hate-mongers shouting,” Justice will be done, Rapist"

And surely you remember that when Reade entered the courtroom, there were shouts that included "Dead man walking!"

Did you speak out in any way that day on behalf of Reade, his family and those who abhor racist hate groups and their enablers?

Did you speak out the way you spoke out today for yourself?

The answers to those questions tell, don’t they?

New item:

Think of the old ad: “Run, don’t walk to our auto showroom.”

Yes, it’s a hustle.

But folks, believe me, if you haven’t been to McClatchy’s Editor’s Blog in the last day or two you need to run, not walk there.

Readers are teeing off with fact-based questions about the Duke lacrosse case and Raleigh N&O exec editor Melanie Sill has been unable to fob off the readers.

Here's the kind of thing readers are getting at: The judge in the case has not asked his protégé, DA Mike Nifong, to turn over records of the accuser’s cell phone. That’s troubling on many counts, not least because while Sill and the rest of the N&O’s “news team” tell us the “victim of sex crimes” is a “dancer,” “mother,” “honor student,” etc; it turns out her cell phone records (or perhaps Kim's. I don't think is entirely certain who owned the cell) may contain records of calls to – you know -- “dance partners” and “ prominent citizens from the fields of law, politics and journalism.”

See what’s happening at the Editor’s Blog. It’s extraordinary. I hope you comment there. If you do, please link or “heads up” here.

Later today I’ll post a few of the questions I’d be asking Sill if she hadn’t repeatedly threatened to ban me from McClatchy’s blog.

Meanwhile, it looks like intelligent readers are doing just fine at the Editor’s Blog.

I’ll post the next Talking with JinC Regulars post this weekend.

Thursday, July 06, 2006

The Churchill Series – July 6, 2006

(One of a series of weekday posts about the life of Winston S. Churchill.)

When someone mentions the Churchill- Roosevelt relationship we assume the person is referring to the two great Allied war leaders. But in today’s post, when we talk about Churchill and Roosevelt, we’ll be talking about Winston and Eleanor. Did you know they had a little spat at a London dinner in October, 1942?

Mrs. Roosevelt was in England for a goodwill visit. She made the usual visits to factories and training facilities and met the people who needed to be met. The trip was a great success except for the little spat. Jon Meacham, author of Winston and Franklin: An Intimate Portrait of an Epic Friendship, tells us about it:

At a small diner in London, Eleanor and Churchill exchanged words over Loyalist Spain. “I remarked that I could not see why the Loyalist government could not have been helped, and the prime minister replied that he and I would have been the first to lose our heads if the Loyalists had won – the feeling against people like us would have spread,” Mrs. Roosevelt recalled.

[She continued]: “I said that losing my head was unimportant, whereupon he said: ‘I don’t want you to lose your head and neither do I want to lose mine.’

Then Mrs. Churchill leaned across the table and said: ‘I think perhaps Mrs. Roosevelt is right.’

The prime minister was quite annoyed by this time and said: ‘I have held certain beliefs for sixty years and I’m not going to change now’” (p. 200)
Meacham goes on to say Eleanor Roosevelt’s friends thought Churchill “hopeless.”

Eleanor Roosevelt and Winston Churchill’s relationship was one of mutual respect but no great affection. Many factors explain that. For one thing, Churchill had a wonderful sense of humor which bubbled even in the worst of times. Eleanor was almost humorless. In my experience, a humorless person always finds someone like Churchill a strain.

Also, Eleanor disapproved of Churchill’s enjoyment of alcohol. Her father and brother were both alcoholics whose lives were cut short by their drinking.

Duke lacrosse: Prof who misrepresented Coach K responds

Reader’s Note:

Welcome visitors from Court TV, Duke Basketball Report, Friends of Duke University, Free Republic, History News Network, and Johnsville. If I’ve missed some blogs linking, please let me know.

If you’re not familiar with Duke professor of cultural anthropology Orin Starn’s misrepresentation of remarks by Duke’s Men’s basketball coach Mike Krzyzewski go here for background.

John
____________________________________________

This post contains: 1) a copy of the email I sent Starn yesterday, July 5; 2) a copy of Starn’s reply which I received yesterday afternoon; and 3) my response to Starn’s email.

Item 1) my email to Starn - - -

Dear Professor Starn:

I blog as John in Carolina and read your Raleigh N&O op-ed, “Let’s Talk Sports.” I’ve just posted a response, "Duke lacrosse: "Prof misrepresents Coach K."

Surely we can agree that at his recent press conference Coach K said: “The racial aspect of this, in some ways, has been the most sensitive thing and some people have tried to create something that isn’t there in our community.”

Could Coach K have been any clearer when he said the “racial aspect of [the Duke lacrosse case is], in some ways, its most sensitive aspect?”

And after reading Houston Baker’s letter, listening to the rants of some Duke faculty and the New Black Panthers, and watching DA Nifong at work, who doubts that some people have exploited a terrible situation by creating “something that isn’t there?”

Yet you told N&O readers: “It's hard to understand how Coach K or anyone else could not see a ‘racial aspect’ here.”

Frankly, Professor Starn, it’s hard to understand how you could have misrepresented what Coach K actually said, even allowing for your bias toward him.

Whatever the explanation, you owe Coach K an apology and N&O readers a correction.

In the coming days I’ll be posting on other parts of your op-ed.

In the meantime, why do you single Mike Nifong out for resignation? He had so many enablers. Shouldn’t they be held to account?

Sincerely,

John
www.johnincarolina.com
_______________________________________________

Item 2) Starn’s email to me - - -

Hi, John:

I really disagree about this. Coach K was saying that the "racial aspect" of the case was brought in by people (I guess the media, professors, or others, although I'm not sure who he meant) trying to "create something that isn't there." That he says he thinks it's now a "sensitive thing" (as, of course, it is) does not take away from the fact that he was saying it was made up from nothing in the first place. In fact, he went on directly afterwards to talk about Durham's "excellent" race relations, as if to underline his assertion that race was not a factor in the case. I don't know if Coack K saw that statement, but it reminded me of when Joe Cheshire said at the courthouse press conference words to the effect that race was absolutely no factor in the case. The charges of sexual assault may indeed not be true as I said in the article (although we are now only getting the defense version), a sadly terrible false accusation if it is so. But for Coach K, Cheshire, or anyone to say there is no race element in the case is just wrong, at least if the reports of what was said at the party are true (and I suspect the defense would have denied them by now if they were not, although I could be wrong). For me, this is more than a matter of just back-and-forth argument about the case. If students at an all-white Duke party are using racial epithets as it appears, it suggests that we need to do more work around race relations, as opposed to assume that things are fixed already.

As to judging who has acted badly in this case and who is not, I want for my part to hear the defense case -- and the testimony of the woman making the charges -- before making up my mind. I do think, if the charges prove false, that Nifong bears a central responsibility. He is our chief law enforcement officer -- and he told us all in no uncertain times and in many forums that the lacrosse guys were guilty. Although there may be lessons to be learned all around, it does seem to me that his role, especially if he knew otherwise, is probably the single most problematic one. Contrary to what some have suggested, neither Houston Baker nor the AAS faculty in that add said that the lacrosse players were guilty (and, in fact, both mentioned that we'd have to see what happened) -- and in that sense were more cautious than Nifong.

all the best, Orin
______________________________________________________

Item 3) My response to Starn’s email to me - - -

Dear Professor Starn:

Thank you for your response yesterday to my email. I hope by now you’ve also read the JinC post, whose URL I included in my email.

Coach K said:

“The racial aspect of this, in some ways, has been the most sensitive thing and some people have tried to create something that isn’t there in our community.”
You presented to N&O readers the following as representing what Coach K had said:
“Those who see a ‘racial aspect’ to the lacrosse case have ‘tried to create something that isn't there.’”
Let’s look at what you had to do with Coach K’s statement in order to create what you presented to N&O readers.

First, you took Coach K's unambiguous acknowledgement of "The racial aspect of this" and substituted in its place something entirely different: "Those who see a 'racial aspect.'" (bolds mine)

Next, you withheld from readers the fact that Coach K had said the racial aspect was, in some respects, the case's "most sensitive" aspect. (bold mine)

Only by eliminating Coach K’s unambiguous acknowledgement of “The racial aspect;” substituting for his words your words that made it appear he was saying some people were merely perceiving a racial aspect (“Those who see…”); and withholding from readers the information that the coach had said the racial aspect was in some ways the case’s “most sensitive” aspect were you then able to present to N&O readers as what Coach K had said: “Those who see a ‘racial aspect’ to the lacrosse case have ‘tried to create something that isn't there.’”

You misrepresented what Coach K said and it’s very hard, Professor Starn, to see how your misrepresentation could be anything other than deliberate.

After misrepresenting Coach K, you went on and falsely accused him of “not see[ing] a ‘racial aspect’ here.”

You owe the coach an apology and N&O readers a correction.

Is your treatment of Coach K’s statement typical of how you treat raw data when you prepare lectures, articles and books? Is what you did accepted practice for Duke faculty? If you can't speak for the broader faculty, than is what you did accepted practice in the Department of Cultural Anthropology?

You know those are important questions. I hope you'll answer them. I also plan to ask them of others.

I’ve said what I feel needs to be said at this time about your misrepresentation and false accusation.

If you care to respond, I’ll find a way to post your email but other than referring readers back to what I say here and my posts yesterday and today, I don’t see any need to get into extended and tangential discussions.

I raised a clearly defined, important matter and called it to you attention and the attention of readers.

What I’ve said and what you published in the N&O and your response(s) here will be in the blogosphere, and available for anyone to look at and make whatever judgments they care to make.

Here’s a link to today’s post:
http://johninnorthcarolina.blogspot.com/2006/07/
duke-lacrosse-prof-who-misrepresented.html

During the next few weeks, I’ll be posting on others parts of your N&O op-ed, your email of yesterday, and your writings about Duke, particularly those relating to the lacrosse case.

I’ll send you links and will share with readers any responses you care to make.

Sincerely,

John
www.johnincarolina.com
_____________________________________________________

http://johninnorthcarolina.blogspot.com/2006/07/duke-lacrosse-prof-misrepresents-coach.html

http://www.goduke.com/ViewArticle.dbml?DB_OEM_ID=4200&ATCLID=299360

http://www.newsobserver.com/691/story/456646.html

http://hnn.us/blogs/entries/27726.html

Wednesday, July 05, 2006

The Churchill Series – July 5, 2006

(One of a series of posts on the life of Winston S. Churchill.)

In 1876 Lord Randolph Churchill was appointed Private Secretary to the Lord Lieutenant of Ireland, his father. Two year old Winston Churchill accompanied his parents to Dublin where the Churchills would live for the next for years. Young Churchill’s nurse, Mrs. Elizabeth Ann Everest, accompanied him to Ireland. We learn, courtesy of the Churchill Centre, a few things about Winnie, as family members often called him, from a letter of his mother's and his granddaughter's commentary.

A letter from his mother described life in Dublin with her young son: "Winston is flourishing tho rather X the last 2 days more teeth I think. Everest has been bothering me about some clothes for him saying that it was quite a disgrace how few things he had & how shabby at that."

Churchill's granddaughter, Celia Sandys, offers this portrait: "Winston had arrived in Dublin a month after his second birthday dressed, as was the fashion, like a girl. At that time children were dressed alike, making boys and girls indistinguishable one from the other, for the first few years of their lives."
Randolph and Jennie Churchill were neglectful parents; and their neglect of a son who loved them constituted more than harshness. It amounted to a cruelty.

I often wonder how Churchill would have turned our if Mrs. Everest hadn't been there from right after his birth until he was a young man. She was to him and his younger brother John (Jack) everything a loving parent should be.

Everest never married. The Mrs. before her name reflects the custom at the time to call nurses Mrs. even if they were unmarried.

Also, you may have seen her middle name spelled “Anne.” That’s how it’s usually spelled. But the Churchill Archives at Churchill College, Cambridge University give it as “Ann” so that’s what I use.

Duke lacrosse: Prof misrepresents Coach K

At a recent press conference Duke Men’s basketball coach Mike Krzyzewski spoke about the racial aspect of the Duke lacrosse case: “The racial aspect of this, in some ways, has been the most sensitive thing and some people have tried to create something that isn’t there in our community.”

Reasonable people will agree with Coach K that the race aspect of the case, if not its most sensitive aspect, is certainly one of them. And after reading Professor Houston Baker’s letter, listening to the rants of some Duke faculty and the New Black Panthers, and watching DA Nifong in action, who doubts that some people have exploited a terrible situation by “creating something that isn’t there?”

With Coach K’s remarks in mind, let’s look at what Duke professor of cultural anthropology Orin Starn did with them in an Apr. 2 Raleigh News & Observer op-ed, "Let talk Sports."

Starn told readers we have “learned from the men’s basketball coach :”

Those who see a "racial aspect" to the lacrosse case have "tried to create something that isn't there."
After sharing some of his take on the racial aspect of the case, Starn told readers:
It's hard to understand how Coach K or anyone else could not see a ‘racial aspect’ here.
What Starn told readers Coach K said is the opposite of what the coach actually said.

No one reading Starn’s op-ed could miss his biases toward Coach K. They reek throughout it. But even allowing for them, how could Starn have gotten such a simple but important matter so wrong?

I’m sending Starn the following email which includes a link to this post. I’ll let you know if he responds. I’m also sending the N&O an email letter to the editor, a copy of which follows my email to Starn.

I’ll soon post on other parts of Starn’s op-ed that disturbed me as much or more than his misrepresentation of Coach K's statement.

Also, I hope you take a look at historian and Brooklyn College Professor KC Johnson's lucid and detailed response to Starn. Johnson's post is titled "Shameless."
_____________________________________________

Dear Professor Starn:

I blog as John in Carolina and read your Raleigh N&O op-ed, “Let’s Talk Sports.” I’ve just posted a response. Here's the URL:

http://johninnorthcarolina.blogspot.com/2006/07/
duke-lacrosse-prof-misrepresents-coach.html

Surely we can agree that at his recent press conference Coach K said: “The racial aspect of this, in some ways, has been the most sensitive thing and some people have tried to create something that isn’t there in our community.”

Could Coach K have been any clearer when he said the “racial aspect of [the Duke lacrosse case is], in some ways, its most sensitive aspect?”

And after reading Houston Baker’s letter, listening to the rants of some Duke faculty and the New Black Panthers, and watching DA Nifong at work, who doubts that some people have exploited a terrible situation by creating “something that isn’t there?”

Yet you told N&O readers: “It's hard to understand how Coach K or anyone else could not see a ‘racial aspect’ here.”

Frankly, Professor Starn, it’s hard to understand how you could have misrepresented what Coach K actually said, even allowing for your bias toward him.

Whatever the explanation, you owe Coach K an apology and N&O readers a correction.

In the coming days I’ll be posting on other parts of your op-ed.

In the meantime, why do you single Mike Nifong out for resignation? He had so many enablers. Shouldn’t they be held to account?

Sincerely,

John
www.johnincarolina.com
_______________________________________________

To the editor

At a June 20 press conference Duke University’s Men’s basketball coach Mike Krzyzewski said this about the Duke lacrosse case: “The racial aspect of this, in some ways, has been the most sensitive thing and some people have tried to create something that isn’t there in our community” The coach couldn't have been clearer about there being a racial aspect to the case, could he?

So why does Duke professor of cultural anthropology Orin Starn (“Let’s talk sports,” July 2 Op-ed page) use selective quotes from Coach K’s statement to create and pass on to N&O readers the following misrepresentation of what the coach actually said: "Those who see a 'racial aspect' to the lacrosse case have 'tried to create something that isn't there?’'' And why does Starn compound his misrepresentation by saying: “It's hard to understand how Coach K or anyone else could not see a ‘racial aspect’ here?”

What fair-minded readers will find hard to understand is why Professor Starn misrepresented what Coach K said. Starn owes the coach an apology.

For his part, Coach K might use Starn’s misrepresentation the next time he’s talking about people trying to “create something that isn’t there.”

Sincerely,
____________________________________________________

http://www.goduke.com/ViewArticle.dbml?DB_OEM_ID=4200&ATCLID=299360

http://www.newsobserver.com/691/story/456646.html

http://hnn.us/blogs/entries/27726.html

Tuesday, July 04, 2006

The Churchill Series – July 4, 2006

(One of a series of weekday posts on the life of Winston S. Churchill.)

Churchill’s family ties to America were many. His biographer, Martin Gilbert, tells us something about them:

In 1963, in a message sent when he was eighty-three years old, Churchill remarked with pride to President John F. Kennedy that the story of his association with the United States went back nearly ninety years “to the day of my father’s marriage.”

That marriage took place in Paris on 15 April 1874. The bridegroom, Lord Randolph Spencer Chruchill, was the son of a British duke. The bride, Jennie Jerome, was the daughter of an American millionaire – although at that precise moment Leonard Jerome’s fortune has taken a temporary dip. […]

The first member of [Jennie’s] family to settle in America was an Englishman, Timothy Jerome, who reached America from the Isle of Wight in 1710, a descendant of Huguenot Protestants who had fled France for Britain three generations earlier.

One of Winston Churchill’s great-great-grandfathers, Lieutenant Reuban Murray, had served during the American Revolutionary War in the 17th Connecticut Regiment and the 7th Connecticut Regiment and the 7th Albany Regiment, New York Militia. […]

Leonard Jerome and his brother Lawrence married two sisters. Lawrence Jerome’s son, William Travers Jerome – Churchill’s second cousin – was to become a reforming District Attorney of New York who refused to bow to the dictates of Tammany Hall, with its strong political control. In 1906 he sought to be nominated as Governor of New York, but was unsuccessful.

The biographer of Churchill’s mother, Ralph G. Martin, speculates that if Travers Jerome had won the nomination and the governorship in 1906, “he might well have been nominated by the Democrats for President in 1912 instead of Woodrow Wilson.” […]

In 1865, from the window of their house on East Twenty-sixth Street, Jennie and her two sisters watched as the horse-drawn coffin of the assassinated President Abraham Lincoln passed in solemn procession on the street below.
All three of Leonard Jerome’s daughters married Englishmen.

I think Churchill had it right when, in his December 26, 1941 address to a Joint Session of Congress, he said:
By the way, I cannot help reflecting that if my father had been American and my mother British instead of the other way around, I might have got here on my own. (laughter)

In that case this would not have been the first time you would have heard my voice.(laughter)In that case I should not have needed any invitation. But if I had it is hardly likely that it would have been unanimous. (laughter) So perhaps things are better as they are.
I’m late with this post. I hope you all had a good Fourth.
_________________________________________________
Martin Gilbert, Churchill and America. (pgs. 1-4) Churchill's address to Congress can be found here.

Pundit asks: "Is patriotism obsolete?"

Like most of you who visit and comment at JinC, columnist and scholar Thosmas Sowell loves America; and he's worried about the decline in patriotism. Sowell calls patriotism the "glue" that holds America together. This from his July 3 column:

On the eve of a holiday that used to stir patriotic emotions -- the Fourth of July -- it has been painful to see examples of how little remains of that glue that holds a society together.

Perhaps the worst of these signs of national disintegration was the New York Times' recent revealing to the whole world the covert methods by which the American government has been tracking the money that finances international terrorism.

The usual excuses about "the public's right to know" ring even more hollow than usual in this case. The public was not dying to know the methods by which their lives were being safeguarded. Only the terrorists were helped by these revelations.

Americans may in fact be dying literally now because of what the terrorists have been told -- and ultimately because a jerk inherited the New York Times. As usual, the mainstream media circled the wagons around one of their own.
Folks, to help our country - to do something for the men and women defending us - please call, write or email you local editor ASAP.

Tell him or her what you think about the Times handing out national security secrets to terrorists with a "we know best and the safety of our service men and women be damned" attitude.

If you get stuck for words, just tell the editor you sending along a copy of Sowell's column.

Let's stay at it. We need to turn things around.
____________________________________________
Post URL:
http://jewishworldreview.com/cols/sowell070306.asp

Ye Olde Times exposed

Scott Johnson at Powerline discloses what the New York Times was doing in 1775.

Some organizations never change.

Hat Tip: Michelle Malkin

A great post on patriotism

Betsy Newmark has a great July Fourth post on patriotism. She begins with a link to a Lorie Byrd post, "Some thoughts on patriotism," in which Lorie discusses the problems many Libs have with patriotism. Betsy summarizes Lorie’s post along the way providing this dumber than dirt quote from Dixie Chick Natalie Maines:

"The entire country may disagree with me, but I don't understand the necessity for patriotism," Maines resumes, through gritted teeth. "Why do you have to be a patriot? About what? This land is our land? Why? You can like where you live and like your life, but as for loving the whole country… I don't see why people care about patriotism."
Of course, the whole country doesn’t disagree with Maines. To find that out all she needs to do is spend a little time in some MSM news rooms, go to a few “speak-outs” on college campuses or just listen a little more the next time she’s at a Hollywood Gala for Hillary Clinton or John Kerry.

There’s a lot more in Betsy’s post including a graph comparing Ds, Rs and Is agree/disagree responses from 1987 through 2003 to the statement: “I am very patriotic.”

My favorite part of the post comes at the end. Betsy’s commentary is in italics; the portion of Lincoln’s speech she quotes is indented. The bold is Betsy's.

At this time of the year when we are remembering the Founders, I like to go back to what Abraham Lincoln had to say about the founding. He firmly believed that the Declaration of Independence was the crucial founding document of our nation because it established the ideals of what our country could be, not what it was, but the ideal that all free men should strive for. In a speech in June, 1857 in response to the Dred Scott decision, he laid this out so clearly.
Chief Justice Taney, in his opinion in the Dred Scott case, admits that the language of the Declaration is broad enough to include the whole human family, but he and Judge Douglas argue that the authors of that instrument did not intend to include negroes, by the fact that they did not at once, actually place them on an equality with the whites.

Now this grave argument comes to just nothing at all, by the other fact, that they did not at once, or ever afterwards, actually place all white people on an equality with one or another. And this is the staple argument of both the Chief Justice and the Senator, for doing this obvious violence to the plain unmistakable language of the Declaration.

I think the authors of that notable instrument intended to include all men, but they did not intend to declare all men equal in all respects. They did not mean to say all were equal in color, size, intellect, moral developments, or social capacity. They defined with tolerable distinctness, in what respects they did consider all men created equal—equal in "certain inalienable rights, among which are life, liberty, and the pursuit of happiness." This they said, and this meant.

They did not mean to assert the obvious untruth, that all were then actually enjoying that equality, nor yet, that they were about to confer it immediately upon them. In fact they had no power to confer such a boon. They meant simply to declare the right, so that the enforcement of it might follow as fast as circumstances should permit.

They meant to set up a standard maxim for free society, which should be familiar to all, and revered by all; constantly looked to, constantly labored for, and even though never perfectly attained, constantly approximated, and thereby constantly spreading and deepening its influence, and augmenting the happiness and value of life to all people of all colors everywhere.

The assertion that "all men are created equal" was of no practical use in effecting our separation from Great Britain; and it was placed in the Declaration, not for that, but for future use. Its authors meant it to be, thank God, it is now proving itself, a stumbling block to those who in after times might seek to turn a free people back into the hateful paths of despotism. They knew the proneness of prosperity to breed tyrants, and they meant when such should re-appear in this fair land and commence their vocation they should find left for them at least one hard nut to crack.
And that is enough for me. I love the ideal of this country and that it was founded on those principles and even though I know we fall short every day, I still love being part of a country that, unlike any other country, had that ideal as its foundation.

So do I, Betsy, and so do many others. Thanks for a great July Fourth post.