Folks,
A lot of comments have been posted that I want to respond to, but like the young Augustine asking God to make him chaste: not now.
Later today I will.
If you have time, I hope you take a look at the comment threads of the posts this past week. There is a great deal of outstanding commentary there as well as some humor.
I'll be back late this afternoon.
John
Sunday, December 21, 2008
Note to JinC Regulars & Commenters
Posted by JWM at 1:30 PM 0 comments
N&O’s public editor today & my response
The McClatchy Company’s Raleigh News & Observer’s public editor Ted Vaden, who self-describes as “the readers’ advocate,” begins his print column today - - -
The News & Observer spent weeks trying to get Gov. Mike Easley to talk on the record about the state's probation system, which the paper examined critically in a three-part series this month. …
Steve Riley, the N&O senior editor who edited the series, said Easley's response did not address the core issue raised by the series, "which is the quality of the supervision of the killers they were charged with supervising."
Riley noted that the state has refused to release records of 2,200 criminals who committed serious crimes, including 580 murders, while they were on probation. (emphasis added)
The rest of Vaden’s column's here.
*************************************************************
Comments:
The N&O wants the state to release certain individuals’ probation records.
But it won’t produce what Vaden and other senior N&O editors told readers is the “police report” it relied on for its Mar. 25, 2006 page one, above the fold story with five-column-wide headlines:
Dancer gives details of ordealThat’s the story that laid out both the essential material to be used in the slander and libeling of the entire Duke 2006 Men’s lacrosse team and “the script” to be used for the public portion of the frame-up attempt.
A woman hired to dance for the Duke lacrosse team describes a night of racial slurs, growing fear and, finally, sexual violence
The N&O’s deliberately fraudulent, now discredited story included this:
The thought she would be dancing for five men at a bachelor party, she said Friday. But when she arrived that night, she found herself surrounded by more than 40.In Vaden’s Apr. 2, 2006 column he told readers:
Just moments after [the woman who says she was raped last week by three members of the Duke University lacrosse team} and another exotic dancer started to perform, she said, men in the house started barking racial slurs. The two women, both black, stopped dancing.
"We started to cry," she said. "We were so scared."
… But let's talk more about the anonymous interview. [Editor Linda] Williams said editors and the reporter discussed the fairness issue at length before interviewing the woman and publishing the story.Vaden’s right about one thing: the “police report” he mentions, if it existed, would be a public record.
The governing decision, she said, was to print only information from the interview that conformed with the police reports. "We limited for publication the statements from the woman that were in line with what she said in the police report," Williams said. (all emphases added) …
In this case, as Williams pointed out, the story used only information from the interview that corroborated the public record, so it didn't add new facts. …
But in the now almost three years since the N&O published its phony Mar. 25 story about “a night of racial slurs, growing fear and, finally, sexual violence,” the N&O's never produced its “police report.”
Except for the N&O’s attribution to Crystal Mangum of “racial slurs” being “bark[ed]” at her and the other dancer, no one who was in the house that night, including the other dancer, has said there were any racial slurs made inside the house.
Except for the N&O, I know of no one, including NC's attorney general, who’s investigated the case evidence and reported finding a police report containing a charge by Mangum or anyone else that racial slurs were barked inside the house at the dancers.
I left the following comment on Vaden’s column thread:
Yes, the Easley interview should have been on page one.
As for making public records available, you said the Mar. 25, 2006 "anonymous interview" with the Duke false accuser stuck strictly to "the police report." The N&O reported she said men inside the house surrounded her and barked racial slurs. But that's in no police report anyone's ever found.
Produce that "police report" or admit there never was a “police report” that fit with the N&O’s story before asking the Governor for other public records.
Isn't that the least a "readers' advocate" should do?
John in Carolina
Update: In my comment to Vaden instead of saying "asking the Governor for other public records" I should have said: "asking the Governor to make public other government records not now public."
Posted by JWM at 12:50 PM 1 comments
Why did Duke’s trustees enable the frame-up attempt?
I can understand why Duke’s trustees went along with investments in hedge funds.
Big rewards, at least until recently.
And we can all understand why the trustees are now spending many millions of dollars to cover up the university’s role in the slandering and libeling of the students on its 2006 Men’s lacrosse team, and the attempt to send to prison for gang rape and other felonies three transparently innocent Duke students.
But can you understand why the trustees served as primary enablers of the Duke/Durham frame-up attempt in the first place?
I can’t.
Like many of you, I’ve read attorney Bob Ekstrand’s suit filing which alleges the mistreatment of the lacrosse players was, to a very significant degree, one episode in a series of episodes in which Duke students were mistreated by Durham authorities; and what’s more, again according to Ekstrand, that mistreatment was in large measure the result of a prior mutual agreement involving Duke and Durham Police.
Yet even if we agree, “OK, in March 2006 things were just as Ekstrand alleges,” that still leaves the question: But why did the trustees go along with such a wildly absurd, transparently false hoax story and the frame-up attempt to which it gave rise?
Why, even allowing Duke was already operating in the disgraceful manner Ekstrand alleges, didn’t the trustees tell their Durham partners they weren’t “on board” for the Duke/Durham hoax and framing?
Wouldn’t you think Duke’s trustees would’ve told their Durham partners and Duke’s senior administrators that “the lacrosse gang rape story” was too absurd, too vicious and much too public for them to let Duke be the leading enabler of the slandering and libeling of 47 of its students and the conspiracy to frame and send three of them to prison?
Why didn’t they?
I’ll close with this - - -
Allowing that many Realtors are honest people, let’s imagine for the purpose of this post that we are shady Realtors.
We tell potential buyers that a 2400 sq. ft., 15 year-old house is really a 2600 sq. ft., only 5-year-old house.
And we steer unsuspecting buyers to an appraiser and a closing attorney who’ll go along with our scam.
We’re shady Realtors – really worse – but we’re not crazy. We know we can pull the deal off. After all, many people have pulled off real estate deals involving even greater misrepresentation than what I’ve sketched here.
But suppose instead of trying to pass that 2400 sq. ft. house off as being 2600 sq. ft., we tell prospective buyers it’s really a 30,000 sq. ft., brand new house “the same as the one former Sen. John Edwards built for himself?”
Who’d believe us?
We’d be crazy to try to market the house that way.
There’s no Realtor here in Durham I know who’s ever tried to market a 2400 sq. ft. house as a 30,000 sq. ft. house.
But Duke’s trustee’s went along with a crazy story (really a series of contradictory crazy stories) told in the DUMC emergency room during the early morning hours of March 14, 2006.
Why?
Duke’s trustee’s agreed to serve as enabling partners of a rogue prosecutor.
The rogue’s conduct was so offensive to due process and legal ethics that within four days of his first public statements meant to advance the framing, the North Carolina State Bar opened a case file in anticipation of the time when it would have to consider bringing ethics charges against him; something that later happened and led to his disbarment.
Wouldn't it be crazy for a university’s board of trustees to partner with a rogue prosecutor hell bent on trashing and framing its own students?
But Duke’s trustees did that?
Why?
Message to the board of trustees: Tell us why.
Cost saving suggestion for the trustees: Tell us why in the same communication in which you ask us to give money “no questions asked” to help pay your suit defense expenses and those hefty fees the hedge fund managers got.
Posted by JWM at 12:49 PM 5 comments
Did the Herald Sun mean to dis the President?
Hampton Dellinger hopes to rebound from an unsuccessful run this year for lieutenant governor by securing a presidential appointment that would make him one of the state's three leading federal prosecutors.
The
President-elect Barack Obama would make the selection, in consultation with the state's new
Dellinger -- the son of Duke University law professor emeritus and former acting U.S. Solicitor General Walter Dellinger -- recently contacted Durham Mayor Bill Bell to ask Bell for help in securing the appointment. …
The rest of the story’s here.
Comments:
The story goes on to mention a number of other individuals who hold elective or appointive public offices or are about to occupy one, as in the case of Walter Dalton, whom the Herald Sun identifies as “Lt. Gov.-elect Walter
On first reference the H-S used the public office title of all individuals save one: the President of the
So we read: Its present U.S. Attorney is Anna Mills Wagoner, a George W. Bush appointee who appears unlikely to retain her job.
”Mayor Bell,” “new U.S. senator, Greensboro Democrat Kay Hagan,” “former acting U.S. Solicitor General Walter Dellinger,” “Gov. Mike Easley,” and “Lt. Gov.-elect Walter Dalton.”
But merely “a George W. Bush appointee.”
I’ve praised Ray Gronberg’s reporting many times. I don’t know his politics, but I find it hard to believe he’d stoop to dissing President Bush by failing to use on first reference the title of the office he holds.
Even if Gronberg did, it’s something an editor should’ve caught and corrected.
I’ve left a phone message for the H-S managing editor and I’m sending Gronberg a link to this post.
I’ll let you know what, if anything, I hear back.
Posted by JWM at 12:48 PM 2 comments
Friday, December 19, 2008
The Churchill Series - Dec. 19, 2008
(One of a series of weekday posts about the life of Winston S. Churchill.)
Churchill said that as a boy there were some things about school he liked. They included memorizing “lots of Poetry by heart.”
When well into his late eighties, Churchill could still recite poems he'd learned as a boy. Invictus, by William Ernest Henley, was one of his favorites. The poem stirred him, he told people, and gave him strength in trying times.
The following version is taken from Louis Untermeyer’s Modern British Poetry.
Out of the night that covers me,I hope you all have a good weekend.
Black as the Pit from pole to pole,
I thank whatever gods may be
For my unconquerable soul.
In the fell clutch of circumstance
I have not winced nor cried aloud.
Under the bludgeonings of chance
My head is bloody, but unbowed.
Beyond this place of wrath and tears
Looms but the horror of the shade,
And yet the menace of the years
Finds, and shall find me, unafraid.
It matters not how strait the gate,
How charged with punishments the scroll,
I am the master of my fate;
I am the captain of my soul.
John
Posted by JWM at 11:50 PM 0 comments
Who has title to Camelot?
The problem is Kennedy's sense of entitlement. Given her rather modest achievements, she is trading entirely on pedigree.
[The founders] believed in aristocracy. But their idea was government by natural -- not inherited -- aristocracy, an aristocracy of "virtue and talents," as
And yes, of course, we have our own history of dynastic succession: Adamses and Harrisons, and in the last century,
… Ms. Kennedy [is not] alone in her sense of entitlement. Vice President-elect Biden's Senate seat will now be filled by Edward Kaufman, a family retainer whom no one ever heard of before yesterday. And no one will hear from after two years, at which time Kaufman will dutifully retire. He understands his responsibility: Keep the Delaware Senate seat warm for two years until Joe's son returns from
This, of course, is the Kennedy way. In 1960, John Kennedy's Senate seat was given to his Harvard roommate, one Ben Smith II (priceless name). He stayed on for two years -- until Teddy reached the constitutional age of 30 required to succeed his brother.
In light of the pending dynastic disposition of the
Sadly, however, even this auction was not free of aristo-creep. On the evidence of the
Caroline Kennedy, Beau Biden and Jesse Jackson Jr. could some day become great senators. But in a country where advantages of education, upbringing and wealth already make the playing field extraordinarily uneven, we should resist encouraging the one form of advantage the
Krauthammer’s entire column’s here.
***************************************************
Comments:
I couldn’t agree more with what Krauthammer says or with what my wife is saying, “Come to dinner right now.”
I’ll be back later tonight or tomorrow AM.
Quick – she’s left the room for a moment – have you noticed in even a few of the MSM stories about “a return of Camelot” any mention of Judith Exner or those MLK wiretaps that Kennedy court historians keep telling us “J. Edgar Hoover and the F.B.I. made Jack and Bobby use them?”
Me neither.
Posted by JWM at 8:42 PM 3 comments
Treat Duke’s “19% endowment loss” as a factoid; and be wary
The Free dictionary defines factoid as “a piece of unverified or inaccurate information that is presented in the press as factual, often as part of a publicity effort, and that is then accepted as true because of frequent repetition:”
Today’ Raleigh News & Observer headlines a story:
Duke's endowment shrinks 19%Today’s Durham Herald Sun reports:
The value of Duke University's endowment funds has plummeted 19 percent amid the global market downturn.And just 2 days ago Duke’s President Richard H. Brodhead said in an email to faculty and staff:
As of early December, the market value of the endowment was approximately 19 percent lower than it was on July 1.I encourage everyone to be skeptical of repeated statements of a “19% endowment loss” at Duke.
For one thing, Brodhead was somewhat vague in his statement.
“Early December” is when? The first, fifth, tenth?
Brodhead also labels the 19% an approximate figure, which he’s very right to do.
Given that a lot of Duke’s endowment has been in hedge funds and other investments that are difficult to value, treat the “19%” as a factoid.
And be wary of news stories like those linked to here in the N&O and H-S that quote Duke people putting a positive spin on Duke’s current financial situation without also including in their stories comments such as those made by Ed Rickards in his JinC column What Duke's endowment loss means and this comment on a post thread here:
I suspect that the 19 % loss may be an understatement since, like Harvard/Yale, a significant portion of Duke's assets are in exotic/illiquid type investments ( private equity, real estate, hedge funds )which may have been particularly hard hit and whose values are not always readily available. And the fiscal year is not even half over, with the real prospect of additional losses between now and 6/30/09.The entire N&O story's here; the H-S story's here.
As I commented in a previous post, Duke's investment losses go well beyond losses on its endowment ( $ 6.1 billion as of 6/30/08. ) Duke/DUHS had an additional $ 3.7 billion of investment assets ( including $ 1.3 billion in its pension plan )as of 6/30/08. Applying Duke's estimated 19 % to the total assets ( $ 9.8 billion ) results in losses of nearly $ 2 billion -- and I believe this is a low estimate.
Posted by JWM at 4:29 PM 3 comments
Thursday, December 18, 2008
The Churchill Series - Dec. 18, 2008
(One of a series of weekday posts about the life of Winston S. Churchill.)
November 8, 1895 Churchill, a few weeks shy of his 21st birthday, was aboard Cunard's RMS Etruria and nearing the end of his first trans-Atlantic crossing.
In a letter to his mother he wrote:
I do not contemplate ever taking a sea voyage for pleasure, and I shall always look upon journeys by sea as necessary evils which have to be undergone in the carrying out of any definite plan. ...The following day Etruria and the very critical young Churchill sailed through the Narrows into New York harbor. To starboard he could see Brooklyn, where his mother, Jennie Jerome, was born and grew up. Directly ahead was Manhattan.
[Although the weather gave some] bad moments we were never seasick. ...
There are no nice people on board to speak of - certainly none to write of. ...
There is to be a concert on board tonight at which all the stupid people among the passengers intend to perform and the stupider ones to applaud.
The days have seemed very long & uninteresting.
A few hours later Churchill set foot in America for the first time.
___________________________________
Randolph S. Churchill, Winston S. Churchill: Youth, 1874 - 1900. (pgs. 256-259)
Posted by JWM at 11:50 PM 0 comments
McClatchy hack encourages shoe throwing at our President
Kevin at McClatchy Watch posts with disgust a cartoon by the liberal/leftist McClatchy’s Sacramento Bee’s Rex Babin.
Bebin’s cartoon will please hundreds of millions of Muslims and Arabs and those in this country who thought 9/11 was America’s “chickens coming home to roost.”
You can view the cartoon and its comment thread here.
After viewing Babin’s loathsome cartoon, I called him to learn why an American cartoonist would pen something he had to know would be popular with our country’s enemies and encourage those who seek to attack our President.
Babin told me straight out he’d gotten lots of criticism for his cartoon and didn’t like it one bit .
The criticism wasn’t deserved, he said, because “I don’t actually want Bush to take a bullet”
But, Babin explained, “Bush is responsible for the deaths of thousands of people. What should he expect?”
Our conversation didn’t go very far from there.
Changing gears - - -
On the “good news for truth-seekers” front, McClatchy Watch reported a few hours ago that today McClatchy’s stock closed down a whopping 29% @ $1.05.
Advice to Sacbee executive editor Melanie Sill and McClatchy CEO Gary Pruitt: There's no conclusive evidence of any connection between the continuing crash of your company’s stock and Babin’s viciousness directed at our President
Still, be careful not to make him mad at you.
We can never be sure what self-righteous ideologues like Babin will do.
Posted by JWM at 9:17 PM 8 comments
Reade Seligmann Humanitarian Award honoree
Seligmann received the IMLCA’s inaugural Boston Market Humanitarian Award which recognizes “student-athletes for their strategies and efforts in addressing community needs with campus-based efforts.”
You can read more at this Liestoppers post. Also, this Lacrosse Magazine page has a nice color photo of Seligmann on the field for Brown.
Congratulations to Reade Seligmann who transferred from Duke to Brown after NC attorney general Roy Cooper declared him and the two other students innocent of all charges brought by Nifong, whom Cooper called “a rogue prosecutor.”
Posted by JWM at 4:53 PM 0 comments
North Carolina's grand jury gaming
Tarheel Hawkeye writes about it. I comment below the star line.
TH begins - - -
[Why] does North Carolina not keep grand jury transcripts?
As we saw very clearly in the lacrosse frame, the Durham police officers who testified before the GJ that indicted the players obviously perjured themselves.
The NC AG, Roy Cooper, later said "there was no crime" committed against Mangum.
If there was no crime, then what was the GJ told to convince them there had been a sexual assault?
With no evidence of a crime, the police obviously lied to the GJ.
Until the state passes a law requiring GJ transcripts to be made available for legitimate review, police and prosecutors have a license to abuse the system and malicious prosecution cannot be prevented.
North Carolina is one of only three states that doesn't maintain transcripts.
I have the greatest respect for law enforcement professionals, but there is ample evidence that there are many police and prosecutors out there who game the system for their own advantage.
This must end.
****************************************************
Comments:
The grand jury secrecy in NC which leads to the gaming by corrupt or incompetent prosecutors and police must end.
A major JinC goal in 2009 will be to post and pressure for recordings (text and videos) of grand jury proceedings.
Thanks, TH, for making the case so clearly and concisely.
Posted by JWM at 2:15 PM 0 comments
What Duke’s endowment loss means
Just days ago, at the end of its December meeting, Duke’s Board of Trustees failed refused to release actual, current numbers about its investments.
Last evening Duke reversed course (I wonder why). President Richard H. Brodhead acknowledged a 19 percent loss in the value of the endowment, a total of $1.2 billion gone poof.
He issued the statement himself. Trustee chair Bob "Wachovia" Steel was no where to be found.
Brodhead could have included in his statement – an email address to faculty and staff - the words "lost so far."
Like Harvard, whose president recently explained its giant holdings in hedge funds and private equity still have to be re-evaluated, Duke has focused its holdings in these turbulent areas.
In fact, Duke has focused more in these areas than Harvard. As of July 1 Duke had 42 percent of its money in hedge fund; and 23 percent of its money in private equity.
There is no ready market for these: the Wall Street term is how these investments are "marked" -- that is -- how you estimate their value. These estimates can vary widely.
Harvard’s President Drew G. Faust correctly warned that its numbers will be adjusted downward when all the dust settles; President Brodhead did not
In November, Barrons, the weekly magazine of the Wall Street Journal, estimated that such holdings in university endowments have already lost half their value. If that's true for Duke, its reported loss of $1.2 billion will prove to be $2.5 billion.
In his only formal statement before tonight, Brodhead reassured us that Duke was "stable and secure" with a "strong financial foundation." A sunny island in the tempest. That was misleading to say the least.
Let's look at what $1.2 billion -- the acknowledged loss in the endowment -- means so far to Duke:
-- In recent years, Duke has gotten contributions of about $125 million per year for new endowment. That means a whole decade of giving is wiped out.
-- It took Brodhead one "quiet" year and three years in public to eke out $300 million for the Financial Aid Initiative. This wipes out this gain -- and four others just like it.
-- When the full impact of the loss is felt, Duke will have $60 million less to spend in its annual budget. The highly touted increase in this year's financial aid budget amounted to only $11 million.
In the past 24 hours, there was one other set of numbers with ominous implications for Duke. Sixty-six percent of the young people who were given early admission to the class of 2013 said they needed financial aid.
Statistics for the class of 2012 were not released a year ago, but in the two years before that, only half as many -- around 32 percent -- said they’d need financial aid.
It's clear Duke's budget will not only have less money to spread around, but its highest priority -- need based undergraduate aid -- will be crying for more.
Tonight's statement by Brodhead touched only Duke's endowment. Duke Management Company invests all of the university's funds, huge amounts of money.
-- There will be similar losses in the two Duke Pension plans; perhaps driving their value to the point where Duke will have to increase contributions from its annual budget to keep them fully funded.
-- There will be similar losses in the cash account. For example, money that parents paid last summer for tuition for the fall semester just ending was in the same pool -- where at least 19 percent has been lost.
There is much more that needs to be said in the interests of informing the Duke community.
But for now, I’ll just end with this: What I missed most in President Brodead’s statement was any sense that the financial plight of Duke is a responsibility and burden for all of its. There was no invitation for ideas to save money, no suggestion there be a dialogue to adjust priorities.
Brodhead's statement is consistent with his way of operating -- to deny information to students, faculty and alumni so that their effective participation in university governance is emasculated.
Posted by JWM at 12:34 PM 7 comments
Wednesday, December 17, 2008
The Churchill Series - Dec. 17, 2008
(One of a series of weekday posts about the life of Winston S. Churchill.)
I first published this post three years ago. It still makes me smile, as I hope it will you.
For most of World War II, the noted Oxford historian Isaiah Berlin served in the Foreign Office; assigned to the British Embassy in Washington, where he wrote dispatches assessing current American political and social matters.
Churchill became a regular and admiring reader of Berlin's dispatches. He told aides if ever Berlin was in England, he wanted to meet him.
The Prime Minister's wish was swiftly passed on to Foreign Office staffers and others.
Not long afterwards, word came back to Churchill's aides that Berlin was indeed in England. They arranged an invitation for him to join a luncheon the PM would be hosting at 10 Downing Street. On the seating plan, Berlin was placed close to Churchill.
Now, readers, our story comes to one of those "bumps in the road."
Not for the first time, eager government staffers here, there and in other departments didn't get it all quite right. Which is why a surprised and honored Irving Berlin received a luncheon invitation just days after arriving in England with a USO show.
Author Stefan Kanfer tells about the luncheon:
Berlin showed up at Number 10. The PM addressed him as Professor and grilled him about the progress of the war.Perhaps the aides later comforted each other with something like, "Simple enough mistake. Both I. Berlin, you know."
Bewildered, the composer answered in monosyllables, until a frustrated Churchill gave up and turned to the guest on his left.
Later, (Churchill) commented: “Berlin’s like most bureaucrats. Wonderful on paper, but disappointing when you meet them face to face.”
__________________________________________________________________________
Stefan Kanfer, "The Americanization of Irving Berlin." City Journal (Spring, 2002)
Posted by JWM at 11:50 PM 0 comments
Brodhead to faculty & staff: “Duke’s endowment … has declined”
Duke's endowment has lost 19 percent of its value as of early December, despite assurances from University officials in recent weeks that Duke's financial situation is secure.
President Richard Brodhead attributed the drop to the ongoing recession and financial turmoil in an e-mail sent to faculty and staff early Wednesday evening and obtained by The Chronicle.
According to the Web site of the Duke University Management Company, which manages Duke's endowment, the value of the endowment June 30 was $6.1 billion. That would put the current value at approximately $4.9 billion.
"Duke is not immune from the powerful forces that are buffeting the economy. Duke's endowment, like virtually every other investment fund, has declined over the past few months," Brodhead wrote in the e-mail. "In addition, research universities such as Duke are also uncertain about the future of other funding sources, including federal research support."
Endowment spending typically comprises 15 percent of Duke's annual budget. Spending policies call for a payout of 5.5 percent of the endowment's three-year average value, and these policies are intentionally structured to compensate for difficult economic times.
In light of the endowment losses, senior administrators will begin drafting plans and recommendations to adjust to lower revenues, Brodhead wrote in the e-mail.
The rest of The Chronicle story’s here.
Comments:
The full text of President Brodhead’s email follows below.
On a first read, it looks to be long on puffery and very short on critical information concerning Duke’s endowment, finances and decisions influenced by them.
Brodhead tells us, for example, that “a Duke student won the Rhodes Scholarship, and two others were selected as Marshall Scholars.”
Those students have brought honor to Duke and earned our admiration and cheers for their outstanding achievements.
But President Brodhead knows their achievements were announced weeks ago.
Tonight, faculty, staff and the broader Duke community, especially students and parents, wanted and needed to hear things much more substantial and specific than that Duke’s “[i]dentifying cost reductions, savings and efficiencies in all school and administrative budgets.”
Or that Duke’s seeking “resources for our most strategic priorities while continuing to protect our core commitments.”
Doesn’t Duke do those sorts of things all the time; not just now?
On Dec. 1 a Bloomberg report mentioned Duke:”Crippled financial firms such as American International Group Inc. and bankrupt Lehman Brothers Holdings Inc. are joining strapped endowments such as the ones at Columbia University in New York and Duke University in Durham, North Carolina, in trying to sell private-equity stakes.”
President Brodhead did nothing tonight to explain why Bloomberg would call Duke’s endowment “strapped” and lump the university with “[c]rippled financial firms.”
Perhaps he will tomorrow. But I'm not betting on it.
Hat tips to those who gave heads-ups regarding Brodhead’s latest email and to the commenter who sent the Blomberg link.
Now, what are your reactions to Brodhead’s email tonight?
________________________________________________ Text of President Brodhead's Message
Dear Faculty and Staff Colleagues,
As the year comes to an end, I want to update you on the impact of the global economic situation on Duke.
By many measures, Duke continues to enjoy great strength and stability. With help from generous supporters, we crossed the goal line of our $300 million Financial Aid Initiative, which will help ensure that a Duke education will remain affordable for all.
Last month, a Duke student won the Rhodes Scholarship, and two others were selected as Marshall Scholars. And student interest in Duke has never been higher, with a 23 percent increase in early decision applications this fall.
At the same time, Duke is not immune from the powerful forces that are buffeting the economy. Duke’s endowment, like virtually every other investment fund, has declined over the past few months. In addition, research universities such as Duke are also uncertain about the future of other funding sources, including federal research support.
As of early December, the market value of the endowment was approximately 19 percent lower than it was on July 1. This is a serious concern, but the news could be worse. First, Duke’s investments have been skillfully managed. Over the past 10 years, only one university endowment has outperformed Duke’s, and the decline we have experienced this fall has not been as sharp as many of our peers have reported. Second, it is important to remember that spending from the endowment has historically made up about 15 percent of the University’s annual operating budget – again, a lower proportion than many of our peer institutions. And finally, the impact of this decline on our activities will be tempered by our spending policy, which calls for paying out 5.5 percent of the average value of the endowment over a three-year period.
This policy has kept us from overspending in years when the endowment earned large returns, and lessens our exposure to a sharp downturn now. (For more information about Duke’s endowment and investments, click here.)
Duke is fortunate to have responsible, prudent and creative leadership of both our investments and operations, which has shielded us from some of the worst aspects of this crisis and makes it possible to continue our forward momentum. We need to draw on those same virtues now to face the new facts around us.
While we will have a clearer picture of the future as the winter progresses, I have asked the university’s senior administrators and deans to plan for various scenarios as we develop the budget for the next fiscal year. The specifics will vary by school and program, but our overarching approach includes:
-- Identifying cost reductions, savings and efficiencies in all school and administrative budgets;
-- Recognizing that the current downturn may be of sustained duration and that we must look for both one-time and more durable interventions;
-- Reviewing and potentially delaying proposed capital projects until funding sources are clearly defined; and
-- Seeking resources for our most strategic priorities while continuing to protect our core commitments, including faculty excellence and student financial aid.
We need to regard this as a time of challenge, not of retreat. All of us have been through a mix of better times and leaner times. When leaner days come, a family cuts back on less essential expenses and concentrates on what matters most. That is what Duke must do now, and I ask for your cooperation as we do it. If we do it right, I’m confident that we can make this a time of opportunity, a chance to further strengthen this great school.
Duke’s strong sense of community is its most valuable asset, and this source of wealth continues intact. With deepest thanks for all that you do for Duke and the community, I send my best wishes for the holiday season,
Richard H. Brodhead
Posted by JWM at 11:11 PM 10 comments
Duke’s endowment, budget reporting trails Harvard’s & Yale’s
I’m a Duke alum so I like to see Duke excel.
But when it comes to timely, detailed reporting of the financial downturn’s effects on endowments and budgeting, Duke’s reporting lags that of Harvard's and Yale's.
Just 2 days ago Yale President Richard C. Levin released a lengthy Budget Letter
Following release of his letter, Levin participated in a Q&A with the Yale Daily News. (see here)
On Dec. 2 Harvard President Drew G. Galpin released a Financial Update, one of a number of recent letters she's released and interviews she's granted in which she's sought to keep the Harvard community informed as to the current value of Harvard's endowment and specific budgeting plans for the university.
It was back on Oct. 23 that Duke President Richard H. Brodhead released his most recent letter on "Duke and the economy." On Dec. 8 Brodhead and BOT chair Robert Steel granted an interview to The Chronicle. Judging by what The Chronicle published, their goal was to simply reassure the Duke community that everything's being well-managed. (Chronicle story here)
Brodhead's letter contains a good deal of back-patting and failed to inform regarding the then current value of Duke's endowment.
Here's a representative excerpt from Brodhead's letter :
Duke’s endowment has been one of the most successful among all U.S. universities. For the fiscal year ending June 30, 2008, the endowment recorded a 6.2 percent increase in market value – this at a time when many comparable funds actually declined in value.President Brodhead and the trustees owe the Duke community a current, detailed explanation of the value of the endowment and of current budget planning, particularly as regards student aid, salary and benefits, and major projects currently in the planning stage.
Indeed, though the past few months’ results have not been positive, over the past ten years the Duke University endowment has grown at an average annual rate of 15.6 percent, which places it among the top performers of all university endowments.
Hat tips: a number of you who are sending on links and info
Posted by JWM at 1:57 PM 7 comments
Tuesday, December 16, 2008
The Churchill Series - Dec. 16, 2008
(One of a series of weekday posts about the life of Winston S. Churchill.)
During late January and early February, 1932, Churchill was on a speaking tour in America. He warned of "communism and the disintegrating forces of a disunited Europe."
He argued that Britain and America should ally to keep order in the world. "Why should we not frankly recognize that there must be some source of doctrine and authority to rescue nations from confusion?"
Quite apart from the political controversy his remarks engendered, it took physical courage for Churchill to stand before his audiences. He knew there were a number of plots by Asian Indian extremists to assassinate him.
Host cities went to great lengths to protect his life . Detroit, for example, assigned a special detail of 12 detectives to accompany him while he was in the city. Another dozen plainclothes officers were in the audience when he spoke while many uniformed police officers watched the lecture hall.
Churchill was stoned twice during the tour; and in one case an armored car was put at his disposal. But he completed the tour, having refused to cancel any engagement in the face of threats.
________________________________________________________________________
Martin Gilbert, Churchill and America. (pgs. 136-139)
Posted by JWM at 11:50 PM 0 comments
Harvard, Duke & Yale report on their endowments
On Dec. 2, The Crimson reported: “Harvard Endowment Fell 22 Percent in Four Months”
The precipitous drop will require Harvard’s faculties to take a “hard look at hiring, staffing levels, and compensation,” wrote University President Drew G. Faust and Executive Vice President Edward C. Forst ’82 in a letter informing the deans of Harvard’s losses.
The decline, which amounts to more than $8 billion, is larger than the endowments of all but four other universities—Yale,
In the same period, the S&P 500 fell 24.6 percent. The index has fallen an additional 12.4 percent since then.
The estimate of 22 percent may not fully capture the actual losses from this period, Forst said in an interview yesterday, as some of Harvard’s money is invested with external managers that have yet to report their latest figures. Faust and Forst wrote in yesterday’s letter that the University should plan for a 30 percent drop-off in endowment value for the year ending June 30, 2009.
The news comes during the worst economic turmoil in decades. University endowments across the country have begun announcing unprecedented losses and instituting hiring or construction freezes in an effort to save funds.
The Faculty of Arts and Sciences placed a freeze on staff hiring last week, following a cautionary letter from Faust a month earlier that warned of cutbacks ahead. ….
____________________________
As other universities announce cuts for budgets impacted by the economic crisis, Duke's Board of Trustees spent the weekend culling information about-rather than passing resolutions on-the underlying structures that have kept its finances relatively secure.
"There is a fact that we are in a very challenging financial time for everyone," Chair Robert Steel, Trinity '73, said in an interview with The Chronicle Saturday.
President Richard Brodhead and Steel said there has been no discussion of tuition changes; last March, the Trustees approved a tuition increase of 5 percent. Actual budgeting across the University will come in January.
The agenda for this meeting was more than a year in the making, meant to deeply analyze financial modes for the University, health system, DUMAC and strategic planning and fundraising.
"As it turned out, that was a really good thing to be doing at this meeting," Brodhead said. "We just want to make sure that we match our resources with our mission and aspiration in the right way going forward."
Brodhead and Steel did not disclose specific numbers, noting that Duke has had to be adaptive but relies less on its nearly $8 billion endowment than some peers.
DUMAC's most recent quarterly report for fiscal year 2008 showed the endowment had increased by 6.2 percent-still a much more conservative gain than typical-but Executive Vice President Tallman Trask told The Chronicle in October that he expected much of that had been lost in the ensuing economic crisis. Other streams of revenue for the University include tuition, gifts and grants.
"In some ways, it's a good thing to be the richest of the poor kids, or the poorest of the rich kids," Michael Schoenfeld, vice president for government affairs and public relations, said in an interview Thursday.
__________________________________________________
Today, Dec. 16, The Yale Daily News reported: ENDOWMENT FALLS 25 PERCENT
Its story, updated at 7:12 p.m. eastern begins - - -
Yale’s endowment lost roughly a quarter of its value since the start of summer, and several capital projects — possibly including the two new residential colleges — will be delayed as a result, University President Richard Levin announced Tuesday.
Yale will not implement a formal hiring freeze or reduce financial aid even as its endowment has plunged in value to approximately $17 billion today from $22.9 billion on June 30, Levin said. But in a letter to the community and an interview with the News, the president called for budget cuts and postponements of many high-profile construction projects, including the new School of Management campus.
“In recent years, we have been in the fortunate position of being able to pursue many new ideas and exciting initiatives,” Levin said in the letter. “Now we will have to make harder choices.”
From the start of the fiscal year to Oct. 31, Yale’s marketable securities lost 13.4 percent of their value. But Levin noted in the letter that those losses grew in November and December, adding that it is difficult to know exactly how much the University has lost in investments that “are not traded on a daily basis and are difficult to value with precision.”
Given all this, Levin estimated the endowment’s value at $17 billion, representing a 25 percent decline since June 30.
“We are less hard hit than some other institutions,” Levin told the News Tuesday afternoon. “That’s because of the excellent management of our endowment by David Swensen.”
Even still, Levin wrote that he anticipates flat endowment returns in the 2009-’10 year and positive growth thereafter. He said the losses would create a budget shortfall that will stand at $100 million in 2009-’10 and is projected to rise to over $300 million in 2013-’14.
For that reason, Levin announced five policy changes — effective immediately — in response to Yale’s dramatic losses. [The five policy changes are identified in Levin’s letter linked to above. – JinC]
*************************************************
Comments:
The three stories' titles above link to their entire stories.
Harvard and Yale alums received specific, current accountings of their universities endowments' values.
Presidents Faust's and Levin's letters to their communities and comments to their respective universities’ student newspapers were impressive for the detail the presidents shared regarding how their universities will respond to the drops in their endowments.
Duke alums were told the “good news is that Duke has been very prudently and conservatively managed from a financial perspective for quite awhile. No. 2, we also have very, very good day-to-day controls.”
But they were given no accounting of Duke endowment’s current worth.
Duke Chronicle’s reference to Vice President Trask’s October statement regarding the worth of Duke’s endowment has been so overtaken by further market declines as to be worse than worthless; it’s downright misleading.
More tomorrow.
Meanwhile, if you’ve not already done so, I invite you to take this Quick Duke Quiz.
Posted by JWM at 10:10 PM 5 comments
McClatchy Baghdad journos approve shoe throwing
Some of our guys started making jokes about the incident. I
When I tried to explain my opinion, I was trying to tell the guys that I don't agree with the way the journalist behaved, but I was attacked by them.
One of them said "come on Laith, Bush destroyed
_____________________________________
Again, the entire post’s here. but when you get to it it may have been “edited.”
That McClatchy’s
It’s a safe guess that in McClatchy newsrooms and other news orgs’ newsrooms here in
I mean, if you’re a leftist, you’re just not going to like Bush.
George Soros and Will Ayers are the kind of guys who get high approval ratings in newsrooms.
McClatchy, of course, insists its journalist are unbiased news gatherers. (Wink!)
Hat tip: McClatchy Watch
Posted by JWM at 3:57 PM 2 comments