Friday, September 28, 2007

Edwards & “higher moral ground”

On Feb. 6 of this year USA Today reported :

Democrat John Edwards on Monday joined New York Sen. Hillary Rodham Clinton in saying he will not use public money for the presidential primary campaign or, if he wins his party's nomination, for the general election. […]

Edwards said in an interview that he expects major candidates in both parties to raise unlimited private dollars rather than participate in the public system. He said he needs to do the same "to have the funds to be competitive."[…]
But today the AP reports:
Democratic presidential candidate John Edwards reversed course Thursday by signing onto the public financing system he once rejected with the belief he could raise more money on his own.

The 2004 vice presidential nominee claimed higher moral ground in the debate over money in politics while announcing the change. But it comes after he brought in far fewer dollars than rivals Barack Obama and Hillary Rodham Clinton.

"It is worrisome seeing the amount of money that is being raised in this campaign," Edwards said on CNN. "This is about taking a stand, a principled stand, and I believe in public financing."[…]
John Edwards claims the “higher moral ground” as he flip-flops on public campaign financing.

Who’s surprised?

Edwards regularly flip-flops. And he claims the “higher moral ground” about as often and with as much sincerity as Jesse Jackson.

Did the well-intended people who helped put public campaign financing in place ever realize our money would be used to help keep afloat the imploding campaign of a wealthy trial lawyer with a $400.00 haircut who’d just built himself a 28,000 sq. ft. house?

The full USA Today story is here; the full AP story here.

Brodhead’s Failed Duke (Post 2)

In Brodhead’s Failed Duke (Post 1) I republished a December 23, 2006 post in which I said President Richard Brodhead had failed Duke and should resign “the sooner the better.” I also said that since December, the case for Brodhead’s resignation has grown stronger and cited instances of his failure not mentioned in the December post.

This second post in the Brodhead’s Failed Duke series contains an excerpt from a post by Washington attorney and Powerline blogger Paul Mirengoff, A Perfect Storm of Disgrace.

Mirengoff delivers a devastating indictment of Brodhead, after which I make some comments.

Now Mirengoff:

Brodhead's villainy . . . arguably exceeds that of Houston Baker and the rest of the gang of 88. While, the faculty members were blinded by hatred and a dopey ideology, Brodhead saw things clearly. His actions, like Nifong's, were the result of cynicism and opportunism.

At the outset of his tenure as president of Duke, Brodhead had given Duke's basketball coach Mike Krzyzewski a new multi-million dollar deal. Brodhead thus incurred the ire of many faculty members who were jealous of Coach K's deal and the status of athletics on campus that it represented.

When the rape charges arose, Brodhead's options were to appease Duke's leftist faculty or to grant Duke students the presumption of innocence. The faculty made it clear to Brodhead that he could not do both.

At an emergency meeting of the Academic Council on March 30, 2006, Brodhead urged caution and asked faculty to wait for the facts to come out. But the assembled professors, around 10 percent of the arts and sciences faculty, responded with vitriolic attacks against the team.

Knowing that Harvard president Larry Summers had recently lost a faculty no-confidence vote at Harvard, Brodhead made his choice. Shortly after the March 30 meeting with the faculty "lynch mob," Brodhead cancelled the lacrosse season and appointed a “Campus Culture Initiative” to explore issues raised by the case. Three of the four subcommittees were chaired by gang of 88 members. And one of the four student members had sent a nasty and arguably threatening email to the Duke lacrosse coach, a fact known to Brodhead.

Thus, Brodhead "got out of jail" with his faculty by, in effect, throwing overboard three student athletes who faced the possibility of 30 years in jail, along with the rest of the lacrosse team and its coach.
Folks, I don’t know what Brodhead’s motives were but the actions Mirengoff describes are indisputable; and only some of Brodhead's actions and inactions which mark him as a failed President.

What I find even worse than many of the things Brodhead did, are his refusals to do things any decent university president would have considered it his duty to do.

Even now, more than a year after I first learned of them, I still find Brodhead's refusals shocking and disgraceful. For instance, his refusal to meet with the lacrosse parents even as he was meeting with black community leaders and student groups critical of their sons.

What kind of university president refuses to meet with parents when their sons, his students, are named as suspects in a gang rape investigation and are in physical danger as angry “activists” shout threats, incite the community and hoist a “CASTRATE” banner?

The most shocking Brodhead refusals are his refusal last May to say a single word critical of the black racists who first shouted physical threats and then death threats at Reade Seligmann, and his refusal to say any words of support and comfort to Seligmann and his family.

What sort of university president refuses to speak out in response to the terrible events of May 18, 2006?

Anyone reading this post who remembers President Terry Sanford knows Sanford would never have responded to Crystal Mangum, Mike Nifong and many Duke faculty members’ malicious falsehoods as the craven Brodhead has with, we're told, the support of the current trustees.

Brodhead needs to go and the sooner the better.

And Duke needs trustees with the care and judgment to bring the University a new president with the character and leadership Terry Sanford brought to the presidency of Duke University.

Mirengoff’s entire post is here.

Hat tip: Mike Williams

An Insufficiently Sensitive Comment

Last evening I posted "Anderson’s Until Proven Innocent review". I mentioned that in his review Professor Bill Anderson, while giving the book very high marks, said he had some disagreements with it. I didn’t go into detail but linked to Bill's review and encouraged JinC readers to read it.

This morning on the post thread there’s a comment from a JinC Regular who uses the blog name Insufficiently Sensitive.

IS said in part: “[Anderson’s] disagreements with the authors contain the most important statement of [his] review - that is, the unresolvable enmity between PC and classic liberalism.”

IS is right. I should have said more about Bill's disagreements in my post. I actually tried to do that but didn’t for reasons I’ll explain in a post I’m planning for this weekend. It’ll have a title something like “Talking about blogging.” I plan to discuss some of the issues, opportunities and problems I’ve encountered blogging. I hope you look for it.

In the meantime, please consider reading Anderson’s review here.

Message to Insufficiently Sensitive: Thank you. You were spot on in your most recent comment, just as you’ve been in most of your other comments.

Thursday, September 27, 2007

The Churchill Series – Sept. 27, 2007

(One of a series of weekday posts on the life of Winston S. Churchill.)

Today begins a two-part series within the series focused on the work of a great historian and Churchill’s official biographer, Sir Martin Gilbert.

In In Search of Churchill: A Historians Journey (John Wiley & Sons, 1994) Gilbert recounts his initial involvement in the research and writing of Churchill’s life. The year was 1962 and Churchill’s only son, Randolph, had been selected by Churchill to write his biography. Gilbert explains:

My employment with Randolph was to begin in October 1962. Merton College, which had just elected me to a Junior Research Fellowship, agreed that I could also spend time working with Randolph at Stour. My friends, and I, assumed that my engagement would be of short duration. I was still there four and a half years later. I started work under the watchful eye of Michael Wolff, who bore the brunt of responsibility for the whole enterprise: the other researchers and the secretaries of what Randolph called the “book office.”

Much has been made of Randolph’s irascibility and worse: in these pages I hope a fair picture will emerge of a man who made many enemies by his often violent conduct, but who could be kind, considerate and generous. On my first working day at Stour, which was a copy of his book Fifteen Famous English Homes, inscribed “Martin Gilbert from Randolph S. Churchill”.

I had no idea until then that he had written half a dozen books. A month later he gave me another of them, The Rise and Fall of Sir Anthony Eden, inscribed “Martin from Randolph”. I had been accepted as part of his team. (p. 13)
Randolph Churchill died almost six years later in June, 1968. With the help of Gilbert and others in the “book office”, he'd completed the first two volumes of his father's official biography.

Gilbert was selected to complete what became an eight-volume biography which he did during the next twenty years until the publication in 1988 of the final volume, Never Despair.

Last year Gilbert put up a net site at which he tells something of his life and provides brief descriptions of all his works which include histories of both world wars and the Holocaust.

I hope you give the site a look. If you read this post on a busy weekday, why not email it to yourself and then find some quiet time over the weekend to go back to it, click on the link to Gilbert’s site and read what is a brief account of the work of one of our greatest historians?

Anderson’s Until Proven Innocent review

Professor and columnist William (Bill) Anderson has been there and done it throughout the Duke Hoax.

Bill was there last Spring calling readers attention to Nifong’s frauds. He’s been with the case since, relentless and elegantly arguing for justice.

Recently, he reviewed Until Proven Innocent by Stuart Taylor and KC Johnson.

Bill likes the book. No surprise there. And I like the book. No surprise, either.

So how do I post on Bill’s review without falling into cheerleading, something that’s fine at times and in certain places, but not here and now?

The answer’s easy: Let Bill speak for himself.

Here are some particularly informative and, I think, important excerpts from an outstanding review:

Lest anyone think that this case was pushed by an "overzealous" prosecutor who simply was seeking justice for a poor, black prostitute who was brutalized by some rich white boys, the following incident will put it all into perspective, and Johnson and Taylor do a very good job here.

On March 27, 2006, Police Investigator Ben Himan told Nifong that the case pretty much was at a dead end, with no real evidence existing of a rape. Nifong replied, "We’re f**ked."

However, instead of packing it in right there, Nifong went out that day and began an out-an-out media barrage in which he would tell one news organization after another that there "definitely" was a rape, and that it was racially motivated.

In other words, after he realized that he did not have a case, Nifong at that point began his media offensive.

The timing here is important, as Nifong claimed in his response to charges filed by the North Carolina State Bar (which would take away his law license) that his public statements to the press and to citizens’ groups were done because of a "lack of experience" with his job.

As the authors point out, Nifong’s media offensive was done precisely to create the impression he had a strong case when, in fact, he had no case. This was not an act of inexperience; instead, it was an exercise in legal cynicism.

However cynical Nifong’s actions were, they did work in that he secured two indictments on April 17, 2006, against two people, Reade Seligmann and Collin Finnerty, who were not even at the party when the alleged rape took place, and could prove it.

(Nifong secured another indictment in mid-May against David Evans, who told a press conference that day that the case was based upon "fantastic lies." Nifong’s indictment of Seligmann and Finnerty resulted in his winning the early May primary. His indictment of Evans ultimately would lead to the destruction of his career, as Evans’ attorney, Brad Bannon, managed to uncover the DNA information that Nifong illegally withheld from the defense.)

Much of the book deals with the Duke faculty members, the infamous "G88," that gave the green light to Nifong that he could go after the lacrosse players. And it was not just the radical faculty members who joined in the chorus of condemnation.

The "Triangle" area of North Carolina, with its close proximities of universities, is notorious for its political radicalism, and the hard-left protest machinery that is eternally well-oiled kicked into gear.

This was the "perfect case," and just because the facts did not add up – and the DNA tests came back completely negative – did not discourage these radicals from their morally-satisfying protests and accusations. Even if the truth was otherwise, they did not want to hear it.

The Duke campus exploded with protests led by faculty, radical students, and employees like "sustainability coordinator" Sam Hummel, who coordinated much of the attack machinery. Not only did the protesters openly call for the "castration" of the lacrosse players, but they effectively succeeded in driving many of them away from the university altogether, with some athletes having to sleep in their cars, endure death threats, and generally live in fear because police and prosecutors were lying and faculty, administration, and staff at Duke chose to believe the lies, despite the fact that they were obviously outlandish.

Johnson and Taylor are especially disdainful of Duke’s administration and its weak-kneed president, Richard Brodhead. They lay out just how craven the university administration really was, beginning with the "don’t tell your parents" meeting that the administration scheduled with the players and the police – the players supposedly "represented" by a lawyer who had been disciplined more than once by the state bar. (When parents did hear of the meeting to be scheduled, they immediately demanded that their sons have competent legal representation, and the meeting was cancelled.)

There is much more to dislike from the Duke administration, and Johnson and Taylor lay out in detail the dishonest way in which Brodhead and his top administrators carried out their activities.

While giving lip service to "due process," Brodhead made sure that the players would stand condemned, first by firing the coach and cancelling the season, to his infamous "whatever they did was bad enough" remarks to the Durham Chamber of Commerce.
Bill goes on to note some disagreements he has with Taylor and Johnson but he makes clear he thinks the book is a buy, read and re-read.

Bill's review is here.

Jackson, Sharpton & Dumb

Jackson, Sharpton & Dumb isn't a law firm retained by the Democratic Party to help strike down laws requiring a valid photo ID before “a homeless person” can show up on election day and vote and vote and vote at various polling places.

This post’s title has to do with another one I posted yesterday: Jackson & Sharpton, Who’s Dumber?

Yesterday’s post linked to an audio of the Reverends Jesse Jackson and Al Sharpton talking last Spring on separate programs about what was then called “the Duke lacrosse rape scandal.”

If you’ve heard the audio, you know both Revs embraced and amplified the absurd and false statements of Crystal Mangum, a black, Mike Nifong, a white, and the Raleigh News & Observer, whose Duke lacrosse coverage relied on reporters and editors drawn from a number of racial and ethnic groups.

I asked people to listen to the audio and decide who sounded dumber: Jackson or Sharpton. Jackson got my vote.

Well, if you’ve read the thread of Jackson or Sharpton, Who’s Dumber? , you know some readers took exception to the idea that either man could be dumb. They see the two as smart hustlers.

I’d like to explain why I believe Jackson’s and Sharpton’s comments can be fairly characterized as dumb.

Dictionary.com defines dumb as “ lacking intelligence or good judgment; stupid; dull-witted.”

Both Jackson and Sharpton presented themselves as believers of the lies told by Mangum, Nifong and DPD were telling last Spring. That was dumb.

Smart hustlers wouldn’t have done that in circumstances where their statements were being recorded and could quickly wind up on the Net, where literally millions of people could, if they cared to, listen and parse every word the Revs said.

A smart hustler does the sort of thing Jackson first did when Mangum’s lies brought her national media attention: offer “the young mother” a college scholarship whether the accusation was true or not so she’d never have to “perform” again. Jackson added that he was “looking forward” to meeting her when she was “physically and emotionally ready and having prayer with her.” I posted on what he did in Rev. Jesse Jackson steps into the Duke lacrosse spotlight.

Now, what Jackson did was attention seeking and contemptuous of justice because he said the woman would get her college expenses paid even if her accusations were false.

But it was a smart hustle because Jackson allowed that perhaps Mangum might not be telling the truth, and presented himself as a man of God who wanted to help lift a poor woman out of circumstances in which she was “forced” to strip and set her on the road to a college education.

I don’t know whether Jackson and Sharpton really believed much of what they said.

But what they said showed a lack of intelligence or good judgment. And the Revs came off sounding stupid or, if you prefer, dull-witted.

That’s why I called them dumb and asked you to decide which was dumber.

Message to the Revs: It’s no longer like the old days when you could say something stupid or outright dishonest, and then later deny you said it and call the people noting what you’d said “racists.” It’s a new tech world out there.

Message to JinC readers: I’ll post this weekend on how I see the new technologies helping those of us who want to do all we can to expose and counter frauds and hustlers like Jackson, Sharpton, Nifong and Nancy Grace.

Wednesday, September 26, 2007

The Churchill Series – Sept. 26, 2007

(One of a series of weekday posts on the life of Winston S. Churchill.)

First, in the last week or so a number of you have made affirming and appreciate comments about the series, mostly as part of comments on non-series threads and in a few instances on series post threads. I thank each of you. Your kind words mean a lot.

On a very different matter, regular series readers know I often draw material from the works of Sir Martin Gilbert, Churchill’s official biographer and one of the greatest historians of the twentieth century. Recently, Gilbert suffered what’s descried as “a mild heart attack,” from which he is now making a steady recovery.

I want to share with you a group email I received yesterday, after which I’ll make a few comments:

I WANT TO THANK EVERYONE FOR THEIR GOOD WISHES.

MY HEART IS STILL BEATING, AND I AM SLOWLY AND
STEADILY ON THE MEND.

I AM SORRY TO HAVE DISAPPOINTED THOSE WHOM I WAS SO
LOOKING TO SEE AT THE BOOK LAUNCHES OF "CHURCHILL AND
THE JEWS".
HOPEFULLY YOU WILL FIND THAT THE BOOK CAN
(AS IT WERE) SPEAK FOR ITSELF.

MY MAIN FOCUS, AS SOON AS I AM BETTER, WILL BE THE
REMAINING CHURCHILL DOCUMENT VOLUMES, WHICH ARE TO BE
PUBLISHED BY HILLSDALE COLLEGE PRESS, HILLSDALE
COLLEGE, MICHIGAN.

I HAVE ALREADY SET UP A SPECIAL 65-FOOT LONG DESK IN
LONDON ON WHICH THE DOCUMENTS ARE - EVEN AS I WRITE
THESE WORDS - WAITING FOR MY RETURN, AND FOR MY
ATTENTION.

REGARDS

MARTIN GILBERT
I know we all wish Martin Gilbert well and will keep him in our thoughts and prayers.

The next two series posts will concern Gilbert’s work which, in addition to his eight-volume magisterial life of Churchill, includes outstanding works on the Holocaust and both world wars. I also plan to say a few things about his many acts of help and kindness over decades to those – amateur as well as professional – to those who've contacted him with questions or comments regarding Churchill.

Some of you may have seen this past June the kind comment he left here concerning the series. I was not in direct contact with him at the time. It’s very unlikely he’s a series regular. More likely, he found the series by using a search engine and googling “Winston Churchill” or “Martin Gilbert.” Very few in Gilbert’s position, having found posts by an obscure blogger would give them more than a cursory look. Even fewer would take the trouble to write a thoughtful email. But Gilbert did both. That’s typical of him.

I hope you are back for the next two posts.

John

McClatchy and the N&O

What follows is taken from a news report of President Bush’s address to the U. N. General Assembly. The report begins:

President Bush implored the United Nations on Tuesday to recommit itself to restoring human decency by liberating oppressed people and ending famine and disease.

Speaking before the United Nations General Assembly, the president called for renewed efforts to enforce the U.N.'s Universal Declaration of Human Rights, a striking point of emphasis for a leader who's widely accused of violating human rights in waging war against terrorism.

Bush didn't mention the U.S. prisons in Afghanistan or at Abu Ghraib and Guantanamo Bay, the U.S. practice of holding detainees for years without legal charges or access to lawyers, or the CIA's "rendition" kidnappings of suspects abroad, all issues of concern to human rights activists around the world.

"At first read, it's little more than an exercise in hypocrisy. His words about human rights ring hollow because his credibility is nonexistent," said Curt Goering, the deputy executive director of Amnesty International USA. "The gap between the rhetoric and the actual record is stunning. I can't help but believe many people in the audience were thinking, 'What was this man thinking?' "
The rest of the report is here. The story is from the McClatchy news service.

McClatchy is the parent company of the Raleigh News & Observer, the paper which last March told its readers a deliberately fraudulent story about the “ordeal” of a young, black, Durham mother who was subjected to a night of “sexual violence.”

Three innocent men were subsequently indicted while the N&O withheld for thirteen months critically important news it had that was exculpatory for the men. The N&O only released the news the day after the men were declared innocent by North Carolina’s Attorney General.

McClatchy and the N&O are liberal/leftist news organizations. In my opinion, both engage in Bush-bashing and sliming America; the story cited here being just one more example of that.

However, McClatchy and the N&O both deny doing any of that. The N&O’s executive editor for news, Melanie Sill, says people who think either McClatchy or the N&O do anything other then fair and accurate news reporting are simply wrong.

I reported and commented. Now you decide.

Bollinger Exposed

Columbia’s Lee Bollinger has used just about every line in The PC Moral Equivalency Guidebook for University Presidents Seeking to Curry Favor with the Hard Left and Other Enemies of America to justify his invitation to a Holocaust-denier who regularly calls for the destruction of Israel and currently leads a terror war against Western civilization,

Today, Clint Cowen, a junior at UNC – Chapel Hill, shines the lights of reason and truth on Bollinger.

From The Daily Tar Heel, Carolina’s student newspaper
:

TO THE EDITOR:

I found Columbia's decision to host Mahmoud Ahmadinejad outrageous. How can (Columbia) President (Lee) Bollinger, in good conscience, prohibit ROTC presence on his campus while simultaneously hosting a sworn opponent of the U.S. military?

Ahmadinejad's regime is currently fighting a proxy war against us by aiding and arming the Iraqi insurgency, which is daily killing more of our soldiers and undermining stability in Iraq.

Ahmadinejad also persists in his sponsorship of terrorism to achieve Iran's foreign policy goals in the Middle East. Further, he stands in clear defiance of the (United Nations) Security Council and U.S. interests abroad by continuing to pursue a nuclear weapons program.

It is foolish to claim that Ahmadinejad provided an alternative perspective useful for university dialogue. Ahmadinejad's brutally oppressive regime continues in its shameless record of human rights abuses, actions that directly oppose the individual freedoms for which the United States stands.

He is unworthy of the forum and applause he received.

Allowing the Iranian president's speech confers undeserved legitimacy on his views, which runs counter to basic human values and are bent on destroying our way of life.

President Bollinger's criticism of Ahmadinejad during the forum was insufficient; the Iranian president is an enemy of the United States, and he should have been treated as such.

Clint Cowan
Junior
Religious Studies
It will be a great day for the university and America when Columbia has a president who shares Cowen’s values and acts on them.

A big hat tip to Clint Cowan.

Jackson or Sharpton, who’s dumber?

I posted yesterday Jena & civil rights , in which I noted among other things that while America has some highly intelligent civil rights leaders such as Thomas Sowell and James Coleman, our country also has some really dumb ones such as Jesse Jackson and Al Sharpton.

Didn't Jackson and Sharpton make fools of themselves during the Duke Hoax?

Last night at Liestoppers Forum I came upon the following post by Tony Soprano, one of the citizen journalists whose made a very significant contribution to the fight for justice in the Duke Hoax case.

Soprano links to an audio in which Jackson and Sharpton, appearing last Spring on separate programs, “discuss” the Duke Hoax.

Listening to the audio, I was reminded of Churchill’s observation that it's better for some people to remain silent and have people think they’re fools, than to open their mouths and remove all doubt. (Subsequent to posting this, a commenter signing as C said Lincoln, not Churchill, made the observation. A quick scan of net sources confirms it's most often attributed to Lincoln and occasionally to others. A hat tip and thanks to C. - JinC )

If you’ve got nine minutes, I hope you give the audio a listen. Then tell me which one you think comes off sounding like the dumber of the two.

Jackson has my vote. Now Tony’s post:

This is good audio of Jesse Jackson attacking the Duke LAX players.

Jackson starts around the 2:40 min mark - you should listen to the Jackson portion!

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=luqD-jyBfs0

Interestingly, Sharpton believes that the authorities charges are important and significant in the Duke case- they (the authorities) must have convincing evidence.
He's taking the exact opposite position in JENA.
Thank you, Tony.

Tuesday, September 25, 2007

The Churchill Series – Sept. 25, 2007

(One of a series of weekday posts on the life of Winston S. Churchill.)

From time to time extraordinary events occur which seem to defy logical, natural explanation.

Then there are imperishable words that one need only present to caring readers and then say no more.

With those observations in mind, we read in William Manchester's The Last Lion: Visions of Glory, 1874-1932 of close calls Churchill had while serving as a battalion commander at the front during WW I:

On December 28, 1915, The Times [of London] carried an interview with a corporal, an Orangeman, who was quoted as saying of Churchill, “A cooler and braver officer never wore the King’s uniform. . . . His coolness is the subject of much discussion among us, and everybody admires him.”

Repeatedly, when he was elsewhere on the line, his frail sandbagged shelter was demolished by direct hits. Like Douglas MacArthur, who also defied enemy fire [near the same place] two years later, [Churchill] felt shielded by mysterious intervention, believing that “Chance, Fortune, Luck, Destiny, Fate, Providence seem to me only different ways of expressing the same thing, to wit, that a man’s own contribution to his life story is continually dominated by an external superior power.” (p. 581)
A quarter century later, on May 10, 1940, the King asked Churchill to form a government and lead the country in its hour of greatest peril. Churchill immediately began the process of forming a new government, recalling later that “I felt as if I were walking with destiny and that all my past life had been but a preparation for this hour and for this trial."

Jena & civil rights

We’ve read a lot recently about Jena from MSM’s favorite civil rights leaders, the Reverends Jesse Jackson and Al Sharpton. “No justice, no peace” and all that.

Now, let’s read some of what another civil rights leader, Thomas Sowell, a fellow at Stanford University’s Hoover Center, has just written in response to events in Jena:

Racial hype has replaced all rational discussion.

Moreover, the Jena episode has shown that two can play the racial hype game. Neo-Nazis have published the names and home addresses of all the young blacks involved in the school incident.

The slogan "No justice, no peace" has been used to justify settling legal issues in the streets, instead of in courts of law.

Neo-Nazis have now helped demonstrate what a dangerous slogan that is, since different people have opposite ideas of what "justice" is in a given situation.

Long after the imported demonstrators have left, and the national media have lost interest, the families of the black youngsters involved in the school altercation will have to live with the knowledge that their privacy and security have both been lost in a racially polarized community, with vengeful elements.

The last thing the South needs is a return to lynch-mob justice, whatever the color of whoever is promoting it.
Back in the 1950s, when the federal courts began striking down the Jim Crow laws in the South, one of the rising demands across the country was that the discriminators and segregationists obey "the law of the land."

But, somewhere along the way, the idea also arose and spread that not everybody was supposed to obey "the law of the land."

Violations of law by people with approved victim status like minorities, or self-righteous crusaders like environmentalists, were to be met with minimal resistance -- if any resistance at all -- and any punishment of them beyond a wrist-slap was "over-reacting."

College campuses became bastions of the new and sanctified mob rule, provided that the mobs are from the list of groups approved as politically correct. Otherwise, even an injudicious remark could bring swift and certain punishment under "speech codes."

The politics of condoned law-breaking is part of the moral dry rot of our times. So is settling issues in the streets on the basis of race, instead of in courts on the basis of law.
The politics of condoned law-breaking is certainly part of the moral dry rot of out times.

So is the liberal/leftist MSM’s hyping of Jackson, Sharpton and other such race hustlers as “civil rights leaders.”

Why does MSM pay so much attention to the exploitations of the Jacksons and Sharptons while ignoring genuine and outstanding civil rights leaders such as Sowell and Duke Law School Professor James Coleman?

As the Duke Hoax played out last Spring, Jackson and Sharpton paid no attention to violations of its victims' civil rights. They enabled the lies of Mangum, Nifong and the DPD. And they wound up looking like a pair of self-deluded dopes better suited to wearing dunce caps than the mantle of the late Dr. Martin Luther King.

Meanwhile, Coleman and Sowell, tough-minded, fair and disciplined scholars, paid attention to civil rights issues and helped lead us through the Hoax and to the day when the Attorney General of North Carolina declared its greatest victims innocent.

In response to Jena, the network news programs, the cable talk shows and our major newspapers should be featuring what civil rights leaders like Coleman and Sowell are saying. Instead, they feature the likes of Jackson and Sharpton who self-promote at the expense of justice and peace.

Sowell’s column is titled Law Versus Mob Rule.

Hat tip: BN

Commending Kristin Butler

I just left a comment on the thread of Kristin Butler's Chronicle column.
Her column today deals with, among other matters, the possibility of suits against Duke by the 44 members of the lacrosse team who were not indicted, but were subjected to a horrible ordeal during which their physical safety was placed at great risk and some of their rights were very likely violated.

My comment was the second on the thread. Before I wrote anything to Butler, I responded to the previous Anon @ 9:45 commenter who wrote:

Kristin,

I would love to be in the courtroom when Ryan McFadyen comes in to argue that Duke should be forced to pay him millions of dollars in damages. That claim should be good for a few laughs.
To Anon @ 9:45,

I don't know if McFadyen will ask for millions.

On the other hand, wasn't he suspended by Duke for writing a disgusting parody of part of a work that was assigned in at least three courses at Duke?

Did Duke treat McFadyen as it treats all students who do that sort of thing?

Are you sure the DPD obtained McFadyen's email legally?

To Kristin,

Another superb column. I've posted on it and will again later today or tomorrow.

Your columns are an important service to the University. Very few people have the courage to speak truth to power.

Thank you.

John in Carolina
_________________________________

Folks, if you don't already, I urge you to read Butler's columns which appear in The Chronicle every Tuesday.

I plan in a few weeks to go back through her Hoax columns and offer you a post comparing what Butler's been saying with what Board of Trustees Chair Robert Steel, President Richard Brodhead, the faculty Group of 88 and others have been saying in response to the Hoax.

Throughout the Hoax, Butler's been a strong, clear, courageous voice for reason and justice.

Right from the time Crystal Mangum, Mike Nifong and DPD began telling their lies, Butler knew that facts don't change, and that students don't have to prove their innocence at trial. It's a pity President Brodhead didn't, and that the trustees have been so willing to support him in his ignorance.

Had University leaders paid more attention to Butler, the tragedies and injustices endured by the innocent would have been reduced because Duke would've made many fewer blunders.

Duke Suits and “Chains”

Here’s part of Kristen Butler’s column in today’s Chronicle followed by some JinC commentary. Butler begins:

If you thought the $30-million lawsuit against Durham was the end of the lacrosse litigation, think again.

According to blogger KC Johnson, "Duke, its administrators, and its extremist professors are not out of the legal woods yet.... A high-powered legal team representing most of the other 44 members of the 2006 lacrosse team is exploring a possible lawsuit."

Johnson added that the grounds for such a suit could include "mistreating the entire team, including misleading smears of the players by Duke President Richard Brodhead and dozens of professors." In this scenario, attorneys would likely argue that those "misleading smears" were slanderous and asserting that Duke should be held liable for the actions of its employees.

A more creative rationale could hold that participation on the 2006 team constituted a de facto contract to play for the University. Because Board of Trustees Chair Bob Steel admitted that negative publicity ended the team's season (Steel told The New Yorker he did it "to stop those pictures... it doesn't necessarily mean I think it was right"), attorneys might argue that this justification was not sufficient to legally void that contract.

No matter how attorneys decide to structure their arguments, the bottom line is that the University may not be done cutting super-secret settlement checks yet. And although the remaining players' cases probably aren't as compelling as the ones that have already been settled, they could (in a worst-case scenario) lead to lengthy depositions and eventually a trial.
Important facts could be revealed if proceedings went that far, but that would effectively end Duke's chances of "moving on"-at least within this decade.
The rest of Butler’s column is here. It's superb as are so many of her columns.

Comments:

I’ll get to the suits in a subsequent post. Here I want to talk about Duke and “moving on.”

Does Duke really expect people who care about how it acted during the witch hunt to “move on” when it’s never given them a chance to be at a place from which they could “move on?”

Until Duke gives people a chance to “be there” when President Brodhead and Trustee Chair Robert Steel fully explain such shocking and deeply offensive behaviors as Brodhead’s refusal to meet with the lacrosse parents and the University’s disgraceful silence when Reade Seligmann was threatened by racists, the only people “moving on” will be those not upset by such behaviors.

If the “move on” people at Duke have their way, the University will have slunk away from one of the most shameful episodes in its history. That’s in some people’s self-interest.

But Duke’s best interests will only be served if it does what great universities do to grow stronger: admit and examine mistakes, determine why the mistakes were made, and then set in place corrective measures and personnel changes to prevent such mistakes in the future.

If Duke does that, it will move on from the Hoax a better university.

If it doesn’t, Duke will, like Marley’s ghost, be forced drag “the chains forged” by its President’s refusal to meet with parents whose sons were in grave legal and physical danger, its silence as racists threatened a Duke student walking to a courthouse in Durham and other equally odious behaviors.

No one who cares about Duke wants that to happen. The trustees must act to make sure it doesn’t.

Monday, September 24, 2007

The Churchill Series – Sept.24, 2007

(One of a series of weekday posts on the life of Winston S. Churchill.)

What follows is a wonderful story I found in William F. Buckley’s Miles Gone By (Regnery, 2004). It involves Churchill, of course, Henry (Harry) Luce, founder of TIME, Life, Fortune and other magazines, and his wife, Clare Boothe Luce, a journalist, diplomat and, like Churchill, talented amateur painter.

As Buckley recounts the story, his good friend Clare Luce was giving him a painting lesson and:

interwove, with her instructions on how to paint, recollections of her experiences with canvas and oils.

Just after the war she and her husband want to England and spent the weekend as guests of Winston Churchill at Chartwell.

“I tried to be especially ingratiating because Harry wanted U. S. rights to Churchill’s war memoirs for Life magazine. So passing through one gallery I said, “These are wonderful paintings.”

Churchill said, “I’m glad you like them, but only one of them is painted by me.”

Claire flashed her sly, infectious smile, and then a little snort of laughter. “I thought, Oh dear, that makes me sound very sycophantic. I asked which one was his, and he pointed to a pastoral scene, a field of some sort. I thought I’d better do something to establish my critical independence. I said I liked it but I thought it was too - - placid; lacking in movement.”

“Three weeks later in New York that painting arrived, but on it were three sheep bouncing about. His note read, ‘Is that any better?’”(pgs. 263-264)

Did Hillary’s Campaign Kill a Story?

We read at Politico that Senator Hillary Clinton’s campaign killed a story:

Early this summer, Sen. Hillary Rodham Clinton’s campaign for president learned that the men’s magazine GQ was working on a story the campaign was sure to hate: an account of infighting in Hillaryland.

So Clinton’s aides pulled a page from the book of Hollywood publicists and offered GQ a stark choice: Kill the piece, or lose access to planned celebrity coverboy Bill Clinton.

Despite internal protests, GQ editor Jim Nelson met the Clinton campaign’s demands, which had been delivered by Bill Clinton’s spokesman, Jay Carson, several sources familiar with the conversations said.

GQ writer George Saunders traveled with Clinton to Africa in July, and Clinton is slated to appear on the cover of GQ’s December issue, in which it traditionally names a “Man of the Year,” according magazine industry sources.

And the offending article by Atlantic Monthly staff writer Josh Green got the spike.

“I don’t really get into the inner workings of the magazine, but I can tell you that yes, we did kill a Hillary piece. We kill pieces all the time for a variety of reasons,” Nelson said in an e-mail to Politico.

He did not respond to follow-up questions. A Clinton campaign spokesman declined to comment.
You can read the entire story here.

Folks, can it be true?

Did Hillary Clinton’s vast left-wing campaign kill a story GQ, a smallish magazine, was planning to run?

Why would Hillary’s campaign do such a thing?

What could GQ have been planning to say?

Why no shouts from the "free speech" crowd?

And will the NY Betray Us disclose what the Clinton campaign is keeping from us, just as it discloses America’s national security secrets?

I don’t think so. Party loyalty runs too deep.

Your turn.

"Hip, hip, hypocricy"

Today KC Johnson posted The Hypocrisy of Durham "Activists." Given its subject matter, the post is lengthy. But it's very well done. I hope you give it a look.

KC's post reminded me of one I put up on May 6, 2006: Duke lacrosse and "hip, hip, hypocrisy." It follows, after which I add a few comments.
_________________________________________________________________

Barry Jacobs is Chairman of The Orange County Board of Commissioners. Orange borders Durham County and includes the town of Chapel Hill and the campus of the University of North Carolina.

Jacobs regularly writes about women’s sports. Recently he sounded off in response to the Duke lacrosse case and made linkages to things liberal/leftists like to call “the larger truths.” Here's some of what Jacobs says:

Under the best of circumstances, collegiate athletic competition involving women--most often condescendingly called "ladies" or "girls" by the sports media--routinely commands second-class coverage. […]

The off-field excesses of the Duke lacrosse team (men's) [provide] a dark and hurtful reminder of larger truths about sex, race and privilege.

How must female athletes, black and white, look at their male counterparts after such an episode, or rather how must they imagine their male counterparts look at them?

And, if boys-will-be-boys is tolerated by athletic administrators, where does a woman turn for support? […]
Jacobs serves up a lot more just like that and closes with:
But celebration of the ACC [women's basketball's]transcendent season was cut short by tales of racism, alcohol abuse and alleged sexual assault perpetuated (sic) by male Duke athletes. In this, too, the lacrosse team and its excesses served to victimize women.
Jacobs' piece appeared in the Apr. 12 edition of The Independent, a free, weekly newspaper with strong social and political appeal to the region’s “progressive community.”

The Independent survives on advertising revenue. Some of it comes from restaurants, bars advertising happy hours, book stores, and such.

But a lot of The Independent’s revenue comes from what Jacobs could tell you is a special niche market. The Independent pretty much has the market to itself because most other publications avoid it if they can.

I wish Jacobs was here to tell us what he calls the market. We’ll just have to do with a few examples. These ads are from the Mar. 29 Independent:
TRAVELING HOTTIES

Introducing five brand new co-ed hotties to your area for the next three weeks only. Check out our pics online. Offering one-of-a –kind two girl shows. In or Out. Call: XXXX (No contact information will be provided in this post - JinC)

XXXX (ad title is also an internet address)

For the best of exotic dance, massage and entertainment try our ladies. Also selectively hiring
There are a lot more ads with titles such as BIG, SEXY & READY and PARTY, PARTY, PARTY. There’s even one that claims it provides “schedules, reviews & profiles” of other ESCORT SITES.

The Indy, as Jacobs calls it, has pages of ads with photos inviting readers to TRY IT and contact LOCAL DATELINE which bills itself as CASUAL, INTIMATE, and JUST FUN.

Speaking of bills, the ads often remind readers to have a Visa or Amex ready.

If you’re in Durham or anywhere else in the Triangle you can pick up a copy of The Indy most anywhere. The Indy must have at least 5 distribution points at Duke, including one in the lobby of the Bryan Student Center. Duke undergrads are a major target group for most Indy advertisers.

The Indy’s very popular at Duke. The other day I must have seen about 10 copies of it on desks and tables at the Divinity School.

In fact, it wouldn’t surprise me to learn the lacrosse players who hired the exotic dancers found their contact information in The Indy.

I’ll bet it wouldn’t surprise Jacobs, either.

Now a little advice for all of you: If you’re ever speaking before the Orange County Commissioners, for goodness sakes don’t slip up and call a group of women "ladies" or "girls."

You know how mad that makes Commissioner Barry Jacobs.

Now, for Commissioner Jacobs, let’s everybody get up and shout, "Hip, hip, hypocrisy!"

I’m emailing Jacobs a link to this post. I’ll let you know if I hear anything back.

If you’d like to contact Jacobs his email is: barry.j@mindspring.com
----------
URL to full text of Jacobs' article: http://www.indyweek.com/gyrobase/Content?oid=oid%3A30272

**********************************************************************

Folks,

I’ll bet many of you remember last May and the vicious trashing the members of Duke’s Women’s lacrosse team were subjected to by some in MSM for doing no more than speaking the truth: “Innocent!”

The Duke women were trashed just weeks after Jacobs complained women athletes are “often condescendingly called "ladies" or "girls" by the sports media” and opined on the “larger truths about sex, race and privilege.”

But I don’t recall Barry Jacobs ever writing anything critical of his fellow journalists who trashed the Duke Women athletes.

I’ll email him tonight and check just to be sure. I’ll let you know if he responds.

He didn’t the last time.

Perhaps that’s because I didn’t send along a big, busty campaign contribution. Friends tell me Jacobs always responds to them. In fact they say he even acknowledges small ones.
Stay tuned.

John

To NCICU President Williams

Readers Note: Below is the full text of a letter published recently in Duke Alumni Association’s Duke Magazine. The writer, A Hope Williams, is president of North Carolina Independent Colleges and Universities and a Duke alumna.

After Williams’ letter is a double star line followed by an email I’m sending her.

I’ll keep you posted if I hear back from Williams.

John
__________________________________

To the editor:

The most important responsibility of every college and university president is the safety of their students, faculty, and staff. When threats are made against students, as they were during the lacrosse case, those threats must be taken seriously.

Had the lacrosse season continued… and had there been violence against the students, the university would have been in an indefensible position of having placed greater value on athletics than on safety.

During the early stages of the case, President Brodhead was the one individual among those who were quoted often in the media who consistently reminded reporters and the public that under the law the accused students were presumed innocent.

Suspension of students against whom felony charges have been filed is a policy followed by most colleges and universities. The wisdom of this is self-evident. A university could put the safety of its entire community at risk by allowing students who have been charged with crimes of violence to remain in school.

As an alumna in the Triangle, I live in close proximity to the combustible atmosphere of the first months of the case, and safety was clearly an issue. As a Duke parent, I must believe that the administration will keep campus safety as its top priority.

As president of North Carolina Independent Colleges and Universities, the organization of the thirty-six private colleges and universities in the state, I have viewed President Brodhead's actions in the broader context of all higher education. Based on each of these perspectives, I strongly believe that President Brodhead made the right decisions in accordance with the policies of the university and based on the evolving legal situation. In this instance it is the local justice system through District Attorney Nifong that failed the students, the accuser, the Duke community, and the state.

A. Hope Williams '76
Raleigh, North Carolina
******************************************************************
******************************************************************

Dear President Williams:

I agree with some of the things you say in your recent Duke Magazine letter. In the circumstances of last Spring, the University’s decision to suspend Collin Finnerty and Reade Seligmann was proper. And in his public statements at the time, President Brodhead almost always asserted the importance of due process and presumption of innocence.

There’s something else important you could have said in Brodhead’s and the University’s defense: On March 24, 2006 Duke issued a statement in which, among other things, it said the players were cooperating with officals.

In its fraudulent March 25 story which gave credibility to Mangum’s, Nifong’s and DPD’s lies and fueled the witch hunt, the Raleigh News & Observer ignored Duke’s statement and instead promulgated the “wall of silence” lie. The N&O's story of what it said was an "ordeal" which ended in "sexual violence" caught the nation's attention and Duke's statement was overlooked or ignored by almost all the MSM.

There are things you say about which I’d like to ask you questions.
You say:

The most important responsibility of every college and university president is the safety of their students, faculty, and staff. When threats are made against students, as they were during the lacrosse case, those threats must be taken seriously.
Yes, threats against students must be taken very seriously.

Why then, after an angry crowd swarmed in front of a university-owned house and made threatening remarks about the students who lived there;

after the crowd waved a large “CASTRATE” banner while shouting threats;

after copies of a “Vigilante” poster targeting the 43 white Duke students pictured on it were distributed within sight of his office windows by “activists" who’d come on campus;

and after racists threatened a Duke student with physical violence as he walked to a courthouse and then within the courtroom with a death threat;

did President Brodhead say nothing critical of the perpetrators of those terrible actions and nothing supportive of his students who were the perpetrators' targeted victims?

Have you as an alumna and president of NCICU ever reminded President Brodhead of what you correctly say is “[t]he most important responsibility of every college and university?

You say:
Had the lacrosse season continued… and had there been violence against the students, the university would have been in an indefensible position of having placed greater value on athletics than on safety.
Can we agree, President Williams, that the University initially canceled two lacrosse games as a punishment for the party which the University said was a “team event?”

And can we agree that when Brodhead cancelled the rest of the season on April 5, he issued a lengthy statement in which he said nothing about concern for the lacrosse team’s safety?

Do you know when Brodhead first said he was cancelled the season out of concern for the players’ safety?

Lest this letter get unduly long, I’ll move now to a concern I want to share with you and then I’ll invite you to respond to this letter which I’m posting at my blog, John in Carolina.

All of the students targeted during the events I’ve mentioned are white but had they been black I don't think any reasonable person believes President Brodhead and the trustees would have stood by and said nothing.

I assume you agree.

If we can agree on that, then we agree Duke, as represented by its president and trustees, has a double standard when its students come under threat, and that the double standard is based on race.

Now I invite your response which I’ll publish in full at my blog.

I’ve been blogging for more than two years. You can see what it’s like by searching the archives here.

I’m copying this to Senior Vice President for Public Affairs and Government Relations John Burness for his information and in case he cares to say something in response to what I’ve said concerning President Brodhead and Duke.

I look forward to your response.

Sincerely,

John in Carolina

Sunday, September 23, 2007

Holloway's Two Race Standards

We read at Duke News:

The nooses hung from a tree at Jena High School in Louisiana were “unambiguous symbols of a vicious racial threat, linked inextricably to the ways in which white violence has historically followed blacks who sought their constitutional rights,” says a Duke University English professor and author.

The case of the 'Jena 6' has drawn considerable attention recently, and many civil rights and student groups are expected to convene in Jena this week in protest.

Last fall, white students in Jena hung the nooses from a shade tree after a black student asked to sit under it. The incident led to fights between black and white students. In December, six black teens were charged with attempted murder following one of the fights. Many feel the charges are disproportionate to the crime, and supporters have dubbed the teens the “Jena 6.”

“These nooses did not appear accidentally or by happenstance in Jena,” says Karla FC Holloway, the William R. Kenan Professor of English who also holds appointments in the law school and women’s studies department. “The students who hung the nooses worked from their presumptions of how to maintain separate and racially distinct access. They worked from their knowledge of how to signal that authority.

“The nooses are absolute indicators of the racial place of this story,” she says.

Although this seemed an incident that developed from a schoolyard fight, there is more to the story, namely the complicity of the school administrators and the school's perpetuation of a system of unequal treatment, Holloway says.[…]
There’s more to the Duke News report here.

Now you may be asking:

1) Is she the same Professor Holloway who said nothing when an angry crowd waved a “CASTRATE” banner in front of house where three men named as suspects in what turned out to be a false gang rape accusation lived?

2) Isn’t she one of the teachers who thanked “activists” who circulated the “Vigilante” poster targeting students after the school had expressed fears that such an action would add to the danger the students were already facing?

3) Didn’t she say nothing when one of the school’s students was the object of physical threats, including death threats, from a racist group who hounded him as he walked to a courthouse and then within a courtroom?

“Yes” to all three questions.

Why did Professor Holloway say nothing about the “CASTRATE” sign; thank people circulating the “Vigilante” poster; and say nothing when racists threatened the student?

The answer to that question is as easy as telling the difference between black and white.

Does anyone believe Holloway would’ve said nothing if the targeted and endangered students had been black instead of white? Or thanked people for distributing a “Vigilante” poster with face photos of 43 black Duke students on it?

Let's hope Professor Holloway will soon explain her two race standards, and how she thinks they impact her work at Duke, particularly with students under attack by racists.

Who’s Fooled by Sulzberger?

The NY Betray Us finally admits today what most of you have known for nearly two weeks.

From NYT public editor Clark Hoyt:

For nearly two weeks, The New York Times has been defending a political advertisement that critics say was an unfair shot at the American commander in Iraq.

But I think the ad violated The Times’s own written standards, and the paper now says that the advertiser got a price break it was not entitled to.

On Monday, Sept. 10, the day that Gen. David H. Petraeus came before Congress to warn against a rapid withdrawal of troops, The Times carried a full-page ad attacking his truthfulness.

Under the provocative headline “General Petraeus or General Betray Us?” the ad, purchased by the liberal activist group MoveOn.org, charged that the highly decorated Petraeus was “constantly at war with the facts” in giving upbeat assessments of progress and refusing to acknowledge that Iraq is “mired in an unwinnable religious civil war.”

“Today, before Congress and before the American people, General Petraeus is likely to become General Betray Us,” MoveOn.org declared. […]
Further along we read:
[Arthur Sulzberger Jr., the publisher of The Times and chairman of its parent company, ] said he wasn’t aware of MoveOn.org’s latest ad until it appeared in the paper. [He added:] “If we’re going to err, it’s better to err on the side of more political dialogue. ... Perhaps we did err in this case. If we did, we erred with the intent of giving greater voice to people.”[...]
Does anyone believe the NYT would have given a huge ad discount to a Right to Life group wanting to place an ad opposing abortion or a pro-Bush group that wanted to list false statements made by Democrats attacking the President?

The “family and friends” discount the Times gave Moveon.org is an example of how deeply leftist rot has seeped into what was once a very respected news organization.

Sulzberger’s response is an all too obvious obfuscation. What he’s really telling us is things aren’t going to change at the Times.

Hoyt's entire column is here.

Hat tip: Mike Williams

Why’s the N&O Attacking Newsweek?

This is a 1, 2, 3 post in which you’ll find:

1 - Excerpts from N&O managing editor John Drescher’s angry post attacking Newsweek for, according to Drescher, reading the N&O’s Duke lacrosse coverage, re-writing it and “pass[ing] it off as original reporting” in Newsweek’s June 29, 2006 story, Doubts About Duke.

2) - An email dated June 13 from Newsweek’s Susannah Meadows who, along with Evan Thomas, was bylined on the story the N&O says Newsweek “pass[ed] … off as original reporting.”

3) My comments and questions concerning the N&O’s attack on Newsweek.

Let’s begin with excerpts from Drescher’s post:

In its Sept. 10 [, 2007] issue, Newsweek takes credit for being “the first major publication to pick apart the prosecution’s case, in an article on June 29, 2006.”

That’s a stretch. Newsweek apparently doesn’t consider The N&O a major publication because there was little in that late June package that had not already been in The N&O. […]
Drescher went on to say that by June 29, 2006 the “ N&O had published a half-dozen articles showing problems with the prosecution’s case,” citing publication dates from April 22 through June 24.

Drescher then hurled one of the most serious accusations one news organization can hurl at another:
Newsweek can beat its chest all it wants to and claim it “was the first major publication to pick apart the prosecution’s case.” A more accurate description would be it was the first national publication to read The N&O’s coverage, re-write it and pass it off as original reporting.
Now let’s look at a June 13 email Newsweek’s Susannah Meadows sent to then Durham DA Mike Nifong:
From: Susannah.Meadows[meadows]@mycingular.blackberry.net
To: Michael.b.nifong
Sent: Tuesday, 13 June 2006 2:46pm ET
Subject: Possible cover story

Dear Mike,

I've been going over these documents in the duke rape case. And I have to tell you that they raise questions about was known while you were making certain assertions. Please can we talk about this.
I'm not asking that you comment on anything that isn't public.

We're getting ready to do a big story about this, possibly on the cover, about how certain things were said in public when the facts were known to be different. We won't close the issue until saturday morning.

Please think about commenting. As it appears now, it doesn't look good. But I'm sure that's because we haven't heard your side. I can be reached at ___________ I'll be in durham tomorrow night trough friday.

all the best, susannah meadows
A hat tip to The Johnsville News in whose archives I found Meadows’ email.

Comments and Questions:

Folks, I don’t know which “major publication” deserves the prize for being first “to pick apart the prosecution case.”

I’ll leave the judging on that “race” to the N&O, Newsweek and anyone else who cares to join in.

I feel about that “race” the same way many of you do: major publications were unconscionably slow to start picking apart Nifong’s case. Almost all of them were Nifong enablers for weeks and, in some cases, many months.

Instead of disputing who was first at something they were very late in doing, major publications should examine and report why a few journalists, some bloggers, and many sensible citizens began picking Nifong’s case apart within days of the N&O presenting it on March 25, 2006 in a front-page story headlined without any qualifying quotes suggesting doubt:
Dancer gives details of ordeal
I’ve posted in more detail on both the “me first” major publication claim and individuals and blogs who were shredding Nifong’s case before the end of April. See Newsweek’s Thomas Shouldn’t Cluck (9/2/07) and Take a bow, La Shawn Barber (9/18/07).

Read the N&O stories Drescher links to and cites to support his slime of Meadows, Thomas and Newsweek. See whether you can find anything much in them that wasn’t part of the public record and available at many blogs and news organizations at the time the N&O published them.

Example: The April 22 N&O story Drescher cites, DA on the spot for comments , tells readers:
“Defense lawyers and legal experts say District Attorney Mike Nifong may have crossed ethical lines in public comments about rape allegations involving Duke University lacrosse players, potentially prejudicing jurors and setting off a media maelstrom.”
On April 22 that wasn’t exactly “an N&O exclusive report of breaking news,” was it?

A responsible news organization making the extremely serious charges the N&O is making about Newsweek’s June 29 story would cite to support its charges numerous specific examples of news items Newsweek could only have taken from the N&O. That Drescher and the N&O don’t cite even one such example tells us a great deal about him and the N&O. What a newspaper!

Also telling is Susannah Meadows’ email to Nifong. She didn’t copy that from the N&O. She was trying hard to get an interview with Nifong for the June 29 story Drescher charges Newsweek plagiarized from the N&O.

Meadows didn’t get the interview. Instead, she got back from Nifong what The Johnsville News called a ”rambling, long winded, email rant.” Nifong also issued a press release attacking the Newsweek story. You can read all the documents at this TJN post.

Meadows’ “digging” for that interview was what a good reporter does. I salute her for that.

But that wasn’t the only instance in which Meadows and Newsweek did some “digging.”

On June 12, 2006 I posted Newsweek abandons sinking Nifong. The post was based on a Meadows’ Periscope article that appeared in Newsweek’s June 19 print editon, but was written and available on the net days before; hence my posting of it on June 12.

The post contains a link to Meadows’ Periscope article, Lacrosse Scandal: The Duke Accuser – New Credibility Questions.

Read Meadows’ Periscope article and you’ll see it contains reporting of events which appear again in Meadows’ and Thomas’ June 29 article. You’ll see that Meadows is careful to say in the Periscope article that some of the news she reports is “according to a motion filled by defense attorneys last week.” You’ll read that some of the news provided in the story was obtained during a Newsweek interview with Kim Roberts. And you see that Newsweek says it tried to get Nifong on the record for that story just as Meadows tried to do for its June 29 story.

JinC Regulars know I’m not a Newsweek fan. But fair is fair.

There’s nothing I could find that lends any credibility to the N&O’s attack on Newsweek.

And there’s evidence Newsweek did significant independent work – the Roberts interview, repeated efforts to get Nifong on the record – for its June 29 story.

Message to Drescher and the N&O: You owe Newsweek and your blog readers an apology and explanation.

Message to Meadows, Thomas and Newsweek: I'm sorry you're being punished for your “good deed” June 29 story. You’re owed an apology, but as JinC readers often tell me when I call on the N&O to apologize for something it’s done that would embarrass decent journalists: “Don’t hold your breath.”

Question for readers: Why do you think the N&O decided to attack Newsday at this time and on that particular story?

Friday, September 21, 2007

The Churchill Series - Sept. 21, 2007

(One of a series of weekday posts on the life of Winston S. Churchill.)

Yesterday we talked about Churchill and Greta Garbo. She was one of a number of Hollywood luminaries Churchill befriended. Charlie Chaplin was another.

Off the top of my head and in a hurry for which I apologize, I offer the following:

Churchill and Chaplin met at a reception while Churchill was on a trip to California in October 1929. They seemed to have struck up a friendship almost immediately.

The two men had a common interest in Napoleon. Chaplin wanted to play Napoleon in a movie; Churchill had for many years wanted to write the Emperor’s biography. The two men discussed then, and for some years afterward, Churchill writing the screen play for the movie in which Chaplin would star. But nothing came of it.

During the 30s Chaplin was invited a number of times to lunch at Chartwell.

Churchill, of course, was aware of Chaplin's far-left politics but didn't let that get in the way of their friendship. He once described Chaplin as " bolshy in politics - delightful in conversation."

While I'm not citing sources today because of my hurry, I'll vouch for everything I've just said. But the amusing anecdote I'm about to relate I can't vouch for. I tell it in the spirit of "why let facts get in the way of a harmless, funny story" and with the intent of starting your weekends with a smile.

It seems that Chaplin and Churchill once had the following exchange:

Chaplin: "I'm thinking about making a movie on the life of Christ and playing the lead."

Churchill: "Have you cleared the rights?"

Have a nice weekend.

John

About Thompson’s Wife

You know former Senator Fred Thompson’s seeking the GOP presidential nomination.

In this C-SPAN clip, he makes a statement about his wife.

View and listen. See if you agree with what Thompson says.

Reuters: Caught Again

James Taranto at Best of the Web Today offers the following post, Dead Metaphor , after which I make a few comments below the star line ---
____________________________________________________

Here is a story to brighten your weekend: Early this afternoon we received an email from one of our most loyal readers. We'll withhold his name, because our purpose here isn't to make him look silly.

Suffice it to say that he writes us several times a week, his nickname for President Bush is "Chimpy," and the following message, which we quote verbatim is actually quite a bit more temperate than his usual fare:

No wonder the entire world sees this fool for the complete moron that he is.

I now see that his supporters, such as your august self, have truly, really, fundamentally no shame and no sense of embarrassment. Bush makes us all look like dopes--after all he was elected twice (ooops, make that stole the election twice--my bad)

If only his idiot gaffs were the worst of it...

He is truly worthless as a president and as a man!
Our correspondent sent us a link to a blog called First Draft, in which someone styling himself "Holden Caulfield" says of the president, "Christ, what a dumbass," and links to the following Reuters dispatch:
Nelson Mandela is still very much alive despite an embarrassing gaffe by U.S. President George W. Bush, who alluded to the former South African leader's death in an attempt to explain sectarian violence in Iraq.

"It's out there. All we can do is reassure people, especially South Africans, that President Mandela is alive," Achmat Dangor, chief executive officer of the Nelson Mandela Foundation, said as Bush's comments received worldwide coverage. . . .

"I heard somebody say, Where's Mandela?' Well, Mandela's dead because Saddam Hussein killed all the Mandelas," Bush, who has a reputation for verbal faux pas, said in a press conference in Washington on Thursday. . . .

References to his death--Mandela is now 89 and increasingly frail--are seen as insensitive in South Africa.
So, what did President Bush actually say? Here's the quote in context, from the White House transcript:
Part of the reason why there is not this instant democracy in Iraq is because people are still recovering from Saddam Hussein's brutal rule. I thought an interesting comment was made when somebody said to me, I heard somebody say, where's Mandela? Well, Mandela is dead, because Saddam Hussein killed all the Mandelas. He was a brutal tyrant that divided people up and split families, and people are recovering from this.

So there's a psychological recovery that is taking place. And it's hard work for them. And I understand it's hard work for them. Having said that, I'm not going the give them a pass when it comes to the central government's reconciliation efforts.
In this context, it is clear that the literal meaning of "Where's Mandela? is "Where is the Iraqi who will play the role in his country that Mandela played in postapartheid South Africa?" This was a pithy metaphor, not an "embarrassing gaffe."

Now, how did Reuters get the story wrong?

There are, it seems to us, three explanations:

o Stupidity. The reporter was so bone-headedly literal-minded that he simply did not understand the rhetorical device Bush was employing.

o Laziness. The reporter wasn't actually at the press conference and didn't bother to check the context of the quote.

o Dishonesty. The reporter knew full well that Bush was speaking metaphorically and deliberately twisted his meaning in order to fit the stereotype that Bush "has a reputation for verbal faux pas."

In the case of the particular Reuters dispatch "Caulfield" links to, laziness is the most likely answer. It's datelined Johannesburg, so the reporter surely was not at the press conference. But ultimately the explanation for the "worldwide coverage" this "gaffe" has received is either stupidity or dishonesty.

Some journalist either failed to understand or deliberately misrepresented Bush's remark.

And the joke is on people like our Bush-hating correspondent, who gullibly eat this stuff up.

**************************************************************************

About Taranto's "most loyal" reader who calls President Bush "Chimpy:"

I wonder whether he knows "Monkey" and "old Ape" were two of the slurs often used by President Lincoln's enemies?

I also wonder whether Taranto's "most loyal" reader knows he comes across as kind of - how to put this - "Chumpy?"

Message to Taranto: Terrific post

Message to JinC readers: I'll post again tomorrow on Taranto's post.

Hat tip: AC

Jesse Jackson, Obama & “Hymies”

Wednesday a South Carolina newspaper reported:

Jackson sharply criticized presidential hopeful and Illinois Sen. Barack Obama for “acting like he’s white” in what Jackson said has been a tepid response to six black juveniles’ arrest on attempted-murder charges in Jena, La. Jackson, who also lives in Illinois, endorsed Obama in March, according to The Associated Press.
The entire story’s here.

Today we read that Jackson new denies saying Obama was “acting like he’s white,” but the newspaper that carried the original report is standing by its report. You can read that story here.

The above reminded me of 1984 and Jackson’s reference to Jews as “hymies” and his reference to New York as “Hymietown.”

When called out for making the anit-Semitic slurs Jackson at first vigourously denied doing that. Then when he learned there was a tape of his remarks, he decidiced to “have pray” with Jewish bretheren.

Here’s the Washington Posts summerary of what happened:
Jesse Jackson's 'Hymietown' Remark – 1984

Rev. Jesse Jackson referred to Jews as "Hymies" and to New York City as "Hymietown" in January 1984 during a conversation with a black Washington Post reporter, Milton Coleman.

Jackson had assumed the references would not be printed because of his racial bond with Coleman, but several weeks later Coleman permitted the slurs to be included far down in an article by another Post reporter on Jackson's rocky relations with American Jews.

A storm of protest erupted, and Jackson at first denied the remarks, then accused Jews of conspiring to defeat him. The Nation of Islam's radical leader Louis Farrakhan, an aggressive anti-Semite and old Jackson ally, made a difficult situation worse by threatening Coleman in a radio broadcast and issuing a public warning to Jews, made in Jackson's presence: "If you harm this brother [Jackson], it will be the last one you harm."

Finally, Jackson doused the fires in late February with an emotional speech admitting guilt and seeking atonement before national Jewish leaders in a Manchester, New Hampshire synagogue.

Yet Jackson refused to denounce Farrakhan, and lingering, deeply rooted suspicions have led to an enduring split between Jackson and many Jews. The frenzy also heightened tensions between Jackson and the mostly white establishment press.
I've got travel connections now, but I'll say more about this post tomorrow.

N&O Now Lashes Out at JinC

Yesterday I posted N&O Lashes Out at Newsweek . My post concerned the N&O's ego-driven snit-fight with Newsweek over the two publicaions Duke lacrosse coverage. N&O managing editor John Drescher all but said yesterday that Newsweek had plagerized N&O reporting:

Newsweek can beat its chest all it wants to and claim it “was the first major publication to pick apart the prosecution’s case.” A more accurate description would be it was the first national publication to read The N&O’s coverage, re-write it and pass it off as original reporting.
There was more from the N&O. You can read it here.

Newsweek hasn’t responded but you can be sure it will.

Let’s all keep our eyes out for its response. This should be an interesting story for people following either the Duke Hoax, journalism or both.

While we wait for Newsweeks’ response, there’s more N&O lashing out news to report.

And would you believe that this time the N&O is targeting not a major publication that's part of a multi-billion dollar news empire but a little blog in North Carolina, JohninCarolina.com.

You can read about it below. You’ll see a post I left on the thread of Drescher’s post in which I try to tell Drescher what I think decent people want to see happen. That so upset the N&O that Melanie Sill, the N&O’s executive editor for news steped in and said false things about me. You can read the responses which follow Melanie's in character falsehoods, including one I’ve just left further down the thread of Drescher’s post.

I have a heavy travel day today but I’ll be back to this be the weekend at the latest.

Stay tuned.

John
_________________________



Comment from: John in Carolina [Visitor]
09/20/07 at 15:22
Dear Editor Drescher:

Because you don't have a hyperlink option I'm including this URL which contains hyperlinks for the comment which follows.

http://johninnorthcarolina.blogspot.com/2007/09/n-lashes-out-at-newsweek.html

You say:

"Newsweek can beat its chest all it wants to and claim it 'was the first major publication to pick apart the prosecution’s case.'

A more accurate description would be it was the first national publication to read The N&O’s coverage, re-write it and pass it off as original reporting.

As I said in a JinC Sept. 2 post, Newsweeks' Thomas Shouldn't Cluck , I didn’t want to get into trying to decide which was the “first major publication to pick apart the prosecution case.”

What I know for sure is that both Newsweek and the N&O were very late in doing that.

You were both well behind journalists such as La Shawn Barber, Thomas Sowell and Stuart Taylor, and blogs and bloggers such as KC Johnson, Lead and Gold, RealClearPolitics, and The Johnsville News, to name just a few of many.

I just looked at a JinC post from April 9, 2006, which included a comment I sent executive editor for news Melanie Sill asking why four weeks after the alleged crimes on the night of March 13/14, there were no suspect descriptions beyond “white male” and why the N&O had not asked Nifong about that and whether the accuser had been able to make a positive ID of any of her alleged attackers.

But, Editor Drescher, you’re right the N&O did have many “firsts” concerning important aspects of what was then called “the Duke lacrosse rape scandal.”

In your March 24 report which “broke” the “Duke lacrosse story,” you repeatedly referred to Crystal Mangum as “the victim” and thereby cast the Duke students as her victimizers.

That’s an undisputed N&O first and most of MSM rushed along to follow your framing of the players as the victimizers.

On March 25 the N&O was the first newspaper to report Mangum was new to stripping, even though you knew from your own reporting in 2002 of crimes she’d committed that she was strip dancing at least by then. You didn’t report that or her criminal background.

You were the first major news organization to have that information and fail to report it for weeks.

On March 25 you also had the critically important news Mangum told you that the second dancer had also been raped at the party, but hadn’t reported it to police for fear of losing her job, as well as the statement she made to you that she thought the second dancer would “do anything for money.”

You failed to report that news, so extraordinarily exculpatory for the players. And what is worse by many magnitudes of mendaciousness, you covered it up for thirteen months as you watched the players and their families endure an horrific ordeal while you sold newspapers every day of those thirteen months.

No other major publication, not even justly reviled NY Times and Durham Herald Sun did anything as harmful to innocent individuals and our community as the N&O’s withholding of the exculpatory information.

One more “first and only” for the N&O and then I’m done.

On April 2, 2006 the N&O published a photo of the “Vigilante” poster large enough so that anyone, including unstable and dangerous people, could enlarge it and have face photos of the 43 white Duke students pictured on it.

The N&O published the photo after Duke had expressed concerns that doing so would add to the already considerable danger the players were facing. Did Newsweek or any Noth Carolina daily do that?

I think you can credit the N&O with a "first and only" on that. Even the justly reviled NY Times and Durham Herald Sun didn't publish such a photo.

Editor Drescher, instead of getting into an ego-driven snit-fight with Newsweek, the N&O would better serve truth, the community and its own long-term interests if you do the following:

1) Publish a detailed story which holds nothing back in explaining why you withheld for 13 months the exculpatory news Mangum gave you on March 24 and what it was like for N&O staffers to watch the players indicted, threatened, and savaged by most major publications while you were sitting on news that could have changed all that.

2) Retract your March 25 story which you told readers was about an “ordeal” that ended in “sexual violence.” You and the informed public know it was based almost entirely on lies.

3) Publish on your front-page a detailed account of how the fraudulent March 25 story was created, including an explanation of why you left out of it the news you had of the players’ cooperation with police, an explanation of how you came to get the interview with Mangum, and acknowledgment of whatever involvement Nifong and others working the attempted frame-up had to do, as anonymous sources, with the story.

4) Issue a full, unconditional apology to the players, their families, Coach Mike Pressler and his family, who were the people most harmed by your story.

5) Apologize to your readers and the rest of the media whom you deliberately misled.

6) Apologize for publishing the "Vigilante" poster and assure everyone that the people responsible for publishing it no longer work for the N&O or any other McClatchy publication.

Thank you for reading this comment.

I look forward to your response which I’ll copy and post at JinC.

Sincerely,

John in Carolina

Comment from: Melanie Sill [Member] • http://www.newsobserver.com
09/20/07 at 16:52

John, there will be no further N&O response to your accusations, which include greater distortions with each repetition. We have responded repeatedly; see previous posts under category of Duke lacrosse coverage to see accusations and responses.

Comment from: PD Smart via Darby via JinC [Visitor]
09/20/07 at 19:46

Dear Melanie,

I am a south African who has followed the Duke Lacrosse since its inception. I have a question for you:

Why are you seemingly incapable of responding in a reasonable manner to the post above by JinC? It is a well researched, well written and asks questions most reasonable readers would like answers to.

From what I have read of your responses to others who offer a critique (all I have seen seem too well mannered and cogent to be considered a criticism),of articles written by yourself or other N&O staffers you seem only capable of responding that they "border on harassment"!

Why is this? Surely someone as well educated as yourself must be a little more articulate that that. Your readers deserve better!

PD Smart
Johannesburg
South Africa

Comment from: Melanie Sill [Member] • http://www.newsobserver.com
09/20/07 at 21:58

Mr. Smart -- We have responded politely to JinC's accusations numerous times. Please refer to posts under the Duke lacrosse category. Thanks.

Comment from: Walter Abbott [Visitor]
09/21/07 at 06:44

Melanie,

You have done no such thing. Your "response" merely has been to say that your early reporting "could have been better" and that the reason you withheld exculpatory information from the 3/25/06 story was that "you couldn't confirm it."

For the record, the exculpatory information was that Crystal Mangum told your interviewer that Kim Roberts was also raped. Had you put that in the story, everyone would have known from the get-go that Mangum's wild tales were flakey. She told everyone she talked to a different story.

And you knew this.

Yet because you and your newspaper chose to print lies, a lynching almost took place, three men's lives were put on hold for a year, and Durham's taxpayers are on the hook for a lot of money.

You and your newspaper have a lot to answer for. And you will, sooner or later.


Comment from: John in Carolina [Visitor]

09/21/07 at 11:46
Folks,

Because there's no hyperlink option for commenters, here's a URL to a comment I left at this blog in April to a post by Dep. Managing Editor Dan Barkin, who never responded to to.

http://blogs.newsobserver.com/editor/index.php?title=the_environment_a_call_for_ideas_1&more=1&c=1&tb=1&pb=1

Comment _________________

After Duke had expressed concerns about the lacrosse players’ safety, the N&O want ahead and published anonymously on April 2, 2006, a Sunday, your highest circulation day, the “Vigilante” poster photo containing face photos of 43 white lacrosse players, all identified by name.

Although exec editor Melanie Sill has said it was only a “small” photo, it was actually two columns wide, 7.25 inches long, and placed on the most prominent part of the page: top right-center (the 4th and 5th columns of a 6 column page).

I’m told that because of the size of your “Vigilante” poster photo, those seeking to identify and target the students could easily enlarge your photo with a very good resolution that would allow for easy recognition of the players.

On the same day you published the “Vigilante” poster, you ran a story reporting that Duke VP for Student Affairs Larry Moneta had taken the extraordinary but, in my opinion, reasonable step of cautioning Duke students about their safety after attacks on Duke students and a rumor of a possible drive-by shooting.

After Duke had expressed particular concerns for the safety of the lacrosse players and right at the time Moneta was warning all students about threats to their safety, the N&O published its “Vigilante” poster photo.

The N&O knew or should have known it was adding to the endangerment of all Duke students; and particularly to the danger the students pictured on your anonymous “Vigilante” poster photo already faced, forty-three young people, many still in their teens.
_________________________________________

To Melanie and John Drescher: Besides the fact the what you just read is an accurate description of what the N&O did, is there anything else about it that would make you criticize?

To everyone else: Thank you for your intelligent and supportive comments.

If enough of us speak up and refuse to accept its nonsense ,the N&O may improve.

It may even get to a point where it will never again inflict on our community the false, racially-inflammatory coverage and cover-up which did do much to launch and sustain for thirteen months the obviously fraudulent indictments of three innocent young men.

Let’s work to improve the N&O and dream of a better future in which the N&O treats members of all races fairly.

Sincerely,

John in Carolina

Thursday, September 20, 2007

The Churchill Series – Sept. 20, 2007

(One of a series of weekday posts on the life of Winston S. Churchill.)

Readers Note: Some of you left note expressing understanding at my need to cancel yesterday. Thank you very much.

John
___________________________________________

Now Churchill and Garbo.

Churchill had been a movie fan from before the days of talkies. If he really liked a movie, it wasn’t unusual for him to see it five or more times. Charlie Chaplin was one of his favorite actors. There was no question as to his favorite movie actress: Garbo.

In Memories and Adventures (Weidenfield & Nicolson, 1989) Churchill’s grandson and namesake, tells an amusing and touching anecdote about Churchill and the great, enigmatic Garbo:

Grandpapa invited me to spend a few days with him as his guest at the Hotel de Paris in Monte Carlo. One evening we dined with his friend, the Greek shipping tycoon, Aristotle Onassis, at a suburb restaurant called the Chateau de Madrid. Among the guests at the dinner were Greta Garbo and her friend and confidant George Schley.

There is no doubt that my grandfather enjoyed the company of beautiful women. He had been an ardent fan of Miss Garbo since her early screen successes and had seen all her movies many times, Queen Christiana and Ninotchka being special favourites. Though the years had taken their toll and she had become something of a recluse, she was still a wonderful-looking woman. Grandpapa remained in thrall to her as well as, no doubt, to the memory of what she had been.

We were sitting at the table closest to the window. ….

All at once, in the middle of dinner, Miss Garbo, seated on Grandpapa’s right, announced she had a problem. Toward the end of his life my grandfather had difficulty hearing … and Onassis, whenever he was with him, would stand ready to relay the conversation.

“What did Miss Garbo say?” enquired my Grandfather solicitously. Onassis, replying in excellent English, but laced with a heavy Greek accent, answered in a loud voice so that he could be heard: “Miss Garbo, she say, she is too hot in her long … underpants, so she proposes to take them off.”

This announcement caused quite a stir among diners at the immediate adjacent tables. Grandpapa, not sure if he had heard quite right, asked in a tone of some surprise; “What did Miss Garbo say?”

Onassis ever eager to be helpful, repeated once again what he had already said, but with even greater deliberation. By now the eyes of the whole restaurant were riveted on our table as Miss Garbo proceeded to execute a most discreet striptease beneath the tablecloth while Grandpapa patted her gently on the knee, intoning: “Poor lamb, poor lamb” as the offending garment was removed. (pgs. 115-116)