Readers Note: You all will pick up quickly on the email below, which I've just sent KC Johnson offline.
Many of you may have the same or similar questions to those I asked him. You may also have had the same difficulty commenting at KC's Durham-in-Wonderland blog today that I've had.
John
___________________________________________________
Dear KC,
At your Book News post you say:
A reminder that the source notes are available for the book, at the book website. The notes also include corrections to the text. One correction that I wanted to highlight here as well: on pp. 65-66: the discussion of the March 25 N&O story quoted Duke Law professor Paul Haagen’s recollections of his interview for that article. The book stated that Samiha Khanna interviewed Haagen, and Haagen recalled her asking leading questions; in fact, another N&O reporter interviewed Haagen.I went to your source notes website and found the following:
I apologize for the error.
Errata:I went back to Book Notes to make a comment, but could find no place to do so.
pp. 65-66:
The discussion of the March 25 N&O story quoted Duke Law professor Paul Haagen’s recollections of his interview for that article. The book stated that Samiha Khanna interviewed Haagen, and Haagen recalled her asking leading questions; in fact, another N&O reporter interviewed Haagen, and said that she asked fair questions of Haagen, who did not subsequently complain to her. We apologize for the error.
I've checked a number of times today and there's still no place to comment as of 10 p.m.
Have you shut down comments on this post?
I'm sending you this email and posting it for readers who may have encountered the same problem commenting, may have questions similar to mine, or may just want to learn more about the book.
Questions:
Who is the reporter who actually interviewed Professor Haagen?
What was your basis for telling readers in the first place what you and Taylor reported Professor Paul Haagen said Reporter Samiha Khanna did during the interview?
For the benefit of readers who may not have access to Until Proven Innocent, I'll quote what you and Taylor say in regard to Haagen's statements and the interview: "The article concluded by portraying the chairman of Duke's Academic Council, law professor Paul Haagen, as hinting he thought the players guilty.
The story said that Haagen cited studies showing 'that violence against women is more prevalent among male athletes than among male students in general,' and singling out 'helmet sports,' such as football, hockey and lacrosse, for particular notice. The concluding quote: 'These are sports of violence. This is clearly a concern.'
Yet, as Haagen recalled later, reporter Samiha Khanna took the quotes wildly out of context: he had grave doubts about Mangum's story, and Khanna spent most of her interview with him fishing for negative quotes about the players at a faculty meeting that day." (p. 65-66)
KC, you say in your correction: "in fact, another N&O reporter interviewed Haagen, and said that she asked fair questions of Haagen, who did not subsequently complain to her."
What does Haagen say about what this other N&O reporter says about the interview?
Do Haagen and the other N&O reporter at least agree he said what the N&O quoted him as saying?
If Haagen and this other N&O reporter are now in substantial agreement, how did you and Taylor wind up reporting the version of the interview that's in Until Proven Innocent?
In any case, I have my fingers crossed that Haagen has in fact substantially disowned what the N&O quoted him as saying in it’s March 25, 2006 story which fair-minded people familiar with the framing of the players agree was a deliberately fraudulent story.
Haagen disowning the quotes will help those of us who are working to get the N&O to retract the story and to apologize for it to the players, their families and the community for what was a deliberately fraudulent story.
Yesterday N&O executive editor Melanie Sill posted at the Editors' Blog telling readers you recently visited with the folks at the N&O. She spoke very favorably of you as you have of her. She likes the way you and the N&O compliment one another.
However, she went on to say the book has errors but didn’t specify any.
I’d ask her what she thinks they are, but she usually doesn’t respond to my questions.
So I ask you: Was the Haagen matter one of the errors the N&O pointed out?
Can you tell us what are the other errors the N&O says are in Until Proven Innocent?
Given the involvement N&O folks have had helping with the book, and how generous you've been in your praise of them, I was frankly surprised the N&O was fussing with you, even a little bit.
Following this email is a copy of the text of Book News I printed off DIW a little after 10 p.m.
Thanks for your attention to the questions.
Best,
John
---------------------------------------------
Book News
Liestoppers has the video of my colleague Stuart Taylor’s book talk at the Cato Institute from earlier this week.
The video of my Duke talk should be available soon; when it is, I will post a link.
Stuart will be speaking tomorrow at William & Mary, in a forum on prosecutorial misconduct and the Duke lacrosse case. He’ll be joined by legal luminaries (and Duke Law professors) Jim Coleman, Erwin Chemerinsky, and Walter Dellinger. The event runs from 2.00pm-3.00pm.
----------
A reminder that the source notes are available for the book, at the book website.
The notes also include corrections to the text. One correction that I wanted to highlight here as well: on pp. 65-66: the discussion of the March 25 N&O story quoted Duke Law professor Paul Haagen’s recollections of his interview for that article. The book stated that Samiha Khanna interviewed Haagen, and Haagen recalled her asking leading questions; in fact, another N&O reporter interviewed Haagen.
I apologize for the error.
POSTED BY KC JOHNSON AT 12:47 PM
LABELS: BOOK