Monday, December 18, 2006

A real editor for Durham

Two years ago this time the locally owned Durham Herald Sun was one of the most respected community newspapers in the South, if not the nation.

It was then purchased by the privately held Paducah, Kentucky based Paxton Media Group which immediately dismissed dozens of dedicated, talented H-S journalists and other staffers.

Paxton sent Bob Ashley (Duke ’70) to Durham to run the newspaper. “Just wait until you see what I’ll do with the paper,” Ashley told the community.

Today, anyone in Durham with at least a room temperature IQ can see what
Ashley’s done with a once fine newspaper: TRAIN WRECK!

So much for bad news.

Now the good news.

James Robert (Bob) Wilson has agreed to start posting here.

If you know Bob Wilson, I’ll bet you’re smiling already unless you’re someone who says:

“No, really, it’s all just because Mike believes in her. I’ll even tell the Feds that.”
Bob Wilson’s one of North Carolina’s most respected journalists. From 1991 until Paxton/Ashley took over, Bob was the H-S’s editorial pages editor. Like so many others, Bob was let go.

But Bob was just a few months shy of retirement; and he and his wife Betty had been savers. So they now enjoy a nice retirement here in Durham and down on North Carolina’s coast.

For the last two years, I’ve been nudging Bob to “go public.” But he’s been reluctant to get back into the tangled web of “doings in Durham.” Who can blame him?

But with the collapse of the H-S as a serious newspaper, and the silence of Duke and Durham’s leaders in the face of DA Nifong’s travesties, Bob’s no longer willing to remain silent.

He and I haven’t worked out how often he’ll post at JinC or how we’ll distinguish his posts from mine but…

[Please, John, stop talking. You and Bob can work all that out later. What we want now is to hear from Bob.]

OK, folks, sorry to hold things up.

Here’s Bob:
________________

John said, “Just start right in.” I’ll do that and hope you stay with me.

The Durham Herald-Sun, where I served as editor of the editorial pages, is trashing the canons of responsible journalism.

Under editor Bob Ashley, The Herald Sun has become not only a shill for District Attorney Mike Nifong, but also a harsh voice for the Red Guards’-style “justice” preached by Duke University’s faculty Group of 88.

The Herald-Sun has conveniently disregarded, even disparaged, the bedrock principles and rights of English and American common law, including the principle that any one of us accused by the state is innocent until proved guilty.

In The Herald-Sun's twisted interpretation of the legal principles and individual rights most Americans still hold dear, three young men – David Evans, Collin Finnerty and Reade Seligmann -- indicted following a sham investigation, must now prove their innocence in court.

How did The Herald Sun get such important principles and rights so wrong?

Under America’s laws those three young men don't have to prove anything. The burden of proof is on the prosecution.

But the fact that there is no evidence whatsoever that the players committed rape during a team party in March is of no consequence to Nifong, Ashley and their enablers.

Evans, Finnerty and Seligmann are being persecuted -- I use that word deliberately -- not for anything they've done, but for who they are.

That’s a chilling turn of events, one that should concern every resident of Durham and anyone else who cares about justice.

What’s being done to those three young men is so chilling and so perverted that I’ll no longer be a silent witness to Mike Nifong's malicious, possibly criminal, disregard of justice and The Herald-Sun's cheerleading for him.

I appreciate you’re reading what I’ve said. I look forward to reading your comments.

Bob Wilson
_______________________________

Welcome back, Bob.

20 comments:

Anonymous said...

Excellent get, John. Look forward to Mr. Wilson's input.

Walter Abbott

Anonymous said...

Welcome Bob! I could not agree more with your comments. Thank goodness there are still some voices of reason in Durham (I was beginning to wonder). Thank you for speaking out.

DD

Anonymous said...

Thank you, John, for all your fine ongoing work, and now for bringing Bob Wilson in to speak out. Looking forward to hearing from you guys as often as you can find time to post. Best wishes, sic semper tyrannis

Anonymous said...

John and Mr. Wilson,
First of all, thanks to John for having Mr. Wilson. I used to live in the Triangle area and read the Herald-Sun and always found it to be a very good paper. Perhaps that is what has been such a shock reading the garbage that I've read during the past nine months or so. It took me a while to realize that the paper had been sold - what a shame to find out so many qualified people lost their jobs.
I completely agreed with your remarks, Mr. Wilson, and like the other posters appreciate you speaking up. Look forward to reading further comments from you.
Keep up the good work John!

Anonymous said...

That was the one element that I have been so taken back about. The RESIDENTS of Durham have enabled this HOAX all the while NOT getting the big picture here. IF NIfong can TRY and squash three innocent boys that can bring in the big guns, what would he do to his own citizens. With Bob back, maybe, just maybe they will finally 'get it'. WAKE UP DURHAM!!!

Anonymous said...

Thanks John

Mr. Bob Wilson, I sincerely hope to read MUCH more from you.

Thanks,

Kent

Anonymous said...

Bob, I want to hear more!

Greg Toombs said...

Bob-

I'm glad you have decided to contribute to righting this wrong.

Please be careful during your time in Durham. I'm sure the PD would like to nab you for a speeding ticket or two, or having a wine bottle in the car on your way home from the store.

Anonymous said...

Thank you Bob for providing insight and knowledge that only you can have. I look forward to your comments and know that they will contribute greatly to the debate.

Anonymous said...

The "Red Guards" comment truly was spot on, and I admit to having missed that idea in all of my writings on the Duke faculty. All I could say when I finished reading this was to think of the H-S people and the Duke Gang of 88 and administration and mutter, "God help you."

Thank you for Mr. Wilson's insightful comments. Had decent people been in charge there, this whole thing might have been different. Instead, the H-S has been command central for Nifong's propaganda.

Anonymous said...

Thanks for speaking out, Bob. I'm looking forward to all your comments on the case.

Anonymous said...

Mr. Wilson, Bless you for your courage in speaking out!
You have my most sincere admiration as does JinC. I'll be eagerly watching for your posts!

Anonymous said...

Outstanding post, Bob. And kudos to John for his recruiting efforts.

Great to have another strong voice in the fight!

Anonymous said...

Mr. Wilson:

Are there any leaders left
in Durham? What's your
take on Mayor Bell?

Thanks.

Anonymous said...

Anonymous 2:27 asked if there are any leaders left in Durham. Yes, there are potential leaders in abundance. Unfortunately, Durham's sulfurous political atmosphere, much of it generated by seemingly intractable racial polarization, keeps many of these otherwise civic-minded people away from public service.

One to keep an eye on is Councilman Eugene Brown. He's a Durham native and a Duke graduate with the maturity and ability to help lead Durham into the sunlit uplands (thanks to Sir Winston for the phrase).

Bill Bell is a thoughtful guy, but he hasn't shown the moxie that Durham's civil society so badly needs. Too bad, because Bell did fine work as a county commissioner.

Anonymous said...

Bob Wilson:

Thank you for joining the discussion here.

I wouls be very interested in your take on today's (12/19) H-S editorial "Allow judicial process to work".

It seems to have eluded the writer that seeking to have this case dismissed, or the venue changed, is certaibly a part of the 'judicial process'.

I don't think there is any hope for the H-S. This lastest editorial is myopic, obtuse, and disgusting.

Anonymous said...

I wonder how much longer the H-S's circulation will be larger than JinC.com's readership.

You can take the company out of Paducah....

Anonymous said...

Bob Wilson:

Forgot to add - how do you think the current editorial staff feels about their paper being cited in a Change of Venue Motion, especially when the cites cover 8 pages (18-25) and 19 paragraphs (44-62).

Almost 20 instances of H-S coverage or editorials cited as having poisoned the jury pool.

Anonymous said...

Bob Wilson:

Bob, if you've been talking to JiC for some time about contributing to his blog, you're probably aware of the other memebers of the pantheon of DukeLAX blogs.

Here are the recent entries on the 12/19 H-S editorial from 2 of them - Crystal Mess & LieStoppers, respectively:

Dec 19 - Ashley? He Just Went Along For the Ride

Dec 20 - Our Collective Voice - Praise for Propaganda Bob

LieStoppers takes the intelectual approach on this one, CS is more... global thermo-nuclear war, shall we say? lol

Glad you're here, Bob.

Anonymous said...

I've been off the grid for a couple of days, so before I go to gprestonian's question about the Dec. 19 H-S editorial, I should note how much I appreciate Joan Foster's kind remarks.

I nominate her for Mistress of the Revels. Writing satire that hits home is tough work, but Joan makes it seem effortless.

The Dec. 19 H-S editorial struck me as boilerplate, notable only because it revealed such an abysmal understanding of the judicial process.

Of course, there is much more to it than the big-ticket items such as indictments, trials and convictions. Dismissal of a flawed case is part of the process, too, and as we know, there is plenty of justification for summary dismissal of the Duke lax case. Like any other hoax, there is no there there.

The N&O's editorial crew has, at long last, begun to come around to that viewpoint. Today's editorial is the first substantial expression of concern on the part of Editorial Editor Steve Ford and Publisher Orage Quarrels regarding prosecutorial misconduct and related issues. (Like most other newspapers its size, the N&O's editorial page editor reports to the publisher, not to the executive editor.)

Why it has taken nine months for the N&O's editorial crew to wake up to reality is a question that I hope will be answered someday. But for now, better late than never.

It is likely that Steve Ford could not wait any longer to join the fray. Implosion of a hoax does concentrate the mind, especially when you have been silent for so long on one of the watershed events in the history of American journalism.

I suppose Bob Ashley's Herald-Sun will ride this horse over the cliff with Mike Nifong. The hour is so late for the H-S that whatever it does now cannot restore the newspaper's credibility or staff morale. Seeing your newspaper cited 20 times in a legal proceeding for reckless and prejudicial conduct is, like an encounter with a skunk, an event with results that cannot be hidden.

In the end, all a newspaper possesses is its credibility. Lose that and you're toast. Which helps explain that charred smell coming out of 2828 Pickett Road in Durham.