Wednesday, June 08, 2005

If today's MSM had covered World War II

The D-Day anniversary reminded us of what we owe the extraordinary men and women who made our success possible.

It also led me to wonder how today's media would have covered the invasion and other events.

Below is how I ithink ABC Evening News would have done it

References to the pre-invasion disagreement between General Eisenhower and Air Marshall Leigh-Mallory concerning the American paratroop drop are historically accurate as is the information concerning the Enigma project, one of the war's most important secrets.

The peace activist who wants the kids to learn to goose step is, of course, fictional.


Now here’s ABC's Evening News – June 8, 1944


Charles Gibson: “Good evening. We begin tonight with the war news. And there’s plenty of that, including reports of a serious split in the ranks of Allied military leaders.

When we reported the D-Day invasion, we believed Americans and British military leaders had agreed on the invasion plan. Now we learn that was not the case.

We go first to Linda Douglas at the War Department. Linda, we’re hearing rumors of deep splits among Allied military leaders? Is there any truth to them?”

Douglas: “There certainly is, Charles. A source, who must remain anonymous, told me Eisenhower’s air chief, Leigh-Mallory, strongly opposed the plan to drop paratroops into Normandy during the early hours of D-Day. He feared they couldn’t achieve their objectives and would suffer massive casualties.

Eisenhower, not an airman and with no experience commanding paratroops, went against Leigh-Mallory’s advice and ordered the drop anyway.

Now, although the paratroopers achieved their main objectives, even Ike’s headquarters is admitting many lives were lost.

Gibson: “Well then, Linda, do we know yet on who might replace Eisenhower?”

Douglas: “No.”

Gibson “Well, do we at least know when Eisenhower will be replaced?”

Douglas: “I’m afraid it might not be soon, Charles. Ike’s boss, General Marshall, is solidly behind him.”

Gibson: “That’s really not too surprising since Eisenhower is a Marshall protégé. Well, thank you, Linda.

Now we go to Terry Moran at the White House. Terry, do we know why President Roosevelt has failed to tell the American people anything about this major split in the Allied leadership? He spoke to the nation on D-Day and, as I recall, said nothing about it”

Moran: “That’s right, Charles. And he’s still said nothing. And I’ve got to tell you that just from where I’m standing that looks like a really huge blunder.”

Gibson: “And why is that, Terry?”

Moran: “Because it makes you wonder if Roosevelt really knows what’s going on in Normandy.”

Gibson: “Indeed, Terry. ABC News will continue to follow this story.

Now we bring you another report in our series, Your Right to Know. This one concerns a top secret effort to decode German military and diplomatic communications. It’s called the Enigma project.

. George Stephanopoulos is here to explain it to us.

George, can you tell us first whether this Enigma matter is really as important as it seems, or are the Allies exaggerating its importance in order to draw attention away from the quagmire that’s developed in Normanday? It’s almost 48 hours since the invasion began and they're still not in Germany.”

Stephanopoulos: “Charles, it’s really big news. The allies are intercepting and reading communications the Germans thought were secure. They’re doing it in almost real-time”

Gibson: “Thank you, George. Now we go to Berlin where Admiral Karl Donnitz, in charge of German submarine warfare, is standing by.

First, Admiral, thank you for taking time to be with us.

Donnitz: “A pleasure, Mr. Gibson.”

Gibson: “Admiral, I don’t know whether you’ve heard yet, but ABC has just reported the Allies have for some time been intercepting and reading German communications, including those of your submarine fleet.

So if I may, Admiral, I’d like to begin by asking if you would be good enough to give us your reaction to the news. …..Admiral?….We seem to have lost our contact with Berlin.

Well, we’re almost out of time.

Tomorrow night we’ll bring you our Person of the Week. She’s a peace activist who wants the schools in her town to let children wear swastika armbands and learn to goose step so they can better understand children in Germany. But some angry parents and a hostile school board don’t seem to want her to succeed.”

2 comments:

Anonymous said...

Actually I think the men of the WWII generation would have known where to train their friendly fire....

Or Bill Mauldin and Ernie Pyle would have, as my son says, "wailed the bananas out of them."

Barry said...

John,

Great Post! It would be hillarious if it weren't so true. Keep up the good work.